Toby Carvery threatened with legal action over felling of ancient London oak
Toby Carvery has been threatened with legal action by a council over the felling of an ancient oak in a park in north London.
The restaurant chain is facing national outrage after its decision to fell the up to 500-year-old tree without warning on 3 April.
On Wednesday, Enfield council, which had leased the land on which the tree stood for a Toby Carvery car park, escalated its dispute with the company by challenging its rationale for the felling and signalling its plan to sue.
It came after Mitchells & Butlers Retail (M&BR), which owns Toby Carvery, claimed the tree had to be taken down because it was 'mostly dead and diseased' and posed a risk to the public.
The council leader, Ergin Erbil, claimed this was false.
He said: 'We have evidence that this tree was alive and starting to grow new spring leaves when this action was taken. Our team of experts checked the tree in December 2024 and found it was healthy and posed no risk to the neighbouring car park and its users.
'As the tree shows clear signs of life, we will also do everything we can to help the tree regrow.'
The council had reported Toby Carvery to the Metropolitan police, but officers decided to take no further action as there was no preservation order on the tree. On Tuesday the police closed an investigation into the incident after deciding it was a civil matter.
Erbil said: 'The police are treating it as a civil matter, but we will continue to take appropriate legal action.'
He added: 'As the landowner, we believe this action has broken the terms of the lease which requires Toby Carvery to maintain and protect the existing landscape. The tree was the oldest one on site and cutting it down seems to be a clear breach of this condition.'
'We're therefore seeking advice and will take appropriate legal action. If any criminal activity is found during our investigation, we will not hesitate to report this to the police again.
Erbil also said he was 'outraged' that Toby Carvery had 'cut down this beautiful ancient oak tree without seeking any permissions or advice from Enfield council'.
He said: 'This tree would have been home to countless wildlife, fungi and pollinators. This tree is a part of our ecological and cultural heritage.
The Woodland Trust said the oak in Whitewebbs Park was an important habitat, supporting hundreds of species including endangered deadwood beetles.
Ed Pyne, the Woodland Trust's senior conservation adviser for trees, said: 'This is the most shocking fell I think I've ever seen in more than a decade working with ancient trees.
Sign up to Down to Earth
The planet's most important stories. Get all the week's environment news - the good, the bad and the essential
after newsletter promotion
'In my view, and the view of many others, this is ecologically much more significant than the Sycamore Gap – and certainly a more irreplaceable tree.
'Ancient oaks are particularly rich in biodiversity, with habitats that take centuries to develop. They simply can't be replaced by younger trees and can't be replaced quickly.'
He added: 'Some of the biodiversity associated with ancient trees, like the Whitewebbs oak, is among the most threatened in Europe.'
Ed Allnut, an Enfield resident and the secretary of the Guardians of Whitewebbs group, said local people wanted justice for the old oak.
He said: 'The tree belonged to Enfield and to our national heritage. I am personally devastated. We want answers, and we want guarantees the other trees here are being protected properly.'
M&BR has been approached for comment.
It is understood M&BR plans to conduct a review of the incident to determine whether felling the tree was right or wrong. Its chief executive, Phil Urban, also plans to respond to all those who have complained to him about the destruction of the tree. A source close to the company says Urban will apologise for the distress caused but not the action taken.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Wales Online
a day ago
- Wales Online
British trio facing death penalty over Angel Delight cocaine plot
British trio facing death penalty over Angel Delight cocaine plot The three face the death penalty for 'smuggling cocaine in sachets of Angel Delight' into Indonesia Phineas Ambrose Float, Jonathan Christopher Collyer and Lisa Ellen Stocker (Image: AFP via Getty Images ) Three British people are facing the death penalty after being accused of smuggling nearly a kilogram of cocaine into Indonesia in Angel Delight sachets. Jonathan Christopher Collyer, 38, and Lisa Ellen Stocker, 39, were stopped and arrested by officials at an X-ray machine at customs in Bali on February 1. The X-ray machine had highlighted suspicious items in their luggage disguised as food packages, said prosecutor I Made Dipa Umbara. The alleged drug smugglers came into court wearing the bright red waistcoats defendants are forced to wear during trials in Indonesia. Don't miss a court report by signing up to our crime newsletter here The District Court in Denpasar heard that lab tests revealed that 10 sachets of Angel Delight powdered dessert mix in Collyer's luggage combined with seven similar sachets in his partner's suitcase contained 993.56 grams of cocaine, worth an estimated six billion rupiah (£272,000), The Mirror reports. Phineas Ambrose Float, 31, was arrested after a controlled operation which saw the other two suspects hand the drug to him in a hotel car park in Denpasar, the court was told. He is being tried separately. As he was led into court to face the drug charges against him, Float told journalists to "f*** off". He was brought to Denpasar Central Court in Bali in a prison van, wearing a white shirt and red prison vest with his wrists in shackles. Article continues below He hurled abuse at the gathered media as he was taken to a holding cell but was then seen in court smiling at Collyer. The drugs were flown into Indonesia from England via Doha international airport in Qatar, Mr Umbara told the court. The group had got past Indonesian authorities twice before, but were caught on this third attempt, Ponco Indriyo, the deputy director of the Bali Police Narcotics Unit said. The charges against the three were read out in court before a panel of three judges adjourned the trial until June 10 when the court will hear witness testimony. Float was previously jailed in the UK for armed robbery and drug dealing. In 2012, Float - then aged 19 - was sentenced to a year in jail after being caught with mephedrone hidden in his sock. He had been trying to get into the Sugar Mill nightclub in Hull city centre when security at the door stopped and searched him. He had hidden 35 bags of the Class B drug, better known as