
Campaigners 'concerned' by Scottish buffer zones 'weakness'
The legislation – which started as a member's bill proposed by Green MSP Gillian Mackay – enforced 200m exclusion zones around 30 sites in Scotland in an attempt to limit intimidating protests held outside of clinics.
Mackay has repeatedly insisted the legislation is in place 24 hours a day, with the law stating that if an offending act has a 'continuing effect', it 'does not matter' whether any patient is attempting to access services in the zone at the time.
But in an email between a police inspector in Glasgow and an MSP, the officer said legal advice from Police Scotland lawyers and the Crown Office concluded the legislation cannot be enforced when clinics are not operating.
READ MORE: More than 100 anti-abortion protesters target Glasgow hospital
The exchange was sparked after the MSP sought clarity about a protest held outside the Sandyford Clinic in Glasgow by the Scottish Family Party on April 12, which was closed due to it being a Saturday, telling police constituents had been 'understandably distressed' by the protest.
Responding, the inspector referenced a similar incident in March at a clinic in Edinburgh, where advice had been sought and officers told the ban could not be enforced and the Crown would not prosecute if the facility was not open.
Lucy Grieve, who started the campaign group Back Off Scotland that pressed for the introduction of buffer zones for several years with co-founder Alice Murray, said she feels frustrated a 'point of weakness' has emerged in the law given they had been reassured throughout the passage of the legislation that it was 'the strongest bill in the land'.
'I think a lot of the groups that are protesting when the clinic is closed are just screaming into the void essentially, but I would say it's very frustrating when so many times we heard this bill was so robust, and that's why it was taking so long, that this has been left as a point of weakness,' she told The National.
(Image: NQ) 'I'd say it's a lesson for drafting stuff in the future. Certainly the Government and Gillian really reassured us it was going to be the strongest bill in the land so the fact this has been a slip-up is concerning and frustrating.'
Grieve (above, left) said given Back Off Scotland had heard a lot of testimony on staff coming across protesters after opening hours when they leave work, she hoped Police Scotland would take this into consideration.
Murray (above, right) added: 'I think the worry is they [protesters] see this as a loophole and this spirals into a bigger issue.'
READ MORE: Police decline to intervene as anti-abortion group ignores buffer zone
Murray also suggested that because the Scottish bill focuses on punishing people based on the impact their actions have on a patient or staff member rather than the specific behaviours of protesters, the law could be 'up for interpretation'.
She said: 'If you're seen to be doing behaviour that could intimidate or harass etc, and because it is written in that way, that does leave room for interpretation because if you're saying it's illegal to intimidate or harass, and a protester then says that's impossible when there's no one inside, then that is up for interpretation.'
Grieve said despite the concern, complaints to Back Off Scotland had dropped since the law came in and the law has been shown to be effective with it resulting an arrest earlier this year.
The law clearly states that a person in a safe access zone is committing an offence if they act with the intention of or are reckless as to whether the act has the effect of:
Influencing the decision of another person to access, provide or facilitate the provision of abortion services
Preventing or impeding another person from accessing, providing or facilitating the provision of abortion services
Causing harassment, alarm or distress to another person in connection with the other person's decision to access, provide or facilitate the provision of abortion services
It goes on to say that if the offending act has a 'continuing effect', it 'does not matter' whether any patient is attempting to access services in the zone at the time.
Mackay said earlier this week she would be seeking a meeting with Police Scotland and the Scottish Government on the issue following the 'surprising and disappointing' intervention from police.
The Green MSP said the Holyrood committee scrutinising the law discussed proposals that would have limited the operating hours of buffer zones but did not support them and they were not moved or included in the legislation.
The Scottish Government has said an act carried out which has an impact within the zone when a clinic is closed, but which could continue to have that impact once services are open, could give rise to an offence.
'However, this will always be a matter for enforcement agencies and will depend on all the facts and circumstances of the case,' a spokesperson went on.
There are calls for a buffer zone at the Queen Elizabeth University Hospital to be extended beyond 200m after more than 100 protesters gathered just outside the zone earlier this month.
Mackay said: "Like most laws, buffer zones were designed to apply all day every day and should be enforced that way.
"The committee scrutinising the act took time to consider proposals that would have limited the operating hours of buffer zones but did not support them. These proposals were not moved or included in the legislation.
"I am very concerned by Police Scotland's comments on this and am even more concerned that their policy will serve as an invitation for more protesters to target health facilities.
"Abortion rights are human rights. I have written to Police Scotland to seek an urgent meeting to discuss the situation and their approach to enforcement."
