Pakistan PM's 'military retreat speech' is doctored
The video apparently shows Sharif telling parliament in Urdu: "We are retreating in the ongoing war with India. Our armed forces are fighting bravely, but lack of resources, political isolation and the power of the enemy has put us in a quandary."
Similar posts sharing the clip circulated among Indian users elsewhere on Instagram, Facebook, X and Threads the same day US President Donald Trump unexpectedly announced a ceasefire (archived link).
The truce halted four days of intense fighting between the South Asian rivals that killed more than 70 people on both sides (archived link).
Fighter jet, missile, drone and artillery strikes erupted two weeks after gunmen killed 26 people on the Indian-run side of disputed Kashmir in an attack New Delhi blamed on Islamabad. Pakistan denies the accusations (archived here and here).
The ceasefire has held, but the circulating video does not show a genuine speech from Sharif.
A reverse image search on Google using keyframes led to longer footage published May 7 by the Pakistani Urdu-language news channel Samaa TV on YouTube (archived link).
"PM Shehbaz Sharif's Aggressive Speech at National Assembly | India Attack Pakistan | Pak Army Alert!" the title says.
Sharif commends Pakistan's armed forces, saying they thwarted India's strikes that day -- but nowhere in the video does he make the remarks claimed in the false posts.
"With the prayers of 240 million Pakistanis, our brave and valiant Pakistani armed forces gave a befitting reply to the filthy attack by India, turned that dark night into a moonlit night," he said.
"In this attack by India many Pakistanis were martyred including children, women and men. Please pray for them."
The newspaper Pakistan Today, as well as Indian news websites Hindustan Times and Brut India, also covered Sharif's remarks (archived here, here and here).
An analysis of the clip circulating online found several visual inconsistencies suggesting it was doctored.
Sharif's lip movements and hand gestures are unnatural, indicating manipulation using artificial intelligence technology. An AFP journalist in Islamabad confirmed the voice and accent is not Sharif's.
As of May 16, there had been no official reports of Sharif announcing before Pakistan's parliament that the country was retreating.
AFP has debunked a wave of misinformation about the India-Pakistan conflict here.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hill
an hour ago
- The Hill
Hong Kong pro-democracy activists granted asylum in Australia and Britain
TAIPEI, Taiwan (AP) — A Hong Kong pro-democracy activist and a former lawmaker who are wanted by the city's authorities have been granted asylum in Great Britain and Australia, respectively. Tony Chung, an activist who was imprisoned under Hong Kong's sweeping national security law, and Ted Hui, a former lawmaker who was facing trial for his role in anti-government protests in 2019, both announced over the weekend that they have received asylum in the countries where they now live. They are among dozens of activists on the run from Hong Kong authorities. Civil liberties in the city have been greatly eroded since Beijing in 2020 imposed a national security law essentially criminalizing dissent in the former British colony. Both Beijing and Hong Kong have hailed the security law as bringing stability to the financial hub. Hui, who fled Hong Kong in December 2020, is part of a group of overseas activists who are targeted by police bounties of up to 1 million Hong Kong dollars ($127,800). The former lawmaker is now working as a lawyer in Adelaide. He announced on Facebook on Saturday that he and his family have been granted protection visas. 'I express my sincere gratitude to the Government of Australia — both present and former — for recognising our need for asylum and granting us this protection,' Hui wrote. 'This decision reflects values of freedom, justice, and compassion that my family will never take for granted.' While in Hong Kong, Hui had been an outspoken pro-democracy lawmaker. He was also known for disrupting a legislative session after he threw a rotten plant in the chamber to stop a debate of the national anthem bill — controversial legislation making it illegal to insult the Chinese national anthem. He was subsequently fined 52,000 Hong Kong dollars ($6,600) for the act. Chung, who had advocated for Hong Kong's independence, was sentenced to almost four years in prison for secession and money laundering in 2020. He was released on a supervision order, during which he traveled to Japan, from where he fled to Britain seeking asylum. In a post on social media platform Threads on Sunday, he expressed his excitement at receiving refugee status in Britain along with a five-year resident permit. He said that despite his challenges over the past few years, including persistent mental health problems, he remains committed to his activism. British and Australian authorities didn't immediately comment on the activists' statuses. Hong Kong's government did not comment directly on the cases but issued a statement on Saturday condemning 'the harbouring of criminals in any form by any country.' 'Any country that harbours Hong Kong criminals in any form shows contempt for the rule of law, grossly disrespects Hong Kong's legal systems and barbarically interferes in the affairs of Hong Kong,' the statement read.
