India-US spat over trade and oil threatens wider fallout
Trump
's tirade against
India
over trade and Russian oil purchases threatens to undo two decades of diplomatic progress, analysts and officials say, and could derail other areas of cooperation as domestic political pressures drive both sides to harden their stances.
India's opposition parties and the general public have urged Prime Minister Narendra Modi to stand up to what they call bullying by Trump, who on Wednesday signed an executive order subjecting Indian imports to an additional 25% in duties on top of an existing 25% tariff, due to its big purchases of Russian oil.
Productivity Tool
Zero to Hero in Microsoft Excel: Complete Excel guide
By Metla Sudha Sekhar
View Program
Finance
Introduction to Technical Analysis & Candlestick Theory
By Dinesh Nagpal
View Program
Finance
Financial Literacy i e Lets Crack the Billionaire Code
By CA Rahul Gupta
View Program
Digital Marketing
Digital Marketing Masterclass by Neil Patel
By Neil Patel
View Program
Finance
Technical Analysis Demystified- A Complete Guide to Trading
By Kunal Patel
View Program
Productivity Tool
Excel Essentials to Expert: Your Complete Guide
By Study at home
View Program
Artificial Intelligence
AI For Business Professionals Batch 2
By Ansh Mehra
View Program
While India has emerged in recent years as a key partner for Washington in its strategic rivalry with China, its large U.S. trade surplus and close relations with Russia - which Trump is seeking to pressure into agreeing to a peace agreement with Ukraine - have made it a prime target in the Republican president's global tariff offensive.
Trump's taunt that India could buy oil from arch enemy Pakistan has also not gone down well in New Delhi, said two Indian government sources. India has also rejected repeated claims by Trump that he used trade as a lever to end a recent military conflict between India and Pakistan.
In an unusually sharp statement this week, India accused the U.S. of double standards in singling it out for Russian oil imports while continuing to buy Russian uranium hexafluoride, palladium and fertiliser. On Wednesday, it called the tariffs "unfair, unjustified and unreasonable," vowing to "take all actions necessary to protect its national interests."
Live Events
But New Delhi knows that any further escalation will hurt it in matters beyond trade, said the sources. Unlike China, India does not have leverage like supplies of rare earths to force Trump's hand to improve the terms of any trade deal, they said.
In recent years, successive U.S. administrations, including Trump's first, carefully cultivated relations with India with an eye on it as a vital partner in long-term efforts to counter the growing might of China.
But analysts say Trump's recent moves have plunged the relationship back to possibly its worst phase since the U.S. imposed sanctions on India for nuclear tests in 1998.
"India is now in a trap: because of Trump's pressure, Modi will reduce India's oil purchases from Russia, but he cannot publicly admit to doing so for fear of looking like he's surrendering to Trump's blackmail," said Ashley Tellis at Washington's
Carnegie Endowment for International Peace
.
"We could be heading into a needless crisis that unravels a quarter century of hard-won gains with India."
Indian state refiners have in recent days stopped buying Russian oil as discounts narrowed and pressure from Trump rose, Reuters has reported.
NEW CHALLENGES FOR RELATIONS
A more pressing challenge for India, analysts say, is the stark divergence between its priorities and Trump's political base on key issues such as work visas for tech professionals and offshoring of services. India has long been a major beneficiary of U.S. work visa programs and the outsourcing of software and business services, a sore point for Americans who have lost jobs to cheaper workers in India.
Relations with India risk becoming a "football in American domestic politics," warned Evan Feigenbaum, a former senior
State Department
official under the Republican presidency of George W. Bush.
"Issues that directly touch India are among the most partisan and explosive in Washington, including immigration and deportation, H1B visas for tech workers, offshoring and overseas manufacturing by U.S. companies, and technology sharing and co-innovation with foreigners," he wrote in a LinkedIn post.
Since a 2008 deal to cooperate on civilian nuclear technology, the two countries have deepened intelligence sharing and defence cooperation and expanded interactions with Australia and Japan through the Quad grouping aimed at containing China's dominance in the Indo-Pacific.
But fractures have appeared, despite Modi's rapport with Trump in his first term and then former President Joe Biden.
