Return to sender: Court throws out bank's RM3.5mil claim on loan guarantors over wrong addresses
Justice Alexander Siew, sitting in Kota Kinabalu on Friday (July 11), dismissed the claim by the bank against two personal guarantors of a bai bithaman ajil (BBA) Islamic facility worth RM2.8mil granted to a company to finance the purchase of land in Kampung Ganggarak, Labuan.
The bank sued both the company and its guarantors on Nov 9, 2018, seeking full repayment, interest and costs after claiming the company allegedly defaulted in repayment.
Justice Siew, in his judgment, found that the bank's notices of demand had been addressed to the wrong addresses and, as such, the bank failed to make a demand on the defendants for repayment.
"As the guarantees were on-demand in nature, the failure to serve valid demand notices was fatal to the bank's case," he said in dismissing the claim against the guarantors, awarding RM10,000 in costs to each.
The guarantors' counsel Datuk Seri K. Rakhbir Singh had submitted to the court that the bank's notices of demand were fundamentally defective.
'The plaintiff (bank) keeps repeating that it had issued the notices. However, this is not the point of contention. The point of contention is that the notices were all sent to the wrong addresses," he argued.
The court, however, allowed the bank's claim against the company with costs on separate grounds, in line with the position that the writ itself could constitute sufficient demand against a principal borrower.
Rakbhir later said the ruling reaffirms that strict compliance with procedural requirements is not a mere technicality, but a fundamental element in the enforcement of guarantees.
"The case stands as a timely reminder to lenders that shortcuts in service and notice can prove costly, even in claims worth millions," he added.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New Straits Times
an hour ago
- New Straits Times
Johari: RM1.4b over five years to replant ageing oil palm trees
JOHOR BARU: Under the 13th Malaysia Plan (13MP), the government is expected to allocate RM1.4 billion over the next five years to support smallholders in replanting ageing oil palm trees. Plantation and Commodities Minister Datuk Seri Johari Abdul Ghani said today that the initiative aligns with the government's goal of strengthening Malaysia's position as the world's second-largest palm oil producer. "The parliamentary debate on the 13MP begins tomorrow, and we expect valuable feedback from members of parliament." Johari added that the ministry is making a strong push to assist smallholders with replanting. He said about RM1.4 billion will be required over five years — not annually — to encourage smallholders to rejuvenate aging plantations with higher-yielding varieties. He said this after officiating the Umno Johor Baru conference here, accompanied by division chief Datuk Yahya Jaafar. He was responding to questions about the 13MP, which was tabled in Parliament on Thursday by Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim. While tabling the 13MP, Anwar reaffirmed the government's resolve to revitalise strategic sectors, including agricultural commodities, the halal industry, and Islamic finance, by boosting productivity in palm oil, rubber, and cocoa through modern technologies such as mechanisation, automation, robotics and targeted R&D. Johari, who also serves as the natural resources and environmental sustainability minister, said an aggressive replanting initiative would boost Malaysia's export potential and strengthen its global market share. "Malaysia's commodity exports stand at about RM115 billion, and this replanting initiative is expected to contribute to our export growth. "If we can upgrade and replant large areas of ageing oil palm trees, it will boost our capacity and competitiveness in the global palm oil market."
