In Hindus, there's Moksh: Supreme Court on 'waqf is charity to God' argument
"In Hindus, there's Moksh," the Supreme Court remarked on Thursday as it heard petitioners responding to Centre's arguments in favour of the Waqf (Amendment) Act, 2025.The development came a day after the Centre told the court that waqf is nothing but charity and is not an essential part of Islam.In response to Centre's argument, senior advocate Kapil Sibal, representing the petitioners, told the court today, "Waqf is a dedication to God, for afterlife. Unlike others, Waqf is a charity to God. Charity is to a community, Waqf is a dedication to God. This is for the future, for a spiritual benefit."advertisement
To this, the Chief Justice remarked, "In Hindus, there's a concept of Moksha". Justice Augustine George Masih echoed the Chief Justice, referring to a similar provision in Christianity, saying, "we all try to get to heaven".Countering the Centre' argument, Advocate Rajiv Dhawan said that, according to the Vedas, temples are not an essential part of Hinduism. "There is a provision to worshipping nature. There are gods of fire, water and rain. There are mountains, oceans etc".Notably, the petitioners had earlier claimed that waqf is basically charity in the name of God, to which the Centre had replied that charity is integral to all religions."Waqf is an Islamic concept. But it is not an essential part of Islam... Waqf is nothing but just charity in Islam. Judgments show that charity is part of every religion and can happen for Christianity also. Hindus have a system of daan. Sikhs also have it," Solicitor General Tushar Mehta had said on Wednesday.advertisement"Charity is a fundamental principle of other religions also," Chief Justice Gavai said on Thursday, apparently intending to draw parallels between religions when it came to donations.Sibal then raked up the provision paving the way for non-Hindus to be included in the Central Waqf Council and state waqf boards, saying that as far as the endowment of Hindu religious places is concerned, non-Hindus are not included in it."But as far as waqf is concerned, here also non-Muslims are not included in it. The reservation for four persons has been made for non-Muslims. In my opinion, even one is enough".
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
26 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Amid NEP row, Madras HC tells Centre to consider paying RTE funds to T.N. by delinking it from Samagra Shiksha
The Madras High Court on Tuesday (June 10, 2025) directed the Union Ministry of Education to consider splitting the disbursal of funds to the Tamil Nadu government under its flagship Samagra Shiksha scheme, so that money needed to reimburse private schools under the Right of Children to Free and Compulsory Education (RTE) Act can be disbursed. The RTE component amounts to about ₹200 crore, while the total amount pending to Tamil Nadu under the SSS amounts to ₹2,151.59 crore, amidst a row over the State's refusal to implement the National Education Policy, 2020. The court also told the State government that non-receipt of funds from the Centre cannot be used as a 'reason to wriggle out' of its own obligation to pay the private schools. Concurrent responsibility A Division Bench of Justices G.R. Swaminathan and V. Lakshminarayanan noted that the Centre had some issues in releasing SSS funds as the State government has not adopted the NEP. However, it has an independent obligation under the RTE Act of 2009, which has nothing to do with non-adoption of NEP, the judges said. 'Section 7 of the RTE Act states that the Central government and the State governments have concurrent responsibility for providing funds for carrying out the provisions of the Act... Therefore, funds payable to the State Government representing the Central Government's share towards discharging the RTE obligations need not be linked to NEP 2020,' the Division Bench observed. Since the Tamil Nadu government had already filed a civil suit before the Supreme Court demanding release of SSS funds of ₹2,151.59 crore, the judges said: 'We are not in a position to issue any binding direction in this regard,' and stopped with issuing a direction to the Centre to merely 'consider' delinking the RTE component from the SSS funds and disbursing the amount accordingly. T.N. cannot 'wiggle out' On the other hand, taking note of various judicial precedents, the Division Bench directed the State government to reimburse the private schools which make admissions under the RTE Act. 'The State government has an obligation to reimburse private unaided schools. Non-receipt of funds from the Union Government cannot be cited as a reason to wriggle out of this statutory obligation,' the court observed. The orders were passed while disposing of a public interest litigation petition which sought a direction to the State government to commence the RTE admissions for the academic year 2025-26 without any delay. Additional Advocate General J. Ravindran told the court that the State government was unable to reimburse the private schools on time due to non-receipt of Central funds. He said the ₹188.99 crore expenditure towards RTE reimbursement for the year 2022-23 was borne in entirety by the State government. In view of such complaints, the judges suo motu impleaded the Union Ministry of Education as one of the respondents to the case and requested Additional Solicitor General (ASG) A.R.L. Sundaresan to obtain necessary instructions. RTE obligations The ASG told the court that SSS was an integrated scheme that envisages education as a continuum from pre-school to Class 12, and that the scheme was aligned with the provisions of NEP 2020. Since the Tamil Nadu government had not agreed to implement NEP 2020, there were issues regarding the disbursement of funds. He also said that it was the primary responsibility of the State government to implement the RTE Act. Disagreeing with him, the judges said that both the Centre as well as the State governments were obligated to implement the Act. Authoring the judgement, Justice Swaminathan quoted former Chief Justice of the United States Earl Warren, saying: 'Today, education is perhaps the most important function of the state... It is doubtful any child may reasonably be expected to succeed in life if he is denied the opportunity of education.'
