Monetary Policy Affects Some Parts Of The Economy Differently: RBNZ Analytical Note
Reserve Bank of New Zealand – Te Pūtea Matua research found that sectors that make or trade goods, as well as housing and real estate related sectors are among the most sensitive to changes in the Official Cash Rate.
'When the OCR increases, these sectors tend to cool more quickly. On the other hand, sectors like primary production including dairy and meat, are less sensitive,' the Analytical Note authors say.
The research also looked at how monetary policy affects prices across a wide range of domestic goods and services, which do not face as much foreign competition as internationally traded goods.
'We found that prices for accommodation are quite sensitive. So, when the OCR increases, it puts downward pressure on the cost of going on holiday or business,' the authors say.
An OCR increase also has a strong impact on the cost of building a home. This means when the OCR increases, there is relatively more downward pressure on these costs than for prices of other domestic goods and services in the economy. Some services, like household power prices and insurance, are slower to respond to increases in the OCR.
We carried out this research because identifying which parts of the economy are relatively more sensitive to monetary policy allows us to better understand how various parts of the economy may react when interest rates change. It also means we can see more clearly if past policy decisions are working through to the economy as expected.
Key findings:
We investigate the sensitivity of output and prices to monetary policy at a disaggregated level, focusing on GDP sectors and CPI non-tradables subgroups in New Zealand. Identifying which parts of the economy are relatively more responsive to monetary policy allows us to better understand how various parts of the economy may evolve in response to policy decisions and to better assess whether past policy decisions are transmitting to the economy as expected.
For GDP, we find that goods-producing and goods-trading sectors are the most sensitive to monetary policy, while primary production and public services are the least sensitive.
For CPI non-tradables inflation, we find subgroups such as housing construction costs and accommodation services are more sensitive to monetary policy, while subgroups such as energy and insurance are less sensitive.
The small sample size leads to greater variation in estimated effects across model variations. As such, this analysis aims to serve as a starting point for further work in this area.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scoop
4 days ago
- Scoop
Tariffs And Uncertainty Likely To Dampen Medium-Term Inflation Pressures
Global tariffs and economic uncertainty are likely to mean less inflation pressures in New Zealand and a pullback in business investment and household spending, RBNZ Chief Economist Paul Conway says. However, the economy is currently supported by high export prices and lower interest rates, he says. In a speech delivered to Business New Zealand in Wellington today, Mr Conway says that as a small, open economy, we are heavily influenced by global developments. 'Being tied in with the global economy helps us prosper. It also means that when something big happens offshore, such as the imposition of tariffs, its ripple effects impact the New Zealand economy,' he says. The US has made a decisive shift towards a more trade protectionist stance, which is a major change in the global trading environment with significant implications for the global economy, Mr Conway says. Tariffs may make global supply chains less efficient and could nudge up the cost of imports. This is why tariffs are expected to add to inflation pressures in the US. But for New Zealand, the main impact is likely to be weaker global growth, which could reduce demand for our exports and lower import prices. Import prices could fall further as other countries redirect their exports away from the US. This is expected to reduce inflation pressures here. At the same time, uncertainty is elevated, making it harder for households and businesses to plan. 'When businesses aren't sure what's coming, they hold off hiring and delay big investments. Households tend to respond to increased uncertainty by putting off big spends or job moves,' Mr Conway says. 'There's a whole lot of 'wait and see' going on out there right now.' 'On net, these developments are expected to slow New Zealand's economic recovery over mid-2026 and reduce medium-term inflation pressures. This is against a backdrop of strong export prices, especially for dairy and beef, and lower interest rates. With inflation back under control, the Monetary Policy Committee has cut the Official Cash Rate (OCR) from 5.5% last year to 3.25% now. As outlined in the July Monetary Policy Review, the Committee sees scope to lower the OCR further if medium-term inflation pressures continue to ease as projected, Mr Conway says.
