Malema's private member's bill to nationalise SARB gets mixed reaction during public hearings
FILE: EFF leader Julius Malema in Parliament. Picture: Parliament/Phando Jikelo
CAPE TOWN - Economic Freedom Fighters (EFF) leader Julius Malema's private member's bill aimed at nationalising the South African Reserve Bank (SARB) has a received a mixed reaction during public hearings.
Some organisations like labour federation, COSATU, voiced support for Malema's South African Reserve Bank Amendment Bill, while others warned that it could have serious repercussions for the economy if the current model was tampered with.
COSATU, the National Treasury and other organisations made submissions before the Standing Committee on Finance on Wednesday, seven years after the bill was first introduced in Parliament.
The Standing Committee on Finance continued public hearings on Malema's private member's bill, which was submitted in 2018.The bill aims to amend the South African Reserve Bank Act and proposes changes to the appointment of the bank's directors.
The bill also wants the state to be the sole shareholder of the central bank, which has two million shares held by private and foreign investors.
COSATU's Tony Ehrenreich said that they supported this move.
"The ownership of the South African Reserve Bank must only be vested with the state in line with international norms."
But Christopher Axelson, National Treasury's deputy director-general for tax and financial sector policy, said they don't support the bill, warning that it could have serious implications.
"The governance arrangements could also be weaker and may negatively impact the independence of the SARB and so we don't support the bill."
The committee will now further process the submissions before a motion on the bill's desirability is considered.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
IOL News
5 hours ago
- IOL News
Julius Malema warns that Trump poses a danger to global stability
EFF leader Julius Malema said US President Donald Trump is a danger to the world. Image: Ayanda Ndamane / Independent Newspapers The EFF leader Julius Malema has warned that US President Donald Trump and his policies is a danger to the world and should be removed from power. Malema was addressing the party's third Central Command Team (CCT) meeting in Bela Bela, Limpopo on Saturday. The CCT is the highest decision-making body in-between national people's assemblies and the meeting took place against a backdrop of national turmoil, including the looming US 30% tariffs wall on South Africa's exports. Malema, who called for his party to force Africa to cut ties with imperialist powers, said the EFF would work with allies to remove Trump from office. Video Player is loading. Play Video Play Unmute Current Time 0:00 / Duration -:- Loaded : 0% Stream Type LIVE Seek to live, currently behind live LIVE Remaining Time - 0:00 This is a modal window. Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window. Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps Reset restore all settings to the default values Done Close Modal Dialog End of dialog window. Advertisement Next Stay Close ✕ Trump showed visuals of the firebrand chanting 'shot the boer' - as he sought to substantiate false claims that there was a 'white genocide' in South Africa during President Cyril Ramaphosa's visit to the Oval Office in May. Trump hosted five leaders from Africa last month-Gabon, Guinea-Bissau, Liberia, Mauritania and Senegal. Malema said at the previous CCT meeting, the EFF had been positioned as an enemy of global imperialism and warned that fighting domestic and global capital could lead to political or personal destruction, starting with disinformation and escalating to invasion or assassination. Just days after that warning, Trump identified the EFF as a threat during the meeting with Ramaphosa. Trump confronted Ramaphosa with baseless claims of white genocide and land seizures, screening EFF protests and labelling the party a danger. 'Today, members of the US Congress are demanding the release through legislation of what is referred to as the 'Epstein Files', which have become a growing concern for Trump and his administration and may lead to his impeachment and conviction', said Malema on Saturday, adding that the EFF, which is a Marxist-Leninist and Fanonian organisation, has the goal to change the world, not to end it. Malema said in order to effect change to the world, Trump's reign as the US President must end. 'It is not only for us as the left and socialists to whom Trump is a threat, but even to the capitalist system itself because he is using its logic in an illiterate manner - as a result he will destroy capitalism inadvertently but he will kill any and all possibilities of socialist economic order as well,' he said. 