Labour Party's legal bid to halt National Dialogue dismissed by Gauteng High Court
Image: Itumeleng English / Independent Newspapers
The Labour Party of South Africa has failed in its urgent legal bid for an interim interdict to halt the National Dialogue set to commence on August 15.
The party turned to the Gauteng High Court, Pretoria, to urgently halt the President's decision to convene a National Dialogue and two related conventions.
At the heart of its objections were the costs associated with this. It argued that the National Dialogue is not a genuine democratic exercise, but a costly and dangerous duplication of the national legislature.
It argued that the National Dialogue Preparatory Committee estimates that the initiative will cost over R700 million, according to an announcement dated June 12. The government, however, in its argument to court, denied this amount. According to the State respondents, a final budget will only be developed following engagements with the National Treasury and other potential partners.
The Labour Party's approach to the court was motivated by constitutional concerns. It questioned what power the President has to establish a National Dialogue. It argued that if its ultimate aim is to ensure public participation, create policy and make binding decisions, this is a duplication of the functions of Parliament. It also questioned whether it would be lawful to attach a R700 million price tag for a part of this endeavour.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Ad loading
They asked the court to halt the National Dialogue, pending an opportunity to later review the President's decision.
Acting Judge I de Vos said the Constitution mandates the President to promote national unity and the jurisprudence of the Constitutional Court has repeatedly asserted this process is ongoing and that this duty falls to the President.
'The court is not, based on the text of the Constitution and the jurisprudence from the Constitutional Court, persuaded that the President is acting outside his powers,' she said. The judge added that the court is not persuaded that the applicant has made out a prima facie case on this basis or that it bears strong prospects of success in the review on this ground.
'The court is not empowered to determine if a National Dialogue is the best method for promoting national unity. Or if the same people that have been invited to the table to do the preparatory work are the ones the court would have chosen. Or even if it would rather spend money on a National Dialogue or on health care or some other issue.'
Judge de Vos added that the goal of the National Dialogue, which consists of public participation and engagement, is to promote national unity. 'There is a rational link between the National Dialogue, particularly one premised on public participation, and the promotion of national unity,' she said.
In turning down the application, she concluded that the Labour Party has failed to meet the threshold to show irrationality in the method employed in announcing the National Dialogue.
'The court is not convinced that the Labour Party has proven a prima facie right in this regard and is doubtful as to its prospects of success at the hearing of the final relief,' she said.
As to the money involved, the judge said the court is not empowered to ask whether this is the best use of money. That is the domain of the executive.
Cape Times
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Maverick
2 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
What does it mean to be South African? Navigating identity in a complex democracy
In a Daily Maverick webinar asking 'What does it mean to be South African?', professors William Gumede and Pierre de Vos joined Zukiswa Pikoli to delve into identity, citizenship and inclusion 30 years into South Africa's democracy. Here are 10 takeaways. 1. Defining South Africanness: A contested and plural concept The webinar highlighted that defining 'South Africanness' is contested terrain, especially 30 years into democracy. Unlike monocultural countries, South Africa's identity is plural and layered, based on multiple identities and an acceptance of difference rather than a single shared culture, language or race. 2. The Constitution as a 'civic religion' While South Africa boasts diverse cultures and languages, the Constitution and its democratic institutions serve as a common civic identity, a 'civic religion' that binds citizens together. It's seen as a crucial pillar for a country with a deeply divided past. 3. Beyond Western models of nationhood Traditional Western models of nationhood, often based on shared culture or language, don't fully apply to South Africa. The country's identity must be more embracing, incorporating the best elements of its diverse past, present, histories and cultures. 4. Addressing xenophobia and exclusion A critical concern raised is the potential for national identity to be used for exclusion, leading to xenophobia and other forms of discrimination. The discussion emphasised the need for a shared commitment and recognition of interdependence to foster a functional constitutional democracy. 5. The role of, and pressure on, the Constitution The Constitution, with its core values of human dignity, equality and freedom, is an aspiration. However, it faces immense pressure as visible inequalities persist, leading some to question whether these values are truly shared or merely promises unfulfilled. The document itself cannot act; it is about how people and institutions behave. 