Images in February of Indians deported by the U.S. on military planes, their hands and legs shackled, horrified the country just days before Modi went to see Trump seeking to stave off high tariffs.
The relationship was also seriously tested in late 2023 when the U.S. said it had foiled a plot with Indian links to kill a
Sikh
separatist leader on U.S. soil. New Delhi has denied any official connection to the plot.
"The Modi regime's credibility in the U.S. has gone down," said Sukh Deo Muni, a former Indian diplomat and a professor emeritus at New Delhi's
Jawaharlal Nehru University
.
"And maybe there are people who think that India or Modi had to be brought back on track, if not taught a lesson. And if that trend continues, I'm quite worried that the challenge is quite powerful and strong for India to navigate."
STRENGTHENING TIES WITH U.S. RIVALS
One Indian government source said India needs to gradually repair ties with the U.S. while engaging more with other nations that have faced the brunt of Trump tariffs and aid cuts, including the African Union and the BRICS bloc that includes Brazil, Russia, China and South Africa.
India is already making some moves with Russia and China.
Russian President
Vladimir Putin
is expected to visit New Delhi this year and on Tuesday, Russia said the two countries had discussed further strengthening defence cooperation "in the form of a particularly privileged strategic partnership."
India has also boosted engagement with China, a change after years of tensions following a deadly border clash in 2020. Modi is set to visit China soon for the first time since 2018.
"Russia will attempt to exploit the rift between the U.S. and India by proposing the restoration of the Russia-India-China trilateral and new projects in defence," said analyst Aleksei Zakharov at the
Observer Research Foundation
in New Delhi.
"India will undoubtedly be mindful of structural factors such as sanctions against Russia and will seek to find a compromise with the Trump administration."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
13 minutes ago
- Indian Express
As Russian oil discount narrows, economists think India can afford import diversification
With US President Donald Trump doubling the tariff on Indian goods to 50 per cent, economists think India can afford to reduce its purchase of Russian oil due to the narrowing of the discount on offer and diversify its sourcing. From around 2 per cent prior to the invasion of Ukraine in February 2022, the share of Russian oil in India's oil imports has increased sharply to 35-40 per cent, with Indian refiners lapping up discounted Russian oil that was shunned by developed nations. However, the tariff war instigated by Donald Trump – initially with a focus on addressing the US' trade deficit with other nations – has seen the imposition of so-called secondary tariffs on India for its purchase of Russian energy and defence equipment. On July 30, Trump threatened a 25 per cent on India and an additional unspecified 'penalty' for its Russian trade. On Wednesday, the penalty was revealed to be a further 25 per cent tariff on Indian goods that will come into effect on August 27. According to Barclays economists led by Aastha Gudwani, the purchase of discounted Russian oil helped lower India's oil import bill by around $7 billion-10 billion in 2024 to $186 billion. 'As of now, the discount on oil imports from Russia having narrowed to around $3-8/barrel lower than Middle eastern grade. Media reports suggest that Indian refiners would be pushed to pivot towards traditional West Asian suppliers and new players such as Brazil to make up for lost Russian supplies, with price increases around $4-5/barrel. With global oil prices in 2025 so far settling around $9/barrel lower than 2024, such a diversification of oil supply sources is unlikely to hurt India's oil import bill,' they added. Meanwhile, Nomura economists Sonal Varma and Aurodeep Nandi estimate the implied discount on Russian crude oil for Indian refiners declined to around $2.2 per barrel in 2024-25 from over $12 per barrel in 2022-23. As such, if India chooses to reduce its purchase of Russian oil, India's annual import bill may only rise by around $1.5 billion, they calculated. Morgan Stanley economists were in agreement, estimating that the discount India got on Russian crude oil in 2024-25 was only $2-3 per barrel. To be sure, Indian refining companies began cutting their purchase of Russian oil even prior to Trump's threat of a 'penalty'. In July, India's crude imports from Russia averaged 1.6 million barrels per day, as per data from Kpler, a global trade data and analytics firm, down 24 per cent from June. However, a move by India to procure more oil from countries other than Russia could push up prices globally, which would raise the import bill. While difficult to estimate, Nomura economists think that given India imported 1.8 billion barrels of oil in 2024-25, India's annual import bill could rise by around $1.8 billion for every $1 increase in global crude prices. 