Experts advise against black seed oil as bird flu treatment
"This black seed oil is so potent -- 90 percent killing all avian influenza virus, called H5N1, known as bird flu," claims Bryan Ardis in a February 3 Instagram reel.
Different versions of claims touting black seed oil spread on Facebook, Instagram and X, many of them referencing Ardis, who has an online show discussing health topics. AFP has previously fact-checked Ardis for spreading misinformation about
Image
Screenshot of an Instagram post taken February 28, 2025
The clip of Ardis discussing black seed oil comes from a video outlining the supposed benefits of a product he sells on his website that contains the su
The studies linked under Ardis's "bio-defense" to potential benefits of black seed oil in treating various conditions (archived here, here and here), but experts told AFP more research needs to be done before the herbal formula could be proven as a treatment for bird flu in humans.
Over the past year, doctors and the poultry industry have been tracking outbreaks of bird flu which have led to American egg shortages and in some cases spread to dairy cattle.
Dean Blumberg, chief of the pediatric infectious diseases division at University of California, Davis Health (archived here), told AFP in a February 24 interview people who work with animals -- especially who come in contact with liquid secretions from birds -- are currently the most at risk from avian flu.
Black seed oil, is often touted across the internet as an immune booster and general health treatment (archived here) but Blumberg said that even though there are some promising cases and small studies (archived here and here) he would not recommend the supplement to a patient to protect against or treat bird flu.
"You really want large studies that really prove that something works before you rely on it," Blumberg said. "If I had bird flu, there's no way I would take something unproven like this."
Blumberg favored double-blind, clinical trials, which he said had not yet been performed for black seed oil as a treatment for bird flu and other diseases. AFP was able to find a study of a labelled as a randomized, clinical trial which assessed black seed oil for general health and found "promising" results (archived here).
Prioritizing 'proven benefits'
To prevent bird flu, Blumberg recommended personal protective equipment (PPE) for people working with animals to lower the risk of exposure to contaminated fluids. He also said that while there were human cases of bird flu with unknown origin, most circulating strains of the virus do not appear to typically spread between people.
"It hasn't evolved yet into an efficiently transmitted human-to-human pathogen," he said.
According to the US Centers for Disease Control, human vaccination against bird flu is not recommended at this time (archived here). While Health Canada says there is a low public risk for the pathogen, it did acquire 500,000 doses of GSK human bird flu vaccines (archived here).
Blumberg explained that human cases of bird flu can be treated with antiviral medications such as Tamiflu and supportive care including supplemental oxygen if a patient is having trouble breathing (archived here and here).
David Cennimo, an associate professor of medicine and pediatrics at the Rutgers New Jersey Medical School (archived here), agreed with Blumberg that even if there is some potential for black seed oil to treat bird flu and other diseases, clear and widely-accepted evidence is lacking.
"Some authorities on alternative medicine suggest robust studies need to be done," Cennimo said in a February 25 email. "I tend to favor that approach."
Cennimo said he had not found any significant toxicities from black seed oil, but still recommended users check for adverse interactions between supplements and prescription medication.
He also said common antivirals used against influenza had already proved effective against current strains of avian influenza and that he would prefer to treat someone with medication that has been evaluated in "well-designed studies."
"I caution individuals not to pass up a proven benefit for an uncertain claim about black seed," he said.
Robert Hopkins, medical director of the National Foundation for Infectious Disease in the United States (archived here), also discouraged the use of black seed oil for bird flu and recommended limiting exposure to animal fluids and consultation with a health professional for guidance on testing and treatment.
"Scientific studies do not support the use of black seed oil as a treatment for bird flu," Hopkins said in a February 25 email. "However, antiviral flu drugs like oseltamivir are effective in treating bird flu, and new vaccines are being developed," (archived here).
Substance regulations
Health Canada told AFP that black seed oil is a regulated Natural Health Product (NHP) in Canada and that the agency had authorized two formulations which used it in combination with other substances for general health maintenance products (archived here and here). However, it does not recognize black seed oil as a reliable treatment for bird flu.
"Health Canada has seen no evidence to suggest black seed oil works to cure diseases like bird flu, and the department has neither received nor authorised the use of any NHP for treating bird flu in humans," said Mark Johnson, a Health Canada spokesman, in February 25 email.
Johnson said selling or advertising unauthorized health products in Canada is illegal.
The US Food and Drug Administration has issued at least two warnings to sellers of products with black seed oil over unproven claims that their stock cured, prevented or treated disease (archived here and here).
