Pakistan PM's 'military retreat speech' is doctored
"Pakistan Prime Minister Shahbaz Khan accepted defeat in Parliament," reads the Hindi-language caption of a clip shared May 10, 2025 on Facebook, misspelling the premier's name and using a popular Pakistani surname.
The video apparently shows Sharif telling parliament in Urdu: "We are retreating in the ongoing war with India. Our armed forces are fighting bravely, but lack of resources, political isolation and the power of the enemy has put us in a quandary."
Similar posts sharing the clip circulated among Indian users elsewhere on Instagram, Facebook, X and Threads the same day US President Donald Trump unexpectedly announced a ceasefire (archived link).
The truce halted four days of intense fighting between the South Asian rivals that killed more than 70 people on both sides (archived link).
Fighter jet, missile, drone and artillery strikes erupted two weeks after gunmen killed 26 people on the Indian-run side of disputed Kashmir in an attack New Delhi blamed on Islamabad. Pakistan denies the accusations (archived here and here).
The ceasefire has held, but the circulating video does not show a genuine speech from Sharif.
A reverse image search on Google using keyframes led to longer footage published May 7 by the Pakistani Urdu-language news channel Samaa TV on YouTube (archived link).
"PM Shehbaz Sharif's Aggressive Speech at National Assembly | India Attack Pakistan | Pak Army Alert!" the title says.
Sharif commends Pakistan's armed forces, saying they thwarted India's strikes that day -- but nowhere in the video does he make the remarks claimed in the false posts.
"With the prayers of 240 million Pakistanis, our brave and valiant Pakistani armed forces gave a befitting reply to the filthy attack by India, turned that dark night into a moonlit night," he said.
"In this attack by India many Pakistanis were martyred including children, women and men. Please pray for them."
The newspaper Pakistan Today, as well as Indian news websites Hindustan Times and Brut India, also covered Sharif's remarks (archived here, here and here).
An analysis of the clip circulating online found several visual inconsistencies suggesting it was doctored.
Sharif's lip movements and hand gestures are unnatural, indicating manipulation using artificial intelligence technology. An AFP journalist in Islamabad confirmed the voice and accent is not Sharif's.
As of May 16, there had been no official reports of Sharif announcing before Pakistan's parliament that the country was retreating.
AFP has debunked a wave of misinformation about the India-Pakistan conflict here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
DoJ urged to investigate US group accused of working as Modi-backed ‘foreign agent'
One of the largest Sikh houses of worship in the US is calling on the Trump administration to investigate a non-profit it has alleged is working as a 'foreign agent' on behalf of the the Indian government and prime minister Narendra Modi. The Fremont Gurdwara Sahib, which said it draws 5,000 Sikh worshippers every week and is a 'fulcrum' of the Sikh community in the US and around the world, has asked the Department of Justice to launch a national security investigation into the Hindu American Foundation (HAF), to determine whether the Pennsylvania-based non-profit should be required to file as an Indian foreign agent. Under the Foreign Agents Registration Act, any such determination by the DoJ would require the HAF to publicly disclose details of its activities, including meetings with lawmakers, and any contracts and financial arrangements it has with the Indian government. 'The HAF has facilitated meetings between foreign principals and US lawmakers, platformed foreign principals at their own events, and consistently and unequivocally advocated for the interests of the BJP on both domestic and foreign policy matters,' a representative for the Gurdwara wrote in a letter last week to Pam Bondi, the US attorney general. The HAF denied the claims. In a statement the group said it was a non-partisan tax-exempt charity that is wholly independent and American and has 'absolutely no affiliation or ties to any organization or political parties in the US or abroad'. It also hit out against what it called 'coordinated campaigns' against the HAF by the Khalistan separatist movement, which is seeking to establish an independent Sikh state. 'To discuss these dangerous and false accusations against us from activists supporting transnational violent separatist movements focused on India, [the] HAF welcomes the opportunity to meet with attorney general Pam Bondi, FBI director Kash Patel, director of national intelligence Tulsi Gabbard, as well as all homeland security officials,' the HAF said. The allegations and counter-claims come at a tense time between Sikhs who support an independent state and the Indian government. Individuals connected to the Indian government have been accused in both Canada and the US of waging a campaign of transnational repression against Sikhs outside of India after the 2023 assassination of Hardeep Singh Nijjar, a Canadian advocate for Khalistan. The Canadian government has said there were 'credible allegations' that 'agents of the Indian government' were behind Nijjar's death. In the US, prosecutors have alleged that at agent of the Indian government directed the attempted assassination of an American citizen who is also a Sikh activist. A recent investigation by Al Jazeera, the news outlet, reported that when the HAF emerged two decades ago it was a voice for the Hindu community in the US, and not a 'champion' of the Indian government. That, Al Jazeera reported, changed since Modi became prime minister in 2014, when HAF is alleged to have 'ramped up its political activities in favour of the Indian government'. The HAF has not faced accusations that it is involved in violent campaigns against Sikhs. In its letter to Bondi, the Gurdwara said the HAF 'has facilitated meetings between foreign principals and US lawmakers, platformed foreign principals at their own events, and consistently and unequivocally advocated for the interests of the Bharatiya Janata party on both domestic and foreign policy matters'. Any determination by the DoJ that the HAF was in fact working on behalf of the Indian government would require the HAF to publicly disclose details of its activities, including meetings with lawmakers, and any contracts with the Indian government. The Indian embassy in Washington did not respond to a request for comment.
