Pakistan PM's 'military retreat speech' is doctored
"Pakistan Prime Minister Shahbaz Khan accepted defeat in Parliament," reads the Hindi-language caption of a clip shared May 10, 2025 on Facebook, misspelling the premier's name and using a popular Pakistani surname.
The video apparently shows Sharif telling parliament in Urdu: "We are retreating in the ongoing war with India. Our armed forces are fighting bravely, but lack of resources, political isolation and the power of the enemy has put us in a quandary."
Similar posts sharing the clip circulated among Indian users elsewhere on Instagram, Facebook, X and Threads the same day US President Donald Trump unexpectedly announced a ceasefire (archived link).
The truce halted four days of intense fighting between the South Asian rivals that killed more than 70 people on both sides (archived link).
Fighter jet, missile, drone and artillery strikes erupted two weeks after gunmen killed 26 people on the Indian-run side of disputed Kashmir in an attack New Delhi blamed on Islamabad. Pakistan denies the accusations (archived here and here).
The ceasefire has held, but the circulating video does not show a genuine speech from Sharif.
A reverse image search on Google using keyframes led to longer footage published May 7 by the Pakistani Urdu-language news channel Samaa TV on YouTube (archived link).
"PM Shehbaz Sharif's Aggressive Speech at National Assembly | India Attack Pakistan | Pak Army Alert!" the title says.
Sharif commends Pakistan's armed forces, saying they thwarted India's strikes that day -- but nowhere in the video does he make the remarks claimed in the false posts.
"With the prayers of 240 million Pakistanis, our brave and valiant Pakistani armed forces gave a befitting reply to the filthy attack by India, turned that dark night into a moonlit night," he said.
"In this attack by India many Pakistanis were martyred including children, women and men. Please pray for them."
The newspaper Pakistan Today, as well as Indian news websites Hindustan Times and Brut India, also covered Sharif's remarks (archived here, here and here).
An analysis of the clip circulating online found several visual inconsistencies suggesting it was doctored.
Sharif's lip movements and hand gestures are unnatural, indicating manipulation using artificial intelligence technology. An AFP journalist in Islamabad confirmed the voice and accent is not Sharif's.
As of May 16, there had been no official reports of Sharif announcing before Pakistan's parliament that the country was retreating.
AFP has debunked a wave of misinformation about the India-Pakistan conflict here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
New York Post
35 minutes ago
- New York Post
Russia blasts Ukrainian maternity ward as it launches ‘one of the largest' airstrikes on Kyiv
Russia blasted a maternity ward in Ukraine overnight Monday as it unleashed one of its largest airstrikes of the war against Kyiv — firing more than 300 drones and missiles over the border, Ukrainian officials said. 'Today was one of the largest attacks on Kyiv,' President Volodymyr Zelensky said. 'Russian missile and Shahed (drone) strikes drown out the efforts of the United States and others around the world to force Russia into peace.' The mass bombardment, which followed the record airstrikes on Monday, lit up the sky in Kyiv for nearly five hours early Tuesday, leaving fires and smoke over the capital, witnesses told Reuters. 5 Kyiv suffered five hours of bombardments overnight in one of the largest Russian assaults on the city since the war began in 2022. Global Images Ukraine via Getty Images 5 Shattered windows littered the halls of a maternity ward in Odesa that was hit by Russian drones. REUTERS Ten districts in the capital were directly hit after the Ukraine Airforce could only intercept 277 of the 315 drones fired, leaving at least one person dead and four people hospitalized, Kyiv officials said. '[It's] a difficult night for all of us,' Timur Tkachenko, head of Kyiv's city military administration, summarized on Telegram. Along with the assault on the capital, the drones also struck a maternity ward, an emergency medical building and a residential building in the southern port of Odesa, the regional governor said. The attack killed at least two men and injured nine others in the port city, but the patients and staff at the maternity ward were spared after evacuating the hospital, Gov. Oleh Kiper said on Telegram. 5 Ukrainian emergency responders continue to put out the flames from the early Tuesday strike in Kyiv. Ukrinform/Shutterstock 5 A woman sits outside a residential building that was struck by Russian drones in Odesa. AFP via Getty Images Footage from inside the hospital showed the aftermath of the blast, with a woman in hospital scrubs seen sweeping the shards of broken glass away as the maternity ward returned to operation on Tuesday. The Kremlin has fired 1,451 drones and 78 missiles over the past week, according to Ukraine's air force, the most intense airstrike campaign of the three year war. Monday alone saw Russia fire 479 Shahed drones and 20 missiles in a record strike that included Ukrainian military targets just 40 miles from the Polish border, triggering a NATO alert. 5 First responders carry a body out of a destroyed building in Odessa, where two men were killed by Russian airstrikes. UKRAINIAN EMERGENCY SERVICE/AFP via Getty Images Moscow had vowed to retaliate hard against Kyiv over the humiliating attack earlier this month that saw Ukrainian drones damage and destroy dozens of Russia's heavy bombers in 'Operation Spider Web.' The growing escalation of violence comes after peace talks between Moscow and Kyiv stalled, with no end to the war in sight despite the Trump administration's efforts to reach a cease-fire deal, which Russia has repeatedly rejected. With Post wires
