Can Aaron Rodgers succeed if he waits until late summer to sign with Steelers? Brett Favre did it
August 18? That can't be possible. That was a few days before the Vikings' second preseason game. We've heard over and over that quarterbacks need all offseason to build bonds with their new teammates and learn the offense. But Favre must have had a terrible 2009 season, starting that late. Right?
Advertisement
Not exactly. He had maybe his best NFL season at age 40. Maybe Aaron Rodgers and the Pittsburgh Steelers can continue to wait for each other.
Rodgers and the Steelers have been connected for months, but still there's no official agreement on a contract. Rodgers said he has been dealing with personal issues, and is on no timetable to make a decision. So we wait.
There has to be some unease about Rodgers being unsigned, though the Steelers haven't shown that outwardly. Coaches like players being at OTAs and minicamps, getting used to teammates and the playbook.
But Rodgers has been following Favre in many ways for many years. And waiting turned out just fine for Favre in Minnesota.
Can Aaron Rodgers be ready if he signs late?
Favre's 2009 offseason was wild. He said he was retiring after a season with the New York Jets and insisted he was never playing again. By the summer that seemed to be a part of a plan to land with the Vikings. The Jets released him and he ended up with the Vikings.
Advertisement
But not until mid-August. In late July, after training camp had already started, Favre insisted he was still retired. Then it changed. And you think that Rodgers not being signed in late May this year is a cause for alarm.
In Minnesota Favre played in a West Coast offensive scheme he was familiar with, and that likely helped. But there weren't many questions at the time about Favre assimilating himself with the Vikings. And it didn't end up being an issue.
In 2009 Favre had one of the best seasons of his career. He posted a 107.2 passer rating, almost eight points higher than the second-best mark of his Hall of Fame career. He finished fourth in the MVP voting and had a good argument to win it. Had the Vikings not melted down late in the NFC championship game, Favre would have taken Minnesota to its only Super Bowl since the 1977 season.
He didn't exactly need all those May minicamp reps. Rodgers might not either.
The NFL world continues to wait for Aaron Rodgers to sign with a new team. (Photo by)
(Andy Lyons via Getty Images)
When will Rodgers sign?
Favre is an outlier. But so is Rodgers.
Advertisement
Rodgers and Favre are linked forever, and their careers have mirrored each other in many ways from the multiple MVPs and single Super Bowl title, to the short late-career time with the Jets to a third team right before retirement (assuming Rodgers does sign with the Steelers or someone else).
Coaches are obsessive about practice reps, and mostly for good reason, but it can be overstated. Favre was fine in 2009. Offenses executed very well in 2020 after an unprecedented and mostly lost offseason due to COVID-19. Just two seasons ago Joe Flacco was signed by the Cleveland Browns in November and helped them to the playoffs. Smart veteran quarterbacks, especially ones with the pedigree of a Favre or Rodgers, usually figure things out.
In a perfect world, Rodgers would sign with the Steelers as soon as possible and be with the team through the rest of the spring and the start of training camp. The Steelers coaches would almost certainly prefer that. With every day Rodgers misses, you'll hear anxious reports about him being ready for the season.
All signs are that Rodgers will sign with the Steelers. It's just a matter of when. And if it takes a while, it still might end up just fine. It did for Rodgers' former Packers teammate.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
USA Today
a few seconds ago
- USA Today
Jaguars coach evaluates current state of DT unit after latest boosts to depth
With the addition of Khalen Saunders along with Arik Armstead and Maason Smith returning to practice, Anthony Campanile evaluated the Jaguars DT unit. In the matter of just a few days, the Jacksonville Jaguars' defensive tackle unit looks a lot different. Earlier in the week, the Jaguars traded for Khalen Saunders, while during Tuesday and Wednesday's practices, Arik Armstead and Maason Smith were back participating in team drills. "I think it makes a difference with all those guys out there," Anthony Campanile said on Wednesday. "They look good. I thought they did a good job in the rush today and do a good job in the run game. They're big explosive bodies, so I think that's going to be a big help to us and that's something we're excited about." Armstead and Smith had been sidelined all of training camp with injuries, which resulted in the Jaguars relying very heavily on the recently signed Austin Johnson, along with Jordan Jefferson and Tyler Lacy. Defensive tackle is a position that has had its unknowns dating back to the offseason. Those question marks lingered when no major outside additions were made in free agency or the NFL draft, and the uncertainty grew while Armstead and Smith were sidelined. But now with those two back in the fold, the unit gets an obvious boost. Armstead is back at defensive tackle, where he put together some dominant seasons in San Francisco. With Smith, the Jaguars are hoping to see a Year 2 leap from him in Campanile's more attacking and movement-heavy scheme. The addition of Saunders provides another run-stuffing presence along the interior and someone who has played in big games in his career, having won two Super Bowls. However, Campanile also likes Saunders' ability to rush the passer as well. "Toughness," Campanile said of Saunders. "He is a really, really twitchy guy, in my opinion. Watching him and all that, just watching him go through the drills and everything, he brings a level of physicality. I think he has tremendous block release, to be honest with you. "When you watch him, he does a really good job of not staying blocked. He's hard to move on the inside along the interior. So it's always great to have a twitchy guy like that inside where you feel like you can still get some rush even in early down action once he reacts to dropback or play-action pass." Improved play from the tackle position in 2025 can go a long way in getting better play out of the entire defense as a whole.