'Domestically, the government will likely keep pump prices constant, which means there is likely to be minimal inflation and growth impact from any shift in oil procurement. This also means that the ultimate cost of any transition will most likely have to be borne by public sector oil marketing companies, and eventually by the government if it needs to compensate them for these under-recoveries at a later stage,' Nomura said, adding that it did not see a 'major upside risk' to the Indian government's fiscal deficit target of 4.4 per cent of GDP for the current fiscal. Meanwhile, reduced demand for Russian oil from Indian refiners, especially state-run ones, is already beginning to reflect in prices, with Homayoun Falakshahi, head of crude oil analysis at Kpler, pointing out on Wednesday that private refiners were 'still scooping barrels, but at a lower pace. Four Aframaxes are currently waiting to discharge at Jamnagar and Vadinar'. An aframax is a type of oil tanker. According to Falakshahi, India's negotiations with the US could lead to New Delhi agreeing to raise its oil and gas purchases. The energy trade between the two countries is worth around $7.5 billion a year. 'This has already started to be the case, with the country's imports of US crude on the rise lately to an average of 225 kbd (thousand barrels per day) since May, nearly twice as much the levels from early 2025. Indian refiners could realistically increase their intake of US crude by another 100 kbd to previous highs of ~300 kbd in 2021,' Falakshahi said. However, he added he was sceptical that India will be able to completely stop the import of Russian oil. Siddharth Upasani is a Deputy Associate Editor with The Indian Express. He reports primarily on data and the economy, looking for trends and changes in the former which paint a picture of the latter. Before The Indian Express, he worked at Moneycontrol and financial newswire Informist (previously called Cogencis). Outside of work, sports, fantasy football, and graphic novels keep him busy. ... Read More
NDTV
13 minutes ago
- NDTV
Deals, Drama, And Delusion: Trump's Return To World Stage Full Of Tamasha
New Delhi: US President Donald Trump's second term in office is not turning out any different than his first - marked less by diplomacy, but more by drama, officials have said. Mr Trump's style, laced with unpredictability, misinformation and showmanship, has turned serious global negotiations into a political circus, they said. The latest in this tamasha is Mr Trump's calculation of tariffs which has confounded economists, many of whom argue they rest on faulty assumptions and lack economic rationale, officials said. A stark example of this can be seen in the way the Trump administration has left allies including Vietnam blindsided and reduced serious policy to political theatre, sources said. This is also substantiated by how the US president routinely bypasses formal channels to announce threats or supposed "deals" on his microblogging website Truth Social, often before informing diplomats or affected countries. Vietnam Tariff Flip-Flop Vietnam thought it had a deal after its negotiators worked out a preliminary agreement with the US to substantially lower punitive tariffs to 11 per cent. But just days before the White House's self-imposed July 8 deadline, Mr Trump unilaterally raised the figure to 20 per cent during a call with Vietnam's General Secretary To Lam, who hadn't even been part of the talks. Mr Trump then announced this so-called deal on Truth Social, touting it as agreed and sealed, while in reality Vietnam never formally accepted the new terms. To date, no documentation exists to back Mr Trump's version of events, sources said, adding that Vietnamese officials were disappointed and angry, having believed they were working toward a credible agreement. Mr Trump's abrupt imposition of harsher tariffs without consensus, paperwork or process derailed trust and embarrassed the Vietnamese side, who now face domestic political fallout for a deal they never fully agreed to, sources said. Experts have warned the episode damaged US credibility, with former United States Trade Representative official Wendy Cutter saying, "It introduces even greater uncertainty, even once you think you've negotiated a deal, he (Mr Trump) can turn around and change the terms unilaterally and publicly. And in this case it appears that he did it unilaterally and publicly without any buy-in from Vietnam." Witch-Hunt Cries, 50% Tariff Threat Over Jair Bolsonaro Trial Mr Trump has turned global trade policy into a tool for personal grudges and political drama, with the Brazil episode being a prime example, sources said. He threatened a 50 per cent tariff on Brazilian goods unless President Lula da Silva stopped the trial of Jair Bolsonaro, Mr Trump's far-right ally