Putin ‘rewarded' for Ukraine invasion with Trump summit, experts warn
Very little appears to have been materially resolved as a result of the meeting.
Mr Trump has insisted 'some great progress' was made, with 'many points' agreed and 'very few' remaining.
Sir Keir Starmer, meanwhile, commended the US president's efforts to make peace, and said Mr Trump had 'brought us closer than ever before' to an end to the war in Ukraine.
Leading foreign affairs and military experts have however claimed the summit's main effect has been to lend legitimacy to Mr Putin, who has been considered a pariah by many world leaders since the invasion began in 2022.
Orysia Lutsevych, deputy director of the Russia and Eurasia programme and head of the Ukraine forum at the Chatham House think tank, said: 'After six bilateral Trump-Putin phone calls, five trips of Trump's envoy (Steve) Witkoff to Moscow, the Alaska summit, watched globally with so much anticipation and anxiety, failed to produce any tangible outcome to stop Russian aggression against Ukraine.
'Russia has received a reward for its invasion.
'Trump called Russia a 'great country' and said there is strong mutual understanding between the two parties.
'This represents a further fissure in the already shaky Transatlantic alliance, the rupture of which is a primary Russian aim.
'The Alaska summit represents another step towards this goal.'
Keir Giles, an associate fellow of the Russia and Eurasia programme at Chatham House, meanwhile suggested there were 'two dangers' which could emerge from the summit.
The first is that Ukraine's Volodymyr Zelensky may now be perceived by Mr Trump as a 'softer target where he is more willing to exert leverage', and that the US president could 'once again try to strongarm Zelensky into compromising the future of his country'.
The second danger is that European leaders 'might once again think the immediate danger has passed' and become complacent, after their scramble to speak to Mr Trump ahead of the summit.
Dr Neil Melvin, director of international security at the Royal United Services Institute (Rusi) meanwhile suggested Mr Putin would walk away considering the summit a success.
Dr Melvin said: 'Vladimir Putin came to the Alaska summit with the principal goal of stalling any pressure on Russia to end the war.
'He will consider the summit outcome as mission accomplished.'
He added: 'Russia's war aims have not changed since it launched its invasion of Ukraine in 2022.
'At the summit, Putin was clear that he wants to address first what he calls the root causes of the war.
'The Kremlin identifies these as Nato enlargement, the emergence of governments in Ukraine resistant to Russian integration projects, and challenges to Russian claims about territory and ethnic Russians in Ukraine.
'This is Russia's precondition and underpins Putin's demand for a 'comprehensive peace deal'.
'This agenda would lead to the subjugation of Ukraine.
'Putin made no concessions at the summit.
'Moreover, he succeeded in presenting himself as a legitimate equal to the US president.
'He will also consider it a victory that he was able to marginalise Zelensky and European leaders from the central discussion about the future of European security.'
Elsewhere, party political leaders in the UK warned against lending Mr Putin legitimacy.
Sir Ed Davey, the Liberal Democrat leader said: 'It's clear Putin doesn't want peace.
'Trump's attempt to sweet talk him into a deal has failed, so it's time for Trump to finally get tough.
'The UK should seize Russian assets to help Ukraine today, and press the US to do the same.'
Green Party MP Ellie Chowns meanwhile said the world was 'left where we started' by the summit, adding: 'A brutal war caused by Russia's aggression and no real solution in sight.
'Any lasting peace plan without Ukraine's full participation and consent will fail.
'When you compare how Trump rolled out the red carpet for Putin to his publicly humiliating Zelensky, it's clear that the only winner from these talks is Putin.