The Scottish Government and Police Scotland have been contacted for further comment.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Scottish Sun
2 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
SNP warned not to ‘squander' £9.1bn boost after Chancellor Rachel Reeves unleashed £300bn UK-wide splurge
LABOUR challenged the SNP not to 'squander' a £9.1billion boost to Holyrood's coffers after the Chancellor turned on the taps at her spending review. Rachel Reeves unveiled a £300billion UK-wide splurge in a bid to appease voters after her party's rocky first year in power. 2 Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar labelled the extra money as 'game-changing' 2 Finance Secretary Shona Robison claimed that if Ms Reeves was being fair, she'd have sent an extra £1bn a year to Holyrood Announcing her long-term spending plans for the years from 2026, she confirmed major investment in defence and nuclear power plus a three per cent above-inflation increase to NHS spending down south. Ms Reeves admitted 'too many people in too many parts of our country' were yet to feel the benefits of the 'change' they voted for when Labour swept back into power last July. The knock-on effect of the Chancellor's funding pledges means a massive cash boost for the Scottish Government to spend as it sees fit. Nats ministers will get an average annual boost of £2.4billion on day-to-day spending and £400million for major projects in the years to 2029. That's on top of the £4billion-plus yearly bonus delivered last October from the first Budget of Sir Keir Starmer's government. Scottish Labour leader Anas Sarwar labelled the extra money as 'game-changing'. He said: 'These plans will bring billions of pounds of investment to Scotland — on top of the record Budget settlement. 'But the massive increase in funds must not be squandered by the SNP government, which has a track record of waste and failure.' Scottish Secretary Ian Murray said voters would face a clear choice at next May's Holyrood election. He said: 'It's either a third decade of the SNP, who've squandered their opportunity over the last 18 years and squandered the £4.9billion extra the UK Government gave earlier. Top 5 takeaways from Spending review 'Or a government that's committed to investing in public services and infrastructure, renewing Scotland and working with a UK Labour government to deliver jobs right across the country.' But experts warned the extra cash could be swallowed by Scottish Government pledges such as pay hikes for public sector workers and higher devolved benefits. FUEL AID HOPE NATS' Finance Secretary indicated the SNP might dish out more cash to pensioners after Labour's winter fuel payment U-turn. But Shona Robison refused to commit to passing on all of an estimated extra £120million from Westminster to struggling Scots OAPs. Labour has now said older people down south with an income below £35,000 will receive the handouts, following an outcry when they were axed. Experts reckon the extra funds now due to Holyrood will be enough to cover £100 payments Nats have already pledged to pensioners. Asked if the payments could be increased, Ms Robison said: 'There's other things we need to fund as well which is why we're looking at the options. We'll deliver the best deal for pensioners.' Nats ministers are already set to spend £2billion more on welfare by the end of the decade than they receive from Westminster. But SNP Finance Secretary Shona Robison claimed that if Ms Reeves was being fair, she'd have sent an extra £1billion a year to Holyrood. She said: 'This review is business as usual from the UK Government, which is yet again treating Scotland as an afterthought and failing to provide the funding we need. 'Had our resource funding for day-to-day priorities grown in line with the UK Government's overall spending, we'd have £1.1billion more to spend on our priorities over the next three years. In effect, Scotland has been short-changed by more than a billion pounds.' But despite the extra cash, an expert warned SNP policy decisions mean tax rises or spending cuts may be needed to balance Scotland's books by 2027/28. David Phillips, associate director at the Institute for Fiscal Studies, said the winner of next year's election 'will face tough choices' due to increased NHS, benefits, and public sector pay costs. Earlier, Ms Reeves told the Commons her plans were the start of Labour's project to 'renew Britain'. She vowed to back the Acorn carbon capture project in Aberdeenshire. But official documents raised questions about how the scheme, to store gas emissions under the North Sea, would be funded. NUCLEAR SWIPE AT FM & CO RACHEL Reeves slammed the SNP's opposition to arms factories and nuclear power as she confirmed defence spending hikes. The Chancellor announced an £11billion boost for the armed forces plus a £600million increase for security and intelligence agencies. She also confirmed a £250million redevelopment of the Faslane base on the Clyde, where new nuclear submarines will be stationed. It means defence spending will be upped to 2.6 per cent of GDP by April 2027. Ms Reeves blasted Nats' opposition to nuclear weapons and munitions. She said: 'Investment in Scotland, jobs in Scotland, defence for the United Kingdom, opposed by the Scottish National Party, delivered by this Labour Government.' Sir Keir Starmer previously set out the UK Government's Strategic Defence Review in a speech in Glasgow last week. Nats and Labour clashed as the No10 chief claimed Nats' goal of scrapping Trident nuclear missiles would make Scotland less safe. Sir Keir said: 'Imagine the effect that would have on the safety and security of the UK and of Scotland.' They concluded: 'A final investment decision will be taken later.' Scottish Tory finance spokesman Craig Hoy warned UK taxes will probably have to rise at the Budget this autumn. He said: 'This spend-now-tax-later statement will offer no comfort to those betrayed by the first year of a disastrous Labour Government. 'Taxes remain sky-high and the Chancellor will almost certainly have to hike them further to pay for her spending plans, breaking yet another of her promises.' Mr Hoy added: 'Scots are saddled with two failing, high-tax, left-wing governments — one at Westminster and the other at Holyrood.'


