Attorney General Lord Hermer 'asks civil servants to snitch on ministers to give himself effective veto over Government policies'
The peer has issued guidance to government lawyers stressing the importance of following international law.
The document includes what has been branded a 'snitch clause', urging civil servants to report any concerns that ministerial actions might be illegal.
The tweaks seemingly water down instructions issued by Suella Braverman in 2022 to prevent lawyers from 'blocking' plans.
In total, Lord Hermer – a senior human rights barrister before entering government – is said to have added 23 references to international law to the guidance.
Legal staff are also instructed to assume that every decision taken by the Government could face a challenge. Previously the advice suggested challenges were unlikely.
Critics have complained that Lord Hermer has put too much emphasis on the letter of international law. Just last month he was accused of 'blocking' Britain from helping to defend Israel against Iran strikes.
He is also said to have played a major role in 'surrendering' the Chagos Islands, the UK's last Indian Ocean territory, to adhere to a non-binding ruling by the International Court of Justice.
Sir Michael Ellis, a former Conservative attorney general, said Lord Hermer had 'effectively given himself a veto over all government business'.
'It is quite something if ministers of the crown within the same Government cannot be trusted, and have to be snitched on by their own officials,' he told The Daily Telegraph.
Tory MP Alex Burghart branded the guidance a 'surrender charter', adding: 'Measures like the snitch clause will undermine discussion across government and harm our national interest.
'Keir Starmer's attorney general is putting the partisan views of activist lawyers before the national interest.'
A source close to Lord Hermer said: 'This is desperate nonsense from a Tory party who have lost credibility on law and order and upholding the rule of law.
'Tory ministers routinely pursued unworkable gimmicks that they knew would be defeated in the courts, such as the Rwanda debacle.
'In contrast, this Government demands lawyers to be creative solution finders, enabling our ambitious Plan for Change to succeed – unblocking obstacles so policies are not held up for years in the courts.'
A spokesman for the attorney general said: 'Government lawyers advise ministers, but it is always ministers that make decisions on policy as has been the case under successive governments.'
A No 10 spokesman said: 'The role of the law officers, including the attorney general, is to ensure the Government acts lawfully by providing frank legal advice, but policy decisions are always for ministers to decide.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Sun
6 minutes ago
- The Sun
Labour unveils £100m plan to battle housing crisis by training 40,000 builders by 2029
JOBLESS youngsters need to get off the couch and on to the building site, the Education Secretary says. Bridget Phillipson warned the housing crisis was being made worse by a lack of construction workers. 2 2 And she added that Brits, rather than migrants, must fill the shortage. She will today announce £100million in funding for technical colleges to train 40,000 brickies, roofers and electricians by 2029. Labour's pledge to build 1.5 million homes by the next election hinges on plugging 35,000 vacancies in the sector. Meanwhile, 12.5 per cent of all 16 to 24-year-olds — around one million — are not in education, employment or training. Ms Phillipson welcomed The Sun's Builder Better Britain campaign for 'putting construction on the map' as we bang a drum for the industry. And she added: 'If you're an out-of-work young person or looking for a career change, get up, get skills and get building.' She said training homegrown talent was the best way to build the homes, schools and hospitals Britain is crying out for. The Department for Education last night said the ten new technical excellence colleges would help end the reliance on overseas construction workers. It said: 'Britain cannot and should not rely on foreign labour.' David Hughes, chief executive of the Association of Colleges, said: 'Today's announcement is very positive news for people wanting good jobs, for the construction employers looking for skilled people and for the Government's ambitions to build 1.5 million new homes.'
The Sun
6 minutes ago
- The Sun
Labour slammed for masking true cost of handing Chagos Islands to Mauritius
LABOUR is under fire for masking the true cost of handing the Chagos Islands to Mauritius. Taxpayers will spend £34.7million on a 99-year lease of the archipelago's military base, a freedom of information request reveals. 2 But yesterday Justice minister Alex Davies-Jones said the government does 'not recognise' that figure. She told GB News: 'The Prime Minister has been forthright in saying the true cost of this is £3.4billion.' Defending the deal as vital to national security, she added: 'The US is on board with this agreement to make sure we can maintain the Diego Garcia base for national security.' But Shadow Chancellor Mel Stride slammed the government's assurances on the cost of leasing the base as 'totally and utterly unacceptable'. He said: 'They want to make the numbers look smaller. 'We don't think that's being straight with the British people.' The £34.7billion figure — obtained by the Government Actuary's Department — is the lease's total cost over 99 years. Financial experts estimate it is the equivalent to around £10billion in today's money, once the effects on inflation have been stripped out. But that's still nearly three times the figure given by Sir Keir Starmer. A Government spokesman said: 'The Diego Garcia military base is essential to the security of the UK and our key allies. Starmer signs deal with Mauritius to hand over Chagos Islands 'The average cost is £101million per year, and the net present value of payments is £3.4billion — less than 0.2 per cent of the annual defence budget. 'The costs compare favourably with other international military base agreements.'
The Sun
6 minutes ago
- The Sun
Sir Keir Starmer slaps down Labour peer after she calls for controversial Foreign Office statue to be torn down
A LABOUR peer has been slapped down by Sir Keir Starmer after calling for the Clive of India statue outside the Foreign Office to be torn down. Baroness Debbonaire branded the 1912 bronze 'a shocking piece of sculpture' and said it was 'not helpful' for Britain's relationship with India. Clive of India was an East India Company clerk who became Governor of Bengal and led Britain's expansion in the subcontinent. But he is also blamed for mismanaging the Bengal famine, which killed millions. His name was stripped from a house at his former private school in the wake of the Black Lives Matter movement. The former shadow culture secretary and Bristol MP told a book festival: 'I'm not sure that a statue of Clive should really have any place outside the Foreign Office. 'I walk past it and the frieze shows happy, smiling people really delighted to see him. "And that's just not historically accurate. "It's not helpful for our current relationship with India and it is deeply unhelpful to see India as a country that Britain civilised.' But the PM's spokesman distanced himself from her comments yesterday, saying: 'I'm not sure you achieve very much by going round taking statues down, but I haven't seen that.' Baroness Debonnaire has previously campaigned against monuments, demanding slave trader Edward Colston's statue be removed two years before it was toppled in Bristol in 2020. At the time she said: 'Having statues of people who oppressed us is not a good thing to be saying to black people in this city.' 2 Statue of Edward Colston is thrown into river after being pulled down in Bristol