NZ Herald
5 days ago
- NZ Herald
John Key is right that New Zealand needs to cut interest rates but we need more than that too
Key warns the coalition risks losing the next election. He says the Reserve Bank got interest rates wrong again – first too low, now too high – and it's crushing the economy. The data backs him. Massey University's GDPLive shows GDP growth at just 0.261% for the quarter and down 0.53% annually. It puts inflation at 2.18%. With dairy booming, most of the economy must be in recession. The Reserve Bank's Nowcast GDP tracker is down 0.288% for the quarter. Key says that with no sign of wage inflation, the Reserve Bank should cut the Official Cash Rate by 100 basis points – from 3.25% to 2.25%. The Taylor Rule that central banks use to guide interest rates indicates the OCR is 50 basis points too high. Key is also right that the central bank's money printing fuelled the inflation that destroyed the last Government. Now, with rates too high, it's strangling growth and may destroy this one. It seems the Government had no plan for replacing former Reserve Bank Governor Adrian Orr. I nominate Key. He's qualified and has the judgment the job demands. If appointed and interest rates are cut, the economy would be growing in election year. If Key is unavailable, appoint the economist who warned that $100 billion in quantitative easing would cause inflation: Auckland University's professor Robert MacCulloch. Internationally recognised for his work on central banking. If the coalition aspires to more than winning elections, it must do what Key never did: tackle why New Zealand is sliding down the OECD rankings. It's not that the world doesn't want what we sell. Dairy prices are excellent, meat sales are solid, and tourism is recovering. We're just badly managed. To lift our standard of living, we must raise our productivity which has been static for a decade. The Treasury's recent analysis highlights that 'New Zealand has much lower levels of capital per worker than OECD peers'. We lag Australia because its compulsory superannuation pumps billions into productive investment. We should have shifted to savings-based super 50 years ago. That's no reason not to do it now. Last week's abandonment of open-plan classrooms was a good start to lifting education standards. Abandoning pupil-led learning would be even better. Health is another failure. We have a Soviet-style monopoly with low productivity. Waiting lists grow despite record spending. More money is not the answer. Singapore achieves better outcomes for less – based on compulsory savings, price transparency, and private providers. We should copy it. One thing Key did achieve was restraining the growth of the civil service. According to the International Monetary Fund, Government expenditure was an estimated 41.39% of GDP in 2023. The 59% of the economy in private hands just isn't big enough to generate the investment, wealth and exports we need. We are over-regulated. The OECD's 2023 Government at a Glance ranked New Zealand last in the OECD for barriers to permits, licences and foreign investment. The Regulatory Standards Bill isn't a nice-to-have. It's essential. Key is also right about the ban on foreign home buyers. Foreigners won't bring their capital or expertise if they're told they can only rent. There are about 200,000 able-bodied adults on Jobseeker Support. That number has barely moved since Key's time, despite job vacancies and social investment strategies. Australia has had a Work for the Dole scheme since 1997. Employment Minister Peter McCardle introduced Work for the Dole scheme in 1998. Labour scrapped it. We should try again. Last year, in an international comparison, New Zealand's economy ranked 33rd out of 37. That makes it a mystery why Luxon waited so long to visit China, our biggest trading partner. And why did the Prime Minister go to a Nato summit in Europe? Every other Pacific PM stayed away knowing the summit would pledge to spend 5% of GDP on defence and criticise China. As New Zealand is not going to do either a PM focused on growth would have stayed at home. We have a bloated bureaucracy focused on political correctness rather than the hard work of delivery. An opposition that thinks New Zealand can tax its way to prosperity. An economy that's 41% government, starved of capital, and bound in red tape. Without reform, we will never climb the OECD ladder. Key's rate cut might win the next election. Only real reform will return New Zealand to the top tier of the OECD.
NZ Herald
5 days ago
- NZ Herald
Deputy Prime Minister David Seymour defends high butter prices, highlights benefits for farmers
'There are two ways you can look at this. One is to criticise the fact that, you know, prices are high, they're set overseas, and they benefit New Zealand farmers. 'Or we can ask ourselves, how do we ensure that New Zealand has a growing economy, a high-wage economy, so that when prices spike like this it doesn't have a big impact on families.' He claimed petrol prices were low at the moment, and those were high when dairy was cheap so the consistent theme was that 'need for a high wage economy'. Yesterday, Finance Minister Nicola Willis met with Fonterra chief executive Miles Hurrell to discuss the high prices, though Seymour said the meeting was not unusual. 'I think people have misrepresented the whole purpose of the meeting'. Willis told Bridge yesterday morning the meeting would not solely be about butter, but the high price paid by New Zealanders for the dairy product would be on the agenda. 'I will be asking about their retail pricing model, how they're seeing the supermarkets' margins, how they're seeing their own margins, understanding what's getting through to the consumer and whether there's anything we can do there.' In May, Fonterra posted a $1.158 billion Q3 profit and pitched its farmgate milk price forecast for the 2025/26 season in a range of $8-$11 per kg of milk solids. Inflation figures released yesterday show the consumer price index (CPI) increased 2.7% in the 12 months to the June 2025 quarter. That means the official inflation rate is at its highest point in the last year. Green Party co-leader Chloe Swarbrick said there needed to be greater urgency when breaking up the supermarket duopoly. 'That looks, of course, like greater transparency around particularly supply chains. And there's been a lot of words on it, but not a heck of a lot of action.'