'Our economies are unequal due to historical dominance by the West of the global economy, and as a result trade barriers have been eased so that our markets and economies can grow - imposing tariffs on the infant economies of the global south is merely a method by Trump to create a global economy that depends solely on America, and as a result Trump poses a threat to the stability and existence of a global economy,'' Malema said. He added that leaders such as Brazil's President Lula da Silva, criticised Trump's diplomacy, Russia's former President Dmitry Medvedev warned of retaliation, Iran struck Israel, and China's President Xi Jinping inspired a US-free future. 'While the world resists imperialism, African leaders humiliate themselves at the Oval Office. The EFF must force Africa to cut ties,' Malema added. With Ramaphosa being one of the African leaders who also visited Trump, Malema said he was summoned for the purpose to discuss the EFF and to distance himself from the party and 'kill the boer', the liberation song born from his movement (the ANC). Malema said Ramaphosa failed to live up to the occasion. 'He was summoned to discuss the EFF due to its position on land expropriation without compensation and firm opposition to the introduction of Starlink in South Africa if it undermines our laws on transformation and due to it posing a security threat. "As the President of our nation shook in fear and mumbled as he was unable to defend sovereignty of our Constitutional court, Supreme Court of Appeals and Equality Court, the US launched an onslaught on our liberation history which he could not defend because he desperately wanted to disassociate with the EFF,'' he said. He added that any claim that diplomatic relations are being mended behind closed doors has also proven to be untrue, as it has been revealed that presidential envoy, Mcebisi Jonas, has not been granted any audience by Washington, even though months have passed since his deployment. Meanwhile, the FW De Klerk's foundation has added its voice in calling for South Africa to stop being overly reliant on America and look elsewhere for trade deals amid concerns over President Donald Trump's 30% tariffs on exports. In what could be seen as the country's population banding together against the economic squeezing tariffs, the foundation echoed DA leader John Steenhuisen's call for the country to spread its wings wider, looking for alternative markets across the world.
The South African
8 hours ago
- The South African
Malema: 'EFF has never been in the pockets of criminals'
EFF leader Julius Malema firmly denied that criminals have captured the Economic Freedom Fighters. Speaking on Saturday at the party's 3rd Central Command Team meeting of the 3rd National People's Assembly in Bela-Bela, Limpopo, Malema said the EFF has consistently been at the forefront of demanding accountability from the state. The Central Command Team is the EFF's highest decision-making body between the National People's Assemblies. According to IOL , Malema criticised President Cyril Ramaphosa for allegedly failing to act on warnings from the National Prosecuting Authority (NPA). He said the EFF called for an inquiry after NPA head Shamila Batohi claimed 'sinister forces' had captured the institution. 'It was the EFF that wrote to the president, demanding an inquiry into Batohi's claims. Instead of acting, he coerced her into withdrawing her remarks, calling it a misuse of language,' Malema said. Malema also pointed to the EFF's 2024 parliamentary motion to establish an ad hoc committee to investigate extortion rings targeting businesses and residents. He said the ANC, DA, and IFP, which govern the provinces worst hit by extortion, the Eastern Cape, Western Cape, and KwaZulu-Natal, rejected the proposal. 'Extortionists and criminal syndicates celebrated that day, as their political protection worked in their favour,' Malema said. Malema praised KwaZulu-Natal Police Commissioner Lieutenant General Nhlanhla Mkhwanazi for exposing the links between criminal cartels and political figures. 'It took Mkhwanazi breaking ranks for the truth the EFF has always spoken to finally be taken seriously,' he said. Malema reiterated that the EFF remains independent. 'We have never been and will never be in the pockets of criminals. When we gave other parties the chance to stand against crime, they refused,' he said. Malema reaffirmed his support for Mkhwanazi and said the EFF would welcome him to join the party if he loses his position in the SAPS. Let us know by leaving a comment below, or send a WhatsApp to 060 011 021 1 Subscribe to The South African website's newsletters and follow us on WhatsApp, Facebook, X and Bluesky for the latest news.