and former Brazilian president. The threat was not based on trade concerns; the US actually enjoys a surplus with Brazil, but purely on ideological and personal grounds, officials said. Mr Trump openly called the trial a "witch hunt" and used his social media platform to put pressure on Brazil's democratic institutions, saying he told President Lula to "stop this nonsense" or face economic consequences. Blackmailed Columbia Into Tariffs: Deport Or Get Taxed Earlier this year, in a fresh episode of Mr Trump's coercive trade diplomacy, he threatened to slam Colombia with tariffs and sanctions, all because Bogota refused to accept two US military aircraft carrying deported Colombian nationals. Canada: "51st State Of US" In February, Mr Trump imposed a 25 per cent tariff on nearly all goods imported from Canada under the International Emergency Economic Powers Act (IEEPA), citing Canada's alleged role in the fentanyl crisis and illegal immigration as justification. The then Canadian Prime Minister Justin Trudeau called Mr Trump's tariff justification "completely bogus" and accused the US president of trying to harm the Canadian economy to facilitate annexation, a claim Mr Trump had joked about and later reiterated seriously in some contexts. Mr Trump subsequently raised tariffs on Canada to 35 per cent in mid-2025 due to perceived insufficient Canadian action to curb illicit drug flows into the US, and threatened a 40 per cent tariff on goods transhipped to evade tariffs. These unilateral tariff moves were widely criticised in Canada and internationally, seen as politically motivated, destabilising longstanding trade agreements and undermining North American economic integration. Mr Trump's remarks about annexing Canada and referring to Canadian leaders in derogatory terms contributed to the perception that his approach was more theatrical and confrontational than diplomatic, turning a bilateral relationship into a public spectacle of threats and retaliation. "White Genocide" And South Africa South Africa, a member of the BRICS grouping, has been hit with a steep 30 per cent tariff by the US, not over trade deficits, but politics and conspiracy. The move comes as Mr Trump escalates tensions with Pretoria over claims of a so-called "white genocide", a false narrative pushed by far-right circles and amplified within Trump's MAGA base, officials said. MAGA, short for Make American Great Again, is Mr Trump's campaign war cry. Instead of engaging through facts or diplomacy, Mr Trump appears to be weaponising tariffs to pander to extremist talking points, turning trade policy into a tool of political spectacle and disinformation, sources said. Brinkmanship Or Blackmail? Trump's 35% Tariff Sword Over EU In a fresh bout of economic blackmail, Mr Trump threatened a blanket 35 per cent tariff on goods from the European Union (EU) if they did not make a $600 billion investment, a demand tied to vague and shifting trade negotiations. On April 2, Mr Trump unleashed a wave of tariffs dubbed "Liberation Day," accusing the EU of "unfair trade practices." In swift retaliation, the EU announced counter-tariffs targeting politically sensitive US exports, including bourbon, Harley-Davidsons, and farm goods from key Republican states. Mr Trump's move had already slapped a 20 per cent tariff across a wide spectrum of EU imports, ranging from cars and pharmaceuticals to machinery and agriculture. By late July, Mr Trump abruptly shifted tactics, offering to reduce tariffs if the EU committed to a $600 billion investment in US infrastructure and manufacturing, a demand with no formal agreement, rationale or documentation. When the EU did not comply, Mr Trump escalated his threat to a 35 per cent blanket tariff, again without giving meaningful details or process. Trump's '100% Chip Tariffs' Hit Japan's Giants In another reckless trade salvo, Mr Trump imposed 100 per cent tariffs on semiconductor imports, hitting Japanese tech giants hard. Without warning or negotiation, Mr Trump's unilateral move threw Asia's supply chains into disarray and jeopardised key allies. Japanese giants Toyota and Honda were blindsided by the sweeping tariffs imposed by Mr Trump. Trump Strong-Arms Taiwan With Tariff Blackmail Tied To Intel Deal In another move blurring diplomacy, business and coercion, Mr Trump threatened Taiwan with a 15 per cent blanket tariff on its exports, unless the semiconductor giant TSMC agrees to buy a 49 per cent stake in Intel and pour $400 billion into the US economy. Surprise Tariff Rise For New Zealand In a sudden escalation, the Trump administration raised tariffs on New Zealand exports from 10 per cent to 15 per cent, drawing sharp criticism from Finance Minister Nicola Willis, who called it a "very blunt formula." Despite a longstanding friendship and trade imbalance already favouring the US, New Zealand has found itself penalised, highlighting Mr Trump's erratic, ally-agnostic trade playbook.