6. Transforming individual identity towards a broader South Africanness A significant challenge is to transform individual, narrow self-identities (e.g. based on race or ethnicity) into a broader South African identity. This requires more engagement in families, schools, workplaces and communities to foster a sense that one's specific group identity is just a piece of a larger South Africanness. 7. Cultivating empathy and solidarity across difference A crucial missing element in South Africa's nation-building project is empathy and solidarity across different groups. People tend to have empathy for those similar to them, but extending this compassion to those who 'don't look like you' is vital for a stronger common South Africanness. This needs to be actively taught and nurtured, starting in schools. 8. The peril of politicised identity The country's national identity is deeply intertwined with politics. When governance is poor, corrupt or incompetent, or when politicians exploit divisions for votes, it undermines the common South African project. There is a strong call for consequences for politicians who sow division. 9. Reimagining commemorations and recognising diverse contributions Commemorative days and national memory-making need to move beyond focusing solely on politicians or political parties. There's a strong need to memorialise the diversity of South African society, including forgotten and excluded individuals, artists, institution builders and sports stars, celebrating a broader range of contributions to the nation. 10. The importance of recognising and refining indigenous identities While recognising and bringing back indigenous identities erased by apartheid is crucial, it is equally important to critically evaluate and remove anti-democratic or anti-constitutional elements within these identities (e.g. patriarchy). The goal is to integrate the valuable aspects of indigenous identities with the constitutional value of equality. The discussion highlighted the ongoing journey of defining and strengthening South Africa's identity, emphasising the complexities of diversity, the role of foundational values and the need for active engagement from all citizens. DM
Daily Maverick
2 hours ago
- Daily Maverick
ANC NEC seeks more alliances to fortify fragile GNU post-budget crisis
Despite growing challenges and ongoing policy disagreements, ANC President Cyril Ramaphosa maintains that forming the Government of National Unity was the right decision. Yet, the ANC is now turning to parties outside the coalition for support. After a bruising Budget crisis that nearly brought Parliament to a standstill, the ANC's highest decision-making body, the National Executive Committee (NEC), has resolved to engage with political parties outside the Government of National Unity (GNU) to stabilise governance and push for key reforms. The decision comes as the GNU, now more than a year old, continues to face multiple challenges and remains fragile in parts. Its biggest test was the failure to pass the national Budget — not once, but twice, marking an unprecedented moment in South Africa's democratic history. Closing the NEC's four-day meeting in Germiston, ANC president Cyril Ramaphosa said the committee had received a detailed report on the GNU and held robust discussions, ultimately acknowledging the growing fragility of the governing arrangement. 'The Budget process has taught us many lessons, including being able to build tactical and issue-based voting alliances with other parties. We welcome the cooperation on the Budget, including with parties that are not part of the Government of National Unity,' said Ramaphosa. The Budget was eventually passed with support from parties outside the formal GNU arrangement, including ActionSA and Build One South Africa, a development that Ramaphosa described as 'a real demonstration of acting in the interests of the people of South Africa'. 'We are grateful to all those parties that cooperated with us to have the Budget passed. The overall picture is that despite all the noise through the GNU we have been able to safeguard the core progressive policy agenda of the National Democratic Revolution, which is the core pillar of ANC policy,' said Ramaphosa. Beyond the Budget deadlock, the GNU has confronted significant challenges, including disagreements over land expropriation without compensation and pushback against the Basic Education Laws Amendment Act. Both cases sparked fierce opposition and court battles led by the Democratic Alliance, the second-largest party in the GNU. 'We have extensively discussed how we proceed with respect to the Government of National Unity, given our analysis and practical experience of the past 12 months. Accordingly, the National Executive Committee considered a number of options about how to strengthen the GNU and improve its effectiveness and stability to give full and proper effect to the Statement of Intent that was signed by the parties that are party to the GMU, as well as the three strategic priorities of the seventh administration,' said Ramaphosa. As part of this, Ramaphosa said the NEC had agreed to engage with parties that were willing to play a 'constructive role in furthering national unity and stability' so it could achieve three strategic priorities: driving inclusive growth and job creation, reducing poverty and tackling the high cost of living and building a capable developmental state. Despite the challenges faced by the GNU, said Ramaphosa, the NEC had concluded that the decision to establish it was correct. 