New York Post
2 hours ago
- New York Post
Hamas Telegram groups radicalizing Americans
Telegram group chats with hundreds of thousands of subscribers are posting daily propaganda directly from Hamas — and potentially radicalizing anti-Israel activists here in America. The Post monitored two major English-language Telegram networks — Resistance News Network and Gaza Now In English, with more than 100,000 and 200,000 subscribers respectively — over the past week and observed dozens of daily updates purporting to be from spokespeople for Hamas, Hezbollah and terrorist military brigades. NY Post columnist Rikki Schlott shares this story.
Yahoo
3 hours ago
- Yahoo
Celebrities react to LA protest against ICE detention policies
Following Donald Trump's deployment of the National Guard to Los Angeles, artists have been speaking out against U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) deportation raids and offering support to protestors in LA. As reported by Euronews, Trump deployed another 2,100 National Guard members and 700 US Marines, in what the authorities have dubbed Task Force 51 meant to "provide continuous coverage of the area" as unrest in Los Angeles continues. Many celebrities posted messages on social media supporting the protestors and criticising the National Guard's deployment, including Eva Longoria and Mark Ruffalo. Longoria took to Instagram to express her frustration and described the actions as 'Un-American', while Ruffalo shared a lengthy message to Instagram with the caption: "When you have working class people going after the poor and other working class people you know you are living in an oligarchy." He added: "The billionaire up at the top is stealing you blind, and you are worried about the poorest of the poor ruining your life? You are pointing your guns in the wrong direction... The president is a grifter." Ruffalo's post went viral, racking up to 200,000 likes—including from other celebrities, including Jennifer Garner and Halle Berry. Green Day's Billie Joe Armstrong posted a scene from one of the LA protests to his Instagram over the weekend, which he captioned with a middle finger emoji and an ice cube emoji, while Tyler, The Creator wrote on his Instagram Story: 'FUCK ICE.' Singer and actress Reneé Rapp also condemned ICE's actions, writing: 'Fuck ICE fuck this administration fuck all of yall who are complicit in ensuring that this happened this is a fucking disgrace.' One of the most notable reactions came from Oscar-winning singer-songwriter Finneas, brother of Billie Eilish, who attended the 'very peaceful protests' himself and claimed to have been teargassed by authorities. 'Tear-gassed almost immediately at the very peaceful protest downtown. They're inciting this,' he wrote on Instagram. Finneas also reposted a clip that appeared to show a reporter, Lauren Tomasi, being shot in the leg with a rubber bullet by law enforcement while she was reporting from the scene. Elsewhere, Grammy-winning rapper Doechii spoke out against the immigration raids in Los Angeles at the 2025 BET Awards last night. During her speech, Doechii said that though she was 'honoured' by the award, she wanted to 'address what is happening right now outside of the building'. 'There are ruthless attacks that are creating fear and chaos in our communities in the name of law and order,' she continued, citing Trump's deployment of the National Guard. 'Trump is using military forces to stop a protest,' Doechii added. 'I want you all to consider what kind of government it appears to be when every time we exercise our democratic right to protest, the military is deployed against us. What type of government is that?' The heated situation has also prompted a fierce political backlash. Governor Gavin Newsom took to X to announce his plans to sue the federal government over the National Guard deployment, calling it 'an unconstitutional act.' "This is exactly what Donald Trump wanted. He flamed the fires and illegally acted to federalize the National Guard. The order he signed doesn't just apply to CA (California). It will allow him to go into ANY STATE and do the same thing. We're suing him."