Mail & Guardian
12 hours ago
- Mail & Guardian
AI must serve labour, not subjugate it, G20 labour group says
Graphic: John McCann/M&G Labour 20, the G20's employment track, has called for the reclassification of workers in the digital economy, where many are labelled as 'independent contractors', which it said enables exploitation and strips workers of core rights. 'Platform workers are being misclassified, denied basic protections and subjected to inhumane working conditions by companies that exploit regulatory gaps. We believe that this is not innovation but is exploitation wrapped in code,' it said in a communiqué. 'We call for international standards to ensure cross-border accountability, worker data sovereignty and fair taxation of platform giants. Technology must serve labour, not subjugate it.' G20 working groups have made similar recommendations ahead of the November summit of heads of state, with the South Africa, which holds the current Workers in the digital economy are effectively outside the law, Cosatu head of policy Lebogang Meelis told the Mail and Guardian. 'People working in the digital economy who are classified as independent contractors are not recognised as workers. As such, they are not covered by labour legislation and this leaves them vulnerable to severe exploitation,' she said. These workers can't join trade unions, have no protection from unfair dismissals and are excluded from unemployment insurance and collective bargaining. 'They are not afforded a process to try and protect them from retrenchment and minimise the negative impact,' Meelis said. Fedusa general secretary Riefdah Ajam described the 'independent contractor' label as 'a deliberate tactic used by capital and employers to strip them of basic rights'. Contractors, she said, 'are required to work full days and answer to supervisors — whether human or algorithmic', yet are denied basics like UIF, paid leave and the right to unionise. 'The platforms that use this model get away with avoiding responsibility and, ultimately, being non-compliant with the labour laws and other rights as provisioned for in the Constitution and other statutes,' Ajam added, warning that if unions don't push back, a rights-based labour system could soon be a thing of the past. Labour 20 called on governments to implement mandatory due diligence and public oversight of all digital labour platforms operating within their borders. The summit rejected 'digital colonialism', declaring that the infrastructure of the digital economy 'must be public, universal and democratic'. 'We further demand algorithmic transparency, where workers have access to the data that governs their performance and livelihoods. No worker should be at the mercy of a faceless system they cannot question,' it said in its communiqué. Fedusa wants tough regulations that force platforms to disclose how they treat workers, what algorithms they use and where their profits go. The union also backs penalties for non-compliance and calls for stronger local ownership of the digital economy. 'We can't outsource our future to companies who see us as a market but never as equal partners. This is about sovereignty, dignity and economic justice,' Ajam said. With more than 60% of workers globally 'trapped in informal and precarious employment', Labour 20 called for 'a comprehensive agenda for formalisation'. Recommendations included labour law reform, strengthened inspections, ratification of International Labour Organisation conventions and inclusive social protection. 'Trade unions must be at the centre of this shift. We affirm that informal workers are workers. Their rights are not negotiable,' said the communiqué. Governments and employers, it said, must end delays and move decisively toward institutionalising decent work. Meelis said Cosatu had secured a win through negotiations at the National Economic Development and Labour Council with the government agreeing to allow atypical workers — including actors and digital platform workers — to join unions and engage in collective bargaining. However, Meelis said the deployment of AI risks deepening inequality. 'In the short term, more women risk losing their jobs than men — particularly because the initial impact of AI will be the replacement of administrative jobs, which are predominantly held by women workers.' 'If we are to address inequality and not exacerbate it, digital transformation must not outpace social integration,' Meelis added. 'If someone works regularly for a platform, follows set conditions and depends on that income, they should be presumed an employee until proven otherwise. That's how fairness can be restored.' South Africa's labour laws haven't caught up with the gig economy, Ajam said. 'We need them amended so that platform workers are clearly included.' She also criticised new terms like 'dependent contractors' as potential loopholes for further abuse. 'Any new category must carry full protections.' Ajam wants the International Labour Organisation to adopt a binding convention on platform work. 'It should cover fair pay, set working hours, access to benefits, transparency around algorithms and the right to organise.' The communiqué also noted that 'workers are facing spiralling inequality, stubborn unemployment, rising authoritarianism, deepening climate devastation and collapsing public services'. 'In the Global South, these crises are compounded by debt, weak state capacity and the brutal legacies of colonial exploitation. Our call is simple and unwavering: the working class will not pay for the failure of a system rigged against them.' Labour 20 said workers' futures should not be 'sacrificed at the altar of profit and geopolitical power', urging a 'reclaiming and rebuilding' of multilateralism and a reversal of the declining labour share of income. 'Workers are not commodities nor statistics. We are the architects of society, and any global recovery that excludes them is a blueprint for deeper inequality,' the communiqué said.
