Labor urged to rethink 20 per cent student debt cut as leading research body calls for flat $5500 relief
The research, released by not-for-profit research body e61 Institute on Thursday found the policy as is, doesn't meaningfully speed up debt repayment, and unfairly benefits students who graduated in 2024.
Instead of a 20 per cent cut to balances, e61 said the relief would be better targeted if Australia's with student debt were given a flat $5500 cut.
The figure also represents the average amount set to be wiped across all HELP accounts.
e61 said that a $5500 reduction would help 35 per cent of account holders make their final repayment in an earlier year, or 15 per cent more debt holders than a 20 per cent discount.
e61 Research Economist Matthew Maltman said the benefits of a straight cut was important factor due to the policy's $16bn price tag, which equals the annual cost of Jobseeker.
'Most HELP debt is held by university graduates, who have much higher lifetime incomes than the average taxpayer. And even if you look within graduates, those with more costly degrees tend to go on to earn higher incomes in the future,' he said.
'You could make the argument that we need to provide debt relief to humanities students in a
targeted way because of Job Ready Graduates.
'But the current policy isn't at all targeted and that means it's going to give a very large amount of debt relief to future lawyers, dentists and doctors who are going to go on to enjoy very high lifetime incomes.'
University students who finished their degrees in 2024 will also receive twice as much relief as people who left in 2020, and two and a half times more than students who are currently in their first year of a three year degree.
e61 Senior Research Economist Jack Buckley said this would create a debt relief lottery.
'If you cut 20 per cent of each individual's balance, it means two very similar people will receive very different amounts of debt relief simply because one finished their degree in 2024 and the other finished a few years earlier or later,' said Mr Buckley.
Anthony Albanese has repeatedly said the 20 per cent cut to HELP debts will be the first piece of legislation passed when parliament returns on July 22, with the changes backdated to account balances as of June 1.
Labor is also set to increase the debt repayment threshold from $56,156 to $67,000, repayments of payment will also be lowered.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
SBS Australia
29 minutes ago
- SBS Australia
SBS News in Filipino, Wednesday 20 August 2025
Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu accused Albanese of betraying Israel and turning his back on the Jewish community in Australia. The federal government will spend $1.3 billion on new counter-drone systems to be used at the 2032 Olympic Games in Brisbane. Philippines, Australia, and Canada conducted a joint sail in the South China Sea as part of ALON. LISTEN TO SBS Filipino 07:43 Filipino 📢 Where to Catch SBS Filipino
News.com.au
29 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Disgraced former MP Daryl Maguire sentenced after lying to ICAC probe
Disgraced ex-MP Daryl Maguire has been jailed after he was found guilty of giving misleading evidence to ICAC. Maguire, 66, appeared at Sydney Central District Court on Wednesday,dressed neatly in a suit and tie, after he was in June found guilty by a magistrate of one count of giving false or misleading evidence at a public inquiry. The former Wagga Wagga MP had pleaded not guilty to the charge, which related to his evidence before the Independent Commission Against Corruption (ICAC) in July 2018. On Wednesday, Magistrate Clare Farnan sentenced him to a 10-month jail term. He was soon put in handcuffs and taken into custody. He will be eligible for parole in January. In sentencing, Ms Farnan told the court the misleading evidence given by Maguire concerned his dealings with a multimillion-dollar property development. 'The evidence there was nothing in it for him was misleading … and he was to receive a commission if the property was to be sold,' she said. Ms Farnan said Maguire was 'clearly trying to protect his reputation among other things'. 'The community is entitled to expect that those who hold power will conduct themselves with integrity,' she said. Maguire has maintained his innocence, saying he answered the ICAC questions to the best of his ability. He is expected to file an appeal, with the court expected to resume on Wednesday morning before Ms Farnan to hear details of the appeal. Ms Farnan said Maguire had displayed no remorse for his actions, though he had no history of similar offending and his likelihood of reoffending remained low. 'The need for general deterrence does require a period of full-time imprisonment,' she said. While a 12-month stint behind bars was initially to be ordered, Maguire was offered a two-month discount due to delays in the court proceedings. Ms Farnan also took into account the impact of 'significant media interest' in the case on the 66-year-old's mental health. The small courtroom was packed with members of the media on Wednesday, who watched on closely as Maguire was taken into custody. During the ICAC probe, Maguire denied asking to receive a financial benefit for brokering a property deal at Canterbury. However in recorded phone conversations, the former MP admitted he had asked for a slice of the profits if the multimillion-dollar deal with a Chinese developer was finalised. Maguire was found guilty of the charge in June. The former Wagga Wagga MP resigned from the NSW parliament in 2018 after ICAC launched a separate investigation into his conduct while in office. The inquiry revealed he had been in a secret five-year 'close personal relationship' with ex-premier Gladys Berejiklian. She resigned from her position in September 2021 after ICAC announced it would investigate whether she breached the ministerial code of conduct. The commission found in July 2023 that both Maguire and Ms Berejiklian engaged in serious corrupt conduct.
