Adman Sandeep Goyal seeks government grip on surrogate ads in High Court battle
In a significant legal challenge, veteran adman
Sandeep Goyal
, the managing director of
Rediffusion Brand Solutions
, has filed a
Public Interest Litigation
(PIL) in the
Punjab and Haryana High Court
, urging for a direct government-led regulatory body to curb the pervasive issue of
surrogate advertising
. The petition, currently under the scrutiny of Chief Justice Sheel Nagu and Justice Sumeet Goel, contends that existing self-regulatory frameworks are insufficient and too sluggish to combat the real-time impact of these misleading promotions.
Goyal, who has consistently refused to work with tobacco and alcohol brands since their
advertising
was banned in India, asserts that he holds no personal or financial stake in the outcome. His PIL highlights what he describes as blatant violations of crucial regulations, including the Cable Television Network Rules 1994, the Cigarettes and Other Tobacco Products Act 2003, and the CCPA Guidelines on Misleading Advertisements 2022.
The petition specifically points to prominent examples of alleged surrogate advertising, citing brands like Vimal Elaichi, Rajshree Silver Coated Elaichi, and Pan Bahar. These ads, often featuring well-known celebrities, are frequently seen during prime-time television slots and high-profile events such as IPL broadcasts. Goyal argues that such promotions subtly endorse restricted products, misleading consumers and contributing to a growing public health crisis, particularly among young people. "The country is undergoing a health crisis wherein the youth of the nation is getting addicted to alcohol and tobacco at a tender age," the petition states, emphasizing how
celebrity endorsements
"glamorize" and "validate" the consumption of these products.
The PIL underscores the ineffectiveness of current industry self-regulation, including the
Advertising Standards Council of India
(ASCI), in adequately reining in these deceptive practices. Goyal's petition, argued by advocate Aadil Singh Boparai, seeks strict enforcement of existing laws and guidelines. Crucially, it calls for a more robust, government-led mechanism to actively supervise all advertising content.
The High Court has taken cognizance of the matter, issuing notices to the central government, the Central Consumer Protection Authority (CCPA), and the Central Board of Film Certification (CBFC). This move signals the judiciary's recognition of the potential public health implications of unchecked surrogate advertising, setting the stage for a significant legal debate on the future of advertising regulation in India.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Indian Express
14 hours ago
- Indian Express
Punjab and Haryana HC directs training of deputy commissioners, magistrates on SARFAESI Act, warns of contempt for delays
Taking serious note of repeated delays by district magistrates in implementing orders under Section 14 of the Securitisation and Reconstruction of Financial Assets and Enforcement of Security Interest (SARFAESI) Act, the Punjab and Haryana High Court Wednesday directed the Chandigarh Judicial Academy to conduct orientation courses for deputy commissioners and chief judicial magistrates of Punjab, Haryana and Chandigarh within a month. A division bench of Chief Justice Sheel Nagu and Justice Ramesh Kumari observed that despite clear judicial directions, district magistrates and subordinate revenue officers often 'sit over files' for months, frustrating the very scheme of the SARFAESI Act. Section 14 empowers the district magistrate or chief judicial magistrate to assist banks in taking possession of secured assets once default has been established. 'It is surprising that time and again, this court is confronted with petitions where banks complain that orders under Section 14 have not been executed,' Chief Justice Nagu remarked, adding that the law envisages passing of such orders within 30 to 60 days and their execution without delay. 'Merely because the statute does not prescribe a specific time frame for execution does not mean officials can let files gather dust,' the bench noted. The court pointed out that a coordinate bench in May 2024 laid down detailed procedures for district magistrates to follow while dealing with Section 14 applications. Yet, several officials either remain unaware of the order or are 'intentionally not complying with it', the bench said. During the hearing, counsel for banks highlighted that higher-value cases—often running into hundreds of crores—faced the longest delays, allegedly due to political or extraneous considerations. 'Smaller borrowers' cases get decided quickly, but in cases involving ₹100 crore and above, district magistrates either delay passing orders or do not implement them,' the bench was told. Rejecting any distinction between high- and low-value cases, the Chief Justice said: 'Debt recovery cannot be based on the amount involved. Applications should be dealt with on a first-in, first-out basis.' To address the widespread non-compliance, the bench ordered the Judicial Academy to hold a training programme for all deputy commissioners, district magistrates, and chief judicial magistrates. 'After participation, it is expected that they will perform their statutory duty of passing orders within 60 days and ensuring their execution expeditiously,' the bench directed. The court also issued a stern warning: if any district magistrate or deputy commissioner is found failing to comply with their duty under Section 14 after undergoing orientation, it would amount to contempt of court. The bench further underlined that the powers exercised under Section 14 are 'ministerial in nature' and do not involve any adjudicatory function. Referring to Supreme Court rulings, including R D Jain vs Capital First Ltd. (2023) and NKGSB Cooperative Bank vs Subir Chakravarty (2022), the judges reiterated that district magistrates are not quasi-judicial authorities in such matters and must act swiftly to aid banks. The order comes amid mounting complaints from banks across Punjab and Haryana about delays in recovering secured assets, particularly in cases where local political influence or farmer unions resist execution. The bench concluded that fixing accountability and providing orientation were now essential to ensure the law serves its intended purpose.
