Very few have courage to stand up against astrology today: Mashelkar on Narlikar
SCIENTIST DR Raghunath Mashelkar recalled how astrophysicist Jayant Narlikar had the 'courage to stand up against pseudosciences like astrology', while noting that 'many could not do the same today'. Speaking virtually at a tribute event at the Pune International Centre on Saturday, Mashelkar said, 'He fought pseudoscience with reason, not with ridicule. And he stood up. I remember that I was in Delhi at that period of time, there was an effort to introduce astrology courses. And he was the first one to stand up and say astrology is not science. He had the courage to do that. We have very few people today who have the courage to do that. I don't want to elaborate on that.'
In 2008, Narlikar teamed up with the late rationalist Narendra Dabholkar to conduct an experiment testing the validity of astrology. Published in scientific journal Current Science volume 96 in March 2009 titled 'A statistical test of astrology', the experiment invited astrologers to predict the mental capabilities of a set of 40 students based on their birth charts or kundalis. This set of 40 would be randomly drawn from a total set of 200 students. Half of these students were 'intellectually bright' in their schools while the other half were not.
Out of all the astrologers who participated in the experiment, the best performance was 24 out of 40 correct answers while the average correct answer per sample was 17.5. These numbers were below the minimum threshold for success statistically calculated to be 28 correct answers.
Mashelkar added that Narlikar invited pride in ancient Indian astronomy, showing how our scientific heritage is both rich and relevant. Narlikar's death on May 20 led to an outpour of tributes from scientists, citizens, and politicians from across the country. One of the most popular and accomplished scientists from India, Narlikar was the founding director of Inter-University Centre for Astronomy and Astrophysics.
Soham is a Correspondent with the Indian Express in Pune.
A journalism graduate, he was a fact-checker before joining the Express. Soham currently covers education and is also interested in civic issues, health, human rights, and politics. ... Read More
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
4 hours ago
- Time of India
Study reveals widespread microplastic presence in seafood along Vizag coast
Visakhapatnam: Researchers from the department of marine living resources (MLR), Andhra University, have detected widespread microplastic contamination across all examined marine life as part of a recently completed European Commission project. Their study of 100 specimens from 15 different species of fish, shrimp, crabs, and squid – each with edible value and sourced from various landing centres along the Visakhapatnam coast – revealed that microplastic particles smaller than 120µm (micrometre) were consistently found in greater quantities across all analysed tissues of these marine life, including muscle, liver, digestive tract, gonads, and kidney. The most commonly identified plastics included polyethylene, polyvinyl chloride, nylon, polypropylene, and polystyrene, alongside other materials such as latex and polycarbonate. Two Indian universities, including Andhra University and the University of Kerala, participated in the EcoMarine project of the European Commission, which spans multiple countries across various continents, including Germany, Greece, Spain, and Malaysia. A compilation of scientific findings from the marine monitoring labs at these institutions was recently published online. Prof P Janakiram, Dr K Umadevi, S Geetha, and D Chandrasekhar contributed to the study from the department of MLR at Andhra University. In lower trophic-level organisms, microplastics mimic prey due to their minute size, leading to unintentional ingestion. Once consumed, these particles travel up the food chain, increasing their bioavailability within the ecosystem. For instance, microplastics transition from algae to zooplankton, then to fish, eventually entering the human food chain through seafood consumption. Leaching chemicals from plastic additives and monomers have been linked to endocrine disruption and carcinogenesis in humans. Upon exposure, microplastics can accumulate in human tissues and organs, potentially altering immune responses or leading to other clinical complications. Speaking to TOI, Prof P Janakiram, principal investigator of the EcoMarine project, said: "While the detrimental health effects of microplastics are well established, their precise impact requires further investigation. The medical fraternity can conduct extensive research to determine the exact pathways through which microplastics enter biological systems and the extent of their adverse effects on human health. " A separate study conducted by the same research team from the department of MLR has also revealed extensive plastic contamination in water samples collected from seven locations along the Visakhapatnam coast, including Kailasagiri, Rushikonda, Pedda Rushikonda, Bheemili, Pandurangapuram, the inner harbour of Visakhapatnam port, and jetty No. 11 (fishing harbour). According to Prof Janakiram, Dr Umadevi, S Geetha, and D Chandrasekhar, water samples were taken from both surface water and a depth of 10 metres. Gravimetric assessment and FTIR spectroscopy identified polyethylene terephthalate, polyethylene, and polypropylene as the most commonly detected plastic compositions in both surface and deeper water. The presence of these polymers is largely attributed to industrial activities around the Visakhapatnam industrial zone, as well as the dissolution of plastic waste such as PET bottles and discarded plastic items due to human-induced pollution. Based on these findings, the study urges the Pollution Control Board (PCB) to implement stringent regulatory measures on industrial wastewater discharge to curb coastal contamination.