'He was handed the credibility of a seat at the top table while his forces continue their attacks on Ukraine.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
7 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
New analysis shows which political party faces 'registration crisis' in battleground states that could change elections forever
A new analysis of Americans' voter registration habits points to potential long-term trouble for the Democratic Party. Data analyzed by the New York Times has revealed that the number of registered Democrats has declined in every state that tracks voter affiliation by party—a group that includes 30 of America's 50 states. The remaining 20 states do not register voters by party. This trend was consistent between swing states, red states, and blue states. The New York Times notes that explicitly, 'fewer and fewer Americans are choosing to be Democrats.' The Times attributes Trump's sweeping 2024 victory—including wins in every swing state and the national popular vote—to this very trend. For veteran political activists and observers, this shift comes as no surprise. In recent cycles, states that have shifted from Democrat to GOP have almost always seen Republican gains in voter registration precede electoral flips. Republican presidential nominee, former U.S. President Donald Trump participates in a roundtable discussion at the Latino Summit held at Trump National Doral Golf Club on October 22, 2024 in Doral, Florida Florida, once the quintessential swing state—from the infamous 2000 Bush-Gore recount to the razor-thin Trump-Clinton contest in 2016—has trended solidly Republican over the past decade. Republican gains with Hispanic and Latino voters have been pointed to as one reason for the shift. A major milestone came in March, when Republican registrations surpassed Democrats in Miami-Dade County—a longtime Democratic stronghold and Florida's most populous county. Republicans now hold 34 percent of registered voters there, edging out both Democrats (32 percent) and Independents (33 percent.) These trends in voter registration and party loyalty suggest that political realignments in key states may be more durable than previously thought. Evan Power, chairman of the Republican Party of Florida, expressed in a statement to the Florida Phoenix that the flip was 'a total repudiation of the Democrats' failed agenda. Miami-Dade is no longer their safe haven — it's the beating heart of the Republican revolution.' Iowa is another state where Republicans have recently made major gains. After the 2018 midterm cycle, three of the state's four congressional seats were held by Democrats. Republicans subsequently made voter registration a top priority in the 2020 presidential election, and made gains not only in swing seats but statewide before Trump's second victory in the state. After the 2020 election, Republicans held three of the four congressional seats in the state and flipped the fourth into their column after the 2022 midterm election. Conservative activist Scott Presler is the Founder and Executive Director of Early Vote Action and has travelled across the country registering voters in swing states and districts for the past half-decade. Presler told the Daily Mail that he often gets asked if registering more GOP voters in a location means an automatic win. He points to his efforts in flipping Bucks County, Pennsylvania for Trump last year as one indication that the proof is in the pudding. The county is one specifically mentioned in the New York Times analysis, as Republicans flipped the voter registration there last summer in part due to Presler's activism ahead of Trump's win in November. The Daily Mail spoke to Presler via a phone call while he was back in Pennsylvania, this time as part of an effort to flip the swingiest of all swing counties, Erie County, which is '5,900 voters away from flipping blue to red.' Presler said that recent conversations with individuals he's gotten to change their party registration indicate that the data analyzed by the New York Times is 'emblematic of the fact that voters overwhelmingly approve of Trump's policies.' While both parties have had their fair share of infighting, Democrats seem to be losing the most in the eyes of voters. After Trump's decisive defeat of Kamala Harris last year, the party is searching for a new leader. The likes of California Governor Gavin Newsom and Connecticut Senator Chris Murphy are putting themselves forward as figureheads of the anti-Trump resistance, but looking at registration numbers, no one has yet broken through to the average voter to get them to switch back into the Democratic column. Democrat strategist and DNC member Maria Cardona told the New York Times that her party 'fell asleep at the switch' also adding that young Hispanic and Latino voters are no longer default supporters of her party.