Scottish Sun
4 hours ago
- Scottish Sun
Scots drugs campaigner who championed fix rooms found dead at home
An MSP and personal friend of the activist has paid tribute A DRUGS campaigner who championed the introduction of fix rooms in Scotland has been found dead. Peter Krykant passed away on Monday, aged 48, at his home in Larbert, Falkirk. Advertisement 4 Drugs campaigner Peter Krykant tragically passed away at his Falkirk home Credit: Alamy 4 A drug consumption room at Hunter Street Health Centre in Glasgow Credit: PA 4 Scottish Labour MSP Paul Sweeney was 'deeply saddened' over the death Credit: Getty The respected activist, who worked with social justice charity Cranstoun, was a former addict and led calls for decriminalisation. He ran Glasgow's first safe consumption space out of a renovated ambulance so people had a safe place to take drugs. Labour MSP Paul Sweeney worked closely with Peter and said he found out about his death from a colleague this morning. He told The Scottish Sun: 'I am deeply saddened at the passing of my friend Peter Krykant. Advertisement 'He didn't always appreciate the impact he had in terms of changing the policy landscape in Scotland. 'I personally witnessed work that reversed nine overdoses involving eight different people. 'In one case involving a young lady, his intervention was enough to persuade her to get into rehabilitation. 'He did make a difference and in her case she wrote Peter a letter thanking him for saving her life.' Advertisement The pair met at a drugs summit in Possil Park in 2019 and remained in touch. But despite his efforts, Mr Krykant had suffered from a number of relapses. Drug fix rooms could be rolled out across Scotland before end of controversial Glasgow pilot Mr Sweeney, who is deputy convener of Holyrood's health, social care and sport committee, added: 'Peter certainly was very passionate about this issue. 'He was a disruptor and thrived on this idea of taking vested interests on or conventional wisdom and I think he quite liked that idea. Advertisement 'He certainly was a good communicator. I think he talked very well and was a very passionate advocate for his beliefs.' A Police Scotland spokesperson said: 'Around 5.15pm on Monday, 9 June 2025, police attended an address in Graham Avenue, Larbert following a report of a concern for a person. 4 Activist Peter led calls for the introduction of safe consumption rooms Credit: Alamy 'The body of a 48-year-old man was found within. His next of kin has been informed. Advertisement 'A post-mortem examination will be carried out in due course. The death is being treated as unexplained.' Elsewhere residents living near Scotland's controversial drugs fix room have hit out at flyers urging more addicts to use it. Thistle Centre bosses have pasted leaflets at needle dumping areas amid claims the community has been turned into a 'warzone'. It comes as bins for addicts to discard used injecting gear have sprung up in Calton, Glasgow.


The Herald Scotland
4 hours ago
- The Herald Scotland
Drug policy reform campaigner Peter Krykant dies aged 48
Mr Fitzpatrick later lost his job after Scotland's drugs deaths soared to 1,264 in 2019. Krykant, who battled his own addiction issues, said his mobile injection room saved lives and argued for similar facilities to be set up to cut Scotland's soaring drug deaths. Peter Krykant in the converted ambulance, which allowed drug users a safe space to inject (Image: Mark F Gibson) It has been reported that he was found dead at home in Falkirk . He faced police charges over the ambulance, but these were later dropped. He said: "We are all deeply saddened to hear of Peter's passing. 'Everyone from the Scottish Greens is thinking of his family and friends at this extremely difficult time. "Peter was a tireless campaigner for a fairer, more compassionate approach to handling drug misuse and addiction, and his campaigning has left such an important legacy in the UK's first safe consumption room in Glasgow. "His advocacy for drug reform, and of course, his yellow van have no doubt saved countless lives in Scotland." Police Scotland have said that no suspicious circumstances surround the death at Krykant's home in Larbert, Falkirk, on Monday this week. Labour MSP Paul Sweeney, who had helped man the mobile service, which was regarded as illegal at the time, said 48-year-old Krykant's efforts had helped make significant changes to Scotland's drugs policy. READ MORE: Mr Sweeney told The Daily Record: 'I'm shocked and saddened to hear of Peter's death. We can't underestimate the contribution he made to the drugs debate in Scotland, which came amid many years of increasing overdose deaths. 'He undoubtedly played a major part in changing policy in a political a system that was very much set in its ways and resistant to the kind of radical change that Peter advocated.' Earlier this year, The Thistle safe drugs consumption facility opened in Glasgow after years of political wrangling between the Scottish and UK governments, allowing those who inject drugs like heroin and cocaine a safe place to do so, with medical professionals on hand should they be needed. The centre has seen 17 overdoses since it opened, according to service manager Lynn Macdonald in March, some of which she believes would have resulted in death had staff not stepped in.