Time Magazine
42 minutes ago
- Time Magazine
Mahrang Baloch Writes From Prison: ‘Speaking Up for Justice Is Not a Crime'
It has been more than two and a half months since I was thrown into prison —Hudda Prison, in Quetta, Pakistan, the same place father was caged nearly two decades ago, also for promoting the rights of the people of Balochistan. Since my arrest, Pakistan's state secuity agencies have deployed every tactic to break me. I have been offered a deal: stay silent, avoid political activity, and you can be home. I refused. The state has failed to produce a single piece of evidence linking me to any act of violence or criminality. The only "proof" they cite is a press conference I gave a few days before my March 22 arrest. I spoke to reporters after armed militants had hijacked a train and held 300 passengers hostage for hours. The attack occurred in the Balochistan, the largest province in Pakistan, and was carried out by Baloch separatists who have been fighting with the state for decades. At the press conference, I spoke not to defend the hijackers—our movement, the Baloch Yakjehti [Unity] Committee, has always renounced violence. Indeed, my intention was to draw a distinction between those who confront the state with arms and those who confront it with words. It's a crucial distinction, one the state prefers to blur. In Pakistan, 'terrorist' is a label pinned on anyone who advocates for Baloch rights. Those who speak up run the risk of arrest by military and intelligence agencies. After their arrest, they might never be seen again. If they are, it is often as a body, produced after a violent incident like the train attack. This was why I asked reporters: Who were the more than two dozen 'unidentified' bodies brought to Quetta's Civil Hospital after the hijacking? And why were 13 of them buried overnight without being named? The attackers, the Baloch Liberation Party, had released pictures and details of the 12 militants it said were killed. The identities of the rest were a mystery, but we had our suspicions. In Balochistan it is common practice, after violent episodes, for the forcibly disappeared persons to be put to death, and their bodies produced as those of militants. I demanded DNA testing of those who had been buried in the dead of night. Families of the disappeared feared, with good reason, that their loved ones were among them. Read more: Pakistan Jails Baloch Human Rights Activist So I am in jail for insisting on the distinction between peaceful activism and violence. My work had already drawn unwelcome international attention. In May 2024, Pakistani officials were outraged after I visited Norway at the invitation of PEN Norway, the Norwegian branch of PEN International and the World Expression Forum. I was even harassed on Norwegian soil by individuals linked to Pakistan's embassy in Oslo, whose intervention was ended by the Norwegian domestic security agency, PST. When I returned to Pakistan, I was immediately charged with sedition, and treated as if I had returned from an ISIS camp in Syria or Iraq rather than one of the most peace-loving countries in the world. In October, the government's smear campaigns amplified with my inclusion on the TIME100 Next Emerging Leaders. I was called 'Malala 2' and a Western puppet. Surveillance around me intensified, and I was placed on the Fourth Schedule, an anti-terror watch list typically reserved for hardened militants, and which restricts the movement and activities of the listed. I was barred from travelling abroad. I am learning the price of peaceful activism. For decades, Pakistan has kept the rest of the country, and the world, in the dark about Balochistan. It remains an information black hole. Among those the military and intelligence agencies have forcibly disappeared, killed, or forced into exile are journalists who dare to write about these atrocities. According to the Balochistan Union of Journalists, more than 40 have been killed since 2000. Foreign media are denied access to the region. From this darkness, a woman leading a grassroots movement for Baloch rights was unacceptable. The hostility of the state intensified with the BBC's 100 Women list, and a nomination for the Nobel Peace Prize. But if international pressure has prevented my being killed, I face psychological warfare, threats, and the constant spectre of danger. I write this the day my sister told me that the Islamic State of Khorasan (ISIS-K) released a 100-page Urdu-language booklet accusing me of being a Western agent. Their "evidence"? The TIME honor and Norway trip. Other BYC leaders are in jail with me: Sabghat Ullah Shah Jee, Beebarg Zehri (a disabled man), Gulzadi, and Beebow. I tell them: We are not the first to be imprisoned for demanding peace, justice, and rights. From Nelson Mandela to Narges Mohammadi, we walk the same path. We draw strength from their courage, intellect, and defiance. Our movement is rooted in peace. We speak against enforced disappearances, extrajudicial killings, forced displacement, and the systematic denial of basic rights to the Baloch. We are the rightful owners of the Saindak Copper-Gold Project (worth billions of dollars, but the profits are not shared with the local population), the Reko Diq mine (estimated to hold copper and gold reserves worth over $60 billion, but the benefits are not reaching the Baloch people), and Gwadar — the gateway to the China-Pakistan Economic Corridor. Yet, 70% of Balochistan's population lives below the poverty line. Read more: Pakistan Bars Activist From Traveling to TIME Event Honoring Her The state is offended and brands us terrorists and violent. But we are not violent. The