'Our people appreciate that it has brought stability and enabled progress in addressing their challenges. The NEC reaffirms the view that the GNU is a correct tactic and remains valid.' Ramaphosa pointed to increasing pressure from 'global and domestic right-wing forces', but stressed that the ANC had not abandoned its democratic or developmental agenda. 'Through access to state power in the GNU we have been able to defend the democratic gains and to advance our transformation agenda, despite the pressure and resistance from the global and domestic right-wing forces. We have not retreated from the progressive domestic and foreign policy positions of our movement.' Local elections During the 2021 local government elections, the ANC lost control of several key metropolitan municipalities. Of the eight metros nationwide, the party won an outright majority in just two: Mangaung and Buffalo City. Now, with the 2026 local elections looming, Ramaphosa said, 'The marching order to all ANC-run municipalities and ward councillors is that we cannot proceed as if it continues to be business as usual. We need to undertake extraordinary measures to address challenges at local government level.' In a week or two, the NEC will hold a special session to focus more attention on the challenges in local government. SACP Another contentious issue in the discussions was the SA Communist Party's (SACP's) decision to contest the elections independently of the ANC, about which Ramaphosa expressed serious concern. Two weeks ago, the SACP, running separately from the ANC for the first time in the province, garnered only 70 votes in a by-election in a Polokwane ward, representing just 1%. 'We have no wish, nor do we have any intention, to interfere with the decision of the South African Communist Party. However, as we have indicated, we disagree with the decision,' said Ramaphosa. 'We believe that this decision has fundamental implications for the strategy and programme of the National Democratic Revolution … while the alliance between the SACP and the ANC has spanned the better part of a century. This is not about the past. It is not about nostalgia.' The NEC believes the SACP's decision will significantly weaken the forces for national democratic change. 'We will continue to seek to engage with the SACP on how we will run those elections. We will go out from this meeting to explain our position to our structures at every level of our organisation, so that comrades, members of the ANC, are empowered to explain the challenge this poses to our transformation agenda,' said Ramaphosa. Although the NEC is opposed to the SACP contesting elections, Ramaphosa stressed the need for unity within the broader alliance. 'We are determined to ensure that these developments do not divide our movement or cause instability. We reiterate that the SACP members who hold ANC membership are full members of our movement with the same rights and duties as any other ANC member, rights and responsibilities that are clearly stated in our constitution,' said Ramaphosa. However, how this stance will be implemented in practice remains uncertain, particularly in light of Ramaphosa's recent appointment of SACP member Buti Manamela as the minister of higher education, science and technology. DM
IOL News
8 hours ago
- IOL News
News you should know tonight: Top 5 stories you may have missed on August 4, 2025
The Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) has expressed its support for the newly established Ad Hoc Committee in the South African National Assembly, tasked with investigating serious allegations of corruption, criminal syndicate infiltration, and political interference within the country's law enforcement agencies. Good evening, IOL News family! It's Monday, August 4, 2025, and it's time for a wrap of the biggest headlines making waves in South Africa and beyond. Don't forget to join the IOL WhatsApp Channel to stay in tune, informed, and in the know. EFF welcomes Parliamentary Committee to investigate corruption and infiltration in law enforcement The Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) has expressed its support for the newly established Ad Hoc Committee in the South African National Assembly, tasked with investigating serious allegations of corruption, criminal syndicate infiltration, and political interference within the country's law enforcement agencies. To read on, click here. Ramaphosa admits SA is reeling from US tariffs, but insists it is not alone President Cyril Ramaphosa has conceded that South Africa is grappling with the United States' decision to impose a 30% tariff on local imports, but insists the country is not alone in facing mounting global trade challenges. To read on, click here. JMPD officer sentenced to six years for car crash that claimed three lives A Johannesburg Metro Police Department (JMP) police officer has been sentenced to six years in prison for three counts of culpable homicide by the Lenasia Magistrate Court. To read on, click here. MK Party condemns ConCourt's dismissal of court challenge against Ramaphosa The uMkhonto weSizwe (MK) Party has voiced its strong condemnation of the Constitutional Court's recent decision to dismiss a critical challenge against President Cyril Ramaphosa's actions, asserting that the judiciary has failed to hold the head of state accountable for what the party describes as 'flagrant constitutional violations.' To read on, click here. Do you owe SARS? Easy ways to check your tax debt in 2025 Tax season is still in full swing, and while many South Africans are expecting refunds, others may be shocked to discover they owe the South African Revenue Service (SARS) some money. To read on, click here. Get your news on the go, click here to join the IOL News WhatsApp channel. IOL News
