Starmer vows to press on with welfare reform as he takes blame for U-turn
In an interview with the BBC, the Prime Minister acknowledged his Government did not 'get the process right' and failed to 'engage in the way that we should have done' on welfare changes.
But he added his Government would 'come through it stronger' as he vowed to 'reflect' on what needed to be done 'to ensure we don't get into a situation like that again'.
Despite the setback, which saw changes to the personal independence payment (Pip) stripped out of his welfare legislation, Sir Keir said on Thursday his Government was 'pressing on with welfare reform'.
Answering questions at the launch of Labour's NHS plan, he said: 'It is important we reform the system. Welfare isn't working.'
The Prime Minister went on to praise disabilities minister Sir Stephen Timms, who is now leading a review of Pip, saying he was 'a thoroughly decent man of huge integrity that we can have faith in to do the review and make the changes that are necessary'.
Sir Keir's U-turn saw planned changes to Pip eligibility put off until after Sir Stephen has completed his review of the benefit next autumn, leaving only changes to universal credit to go forward.
That decision has caused a fiscal headache for Chancellor Rachel Reeves, with the £4.8 billion of savings the reforms were expected to deliver now unlikely to materialise.
Economists have warned that this is likely to mean further tax rises in the autumn, and the Prime Minister did not rule out the possibility on Thursday.
Ms Reeves has previously promised she would not need to repeat the £40 billion tax raid she set out in October 2024.
Asked if he would repeat that commitment, Sir Keir said: 'No prime minister or chancellor is going to write a budget in advance, but we did really tough stuff in that budget last year.'
But he added that last year's budget had already done much of the 'heavy lifting' on repairing the public finances.
The Chancellor also declined to 'speculate' about tax rises ahead of the budget, but told broadcasters there was 'a cost to the welfare changes that Parliament voted through this week and that will be reflected in the budget'.
Ms Reeves herself appeared alongside Sir Keir and Health Secretary Wes Streeting at the launch of the NHS plan on Thursday, a day after she had appeared visibly tearful in the Commons during Prime Minister's Questions.
The Chancellor told broadcasters it had been related to a 'personal issue', while Sir Keir gave her his full backing, adding: 'I think it's just fantastic she's here and, as I say, none of this would be happening if she hadn't taken the decisions that she's taken.'
Questions about the Chancellor's future had sparked a sharp fall in the value of UK government bonds on Wednesday, but the markets rallied on Thursday morning following repeated reassurances she was safe in Number 11.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Guardian
8 minutes ago
- The Guardian
The Guardian view on Labour's NHS plan: it is right to celebrate medical science, but delivery is the hard part
The NHS is a totemic institution in Labour's history and that of the country, and voters care more about it than most things the government does. So the publication of Labour's 10-year plan for health in England was a crucial opportunity for ministers to show that they are in tune with the public. Given that satisfaction with the health service has hit a record low of 21%, and doctors are again threatening to go on strike, the announcement was also a moment of peril – even before the damage suffered by the prime minister and chancellor earlier this week, when rebels forced a U-turn on planned cuts to welfare. The overarching principles of Labour's reforms were set out last year: more prevention, more technology, more care delivered in the community (as opposed to in hospital). So the challenge was to find something fresh, original and hopeful to say. The promise of science and the potential of localism are what Wes Streeting's team has come up with. The strand of DNA pictured on the document's cover points to high expectations of genomic medicine and other cutting-edge technology. Neighbourhood clinics, by contrast, represent a prosaic recognition of demand for more ordinary services and treatments, from an ageing and increasingly unhealthy population. The aim is to deliver most outpatient care away from hospitals by 2035. This could mean GP surgeries becoming more like hospitals, or hospital trusts taking a bigger role in primary care. The plans for new contracts make it clear that both are possible. But while this sounds fine in theory, questions remain over how, and by whom, such crucial decisions will be taken, and whether the new model will be better than the old one. With the abolition of NHS England, and scaling back of integrated care boards, the existing administration is being radically downsized. One of the risks of the next few years is that this backstage upheaval will distract time and energy from the frontline. Plans to shift resources from richer areas to poorer ones deserve an unequivocal welcome. There is no great secret about expertise being concentrated in prestigious teaching hospitals, or about richer, better educated people being more confident advocates for themselves and their loved ones. Shifting the 'best to the rest' is both a neat slogan and an acknowledgment of present unfairness. Plans to integrate employment support and services such as debt advice into healthcare hubs signal an encouraging awareness that illness and disability have socioeconomic as well as biological causes. The plan tells a promising story. Healthcare is an area of human progress that all can celebrate. It is plausible that proactive Labour ministers can both drive advances and ensure that they are more equitably shared than in marketised systems. Embedding more healthcare workers in communities, and focusing on outreach, could help to improve population health. But there are some worrying gaps. Social care reform is due to be tackled separately, but worsening mental health, particularly in young people, also needs dedicated attention and research. Ministers should also be pressed on the contradictions between their health plan and their pro-growth, anti-regulation message to businesses – including those that sell alcohol and the high-sugar foods that cause obesity. Having brought control of the NHS in England back in-house, to the heart of government, Mr Streeting must now find the people with the imagination to further develop his plan, while turning it into action.
