In Hindus, there's Moksh: Supreme Court on 'waqf is charity to God' argument
"In Hindus, there's Moksh," the Supreme Court remarked on Thursday as it heard petitioners responding to Centre's arguments in favour of the Waqf (Amendment) Act, 2025.The development came a day after the Centre told the court that waqf is nothing but charity and is not an essential part of Islam.In response to Centre's argument, senior advocate Kapil Sibal, representing the petitioners, told the court today, "Waqf is a dedication to God, for afterlife. Unlike others, Waqf is a charity to God. Charity is to a community, Waqf is a dedication to God. This is for the future, for a spiritual benefit."advertisement
To this, the Chief Justice remarked, "In Hindus, there's a concept of Moksha". Justice Augustine George Masih echoed the Chief Justice, referring to a similar provision in Christianity, saying, "we all try to get to heaven".Countering the Centre' argument, Advocate Rajiv Dhawan said that, according to the Vedas, temples are not an essential part of Hinduism. "There is a provision to worshipping nature. There are gods of fire, water and rain. There are mountains, oceans etc".Notably, the petitioners had earlier claimed that waqf is basically charity in the name of God, to which the Centre had replied that charity is integral to all religions."Waqf is an Islamic concept. But it is not an essential part of Islam... Waqf is nothing but just charity in Islam. Judgments show that charity is part of every religion and can happen for Christianity also. Hindus have a system of daan. Sikhs also have it," Solicitor General Tushar Mehta had said on Wednesday.advertisement"Charity is a fundamental principle of other religions also," Chief Justice Gavai said on Thursday, apparently intending to draw parallels between religions when it came to donations.Sibal then raked up the provision paving the way for non-Hindus to be included in the Central Waqf Council and state waqf boards, saying that as far as the endowment of Hindu religious places is concerned, non-Hindus are not included in it."But as far as waqf is concerned, here also non-Muslims are not included in it. The reservation for four persons has been made for non-Muslims. In my opinion, even one is enough".
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
15 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Congress expels Digvijaya's brother, ex-MP Laxman after post-Pahalgam remarks
Bhopal: The Congress on Wednesday expelled former Madhya Pradesh MLA Laxman Singh from primary membership of the party for six years for 'anti-party activities'. A five-time member of Parliament (MP) and a three-time MLA, Laxman Singh is the younger brother of senior Congress leader and former Madhya Pradesh chief minister Digvijaya Singh. After the Pahalgam terror attack, he had targeted leader of opposition in Lok Sabha Rahul Gandhi, Robert Vadra and Jammu and Kashmir chief minister Omar Abdullah during a protest against terrorism in Raghogarh, Guna on April 24. Laxman Singh had said, 'Omar Abdullah is involved with terrorists, Congress should immediately withdraw its support to him in Jammu and Kashmir.' He also attacked Robert Vadra, saying, 'The statement of Rahul Gandhi's brother-in-law says that Muslims are not allowed to offer namaaz on the road, so the terrorists attacked. How long will we tolerate his childish statements? Rahul Gandhi should also speak very thoughtfully. Such incidents are happening due to his foolishness.' Laxman Singh had also said, 'I was saying this in front of the camera, if Congress wants to expel me then they should do so.' 'Congress president has expelled Laxman Singh, former MLA, Madhya Pradesh, from the primary membership of the Indian National Congress for a period of six years with immediate effect due to his anti-party activities,' Tariq Anwar, member secretary of the Congress' Disciplinary Action Committee, said in a statement. The statement did not elaborate based on what 'anti-party activities' it had acted against Singh. The state Congress had made a recommendation to the party leadership for initiating action against him for his alleged anti-party activities and the matter was sent to the Disciplinary Action Committee. Congress media in-charge Mukesh Nayak said, 'Laxman Singh's expulsion is a big message that discipline is for everyone in the party. His primary membership has also been cancelled. Many times Laxman Singh has made statements that made the party uncomfortable.' Meanwhile, BJP spokesperson Hitesh Bajpai said, 'Laxman Singh was speaking the truth, he was trying to bring Congress on the right path but, Congress likes arrogant people. Congress is captured by such people who want to run it like a company. Laxman Singh did a brave job. He should continue doing that.' On the question of joining BJP, he said that, it is his personal matter, BJP has nothing to do with it.