New York Post
an hour ago
- New York Post
Blame Canada: How Trump can help us from being smoked out of our summer
DETROIT — Smokey Bear famously said, 'Only you can prevent forest fires.' But because Canada has not put in an ounce of prevention — the smoke from its wildfires has invaded Michigan and other American skies for three straight summers — it will take a pound of cure to Make Michigan Summer Again. So it falls on the best dealmaker the White House has ever seen to make our northern neighbor an offer it can't refuse: Either Canada puts out the wildfires ASAP. Or the US military will, perhaps en route to Canada's annexation as the 51st state. Since the time of James Monroe, America has been jealous of the events within its hemisphere. Usually any problems emanate from parts south, whether it's fentanyl in Mexico or nuclear weapons in Cuba — not Canada. 4 With Canada not working to prevent wildfires, America's friend to the north has become a bad neighbor. AFP via Getty Images Any one summer of smoke can be understood, even excused. Things happen. Perhaps the second was a coincidence. But the third, as Ian Fleming would say, feels like enemy action. In just three years, America's friend to the north has become a bad neighbor. The Canadian Wildfire Information System shows moderate-to-high threats of fire danger in Ottawa, north of Michigan. In eastern Canada, above New England, the threats range from high to extreme. Esri Canada's map of active wildfires shows a problem from sea to smoke-covered sea. BBC calls 2025 Canada's second-worst wildfire season on record. Conservative member of Canadian Parliament Michelle Rempel Garner has joined the blame game, declaring an 'utter lack of action from the federal government' created the problem. 4 A haze of Canadian wildfire smoke blankets Detroit and creates poor air quality this month. AP Smoky summers were not a fixture of my childhood and cannot become a new normal for Michigan's children. Nobody in Lansing has any answers. I asked a friend at Michigan's environmental department what was being done about the wildfire smoke. I was told it had issued air-quality alerts. That's not exactly the proactive response we're looking for. 'In recent years, Michigan has seen unprecedented levels of wildfire smoke drifting across its communities and much of the rest of the country,' reads the Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy website. 'In addition to pollutants like fine particulate matter carried in the smoke, there are gasses containing the chemicals that — when combined with sunlight — form ground-level ozone. These chemical reactions contribute to elevated ozone levels seen in areas across Michigan.' 4 Canadian wildfire smoke practically erases Detroit's skyline this month. UCG/Universal Images Group via Getty Images Gov. Gretchen Whitmer has thoughts on everything from tariffs to the impact of the Big Beautiful Bill to the price of back-to-school gear. But she's been oddly silent on the smoke that falls on the Traverse City Democrat and the Midland-area Republican alike. Whitmer spent one-fourth of last year traveling abroad, and she is keeping a similar pace in 2025, according to her public calendar. Perhaps too many of her travels this year are to foreign lands and too few within Michigan, to take up the plight of the pleasant peninsulas. Whitmer met with President Trump this month at the White House. She apparently left her folder at home this time rather than hiding behind it. Reports say Whitmer spoke about the $50 million in disaster relief Trump already granted for a northern Michigan ice storm — from months ago. There is no evidence Whitmer spoke a word about the current problem. The Michigan and Wisconsin Departments of Natural Resources have sent waves of firefighters to Canada, but it's not enough. Whitmer doesn't want the smoke with Canada. And why would she? She's just a governor. She's not looking for an international incident, especially when playing on the perception that Trump and Canada are at odds due to tariffs. 4 There's no evidence Whitmer even mentioned the Canadian problem to Trump when they met recently. AFP via Getty Images Michigan Republicans haven't done much better. Rep. John James, who's running in the 2026 governor's race to replace Whitmer, sent Canada a strongly worded letter. Then he got the other six Republicans in Michigan's congressional delegation to join him in a second letter. But Canada is the wrong target. James doesn't need to send a letter up north. He needs to call his friend the president. Trump has an affinity for Michigan and finished all three presidential campaigns there. It would break the man's heart to know we are being smoked out of our summer. Canada can't be trusted to put out the wildfires. The provinces Nova Scotia and New Brunswick have banned camping and hiking rather than fight fire with water. Canada has taken an active disinterest in managing its problem. And now its problem has become our problem. When Trump gets involved, there won't be a problem. The wildfire smoke Canada treats as a gateway to authoritarian rule, offering another chance to order people to 'stay home and stay safe,' is a threat to our lives and livelihoods in Michigan. This aggression cannot stand. President Trump, it's time to make Canada an offer it can't refuse. James David Dickson is a podcaster and independent journalist in Michigan.