M-Cat or Meow Meow, in his sock, which had a street value said to be £216. He also had £105 in cash on him. Float, who was of no fixed address at the time, later pleaded guilty at Hull Crown Court to possession with intent to supply a Class B controlled drug and failing to provide a sample on suspicion of taking a Class A drug. He was still on licence at the time having been released from prison halfway through a sentence for armed robbery, and was told to go back to jail to serve the remainder, along with 12 months for the drugs charges Around 530 people, including 96 foreigners, are reported to be on death row in Indonesia, mostly for drug-related offences. The UN Office on Drugs and Crime said Indonesia, which has some of the strictest drug laws in the world, is a drug smuggling centre. International drug gangs are said to target the nation's young population. Those found guilty of drug smuggling face long jail terms or, in some cases, execution by firing squad. The last executions of an Indonesian and three foreigners were carried out in July, 2016. British woman Lindsay Sandiford was arrested in Indonesia in 2012 when 3.8 kilograms of cocaine was found inside the lining of her luggage at Bali's airport. Now aged 69, Sandiford has been on death row for more than a decade. Her death sentence was upheld by Indonesia's highest court in 2013. Article continues below The Mirror reported that Stocker had been transferred to Bali's Kerobokan jail - the same hell-hole jail where pensioner Sandiford has spent more than 12 years awaiting execution for smuggling cocaine. A source told the paper: "Stocker was moved to Kerobokan and placed in isolation as all new prisoners. Over recent weeks she has slowly been released into mainstream jail life and is due to be assigned a room. It means Sandiford has a new country person."
Sky News
a day ago
- Sky News
Ten killed in Austria school shooting - with one teenager spared because he was off sick
Students and adults are among 10 victims who were killed after a gunman opened fire at a secondary school in the Austrian city of Graz. Interior minister Gerhard Karner said earlier that a further 12 people were injured in the shooting at the BORG Dreierschützengasse high school in Austria's second-biggest city. He gave the figure before it was confirmed that a person in hospital with life-threatening injuries had become the 10th person to die. It is not clear if this reduces the number of those injured to 11. The interior minister also said the suspect was a former pupil of the school who didn't finish his studies. Police have confirmed that the 21-year-old Austrian gunman was found dead in the toilets of the school after the shootings and was operating alone. Nobody can believe it happened here When 'M' - a 16-year-old student - saw mentions of a school shooting on his phone, he assumed it was yet another tragedy in the US. But it couldn't have been closer to home. Three students in his class had been killed - his own cousin had been shot in the shoulder. M only escaped the carnage because he was off school sick. After the terror and panic of Tuesday morning, an eerie calm has settled over these streets. People stand in silence staring past the wire fence that guards the school - through the windows you can see the still-lit corridors; a handful of police officers standing guard outside the main entrance. There are, no doubt, many more police inside the school - out of our view, still gathering evidence - trying to answer the question that's on everyone's minds: why? Why did a former student take two guns - seemingly legally owned - into his former classrooms, and open fire? It's reported a 'farewell letter' was found by authorities at the gunman's home. But can that really provide answers to such a senseless loss of young life? M knows he will never feel secure walking through these corridors again, in a school and town he said was always quiet and safe. Austria has one of the highest rates of gun ownership in Europe, but mass shootings have been - before Tuesday - extremely rare. A national conversation about its gun laws and ownership loopholes must surely follow these coming days of national mourning. Authorities say the suspect had two weapons - reported to be a shotgun and a pistol - which he appeared to have owned legally. A gun expert told Austrian national broadcaster ORF that shotguns could easily be bought in the country once someone turns 18, while purchasing pistols required the buyer to undergo a psychological evaluation. Police have said they did not have information about his possible motive. Footage shared online revealed how gunshots and screaming could be heard after the suspect entered the school before opening fire. French education minister Elisabeth Borne has said that one of those who died was a "young fellow citizen" of France. It came as the mother of a child who survived the shooting retold the distressing moment she received a phone call from her son. "My son called me to say he was in school and that he was being shot and that he thought he was going to die," she said. She only found out two hours later that he was still alive. Special forces were among those sent to the school, just under a mile from Graz's historic centre, after a call at 10am local time (9am UK time) on Tuesday. About an hour and half later, police wrote on X that the school had been evacuated and everyone had been taken to a safe meeting point. Police deployed in large numbers, with emergency vehicles guarding the area around the school and with at least one police helicopter flying above. Graz is located in the southeast of the country and about 300,000 people live there. A 'dark day' Austrian Chancellor Christian Stocker said there would be three days of national mourning, with the Austrian flag lowered to half-mast and a national minute of mourning at 10am on Wednesday. He said that it was "a dark day in the history of our country". President Alexander Van der Bellen said that "this horror cannot be captured in words". "These were young people who had their whole lives ahead of them. A teacher who accompanied them on their way," he said. Well-wishers later lit candles and placed them in the main square in Graz city centre on Tuesday night as a tribute to the shooting victims. People were seen quietly reflecting as the city tried to come to terms with the deadly attack. The school where the attack took place had earlier posted a message on Instagram following the tragedy. The message is written in German, the official language of Austria, and translates in English to: "It was a really terrible day that deeply impacted and affected us all. "Let us continue to stand together as a school community and support one another.