Daily Telegraph
43 minutes ago
- Daily Telegraph
Revealed: Stark divide in city vs bush cost of living struggle
Don't miss out on the headlines from Bush Summit. Followed categories will be added to My News. The cost of living crisis is hitting harder in the bush than it is in the city, with two out of five regional residents struggling to make ends meet and barely one in 10 feeling comfortable with their finances. Regional Australians love their quality of life – 77 per cent rate it as excellent, very good or good. But according to the Mood of the Bush survey, this has fallen since last year, and city slickers are now marginally more likely to be happier. The survey – conducted by SEC Newgate for News Corp Australia – found 69 per cent of regional Australians named the cost of living as the issue of most concern to them, which was overwhelmingly ahead of housing affordability, crime and healthcare. Nationally, three-quarters of those surveyed said reducing cost increases for household bills and other essential expenses was their top priority, with 41 per cent of those in the regions having difficulty paying their bills compared to 35 per cent in metro areas. Emma and Andrew Sheridan run a camp drafting property because they believe traditional farming is no longer viable under a net zero agenda. Picture: Jonathan Ng In regional New South Wales, 74 per cent of residents rated reducing cost increases for household bills and other essential expenses as 'extremely important', followed by investing more to ensure quality affordable healthcare at 64 per cent. Residents of regional and metro NSW indicated they were facing a similar struggle to make ends meet. Asked about their mood in recent weeks, 57 per cent of those in regional NSW selected more negative rather than positive emotions such as 'anxious' and 'stressed'.\ Overall, 78 per cent of regional NSW residents rated their quality of life as being at least good – lower than those in the state's metropolitan areas at 82 per cent but just ahead of the average across the rest of regional Australia. Andrew and Emma Sheridan run a camp drafting property in Wallendbeen, southern NSW. They say cost of living concerns are a 'day to day worry' for their young family, which is why they have chosen camp drafting - a fast growing sport with tremendous business potential - over traditional farming. 'We are worried for our kids and the direction Australia is heading,' Emma said. 'It's unsustainable. Our kids will be paying for the mismanagement of the country for decades to come if government spending is not reined in quickly. 'Rural Australia is being completely neglected and this whole net zero agenda is going to have a serious impact on where Australia fits into the world.' Foodbank Australia chief executive Brianna Casey said regional families and single-parent households that were 'just getting by' were now slipping through the cracks. Brianna Casey, chief executive of the Foodbank charity, says regional families and single-parent households that were 'just getting by' are now slipping through the cracks. 'We warned at the beginning of the cost-of-living crisis that low-income households were always going to suffer first, worst and for the longest,' she said. 'But what we're also seeing is single-parent families and those in regional communities that were just getting by, now reaching their limits and making unimaginable choices.' SEC Newgate research director Peter Collingridge said that while the cost of living was still a 'major concern', the level of stress recorded had declined slightly from last year's result, which could signal a 'turning point'. 'It's obviously the highest concern that's mentioned by people in both regional Australia, more broadly, but it's just come off the boil, just a fraction,' he said. 'Last year, it was 74 per cent around the same time … Potentially with interest rates on the way down, there's a little bit of light at the end of the tunnel for people.' Ms Casey said challenges with mobility and travel seemed to be a key contributor to the inability for families to afford enough food, according to separate Foodbank research. Last year, 20 per cent of regional Australians struggling with food insecurity cited 'limited access/ability to travel and get food' as a contributor, while only 14 per cent of metropolitan residents pointed to the same issue. Respondents said there was often not enough money for food after bills, car repairs, medical costs and insurance.
