Battle for Bradfield hits High Court, to be decided by 150 disputed ballot papers
Nicolette Boele was awarded the seat of Bradfield in north Sydney by 26 votes, or 50.01 per cent of the two candidate preferred, at May's federal election.
Ms Kapterian's legal challenge in the Court of Disputed Returns began on Friday, with Chief Justice Stephen Gageler referring the trial to the Federal Court in NSW.
'The trial will primarily be concerned with the formality of in excess of 150 disputed ballot papers,' he said.
The ballot papers will now be re-examined to ensure all numbers were legible.
While Ms Kapterian is challenging the Australian Electoral Commission's decision to award Ms Boele the seat, Ms Boele will remain the representative for Bradfield.
Ms Boele has been sworn into parliament, and delivered her maiden speech in the House of Representatives.
Ahead of the Friday's hearing she vowed to continue to serve her electorate.
'This is the next step in Australia's strong and trusted democratic process,' she said.
'I have every confidence in the court, the AEC, and the integrity of their work.
'While the court challenge proceeds, I'm focused on delivering the genuine representation Bradfield voted for.'
She has also sought donations from her community to cover the legal costs of the court case, while vowing to either return the money or donate the funds to a nominated cause if the Liberal Party is ordered to pay her costs.
The battle for Bradfield comes after a whirlwind count, which initially awarded the electorate in Ms Boele's favour on a margin of eight votes.
However the ultra-slim margin, under 100 votes, triggered an automatic recount, which declared Ms Boele the winner.
The result was then challenged by Ms Kapterian about 10 weeks following the election on July 15, largely on the premise of the conflicting counts.
The Liberal hopeful said her court bid was not about challenging the 'integrity of our electoral system' but was done to ensure 'the intentions of the voters of Bradfield are accurately reflected in the final count'.
Ms Kapterian's legal team has not asked for the election result to be made void, which would trigger a by-election.
'Pursuing this final step will provide collective confidence that the final result reflects the true wishes of the voters in Bradfield and remove any remaining doubt created by the two conflicting counts,' she said previously.
'Every vote counts'.
This year's May 3 election was the first time the blue-ribbon electorate has been held by a non-Liberal MP.
It was previously held by former minister Paul Fletcher who retired ahead of the 2025 poll.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
4 hours ago
- ABC News
Renewable energy expert accuses Victorian government of concealing true cost of transition plan
Energy experts have accused the Victorian government of concealing the true cost of its plan to transition the state to renewable power. The government has released its final Victorian Transmission Plan (VTP), which outlines the investment and development needed for the state to achieve its goal to reach its targets of 65 per cent renewable energy generation by 2030 and 95 per cent by 2035. The plan divides the state into six onshore energy zones and a Gippsland offshore zone. It names seven priority projects to expand renewable power generation and infrastructure, including offshore wind in Gippsland and new transmission lines between Sydenham and Tarrone, Truganina and Deer Park, and Hazelwood and Yallourn. It was compiled by government body VicGrid, which has costed the shift to renewable generation at $7.9 billion dollars. It said the seven new projects were needed in addition to existing transmission projects, such as Marinus Link, Victoria to New South Wales Interconnector West and Western Renewables Link. In announcing the plan, Energy Minister Lily D'Ambrosio said Victoria had the most ambitious renewable energy targets in Australia. "Coal generators are getting older, they're getting less reliable and they're closing," Ms D'Ambrosio said. "Our government has been very clear in our ambition to grow the necessary replacement electricity that we need to sustain our way of life." VicGrid suggested the VTP would lead to cheaper wholesale power prices. "Overall VicGrid's modelling suggests that Victorian energy bills could be $20 lower per household and $50 lower per small business each year (real $2025)," the report stated. Those figures have been described as "nonsense" by the director of the Victoria Energy Policy Centre at Victoria University, Bruce Mountain. "I don't think this is a plausible plan," Professor Mountain said. Mr Mountain estimated the plan could cost up to $28 billion over the next decade. He said there was no doubt that Victoria needed to expand its clean energy production, but he accused the government of using "sleight of hand" tactics to disguise the true cost. "They are only including a very small subset of the transmission expansion plan that they have set out and they've done that by simply relegating the vast bulk of the expenditure into what they call the base case. "I think the government is petrified of the actual outlays that their plan entail." He said households and businesses would face substantially higher bills over the next decade. "It might well be that if the government proceeds with this plan, customers will simply find it unaffordable and so then taxpayers will be forced to bear some large part of it. "I estimate small household bills will