The 'Ugly Duckling' Scenario Of New Hires: A Tale Of Misalignment

Forbes

17-06-2025

Naira Velumyan, Ph.D., Communication/Relationship Coach, Etiquette Expert, Founder of the Academy of Social Competency.
In today's performance-driven world, people change workplaces, roles and even industries for a variety of reasons, and this transition is rarely as smooth as we would wish.
A survey by Monster showed that 54% of employees surveyed had left a job within the first six months, with burnout and a mismatch between the role and what was described in the interview being the biggest reasons for these exits.
From an organizational perspective, the consequences are significant, as employers face financial losses not only from employee replacement but also from prolonged low-productivity periods of adaptation. Gallup estimates that each employee departure costs the company roughly one-half to twice their annual salary.
Given these staggering numbers, it's no surprise that both employers and employees struggle during this vulnerable "new hire" stage, meaning that both sides need to address the problem. I think the process of a new hire's journey has insightful parallels with the classic tale of "The Ugly Duckling." Just like the ugly duckling, a new hire in the initial integration phase may feel out of place, anxious and uncertain about belonging. They may also be perceived by co-workers and superiors as hesitant, withdrawn or underperforming.
Like the ugly duckling, new employees often internalize the stressful discomforts caused by real or imaginary signs of mistrust or rejection. You need to remember that discomfort is normal in new ecosystems, including being unfamiliar with new standards, experiencing complex emotional turbulences and trying different behavioral strategies to cope.
Just because you feel out of place doesn't mean you lack value or capability. Therefore, rather than trying to prove yourself to anyone, invest your energy in observation, reflection and real growth. Focus on learning and evolving, so that you can rise above any perceived negative opinions, showing your true worth.
The turning point in the duckling's journey was not convincing the barnyard creatures that it belonged—it was finding its fellow swans. In the new workplace, don't exhaust yourself to win over everyone. Instead, build relationships with those who are supportive and value-aligned. Seek out those quiet allies who will help anchor your confidence while the rest catch up.
Don't tie your self-worth to immediate performance. It is widely recognized that new employees don't function at full productivity—one estimate is that they work at about 25% productivity in their first month, increase to 75% by weeks nine through 12 and reach full productivity only after the 12-week mark. Take your time to grow confidently!
Stop comparing yourself to others by irrelevant measures, as it will only erode your self-confidence. Reflect on your own progress and wins, no matter how big or small. Being motivated to grow is always beneficial, especially for your own development.
Fitting in requires conformity, but belonging should not conflict with individuality. Your goal isn't to be like everyone else, but to contribute your unique strengths to the team. Belonging begins with self-acceptance and grows through authentic contribution.
High-performing teams are built not on uniformity but on complementary differences.
Feeling like a fraud in a new role is common, even for advanced professionals. As a new employee, you may experience this not because of a lack of competence but because you've seen no evidence of competence yet. This feeling can be fueled by your expectation that you must perform in your new role or responsibilities perfectly; however, the process of adaptation is not only about effort but also time.
The fable of the "ugly duckling" is about being judged by appearance, not potential. Employers must recognize that early awkwardness or quietness isn't a lack of ability—rather, it may be part of psychological adaptation to a new environment, a natural and time-limited process.
Expecting the new hire to perform by the company's standards from the very start is like expecting a baby swan to act according to the barnyard rules of which they are not yet aware. Onboarding requires a combination of mentoring, gradual exposure to responsibilities and reasonable time for integration while building psychological safety.
The "duckling" didn't fit in at the barnyard, but it had something rare to offer. Many companies prioritize conformity over innovation, unintentionally excluding many who could bring meaningful evolution. Immediate conformity may not reflect the duckling's true value and alignment.
Too often, new hires are left in social isolation, which can make even promising individuals feel unappreciated or out of place. Integration isn't just logistical, but also emotional and relational. Therefore, ensure structured peer introductions, assign onboarding buddies and establish rituals of integration to make new hires feel comfortable.
The workplace culture can help with your new hire's professional integration, but can also erode it. While feedback, openness to questions and acknowledgment of effort help to adapt, a dismissive environment can instill self-doubt before the employee even has a chance to perform. So, encourage instead of criticizing.
The "ugly duckling" phase is not a failure; it is an interactive journey of discovery, adaptation and recalibration. When employees and employers recognize the psychological complexity of this phase and allow space for growth without judgment, both sides will co-create a workplace where potential becomes performance and difference becomes strength!
Forbes Coaches Council is an invitation-only community for leading business and career coaches. Do I qualify?