more AFP's reporting on health misinformation here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
France 24
9 hours ago
- France 24
Startups show off ocean-preserving tech at Paris trade fair
Recently developed AI programs capable of learning from vast datasets have boosted projects trying to understand and predict real-world phenomena, several company founders told AFP. "We have to use AI because in the natural world there are too many variables" to deal with manually, said Emily Charry Tissier, a biologist and founder of Canadian startup Whale Seeker, which is developing technology to track sea mammals. Powered by "neural network" systems that ape the functioning of the human brain, the learning systems behind today's AI models "can calculate a weather forecast 1,000 times faster than a standard digital model running on a supercomputer", agreed oceanographer Alexandre Stegner. He flagged an AI model developed by his firm, Amphitrite, that he said could predict ocean currents by crunching "several layers of satellite data corresponding to different physical variables". It can forecast currents up to 10 days in advance, he said, offering sea captains "a simple way to save fuel" by slightly changing course and using currents to gain a speed boost of up to four knots. That could save operators money on fuel, reduce the carbon emissions from shipping, and avoid the classic solution of telling sea captains to reduce their speed. Global protection push Technologies like these were being shown off in the halls of Vivatech as the UN Ocean Conference (UNOC) drew to a close hundreds of kilometres to the south in French Mediterranean city Nice. The conference has pushed a treaty to protect 60 percent of the world's oceans closer to becoming law, with 55 signatures -- just five shy of the number required for its enactment. New technologies could be "a very good thing" for the oceans, said Andre Abreu, International Affairs Director at the Paris-based Tara Ocean Foundation. But he warned that innovation should not be harnessed to allow more fish to be caught. "That would mean shooting ourselves in the foot" on goals like preserving marine biodiversity, he said. That ambiguity can be seen in technology from OceanEyes, a Japanese startup using AI analysis of satellite data to predict sea conditions. The company hopes to cut the time fishing boats spend tracking down a catch. "A big problem in Japan is the efficiency of the fishery operations. Many fishers spend a lot of time searching for fish in the water," said boss Yusuke Tanaka. With less fuel burnt, operators will save money and greenhouse emissions can be slashed. Anticipating concerns about overfishing, OceanEyes said it also aimed to help vessels comply with recently updated Japanese regulations that oblige fishers to "ensure sustainable use of marine resources". 'Can' vs 'should' Whale Seeker's Tissier said technology could be used in a considered way to find sustainable solutions. "I'd like the market to recognise its own limits -- not the limits of what we can do, but what we should do," she told AFP. That attitude pushed her to refuse to work with a company that wanted to use whale detection to identify nearby fish to catch. But startups cannot grow without funding and, in the context of oceans, investments are likely to come from big firms keen to make a saving -- from fishing and ship management companies to haulage and logistics giants. This could well limit their ability to stand on principle. Stegner called for "regulations that would push the maritime sector to reduce carbon emissions". But Charry Tissier said the initiative could come from business. "Technology is developing so much faster than regulation... what I'd like is for big companies to decide for themselves to be responsible," she said. © 2025 AFP
France 24
10 hours ago
- France 24
EU courts international scientists, but is Europe attractive enough?
Europe 11:35 The EU says science is the key to its future. But is it putting its money where its mouth is? Earlier this year, the French government agreed to cuts in the country's research budget and over the past year, science powerhouses such as Germany, Italy and the Netherlands have proposed or implemented cuts in their research sectors. Those working in universities and research centres say there is a stark gap between the way the EU is presenting itself as a magnet for global talent – the pitch that the French government and the European Commission made at their "Choose Europe for Science" conference in Paris in early May – and the reality. To make Europe more attractive, the EU executive says a €500 million package will be proposed for the 2025-2027 period. Part of that outreach is aimed at American researchers, who say their work is being jeopardised by the Trump administration's cuts. But the €500 million sum is the equivalent of just a fraction of the yearly endowment of a top US university such as Harvard or Yale. We delve into the issue with two MEPs.
France 24
2 days ago
- France 24
New T-Rex ancestor discovered in drawers of Mongolian institute
This slender ancestor of the massive Tyrannosaurus Rex was around four metres (13 feet) long and weighed three quarters of a tonne, according to a new study in the journal Nature. "It would have been the size of a very large horse," study co-author Darla Zelenitsky of Canada's University of Calgary told AFP. The fossils were first dug up in southeastern Mongolia in the early 1970s but at the time were identified as belonging to a different tyrannosaur, Alectrosaurus. For half a century, the fossils sat in the drawers at the Institute of Paleontology of the Mongolian Academy of Sciences in the capital Ulaanbaatar. Then PhD student Jared Voris, who was on a trip to Mongolia, started looking through the drawers and noticed something was wrong, Zelenitsky said. It turned out the fossils were well-preserved, partial skeletons of two different individuals of a completely new species. "It is quite possible that discoveries like this are sitting in other museums that just have not been recognised," Zelenitsky added. 'Messy' family history They named the new species Khankhuuluu mongoliensis, which roughly means the dragon prince of Mongolia because it is smaller than the "king" T-Rex. Zelenitsky said the discovery "helped us clarify a lot about the family history of the tyrannosaur group because it was really messy previously". The T-Rex represented the end of the family line. It was the apex predator in North America until 66 million years ago, when an asteroid bigger than Mount Everest slammed into the Gulf of Mexico. Three quarters of life on Earth was wiped out, including all the dinosaurs that did not evolve into birds. Around 20 million years earlier, Khankhuuluu -- or another closely related family member -- is now believed to have migrated from Asia to North America using the land bridge that once connected Siberia and Alaska. This led to tyrannosaurs evolving across North America. Then one of these species is thought to have crossed back over to Asia, where two tyrannosaur subgroups emerged. One was much smaller, weighing under a tonne, and was nicknamed Pinocchio rex for its long snout. The other subgroup was huge and included behemoths like the Tarbosaurus, which was only a little smaller than the T-rex. One of the gigantic dinosaurs then left Asia again for North America, eventually giving rise to the T-Rex, which dominated for just two million years -- until the asteroid struck. © 2025 AFP