Scotsman
a day ago
- Scotsman
Can you afford not to have a cyber insurance policy?
Scott McLuskey helps clients find the cyber insurance policy that's right for them Cyber attacks cost Scottish businesses £386m annually – but most firms still aren't insured, warns Scott McLuskey Sign up to our Scotsman Money newsletter, covering all you need to know to help manage your money. Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to The Scotsman, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Recent high-profile cyber incidents involving major UK institutions including Marks & Spencer, Harrods, and the Co-op are a stark reminder: no business is immune to attack. I first spoke about the importance of cyber insurance at the inaugural Cyber Scotland Week six years ago, an initiative supported by the Government to promote cyber resilience. Since then, the threat has only accelerated – today, a cyber-attack occurs every 44 seconds in the UK. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Yet despite the scale of risk, many business leaders remain confident that their organisations are protected. Antivirus software, cloud backups, an in-house or outsourced IT Manager and a general belief that they're 'covered' often mask the reality: these measures alone are not enough. It wasn't just a cyber attack, it was an M&S cyber attack that cost millions (Picture: Adobe) Reports surrounding the recent attack on British retail heavyweight M&S suggest that the attack will cost an estimated £300 million and was not the result of poor systems, but of human error – a tale as old as time and the weakest link in any cyber defence strategy. Smaller businesses are also firmly in the firing line. Vodafone estimates Scottish SMEs are losing a combined £386m a year to Cyber Attacks, with 40% of SMEs falling victim last year alone. Costs following an attack can be significant: from forensic investigations, legal advice, regulatory notifications, and PR management, to lost revenue, extortion demands, credit monitoring, and potential lawsuits. The good news is that a cyber insurance policy offers a risk transfer solution to address these costs and assist recovery. Today's leading cyber policies also go beyond simple risk transfer – they include value-added services like vulnerability scans, penetration testing, and employee training. While not a substitute for a dedicated cybersecurity provider, these tools provide vital early protection and peace of mind. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad However, buying cyber insurance isn't always straightforward. With over 30 readily available cyber insurers – plus Lloyd's of London – and each provider offering a different proposition with their own minimum cyber security based acceptance criteria, the market can feel impenetrable. Unlike traditional insurance policies, cyber cover is still relatively new, with the first policy written in the late 1990s - the market and crucially insurer's loss data is continually developing. Compare that with buildings insurance, first developed in the wake of the Great Fire of London in the 17th century. As a result, there's wide variation in policy coverage, pricing, and – most importantly – what policyholders need to do to ensure claims are valid. Too often, businesses only realise this after a breach, when it's too late. There are promising signs. Leading providers like CFC Underwriting report a claims payout rate of over 99% and industry-wide improvements are being made in clarity, claims handling, and support services. But challenges remain – particularly for small and medium-sized businesses. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad A UK Government report found that 50% of businesses suffered some form of breach in the past year, rising to 70% among medium-sized firms. Yet just over half of all companies have cyber cover. Scotland's economy, built on a vibrant mix of SMEs, family-run firms, and fast-growing tech businesses, is particularly exposed. As the majority of organisations have digitised operations, even modest breaches can have a disproportionate impact – not only on individual companies, but on supply chains, customer trust, and investor confidence across the sector. Cyber resilience is no longer just a technical issue; it's an economic imperative. The Association of British Insurers has also identified a communication gap: cyber insurance is too often presented as a standalone 'product,' when in reality it's an ongoing service that begins before a breach and supports the business throughout. At Monteith, we're working to bridge this gap. We help clients understand their cyber exposure, decode policy language, and choose the right level of cover. Most importantly, we walk our clients through the fine print – ensuring they know exactly what's required to stay compliant, so their insurance delivers when it matters most. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad The threat isn't going away. Business leaders must go beyond firewalls and backups. They need to take proactive steps – including securing expert cyber insurance advice – to protect against what is now one of the most persistent and costly risks in modern business.