BBC News
9 minutes ago
- BBC News
Winter fuel: Lyons says 86% of NI pensioners to be eligible for payment
The Communities Minister Gordon Lyons has said 86% of pensioners in Northern Ireland will be eligible for the winter fuel payment this comes after the government performed a U-turn on its controversial had initially scrapped the universal payment as a cost saving now those with an income of £35,000 or below are eligible for the grant. Lyons told BBC Radio Ulster's Evening Extra programme that his officials have assessed that the change in policy will mean 288,000 pensioners are in line for the payment."For comparison, across the UK as a whole about 80% of pensioners will retain [the payment], but it's slightly higher in Northern Ireland because of our lower incomes," he said. "This has been a mess from the start. The government have a lot to answer for on this. This has been handled horrifically by the government and has put a lot of worry and concern into the minds of our older people." Lyons had secured £17m from Stormont to provide a £100 one-off payment for those affected by the cut last said the Labour government's policy was misguided."I said from the start this would not have saved the government a lot of money," he said. "What we have seen is a number of pensioners reach out for help and realise they are eligible for pension credit, which is a passport for other benefits. So in that regard it'll actually cost the government more." What are winter fuel payments? Winter fuel payments were created in 1997 to help everyone above state pension age with their winter heating Chancellor, Rachel Reeves, announced last year that winter 2024 would be the first time pensioners in England and Wales would not be eligible for the Ireland was forced to follow were then restricted to those on benefits and pension credit.
The Independent
11 minutes ago
- The Independent
Government still reforming ‘utterly broken' welfare system
The Scottish Secretary has said the UK Government is still working to reform the 'utterly broken' welfare system, following the substantial concessions made in Parliament earlier this week. Ian Murray also said the Cabinet is in a 'resolved' mood following the tearful appearance of Chancellor Rachel Reeves in the House of Commons. Mr Murray, a former publican, visited Belhaven Brewery in East Lothian on Thursday – where he poured a pint which then had his face imprinted on the foam by a machine at the bar. Speaking almost a year on from Labour's general election win, Mr Murray said his party had achieved 'a lot', adding: 'We've had 30 Bills through Parliament, the most that have ever been passed in the history of a new government. 'We've given 200,000 Scots the biggest pay rise, we've been able to set up GB Energy, we've stabilised the economy.' On Tuesday, Sir Keir Starmer's Government was forced into a last-minute climbdown in order for welfare legislation to pass its first parliamentary hurdle. Ministers shelved plans to restrict eligibility for the personal independence payment (Pip), with any changes now only coming after a review of the benefit. These changes are expected to put pressure on other parts of the Government's finances. Mr Murray said 'everybody agrees' the welfare system needs reform and too many people are 'locked out of the workplace because of the way the welfare system works'. He said the Timms review would examine the Pip system and the Government is confident the 'journey' of reform would continue. Pressed on whether substantial parts of the reform had been dropped, he said: 'A thousand people a day are going into personal independence payments, that's 371,000 a year. 'That's completely unsustainable.' He added: 'This whole system is completely and utterly broken and it's unsustainable and that's what we're trying to resolve. 'The one thing that unites everybody in this debate is the fact they know the system is broken and it has to be reformed.' The Scottish Secretary was asked if the Chancellor's Budget choices would affect the devolved Scottish Government budget, with Mr Murray noting the Spending Review had given Edinburgh a further £9.1 billion over two years. He said: 'The Budget will be set in October as it is in any budget. 'Of course, with things fluctuating so quickly, we wouldn't speculate now what would happen then, because things can change so quickly. 'But we've already said there'd be no change to the Scottish Government's budget.' Mr Murray said the mood in Cabinet is 'one of resolve' following Ms Reeves' appearance in the Commons and markets had responded positively to the Prime Minister's show of support in her.