Indian Express
15 hours ago
- Indian Express
HC clears decks for hybrid paddy procurement, but storage remains hurdle with millers reluctant
After the Punjab and Haryana High Court struck down the Punjab government's ban on the cultivation of notified hybrid paddy varieties, procurement agencies are preparing to buy these paddy varieties from farmers who flouted the ban and sowed them. Officials, however, said the move would bring back the challenges faced last year, as 'rice shellers are still reluctant to mill and store these varieties, citing low out-turn ratios and storage shortages'. Punjab Agriculture Department Director Jaswant Singh said the court's order 'leaves with no choice'. 'When there is no ban on the cultivation of notified hybrid paddy varieties in Punjab, legally these too must be procured from farmers,' he told The Indian Express. 'However, the area under these varieties this year is not much. Owing to the ban during the sowing season, most of the farmers avoided it. If any farmers did grow these hybrids, they might have sourced seeds from neighbouring states. The acreage should be very small,' he said. Officials at Punjab Agricultural University (PAU) acknowledged that hybrid paddy continues to attract some farmers because of its high yield potential up to 36 quintals, which is 5-6 quintals more than other recommended PAU varieties, and could be grown even in poor water quality areas. PAU officials, however, warned that millers have long opposed it due to poor milling results. While the government fixes a 67 per cent rice recovery rate per 100 kg of paddy, millers say hybrids often deliver just 60-62 per cent, pushing them into losses and disputes with procurement agencies. Punjab Rice Millers' Association president Tarsem Saini said, 'Millers will not procure these varieties as their out-turn is low, causing heavy losses.' Asked why they agreed to procure last year after initially refusing, he said the Punjab government had extended several relaxations, which reduced their losses. Farmers who grew such varieties last year also suffered, as in several parts of Punjab, they were forced to give three to six extra bags each weighing 37.5 kg for every 100 bags of paddy to certain arhtiyas, many of whom were also millers, to compensate for the losses. Punjab has around 5,000 rice mills, where all government-procured paddy is stored initially and later milled, handing over rice to procurement agencies. Storage stress on the horizon again With the highest ever area, around 32.49 lakh hectares, including 6.83 lakh hectares under basmati, under paddy cultivation this Kharif season, Punjab has nearly 220 lakh tonnes of foodgrain in government godowns, including around 75 lakh tonnes of wheat and 145 lakh tonnes of rice. Of the 117 lakh tonnes of rice that the Food Corporation of India (FCI) was to receive from Punjab for the 2024-25 season, 116 lakh tonnes have already been delivered by millers, with just one lakh tonne pending, sources with the FCI said. With godowns full, the state again faces the spectre of storage bottlenecks once procurement begins in October. 'The grain is moving out of the state regularly, and by the time fresh rice arrives after milling in December, sufficient space should open up,' Punjab FCI general manager B Srinivasan said, adding that he is yet to read the court order on quashing the ban on notified hybrid paddy varieties. Echoes of last year's mismanagement The high court order comes against the backdrop of Punjab's troubled procurement season in 2024, when poor planning and storage constraints left a majority of procured paddy stuck in mandis by late last October, forcing farmers to slow down harvesting, fearing distress sales, and mandis were choked with grain as rice millers resisted storing government paddy. Farmers bore the brunt, with delayed harvesting threatening the timely sowing of wheat and pushing many into distress sales below the Minimum Support Price (MSP). The state also witnessed farmer protests and blockades amid demands from arhtiyas and labour unions for dues and wage parity. Way forward This year, officials hope the limited acreage under hybrids will prevent major disruption. 'We assume area under hybrid paddy is not much this year, we don't expect a repeat of last year's crisis,' a senior official said, cautioning that 'the sheller resistance and godown saturation remain unresolved concerns'. PAU experts warn that unless the government conducts milling out-turn trials for hybrids, strengthens seed certification and assures millers of timely lifting of rice, the issue will resurface every season. In the long run, they say, Punjab must diversify its crop base to ease the twin burden of procurement and storage, while ensuring farmers are not caught between legal mandates and logistical challenges.