increase by about half. "Large bills paid by large industry, for whom the electricity transmission charge is a much bigger portion of their bill, they can expect bills to increase by between two-and-a-half and three-and-a-half times." The $7.9 billion dollar figure stated in the VTP was double the cost estimate Ms D'Ambrosio gave to a parliament estimates committee two months ago. On Saturday, she attributed the rise to updated transmission costs projections by the Australian Energy Market Operator. "That report itself has already indicated pressures on building costs right across the country," Ms D'Ambrosio said. "But can I say, unequivocally, the cost of not building the projects in the Victorian transmission plan will end up costing every Victorian far more through increased energy bills." Mr Mountain disagreed with Ms D'Ambrosio's assessment. "It's kind of a refuge of the scoundrel to say 'but for our plan, something else would happen' when of course you conjure up any other possibility." Senior fellow of the Energy Program at Grattan Institute, Tony Wood, agreed the figures given in the VTP were misleading. "When it talks about the potential for consumer bills, household bills being $20 per annum less because of this plan, that's not less where they are now, that's less than what they would have been if we had a different plan," Mr Wood said. "Does that mean that we can expect our bills to go up or down? It's not clear at all." But Mr Wood said the plan was important for Victoria's future. "For the first time really, we've got a comprehensive plan on how we're going to build renewable energy in Victoria to replace coal and connect all that renwable energy into the grid. "That's a very important step forward." Opposition leader Brad Battin said Victorian power bills were already too high. "Household energy is getting to a stage that people genuinely can't afford it. Businesses are closing because they can't afford to pay the price of energy here in our state." VicGrid had originally proposed seven onshore zones. But todays final VTP revealed VicGrid has consolidated the Wimmera Southern Mallee and Grampians zones into the single Western renewable energy zone. It said modifications were also made to the zones following feedback from regional communities and Traditional Owners about the need to protect farmland, minimise the effects on biodiversity, water systems and regional areas, and account for natural hazards such as bushfires and flooding. It also said it had expanded the total size of the energy zones after the industry said it needed larger areas to develop technically and commercially viable renewable projects. The VTP has been heavily opposed by some communities, with some farmers vowing to lock developers out of their land. The report sets out that companies proposing projects would need to negotiate with landholders for the right to use their properties, declaring owners would have the right to say no to having new renewable generation on their land. "Landholders who do agree to new renewable development will receive financial compensation that is negotiated with the developer," the report states. Western Victorian farmer Ross Johns is the president of the Wimmera Mallee Environmental and Agricultural Protection Association. He said the final VTP has not provided any certainty or reassurance for farmers. "The government just keeps changing the plans, the rules, the objectives, how it's going to occur," Mr Johns said. Mr Johns said energy projects disrupt agricultural operations and amenities for rural communities. "It looks like to me government doesn't really fully understand the issues. "The footprint of some of these transmission lines is huge, like it's 40 metres by 40 metres so that land will never be able to farmed or operated again. "If it goes angle ways across the paddock, it actually significantly impacts the commercial viability of those farming operations." He declared the government would have to build the new infrastructure 'through enemy territory'. 'What you've got is a bunch of rural people and farmers who are extremely resourceful. Farmer Ben Duxson from Marnoo, also in Victoria's Wimmera region, said his community felt like it was being railroaded by the government. "Our stance has always been that they need to stop and actually get an energy plan that's good for Australia for the next 100 to 200 years and this certainly isn't a plan that's going to do that," Mr Duxson said. "We'll stand in our gateways and we'll fight." Alex Rae is on the board for the Golden Paradise Beach Community Development Fund, which represents communities affected by the Gippsland Shoreline Renewable Energy Zone. He said the communities of Golden Beach and Paradise Beach had been sidelined. "We've put in submissions [and] raised concerns throughout the process with VicGrid, but it just feels like our voice is being dismissed because we're small communities," Mr Rae said. "The maps don't even acknowledge us as being directly in front of the offshore wind zone, where turbines will permanently industrialise the seascape." Mr Rae said projects like Navigator North already had plans to install turbines about 30 kilometres from the coast, which would affect property prices and the local tourism industry. "We're not against renewables of course, but you we are talking about potentially hundreds of these turbines all the way along the coast. "[We are] tiny coastal towns and a lot of the economy here for the small businesses rely on tourism.