state is armed, powerful, and ruthless. It uses violence to silence those who ask for justice. The practices once reserved for the Baloch, considered lesser citizens, are now expanding to other parts of Pakistan. Former Prime Minister Imran Khan and his party are now under the military's wrath. He is jailed. Is Imran Khan also a terrorist? Are members of his PTI party now "agents of hostile agencies"? If the Pakistan Army and its intelligence agencies are as competent as they claim to be, why have they failed to present a single piece of credible proof? Why have they not held a fair, transparent trial? Because this isn't about the law; it's about fear, their fear of our truth. This prison is more than bricks and bars. It carries the memory of my father. As a child, I visited him here. I didn't grow up playing with toys. I grew up holding posters of my father, who was detained and then disappeared. When I turned eighteen, I received his lifeless, tortured, bullet-riddled body. This is not just my story. It's the story of every child in Balochistan. Childhood here is shaped by grief, fear, and posters of the disappeared. When our generation came of age, those of us raised in the shadows of state violence, we vowed: No child after us should suffer the same fate. We are fully aware of the power imbalance between us and a nuclear-armed state. It controls the media. It runs smear campaigns. It weaponizes the judiciary. It deploys overwhelming force. It controls the parliament. It operates proxy groups and armed militias. Our confinement is part of a war of narratives. Speaking up for justice is not a crime. Raising our voices against state violence is not treason. Demanding rights is not terrorism. It is humanity. And one day, we believe, this struggle will succeed.
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
News outlets in crisis mode as Google-led AI search push crushes website traffic
Major news outlets are in crisis mode as artificial intelligence chatbots pushed by Google and other Big Tech giants crush website traffic. Google has rolled out an 'AI Overviews' feature in its search engine that demotes traditional 'blue links' to other sites in favor of auto-generated summaries. Last month, the search giant rolled out 'AI Mode' – which is expected to make the problem even worse by respond to search queries with chatbot-style conversations and few direct links. Nicholas Thompson, the CEO of news outlet The Atlantic, told employees earlier this year that they should assume traffic from Google will drop toward zero over time, according to a report from the Wall Street Journal on Tuesday. 'Google is shifting from being a search engine to an answer engine,' Thompson told the Journal. 'We have to develop new strategies.' 3 Google CEO Sundar Pichai recently rolled out AI Mode for search. AFP via Getty Images Dwindling traffic is hurting revenue for cash-strapped newsrooms and fueling layoffs. When Business Insider slashed 21% of its staff in a newsroom-wide culling last month, its top boss Barbara Peng said the move was meant to help 'endure extreme traffic drops outside of our control.' Traffic to Business Insider's website plunged by a whopping 55% from April 2022 to April 2025, according to data from analytics sites Similarweb cited by the Journal. HuffPost has also lost more than half of its traffic over the same period, the data showed, while the Washington Post – another newsroom racked by job cuts – has lost nearly half its search audience. The rollout of AI-generated summaries in place of links 'is a serious threat to journalism that should not be underestimated,' Washington Post CEO William Lewis said. Google did not immediately return a request for comment. 3 AI features are hurting search traffic for news outlets. REUTERS Despite the traffic losses, Google has claimed that it is still funneling traffic to news sites through search. Critics, such as the News Media Alliance – a trade group that represents hundreds of news outlets including The Post – has warned that AI Overviews and other Google-implemented AI features will have devastating consequences for the industry. They allege that Google and other AI giants have used news content to train their chatbots without proper credit or compensation – and then used those same products to erode traffic. Danielle Coffey, the CEO and president of News Media Alliance, blasted Googles' rollout of AI Mode last month as 'theft.' 'Links were the last redeeming quality of search that gave publishers traffic and revenue,' Coffey said. 'Now Google just takes content by force and uses it with no return, the definition of theft. The DOJ remedies must address this to prevent continued domination of the internet by one company.' 3 Google CEO Sundar Pichai is pictured. AFP via Getty Images The AI push comes as Google faces intense pressure from the feds over its business model – including losses in a pair of antitrust cases brought by the DOJ that could force a breakup of the company. US District Judge Amit Mehta is set to decide by August on how to break up Google's illegal dominance over online search after labeling the company as a 'monopolist' in an initial ruling last year. DOJ lawyers want Mehta to consider the future impact of AI when crafting remedies. Elsewhere, Google recently lost a separate DOJ case in which it was determined to have two illegal monopolies over digital advertising technology. In that case, US District Judge Leonie Brinkema touched on the impact to news outlets, finding that Google's 'exclusionary conduct substantially harmed Google's publisher customers, the competitive process, and, ultimately, consumers of information on the open web.' The remedy phase of the digital ad tech trial will begin in September.