The Wire
a day ago
- The Wire
'This Partnership Is a Good Marriage' - Piyush Goyal Kicks Off IGF London 2025 with UK Trade Secretary Jonathan Reynolds
Goyal and Reynolds push back against criticism over insurance exemptions, marking first joint public appearance since FTA finalisation LONDON, June 19, 2025 /PRNewswire/ -- On the opening day of India Global Forum London, Union Minister of Commerce & Industry Piyush Goyal and UK Secretary of State for Business and Trade Jonathan Reynolds jointly defended the recently finalised India-UK Free Trade Agreement, pushing back against criticism of national insurance exemptions granted to short-term Indian workers. In a rare joint session at the Queen Elizabeth II Centre, both leaders addressed concerns surrounding the national insurance exemption for short-term Indian workers, a provision included in the deal that has drawn scrutiny from segments of the British media and political circles. Piyush Goyal dismissed criticism that the insurance waiver was a one-sided concession. "It's unfair to call it a giveaway," he said. "The agreement provides stability and predictability to business, and benefits workers from both sides. In fact, similar arrangements exist in many countries, and this is a win-win for mobility and trade." Reinforcing the principle of fairness, Goyal added: "They should not be double taxed, as they pay social security costs in the UK and India." UK Trade Secretary Jonathan Reynolds backed the provision, asserting that British workers would not be negatively impacted. He said: "No British worker is undercut by this UK–India FTA agreement. Business mobility has improved due to this; in turn, it has improved access to services and procurement." Both leaders stressed on the strategic alignment between the two nations. UK Secretary Jonathan Reynolds reinforced the need for practical cooperation: "We have built a relationship that allows us to deliver an ambitious agreement like this one. India is one of the most exciting countries in the world, and actually one of the most important; with the problems we face globally, I can't see any way to fix those without India playing a leading role." This was the first public appearance by the two ministers since the FTA's conclusion, and their joint presence on Day 1 of IGF London sent a strong signal of bilateral resolve. Goyal added: "There is hardly anything in which India and the UK compete; we complement each other. I believe this partnership is a good marriage. I see bilateral trade doubling in the next five years." Reynolds also underscored the strength of the bilateral relationship and optimism about the future: "India and the UK have built a relationship to deliver the FTA. I am genuinely excited by the future opportunities for both countries." Echoing this vision of outcome-driven collaboration, Manoj Ladwa, Founder and Chairman of India Global Forum, stated: "We at IGF are building partnerships for the future. We are connecting the dots across sectors, across geographic areas, and across generations. Each initiative is outcome-driven, measurable and future-focused. Powered by three key forces—Technology, Talent and Capital—we are linking Global Britain and Global India in tangible and transformative ways." Day 1 of IGF London 2025 set the stage for a high-powered three-day summit featuring 100+ speakers, 1000+ participants, and sessions across iconic London venues. With bold conversations spanning AI, energy transition, healthtech, geopolitics, and the creative economy, the forum was driving forward the momentum of the UK–India Free Trade Agreement. About India Global Forum India Global Forum tells the story of contemporary India. The pace of change and growth India has set itself is an opportunity for the world. IGF is the gateway for businesses and nations to help seize that opportunity. To know more, click here For Media Enquiries Contact Social Media Handles & Hashtag to Follow Twitter: @IGFUpdates & @manojladwa LinkedIn: India Global Forum #IGFLondon Photo - Logo - (Disclaimer: The above press release comes to you under an arrangement with PRNewswire and PTI takes no editorial responsibility for the same.). PTI This is an auto-published feed from PTI with no editorial input from The Wire. Advertisement Next