New York Post
5 hours ago
- New York Post
Ex-AOC youth organizer Iman Abdul busted for urging 'attack' on Jewish students 'grew up in a mansion,' classmate says
The self-described 'youth organizer' for 'Squad' Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez, who allegedly urged a hate-filled 'attack' on Jewish students at a Brooklyn public high school, was herself a graduate of the school and a popular teen who was voted 'biggest flirt,' a classmate told The Post. She was one of the popular students and definitely had a good time there,' Alina Bernstern said of Iman Abdul, a fellow 2016 alum of Leon M. Goldstein High School for the Sciences in Manhattan Beach, adding that Abdul took part in the school's annual SING! musical show and 'grew up in a mansion.' 'She didn't show any kind of radical tendencies back then,' recalled Bernstein, who took an elective on social justice with Abdul. Advertisement 3 A former classmate said Abdul was a popular student at Leon Goldstein HS — which she identified in a social media post as 'a public school in NYC to attack for whatever reason.' Obtained by the NY Post 'Fear is stupid, so is regret,' reads a quote, attributed to Marilyn Monroe, under Abdul's yearbook photo. Abdul, 27, went on to become the 'face of youth organization' and volunteered on AOC's successful 2018 congressional campaign, Bernstein said. Advertisement A spokesperson for Ocasio-Cortez (D-NY) insisted to Fox News that Abdul was never 'staff.' 'Their comments are appalling and we condemn threats of violence without hesitation,' the spokesperson said. Abdul said in a 2019 interview she worked as a youth organizer for the socialist pol, but the web page with the article was deleted after her arrest. But critics note that the congresswoman, who has an audience of 9.4 million on Instagram, included Abdul among the 3,126 accounts she followed. 'I think it proves that she was part of AOC's campaign or knew her in some way,' Bernstein said. Advertisement 3 Abdul was named as the school's 'biggest flirt,' the yearbook shows. Obtained by the NY Post Abdul is accused of posting a screenshot of the location of Goldstein HS on Google Maps. The caption: 'If anyone needs a public school in NYC to attack for whatever reason … Lexus driving Israhell (sic) loving Zionisits (sic) all attend here.' 'That made me laugh,' said Bernstein, who is Jewish, 'because she grew up in a mansion, having more money than most of the Jews in our school, and drove a Range Rover.' In Instragam posts added by Abdul, she called Bernstein 'a Zionist bitch,' adding, 'Zio girls always be the most p—y' Advertisement The NYPD arrested Abdul on Aug. 9, a day after her post appeared, charging her with making a terroristic threat, acting in a manner injurious to a child, aggravated harassment, and making a threat of mass harm. 3 Abdul, whose social media post sparked her arrest on a charge of making a terroristic threat, quickly hired a high-profile criminal defense attorney. Obtained by the NY Post She was released without bail and set to face the charges on Nov. 19. Abdul immediately hired criminal defense attorney, Geoffrey St. Andrew Stewart. He is the son of the late Lynne Stewart, an infamous lawyer convicted and imprisoned for helping client Sheikh Omar Abdel-Rahman, an Egyptian terrorist, communicate with his followers. 'It is alarming that Iman Abdul has retained a high-profile attorney associated with someone who defended individuals accused of terrorism,' said Matthew Spern, president of United Jewish Teachers. 'The fact that she is out on no bail until November should be a significant concern for all New Yorkers.' Stewart did not return messages seeking comment. Advertisement Abdul, who could not be reached for comment, worked as a director of the AM:PM Gallery in Brooklyn. The gallery did not return a message about Abdul's employment. Representatives of Rep. Ocasio-Cortez did not respond to requests for comment.