The Star
8 hours ago
- The Star
Digital bank: A promising start, with more to unfold
Bank Negara governor Datuk Seri Abdul Rasheed Ghaffour KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia's digital banking journey is making good progress and has great promise in addressing unserved and underserved segments, said Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) Governor Datuk Seri Abdul Rasheed Ghaffour. In an exclusive interview with Bernama, the central bank governor said licensed digital banks have just begun operations, with most now focusing on growing their deposit base. "We have been seeing very good progress with deposits coming in from both underserved and unserved segments,' he said. On the financing side, Abdul Rasheed said most digital banks have yet to fully roll out their credit products to the general public. "In fact, the digital banks are still at the 'foundational phase', where they are subject to asset size limitations. It's still too early to come up with an assessment. "Products are gradually being introduced, with some being offered mainly to target groups, such as staff and families, before the full public rollout. "We will consider all the key data from the digital banks to come up with an assessment as to whether digital banks meet our ultimate aim of serving the underserved and unserved," he said. Malaysia has five licensed digital banks, namely GXBank, AEON Bank, Boost Bank, KAF Digital Bank and Ryt Bank. The five digital banks were awarded their licences on April 29, 2022 by BNM after being approved by the Ministry of Finance (MoF). Of the five, four have commenced offering their products to the public, providing a range of digital financial services, including personal banking, business solutions and Islamic banking products. GX Bank, the Grab-led digital bank, was the first to receive approval to begin operations on Sept 1, 2023. This was followed by Boost Bank, a digital banking venture formed by Boost (Axiata) and RHB Banking Group, which commenced operations on Jan 15, 2024, and AEON Bank, Malaysia's first fully Islamic digital bank that was officially launched and commenced operations on May 26, 2024. MoF granted KAF Digital and RYT Bank licences to commence their operations on Dec 20, 2024. KAF Digital is the operating entity established by an Islamic digital bank consortium, comprising Carsome, MoneyMatch, Jirnexu and StoreHub, with KAF Investment Bank Bhd at the helm. Meanwhile, YTL Digital Bank Bhd -- formed through a joint venture between YTL Digital Capital Sdn Bhd and Sea Ltd to operate as Ryt Bank -- provides a suite of services, including single-text input fund transfers and tailored financial insights, via its artificial intelligence (AI)-equipped platform. - Bernama
New Straits Times
8 hours ago
- New Straits Times
Digital bank: A promising start, with more to unfold
KUALA LUMPUR: Malaysia's digital banking journey is making good progress and has great promise in addressing unserved and underserved segments, said Bank Negara Malaysia (BNM) Governor Datuk Seri Abdul Rasheed Ghaffour. In an exclusive interview with Bernama, the central bank governor said licensed digital banks have just begun operations, with most now focusing on growing their deposit base. "We have been seeing very good progress with deposits coming in from both underserved and unserved segments," he said. On the financing side, Abdul Rasheed said most digital banks have yet to fully roll out their credit products to the general public. "In fact, the digital banks are still at the 'foundational phase', where they are subject to asset size limitations. It's still too early to come up with an assessment. "Products are gradually being introduced, with some being offered mainly to target groups, such as staff and families, before the full public rollout. "We will consider all the key data from the digital banks to come up with an assessment as to whether digital banks meet our ultimate aim of serving the underserved and unserved," he said. Malaysia has five licensed digital banks, namely GXBank, AEON Bank, Boost Bank, KAF Digital Bank and Ryt Bank. The five digital banks were awarded their licences on April 29, 2022 by BNM after being approved by the Ministry of Finance (MoF). Of the five, four have commenced offering their products to the public, providing a range of digital financial services, including personal banking, business solutions and Islamic banking products. GX Bank, the Grab-led digital bank, was the first to receive approval to begin operations on Sept 1, 2023. This was followed by Boost Bank, a digital banking venture formed by Boost (Axiata) and RHB Banking Group, which commenced operations on Jan 15, 2024, and AEON Bank, Malaysia's first fully Islamic digital bank that was officially launched and commenced operations on May 26, 2024. MoF granted KAF Digital and RYT Bank licences to commence their operations on Dec 20, 2024. KAF Digital is the operating entity established by an Islamic digital bank consortium, comprising Carsome, MoneyMatch, Jirnexu and StoreHub, with KAF Investment Bank Bhd at the helm. Meanwhile, YTL Digital Bank Bhd -- formed through a joint venture between YTL Digital Capital Sdn Bhd and Sea Ltd to operate as Ryt Bank -- provides a suite of services, including single-text input fund transfers and tailored financial insights, via its artificial intelligence (AI)-equipped platform.