South Wales Guardian
an hour ago
- South Wales Guardian
UK military chief meets US counterparts for Ukraine talks
Admiral Sir Tony Radakin met senior US defence officials alongside other European military chiefs in Washington DC on Wednesday to discuss military options to secure peace in Ukraine. He later attended a virtual meeting of Nato's military committee, described by its chairman Italian Admiral Giuseppe Cavo Dragone as 'candid'. On Tuesday evening, Admiral Radakin, the chief of the defence staff, had dined with his US counterpart General Dan Caine. The meetings come amid renewed planning for a 'coalition of the willing', led by the UK and France, that would guarantee Kyiv's security in the event of a ceasefire. Earlier in the week, Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer and French President Emmanuel Macron co-chaired a meeting of the coalition, in which members of the group also discussed the possibility of further sanctions on Russia. Western security guarantees, strongly resisted by Moscow, are one of the central issues for any peace deal for Ukraine, which fears Russia could otherwise use a ceasefire to regroup and launch a renewed invasion. So far, only the UK and France have indicated they could commit troops to a peacekeeping force in Ukraine. In an interview on Tuesday Donald Trump ruled out an American ground contribution but suggested the US could be willing to provide some form of air support. His special envoy, Steve Witkoff, had earlier suggested the US could offer Ukraine a mutual defence agreement similar to Nato's Article 5, without Kyiv formally joining the alliance. Renewed talks among the 'coalition of the willing' follow last week's summit between Mr Trump and Vladimir Putin in Alaska as the US president continued to push for an end to a conflict he had promised he could finish on his first day in office. Those talks appeared to result in little progress towards a deal, but sparked concern among some in Europe that Mr Trump could seek to pressure Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky into accepting a deal without sufficient security guarantees. On Monday, Sir Keir and Mr Macron joined other European leaders in travelling to Washington in a show of support for Mr Zelensky during a meeting with Mr Trump. Meanwhile, the UK and Russia traded sanctions as London sought to increase the pressure on Moscow to end its invasion. Europe minister Stephen Doughty unveiled sanctions on a series of organisations linked to Kyrgyzstan's financial services sector, saying they had been involved in Kremlin attempts to 'soften the blow of our sanctions by laundering transactions through dodgy crypto networks'. Russia in turn sanctioned 21 individuals, including former Labour MP Denis MacShane, several journalists, and the Government-appointed independent reviewer of terrorism legislation, Jonathan Hall.
Daily Mirror
an hour ago
- Daily Mirror
Donald Trump's new White House portrait criticised for 'Satanic theme'
A fresh image of Donald Trump has been unveiled in the Oval Office - but it's already causing a stir online, with many branding it as "too accurate" A controversial new portrait of Donald Trump has sparked fierce criticism over its alleged 'Satanic themes'. Sebastian Gorka, the deputy assistant to the president, revealed a fresh image of Trump, which is now displayed in the Oval Office. The artwork shows Trump striding through rows of American flags with an orange glow behind him - compared to flames by critics - and was teased as just "one of the new" Trump-themed artworks decorating the White House. The new portrait comes amid reports of how Trump's Ukraine plans has prompted a Pentagon peace summit with UK military chiefs. The new portrait was created by Vanessa Horabuena, a self-described Christian worship painter. the Express. Not everyone was impressed with the portrait, with some branding it as "too accurate" and others as "too orange." Project Liberal questioned, "Why is the country on fire behind him?". This feeling resonated with many, as another user remarked, "fits. America is on fire in the background and Trump walks away." Others pointed to Trump's collection of self-portraits in the White House, especially after reports last week that portraits of Obama and Bush have been moved to a rarely-used stairwell, reports the Mirror US. Ignited uproar "The man can't get enough of himself," one user slammed. Another added: "As per usual, it's all about his ego." Another person slated the portrait's poor resemblance to Trump's real appearance. "Did you request the portrait to appear 60 lbs lighter than reality?" an X user questioned. The Mirror reached out to both the White House and the artist for a response, but none was immediately available. Trump's portraits and paintings displayed around the White House have previously sparked controversy, and a recent attempt to showcase them to other world leaders didn't go as smoothly as Trump had hoped. Assassination attempt His iconic photo from the Butler assassination attempt, featuring him with his fist raised in the air, is also a source of pride for the president, who often shows it off to visitors. Before a meeting in the East Room yesterday, the seven European heads of state gathered for a photograph with Trump and Zelensky in the Grand Foyer of the White House. As they stood together, the president gestured towards a painting depicting his bloodied ear following an assassination attempt during his 2024 campaign in Pennsylvania. "That was not a good day. Not a great day. See the picture?" Trump said, pointing to a wall on the group's right where the large painting is hung. However, not all the leaders shared Trump's enthusiasm for the image. Patriotic portraits Some of the leaders briefly glanced over, appearing to show minimal interest, while others, like French President Emmanuel Macron, continued to look straight ahead. The Republican leader has been giving the White House a makeover, including refurbishing the Rose Garden and adding numerous gold accents throughout the Oval Office. A substantial portion of these changes includes swapping out portraits of his predecessors. In a recent snap shared on X, Trump's patriotic portrait is proudly showcased between former First Lady Laura Bush and another first lady, nabbing the spot previously held by his long-standing adversary, Hillary Clinton. This comes after Joe Rogan revealed a startling new conspiracy theory about a potential assassination attempt on Trump in 2024.