Time of India
30 minutes ago
- Time of India
Long-pending central govt's infra projects in Belagavi back on track
Belagavi: Several long-pending central govt's infrastructure projects in and around Belagavi are finally gaining momentum after years of delay, primarily due to land acquisition hurdles. The breakthrough comes with the combined efforts of DC Mohammad Roshan and Belagavi MP Jagadish Shettar , who took these stalled projects as a top priority. Key among them is the much-awaited Belagavi-Dharwad railway line via Kittur, a 73-km project sanctioned in 2019 during the tenure of former MP and MoS for railways, the late Suresh Angadi. Despite funding from the Centre, the project was held up for years due to land-related issues. However, DC Roshan recently announced that land acquisition is now complete, and the work is expected to commence shortly. The Halaga-Macche bypass highway, a vital route connecting Pune-Bengaluru NH-4 and Belagavi-Goa national highway, sanctioned in 2009, also faced prolonged delay due to legal land disputes. With the district administration actively mediating and convincing landowners, the impasse has been resolved, and construction is underway. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Use an AI Writing Tool That Actually Understands Your Voice Grammarly Install Now Undo Another major infrastructure project, the Belagavi Ring Road was sanctioned in 2018. The Rs 3,800 crore project to be executed in three phases, received Rs 1,622 crore for the first phase of 34 km. DC Roshan recently confirmed that 80% of the land acquisition is now complete. This ambitious project, sanctioned under the Bharatmala project, will help resolve the traffic congestion in Belagavi city. "Most of these projects were delayed despite being sanctioned, because of land-related issues. After I became MP, I prioritised these issues, met Union ministers, held review meetings with officials, and visited the sites. Today, we are seeing the results. I expect the required land to be fully acquired in the next 2-3 months and the tender process to begin within 5-6 months," said MP Jagadish Shettar. He credited DC Mohammad Roshan for playing a vital role in resolving bureaucratic and on-ground challenges related to land acquisition. In addition, Shettar informed that land acquisition for Belagavi-Hunagund-Raichur highway, a Rs 1,452 crore project, has also reached near completion. He further assured that the new terminal at Belagavi airport will be ready by March 2026, marking a step toward upgrading the facility to international standards.
Time of India
30 minutes ago
- Time of India
Farmers rally for Kalasa Banduri Nala project
Dharwad: The Kalasa-Banduri Nala project aims at diverting Mahadayi water to Malaprabha River through Kalasa and Banduri Nala, to cater to the drinking water needs of Hubballi-Dharwad and other places in Malaprabha Command Area. Karnataka and Goa have been at loggerheads and stuck in legal entanglement regarding the project. Farmers in the region have been agitating for the speedy implementation of the project, for the last two decades but the states and the Centre have failed to take the issue to a logical end. In a recent development environmentalists from Goa and Karnataka jointly opposed the project and took out a rally at Belagavi, which has angered the farmers. Hundreds of farmers affiliated to various organisations, on Tuesday, took out a rally to protest the delay in implementing the project. They came in a procession from Kadapa Maidan protested in front of the DC's office. In a memorandum addressed to chief minister Siddaramaiah, the farmers urged him to expedite the project and work seriously towards getting rid of legal hurdles. They have threatened to intensify the agitation if the govt fails to take the issue to a logical end.