SBS Australia
4 hours ago
- SBS Australia
'Exiles have no home': Australia grants asylum to Hong Kong democracy activist
Hong Kong pro-democracy activist Ted Hui has been granted asylum in Australia, the former lawmaker said, more than four years after he left Hong Kong, where he faces criminal charges over the 2019 pro-democracy protests. Hui said he received written notice from the Australian Department of Home Affairs on Friday approving his claim and that his wife, children and parents were also granted visas. "When people around me say 'congratulations' to me, although I politely thank them, I can't help but feel sad in my heart. How to congratulate a political refugee who misses his hometown?" posted on Facebook. "If it weren't for political persecution, I would never have thought of living in a foreign land. Immigrants can always return to their home towns to visit relatives at any time; Exiles have no home." The Home Affairs Department did not immediately respond to emailed questions sent after business hours. The Hong Kong government said in a statement it was "against the harbouring of criminals in any form by any country". China's foreign ministry did not respond to questions about the decision. Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese visited Beijing last month as part of his administration's years-long push to improve ties with China. A former Democratic Party lawmaker, Hui left Hong Kong in late 2020 after facing criminal charges over the 2019 pro-democracy protests. In July, Hong's national security police issued fresh arrest warrants for Hui — including three other Australian residents — accusing him of subversion, with a bounty of at least HK$200,000 ($38,807). Fellow Hong Kong activist Tony Chung said on Sunday he had been granted asylum by Britain, in a post on his X account. He was sentenced to three years and seven months in prison in late 2021 after being convicted of secession and money laundering. Pro-democracy businessman Jimmy Lai is on trial in Hong Kong on charges related to a national security law imposed by Beijing and alleged sedition.
ABC News
5 hours ago
- ABC News
Former pro-democracy Hong Kong politician Ted Hui granted asylum in Australia
Former pro-democracy politician Ted Hui — who is wanted by authorities in Hong Kong — has been granted asylum in Australia. He said the Australian government granted him a protection visa this week, with asylum also extending to his wife, children and parents. "I express my sincere gratitude to the government of Australia — both present and former — for recognising our need for asylum and granting us this protection," Mr Hui said in a Facebook post on Saturday. Hong Kong has seen dissent quashed since Beijing imposed a sweeping national security law following huge — and at times violent — democracy protests that erupted in 2019. Mr Hui was a high-profile participant at the time in those protests and was arrested in China. He later settled in Adelaide. A vocal critic of Hong Kong and Beijing authorities, Mr Hui is among several overseas activists targeted in 2023 by police bounties of $HK1 million ($200,000) each. The bounties are seen as largely symbolic, given that they affect people living abroad in nations unlikely to extradite political activists to Hong Kong or China. Hong Kong's government has not commented directly on Mr Hui's case; however, a spokesperson said on Saturday local time that those who absconded should not think they could evade "criminal liability". "Any country that harbours Hong Kong criminals in any form shows contempt for the rule of law, grossly disrespects Hong Kong's legal systems and barbarically interferes in the affairs of Hong Kong," the spokesperson said. Mr Hui ended his Facebook post by calling on Canberra to do more for those who "face long sentences for simply defending basic democratic rights". He urged the Australian government not to forget the other Hong Kong pro-democracy activists who remained jailed, including tycoon Jimmy Lai, who has been behind bars since 2020. "Australia must do more to rescue them and to speak up for their humanity," Mr Hui said. "Its stance matters internationally, and its protection of Hongkongers sets a precedent for other democracies." Australian Foreign Affairs Minister Penny Wong previously condemned Hong Kong's arrest warrants and bounties. "Freedom of expression and assembly are essential to our democracy, and we will support those in Australia who exercise those rights," she said in 2023. "Australia remains deeply concerned by the continuing erosion of Hong Kong's rights, freedoms and autonomy." ABC/Wires