The Hindu
7 hours ago
- The Hindu
Aiming for an era of ‘biohappiness' in India
Recently, on a trip to Arunachal Pradesh, we were amazed by the diversity of greens in the diet — all freshly plucked from the forest and fields. Similarly, across rural and tribal areas of our country, one can find many varieties of millets, beans, legumes, tubers, wild fruits and green leafy vegetables, which the urban Indian is hardly aware of. The Nyishi and Apatani tribal communities in the State are knowledgeable about the nutritional and medicinal properties of many of these local plants. A senior government official however warned of the rapid rate at which agrobiodiversity was disappearing in northeast India, mirroring the global rise in the rate of species extinction. Traditional knowledge about the medicinal and nutritional properties of these foods, as well as the culinary practices of tribal communities are probably going extinct at the same pace. India's biodiversity India covers about 2% of global land area, but harbours nearly 8% of global biodiversity. It is ranked as one of 17 'megadiverse' countries of the world; contains sections of four of the 36 global biodiversity 'hotspots;' and is one of just eight centres of global food-crop diversity. Natural services from India's diverse forests are valued at over ₹130 trillion a year, and local ecosystem services sustain livelihoods of a vast majority of the rural population. However, continuous decline in our natural assets reduces India's GDP and hinders sustainable development. Yet, biodiversity and its potential to increase human well-being remain largely unexplored. Global food systems are dominated by three crops — rice, wheat, and maize — which provide over 50% of the world's plant-based calories. This concentration and loss of biodiversity comes at a heavy price, causing nutritional imbalances, and vulnerability to climate shocks. Non-communicable diseases such as diabetes and obesity are rising globally, and despite technological advances in agriculture that have enabled unprecedented gains in productivity, the benefits have not been equitably distributed, as the resilience of our food systems comes under threat. For long we have ignored locally grown crops such as small millets, buckwheat, amaranth, jackfruit, yams and tubers, and indigenous legumes that remain classified as Neglected and Underutilized Species (NUS) in favour of popular commercial crops. The NUS, also known as orphan crops, are now being referred to as opportunity crops because they are nutritionally dense, climate-resilient, and adapted to local environments. Crops and communities Orphan (or Opportunity) crops have always been embedded in local culinary traditions, often linked with cultural identity and ecological knowledge. The community of Kolli hills (Eastern Ghats of Tamil Nadu) preferred growing locally adapted millets. Over three decades, farmers have moved to cultivating cash crops such as cassava, coffee, and pepper, resulting in a decline of agrobiodiversity. The M.S Swaminathan Research Foundation (MSSRF) has been working with agricultural communities here for over 20 years, to prevent the erosion of millet crop diversity in the region through participatory research and empowering farmers' groups. These interventions have enabled a community of farmers, especially women, to document traditional knowledge and best practices, while improving the vitality of the soil, diversifying crop production, improving local processing and value addition, leading to increasing income. India's action plan under the UN-declared International Year of Millets and Shree Anna Yojana was focused on strategies to enhance production and productivity, consumption, export, strengthening value chains, branding, creating awareness for health benefits and more. Many States have their own Millet Missions. In the Koraput district of Odisha, we have worked closely with the Odisha Millet Mission in supporting community-led millet revival from seed to consumption. While the focus nationally has been on ragi, jowar and bajra, the next step should be to expand the State missions to cover a variety of minor millets and to include them in the Public Distribution System. More than five decades ago, Professor M.S. Swaminathan envisioned an Evergreen Revolution — that is rooted not in chemical intensification but in restoring ecological balance and nutrition security. The future of food is diverse and nutritious. To bring these forgotten foods back to the table is also to put our cultural identity and ecological knowledge at the forefront of the climate crisis — for people, planet, and its posterity. An interdisciplinary science Today, a new biodiversity science is emerging across the globe, which India can leverage, given its Human Resources and scientific infrastructure. Furthermore, this interdisciplinary science will help us meet our most pressing challenges in sustainable use of India's unique biodiversity, for agriculture and food production, health and nutrition, climate change and disaster risk management, bio-economy, and providing a variety of jobs to meet the needs of 1.4 billion people. India could become a global leader in conservation and sustainable use of natural resources leading to better health and human well-being. Could we aim for an era of 'Biohappiness', as presciently envisioned by M.S. Swaminathan? Dr. Soumya Swaminathan is Chairperson of the M.S. Swaminathan Research Foundation. Dr. E.D. Israel Oliver King is Director, Biodiversity, M.S. Swaminathan Research Foundation
Time of India
7 hours ago
- Time of India
Indian spectacled cobra, eggs rescued in Ganjam
B Tired of too many ads? go ad free now erhampur: In a 35-minute operation on Tuesday afternoon, snake rescuers saved an Indian spectacled cobra and its 17 eggs from a house in Samalai near Hinjili in Ganjam district. The cobra was found guarding its clutch of eggs near a tree along the boundary of the house. "The situation was particularly challenging because we had to ensure both the snake and eggs remained unharmed during the rescue," said Sandeep Kumar Sethi, one of the rescuers. The snake was released into the wild, while the eggs were handed over to forest officials. Berhampur DFO Sunny Khokkar said the eggs are being kept in a secured environment and are expected to hatch within 10 days. "We're monitoring the eggs closely," said Swadhin Kumar Sahu, another team member. Forest officials and Snake Helpline members are keeping a watch to ensure the eggs hatch safely.