NDTV
13 minutes ago
- NDTV
Kashmir Mediation To Russian Oil: Trump's 'Un'Truth Social
New Delhi: US President Donald Trump has made several misleading or outright inaccurate statements about India -- from falsehoods regarding trade policy to the economy, Trump's remarks have frequently clashed with facts. Trump's announcement of 25 per cent additional tariffs on Indian goods triggered immediate diplomatic pushback from New Delhi and raised questions about Western consistency on Russian energy sanctions. Fact-checking Trump 1. "India Stopped Buying Russian Oil" Trump's Claim: "Well, I understand India no longer is going to be buying oil from Russia. That's what I heard. I don't know if that's right or not, but that's a good step." Fact Check: According to government sources, India continues to import Russian crude oil. 2. "India is the Tariff King" Trump's Claim: India is the "Tariff King" and an abuser of global trade rules. Fact Check: India's simple average tariff stands at 16 per cent, comparable to economies like Turkey (16.2 per cent) and Argentina (13.4 per cent). India's weighted average tariff is only 4.6 per cent. 3. "India is a Dead Economy" Trump's Claim: India is a "dead economy" and the US does "very little business" with India. Fact Check: Contrary to Trump's assertion, India remains the largest trading partner of the United States for the fourth consecutive year, with bilateral trade touching $131.84 billion in FY 2024-25. Indian exports to the US rose by 11.6 per cent, reaching $86.51 billion, and imports from the US stood at $45.33 billion. The two countries have set a target of $500 billion in bilateral trade by 2030 under the "Mission 500" roadmap. 4. Ceasefire Between India and Pakistan Trump's Claim: He personally brokered a ceasefire between India and Pakistan and prevented a nuclear conflict. Fact Check: There is no official evidence to support Trump's claim. Both Prime Minister Narendra Modi and External Affairs Minister S Jaishankar have clarified that no ceasefire was brokered by the United States. "At no stage, in any conversation with the United States, was there any linkage with trade and what was going on. Secondly, there was no talk between the Prime Minister and President Trump from the 22nd of April when President Trump called up to convey his sympathy, and the 17th of June, when he called up the Prime Minister in Canada to explain why he could not meet," Mr Jaishankar said in Parliament. 5. "1,000 Years War" Trump's Claim: "There have been tensions on that border for 1,500 years... a thousand-year fight in Kashmir." Fact Check: The India-Pakistan Kashmir conflict began in 1947 following the partition and independence of India. There is no historical basis for Trump's 1,000-year claim. Prior to 1947, Kashmir was a princely state under British rule and was not subject to the Indo-Pakistani conflict. 6. Kashmir Mediation Offer Trump's Claim: PM Modi asked him to mediate on Kashmir in 2019. Fact Check: India categorically denied that any such request was made. The Ministry of External Affairs stated: "No such request has been made by PM Modi to the US President. It has been India's consistent position that all outstanding issues with Pakistan are discussed only bilaterally." 7. "India Got A Sweeter Paris Deal" Trump's Claim: India got a "sweeter deal" under the Paris Climate Accord, which justified his withdrawal. Fact Check: India is the first G20 country to have met its Paris Climate Agreement targets. India's nationally determined contributions (NDCs) have been praised by international climate monitors. 8. "India is Taking American Jobs" Trump's Claim: "India is taking our jobs... It's not going to happen anymore, folks." Fact Check: Indian companies have created over 425,000 jobs in the United States, with $40 billion invested as per a 2023 Confederation of Indian Industry report. Additionally, Indian students contributed $7.7 billion annually to the US economy between 2019 and 2023. Indian-origin CEOs head major US. firms, including Google, Microsoft, IBM, and Adobe-driving American innovation and competitiveness.