USA Today
a few seconds ago
- USA Today
Pair of Raiders back-end WRs shine at practice with roster cuts looming
The Las Vegas Raiders held one of their final practices of training camp on Tuesday. The Raiders will play their third and final preseason game versus the Arizona Cardinals on Saturday evening. Less than 72 hours later, general manager John Spytek and head coach Pete Carroll will be tasked with submitting their initial 53-man roster on Tuesday afternoon. We've officially reached the critical portion of training camp. Final roster decisions are being made. These last few practices, paired with Saturday's exhibition finale, will help Spytek and Carroll sort through the few remaining position battles. Unsurprisingly, a pair of back-end roster wide receivers used looming roster cuts as motivation. Both Alex Bachman and Marquez Callaway were stellar performers at Tuesday's practice, according to Levi Edwards. The 29-year-old Bachman has been a fan favorite at training camp. A journeyman who first entered the league via undrafted free agency in 2019, Bachman has made several tough grabs in traffic. Through two preseason contests, he's recorded four receptions for 51 yards. Callaway hasn't made a catch in the preseason, but his NFL-quality size and speed has been on display at practice. Once upon a time, Callaway produced 698 receiving yards as a sophomore wideout in 2021. The former Tennessee Volunteer hasn't replicated that production since, and has been waived by a plethora of teams over the previous three offseasons. Callaway and Bachman could be competing for one roster spot.
Miami Herald
a few seconds ago
- Miami Herald
Buoyed by quarterback's return, USF ready to take on daunting early schedule
It's either a gargantuan opportunity for the South Florida Bulls … or a cavernous hole that they will have to dig out of after the first three weeks of the 2025 football season. Here's why: USF's first three games are at home against Boise State, which went 12-2 last year and made the College Football Playoffs; and then on the road against Florida and Miami, who combined to go 18-8. But the Bulls aren't backing down. Alex Golesh, who has gone 7-6 with a bowl win in each of his first two years as USF's coach, said he is aiming much higher this year. 'Sometimes the progress made doesn't immediately show up in the record,' Golesh said at the American Athletic Conference Media Day news conference. 'But I'm proud of what we've built at USF, and I think we're ready to take the next step.' Golesh is thrilled by the return of quarterback Byrum Brown, who played just five games last season before he was lost to a leg injury. However, in 12 games in 2023, Brown completed 64.6% of his passes for a program-record 3,292 yards, 26 touchdowns and 11 interceptions. But what makes Brown even more dynamic is his elite running ability. In 2023, he led USF in rushing yards (809) and touchdowns (11). As for the rest of the team, USF's top running back is Cartevious Norton, a 5-11, 225-pound battering ram who has played two years at Iowa State (where he started seven games) and one at Charlotte. For his career, he has rushed for 1,180 yards, a 3.9 average and 12 touchdowns. USF's offensive line returns four starters, including pro prospect Zane Herring at right guard. The Bulls also added two experienced transfers. Keshaun Singleton — who came on late last season and finished with 26 catches — is USF's top wide receiver, and he gets high grades for his hands and his playmaking ability. Receiver, though, could be an area of concern overall. On defense, the Bulls are aggressive. They were solid against the run last year, but they were the second-worst AAC defense against the pass (279 yards per game). This year's defense will be led by veteran lineman Josh Celiscar, 23, a sixth-year player who is married with a daughter. In other words, he's a grown man, and he previously played for UCF and Texas A&M. Linebacker is the strength of the defense, including Mac Harris, who is ranked the fourth-best pro prospect in the AAC. In 2024, he led USF in tackles (82) and stops for losses (12). Other experienced linebackers are Jhalyn Singer; Rico Watson III; and North Texas transfer Chavez Brown. The kicker is Nico Gramatica, the son of Martin Gramatica, who won a Super Bowl with Tampa Bay and also made the Pro Bowl in 2000. Nico, ranked the top kicking recruit in the Class of 2024, went 3 for 5 on field goals as a freshman last season. He will be the full-time starter this year. In total, the Bulls return six starters on offense and six on defense. 'It's all about developing players, building a team and finding a way to win,' Golesh said. 'We've put USF in a really good position.'
