"Failure At Age Of Eating Chocolates": Tamil Nadu Minister On Big CBSE Move
Quick Take
Summary is AI generated, newsroom reviewed.
Tamil Nadu Education Minister Anbil Mahesh Poyyamozhi criticised CBSE for failing students of Classes 5 and 8, calling it anti-education. He urged parents to challenge this decision, warning it could increase dropout rates and mental stress.
Chennai:
In a sharp escalation of tensions with the Centre, Tamil Nadu Education Minister Anbil Mahesh Poyyamozhi slammed the Central Board of Secondary Education (CBSE) for failing Class 5 and 8 students under the National Education Policy (NEP) 2020, calling the move "anti-education".
He also urged parents to "question and challenge" the CBSE's decision. This comes amid reports that CBSE schools have started collecting signed consent forms from parents of the poor-performing students.
The state, which follows a no-failure policy until Class 8, warned that enforcing exams with detention risks will exacerbate school dropout rates and mental stress among children. "How can children who are still in the age of eating chocolates be expected to understand failure?" he questioned.
Although there is a provision for failed students to re-take the tests in two months, Mr Poyyamozhi said failing students at such a young age will only push them out of the education system. "Imagine the pressure and stigma children labelled as 'failed' will face," he said.
Poyyamozhi argued that introducing high-stakes public exams for Classes 5 and 8 contradicts its efforts to ensure universal access to education and even provisions of the Right to Education. "This move will reverse decades of progress in reducing dropout rates, particularly among marginalised communities," the state Education Minister stated. He added "We have no dropoutsbin elementary level".
Tamil Nadu has long opposed the NEP, which advocates a three-language system, citing its conflict with the state's egalitarian education model.
The state government highlighted additional concerns, including exit options after Class 10 that could "prematurely push students out of formal education".
Chief Minister MK Stalin recently declared his government would "not accept the NEP even if offered Rs 10,000 crore", reaffirming the ruling Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam's (DMK) resistance to what it calls a "divisive" policy.
Tamil Nadu also said the NEP of undermining social justice by discontinuing scholarships for SC, ST and OBC students and introducing national-level entrance tests for arts and science colleges, which could disadvantage rural and economically weaker students.
Further criticism targeted the NEP's vocational education framework, which the state claims enforces "caste-based roles" from Class 6, potentially perpetuating social hierarchies. The DMK has also vehemently opposed the three-language policy, alleging it covertly imposes Hindi and Sanskrit. "Kendriya Vidyalaya schools in the state already lack Tamil teachers, reflecting a deliberate push to sideline regional languages," Poyyamozhi added.
Recently, Tamil Nadu had accused the Union Education Ministry of withholding Rs 2,150 crore funds earmarked for the state under the ongoing Samagra Shiksha programme for their non-acceptance of the National Education Policy.
The Centre argues the NEP aims to improve the quality of education across India. Denying that the three-language policy imposes Hindi, it claims the policy only promotes mother tongue learning and strengthens native Indian languages.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
33 minutes ago
- Time of India
'Not a single thing will move forward: Arvind Kejriwal warns of ‘development freeze' if AAP loses Ludhiana West byelection; praises Sanjeev Arora
Arvind Kerjriwal LUDHIANA: AAP chief Arvind Kejriwal on Wednesday issued a veiled ultimatum to voters in Ludhiana West, warning that public works and development would grind to a halt if they fail to elect AAP candidate Sanjeev Arora in the June 19 byelection. "If you vote for any other party, not a single thing will move forward," Kejriwal told a rally at Sanet village, where he campaigned alongside Punjab CM Bhagwant Mann . "Only an AAP MLA can get your work done." Kejriwal doubled down by promising Arora a cabinet berth in the Mann govt if elected. "Ministers have their own funds and powers. Elect Arora, and Ludhiana West will see unprecedented development," he said, tying basic civic work directly to the party's electoral success. The remarks, though delivered with typical campaign flair, triggered sharp criticism for the implied threat to stall public services if voters reject the ruling party's nominee. At the event, Kejriwal praised Arora as humble, accessible, and a "true Sikh" guided by Guru Sahib's values. He contrasted him with Congress candidate Bharat Bhushan Ashu, branding Ashu as arrogant and ineffective. "He can't bring funds; he only abuses Bhagwant Mann," Kejriwal said. Kejriwal cited Arora's prior involvement in resolving over 70% of long-pending registry issues in Sanet as proof of his capability. "We visited in March, and I gave Arora the task. He delivered within two months. Elect him, and the rest will be sorted within a month," he said. CM Mann echoed the sentiment, vowing that Arora's elevation would fast-track development. "Other govts start working in their final months. We started on day one," he said, touting AAP's record of hiring 54,154 govt employees based on merit, not political recommendation. He also praised Arora's philanthropic work, including a Rs 16 crore fundraiser for a child with a rare disease, and cited improved govt school results, functioning Mohalla Clinics, and reforms in water and energy sectors as evidence of AAP's delivery-focused governance.