NDTV
26 minutes ago
- NDTV
Iran Executes Man Convicted Of Killing 7 People During Protests In 2022
Iran executed a man on Wednesday after convicting him of killing seven people, including a 10-year-old boy, during nationwide protests in 2022, the judiciary said. Abbas Kurkuri was sentenced to death over a shooting in the city of Izeh during a protest sparked by the death in custody of Mahsa Amini, an Iranian Kurd detained for an alleged breach of Iran's strict dress code for women. The judgement handed down by the Revolutionary Court in Ahvaz, capital of the southwestern province of Khuzestan, was upheld by the Supreme Court and the sentence was carried out by hanging, the judiciary's Mizan Online news website said. The court convicted Kurkuri of the capital offences of "corruption on earth" and "moharebeh" -- waging war against God. It found him guilty of "brandishing a weapon with intent to kill and terrorise the public", and "committing crimes by firing a military weapon and forming and joining a rebel group". He was accused of opening fire with a military weapon in Izeh in an attack that left seven people dead, including 10-year-old Kian Pirfalak. Officials described the shooting as a "terrorist attack". At trial, Kurkuri confessed to the charges and said he had been "under the influence of social media", Mizan said. The report described him as a "notorious offender" with a record of "disrupting public order through shootings, armed assault, destruction of property, and trafficking in drugs and alcohol". Hundreds of people were killed during the 2022 protests, including members of the security forces. Thousands more were arrested. Iran has since tried and executed several people detained during the protests. Kurkuri's execution comes a day after Iran hanged nine men convicted of plotting to carry out attacks in 2018 on behalf of the Islamic State group. Iran is the world's second most prolific executioner after China, according to human rights groups including Amnesty International.
Indian Express
34 minutes ago
- Indian Express
Shahjahan Islam remarks row: Youth Congress leaders meet Tripura rights panel chief, demand protection of family, other minority members of Shantipara
A delegation of Youth Congress met Tripura Human Rights Commission chairperson Arindam Lodh on Tuesday and sought to ensure the safety and protection of the family members of its leader Shahjahan Islam and other minority families living at Shantipara in Agartala. Islam's house in Agartala was attacked late on Sunday after he slammed the state government and police for their alleged silence over a few incidents centering on alleged cow slaughter on Eid-al-Adha at Udaipur in the Gomati district on Saturday. Hours after the attack the police had arrested Islam's father and brother. The delegation stated that Islam's residence was ransacked by a gang of miscreants allegedly backed by the BJP on June 8, centering around his statements on animal sacrifice posted on Facebook. According to them, the goon went on a rampage, damaged his goods and furniture, and misbehaved with women members of his family. The Youth Congress delegation, in a letter to THRC chairperson, also alleged that some BJP activists were trying to evict Shahjahan from the locality by giving an ultimatum to his family members, including his mother, wife and nine-month-old son, to vacate the house by June 10 evening, or else, their house will be bulldozed. The family members were also given death threats, they said. The Youth Congress workers pointed out another human rights violation in the incident where the police, without arresting the perpetrators, arrested Shahjahan's father and brother without any cause and sent them to 14 days judicial custody. 'For this, the Youth Congress knocked on the doors of the Human Rights Commission seeking to ensure security to Shahjahan's family and protection of human rights of the other minority families in the area,' the delegation stated. In the controversial video, Shahjahan Islam was seen lashing out at Tripura Police and the state government for purportedly failing to act against the miscreants who allegedly interrupted the customary animal slaughter on Bakrid. Several netizens, including BJP activists, sought action against the Congress leader. Four people were detained for allegedly slaughtering a cow in public near a water body in the Chhanban area in Udaipur. A similar incident occurred in the Rajnagar area of Udaipur, where a minority family was accused of slaughtering a cow in the open Congress leader and former party president Birajit Sinha condemned the 'culture of attacking houses'. 'After the BJP came to power, attacks on people's houses by goons started. I demand police to take an active role,' Sinha alleged. On the other hand, BJP Minority Morcha leader Jasim Uddin on Tuesday slammed Islam for allegedly making derogatory remarks against CM Saha and the state police on social media and demanded his immediate arrest. He further alleged that Islam illegally occupied the land of the Wakf Board for a long time and built a house on the land. He appealed to the state government to recover the land from his possession so that the people of backward classes in minority communities could use the land. 'I condemn the way Congress leader Shahjahan Islam abused the state's popular chief minister Dr Manik Saha and those who are working day and night for the safety of the state and the country — the state Home Department's police — in bad words and demanded the immediate arrest of Shahjahan. Congress leader Shahjahan Islam built a palace after occupying the land of the Wakf Board for a long time. I hope that the state government's Wakaf Board would recover the occupied land in the coming days so that the backward minority community people could use it,' he wrote on Facebook.