Hans India
34 minutes ago
- Hans India
A tightrope walk as debt burden weighs
Vijayawada: It has been a tightrope walk for the Telugu Desam Party (TDP)-led National Democratic Alliance government in Andhra Pradesh, which is completing one year in office on Thursday (today), and its Chief Minister Nara Chandrababu Naidu. Though the government under the leadership of Naidu initiated a slew of measures to boost economic growth and implemented welfare schemes, it had to work against all odds given the debt burden that weighed on the State. Naidu, who assumed charge as of AP Chief Minister for the fourth time on June 12, 2024, frequently said he started off with a millstone around his neck. He pointed out that the previous government had pushed the state back by 30 years, burdening it with Rs 10 lakh crore in debts and another Rs 1.2 lakh crore in unpaid bills. 'The annual interest alone stands at Rs 40,000 crore,' he remarked when the NDA government assumed office. Looking back, the Chief Minister said recently: 'Brick by brick, we are rebuilding the devastated state and in just one year, we have shown what good governance looks like by giving priority to both welfare and development.' Minister for Information and Public Relations K Parthasarathi told Hans India that the one-year period of the NDA government focused on both welfare and development. He said both Chief Minister Chandrababu Naidu and IT Minister Nara Lokesh aimed at wealth creation and uplift of the poor, simultaneously implementing welfare schemes. He said the coalition government had laid a solid foundation for the benefit of future generations. To begin with, the NDA government enhanced the old age pension to Rs 4,000 per month. Apart from that, it has been distributing pension amounts of Rs 6,000, Rs 10,000 and Rs 15,000 to various categories of people including physically challenged. The state government is spending a whopping Rs 33,000 crore a year on pensions to 64 lakh people. No other state government pays such high pension amounts in the country. In addition, under Deepam 2, the NDA government is giving three free LPG cylinders per year to women. Besides, the state government revived 73 central schemes, though the previous government had diverted central funds, resulting in AP being blacklisted. The NDA government is now planning to provide free solar rooftops to 20 lakh SC/ST houses under PM Surya Ghar Yojana. Upon taking office, the NDA govt repealed the Land Titling Act that had removed protection for people's lands and introduced a new Anti-Land Grabbing Act. With the Centre's support, the state government put the much-awaited Polavaram Project back on track. The project will now be completed by December 2027.
The Hindu
38 minutes ago
- The Hindu
U.S. hyphenating India, Pak; PM must drop 'stubbornness' and call special session of Parliament: Congress
The U.S. is constantly making statements which can only be interpreted to mean that it is hyphenating India and Pakistan, the Congress said on Thursday (June 12, 2025) and stressed that Prime Minister Narendra Modi should leave aside his "stubbornness" to call an all-party meeting and a special session of Parliament. Congress general secretary in-charge communications Jairam Ramesh asserted in a post on X that decades of diplomatic progress cannot be allowed to be weakened so easily. "It is reported that Pakistani Army Chief General Asim Munir has been invited to the event organised in Washington DC on the occasion of US Army Day (14 June). This news is a big setback for India from a diplomatic and strategic point of view," Mr. Ramesh said in the post in Hindi. "This is the same person who used provocative and inciting language just before the Pahalgam terror attack - the question arises what is America's intention," the Congress general secretary said. Recently, the head of the US Central Command also stated that Pakistan is a "great partner" of America in the fight against terrorism, Mr. Ramesh said. "The Modi government is saying that Operation Sindoor is still going on. In such a situation, the Pakistani army chief's participation as a guest in the US Army Day is definitely a matter of serious concern," he said. Mr. Ramesh said the Trump administration is constantly making statements which can only be interpreted to mean that it is "hyphenating" India and Pakistan. "The Prime Minister is welcoming the delegation that returned after informing the entire world, including the US, about Pakistan's role in supporting terrorism, and at the same time, such news is coming from Washington DC makes India's diplomatic position even more uncomfortable," Mr. Ramesh said. "The Prime Minister should now leave aside his stubbornness and concern for prestige and call an all-party meeting and a special session of Parliament, so that the nation can clearly express its collective will and a concrete roadmap can be presented to the country," he said. Decades of diplomatic progress cannot be allowed to be weakened so easily, he added. With US Army General Michael Kurilla, Commander of US Central Command (CENTCOM), calling Pakistan a "phenomenal partner" in the counterterrorism world, the Congress on Wednesday asked what PM Modi had to say about this and whether it was not a "diplomatic setback". The opposition party also referred to remarks by a Trump administration spokesperson highlighting President Donald Trump's diplomatic and negotiating skills as having the power to end "generational differences", wondering whether something is cooking in Washington DC. It asked Prime Minister Modi to issue a clarification on it. Mr. Ramesh had also cited a media report which claimed that Pakistan's Chief of Army Staff General Syed Asim Munir is scheduled to visit Washington DC for the US Army Day celebrations and said this is "another huge diplomatic setback for India". US Army General Michael Kurilla, Commander of US Central Command (CENTCOM), has said the United States has to have a relationship with Pakistan and with India, and noted that it cannot be a "binary switch" where Washington cannot have ties with Islamabad if it has relations with New Delhi. Kurilla made the comments during a testimony before the US House Armed Services Committee on Tuesday. Pakistan is "in an active counterterrorism fight right now and they have been a phenomenal partner in the counterterrorism world", the general said. Kurilla's comments came days after an all-party Indian parliamentary delegation visited the US to convey India's strong resolve to combat terrorism emanating from Pakistan in the wake of the April 22 Pahalgam terror attack that claimed 26 lives.
