Refs must retain right to adjudge kick-out mark infringements, insists Deegan
Three-time All-Ireland final referee Deegan revealed he has received several messages following this past weekend's All-Ireland SFC Round 2 games where there were several instances of the rule being implemented.
In the Cork-Kerry game in SuperValu Páirc Uí Chaoimh on Saturday, referee Derek O'Mahoney exercised the 50m advancement on several occasions much to the ire of both managers John Cleary and Jack O'Connor.
In the second half, Cork were adjudged to have obstructed Kerry a few times and as per rule the visitors took the option of bringing the resultant free advanced 50m outside the arc for a two-point free.
Deegan is adamant it should be left up to referees to determine what constitutes an obstruction within four metres of a kick-out mark.
'That part of the rule has been there for some time now but it's probably being more enforced now.
'As for it being policed a bit too harshly, I don't think so. I would say the lads are policing it correctly. You're probably seeing more implementing it to the letter of the law.
'Every referee is different in how they judge certain facets of the game. It's like the advantage rule, which now has no time limit in football. The extent of the advantage given is open to the interpretation of the referee.
'There had been a time limit of kick-outs earlier this year but there is none now and that is also up to the referee and what he thinks is the acceptable amount of time for the 'keeper to take the kick. You don't want to take that out of the referee's hands either.
'The rules are being scrutinised like never before and I can understand where they are coming from. Nobody should want to take the power out of the referee's hands. It would be the wrong to do that. You have to trust the referee. It's the same in every walk of life, everyone is different.'
Deegan accepts the point that the act of a player in unsuccessfully challenging to claim a kick-out shouldn't be considered as a tackle within the four metres.
'No, that isn't a challenge in that sense. If two players are coming down to the ground, you would imagine that is fine and the player who wins the mark either takes it or plays on.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
14 minutes ago
- The Irish Sun
Tipperary camogie manager hailed for ‘outstanding commitment and dedication' as he steps down from role
Galway's Aoife Donohue also spoke about the heavily criticised physicality and tackles by the Tribeswomen in the All-Ireland final KINGLY KELLY Tipperary camogie manager hailed for 'outstanding commitment and dedication' as he steps down from role DENIS Kelly described his time in charge of the Tipperary senior camogie team as 'a huge honour' after he announced his decision to step down. The Borris-Ileigh man spent three years at the helm, having also served as coach under Bill Mullaney for the previous two. 2 Kelly had been involved in Tipp camogie for five years before deciding to step down 2 Tipperary lost out 1-18 to 1-11 to Galway in the All-Ireland semi-final this year Kelly steered the Premier to National League and Munster titles during his tenure. However, his side fell short in All-Ireland semi-finals in each of the three campaigns he oversaw. The Tipp County Board hailed Kelly for 'his outstanding commitment and dedication to Tipperary camogie' while he occupied the hotseat. A statement added: 'Alongside his management team, Denis ensured that every player representing Tipperary was prepared to the very highest standards. 'During his time in charge, Denis brought silverware back to the county, most memorably securing the Division 1 National League title in 2024 — our first in 20 years — with a brilliant victory over Galway in Croke Park. 'He also guided the team to a Munster title in 2023 and to three successive All-Ireland Championship semi-finals. 'We thank Denis sincerely for his immense contribution to Tipperary Camogie and extend our very best wishes to him for the future.' Meanwhile, Galway's Aoife Donohue was delighted to see the brute force on display in their All-Ireland camogie final win over Cork. While Rebels boss Ger Manley accused ref Justin Heffernan of a 'shocking' performance in his side's one-point defeat, Galway gaffer Cathal Murray praised the Wexford official for facilitating a superb spectacle by letting it flow. Tribe forward Donohue said: 'Looking back at it now, some of the tackles and the physicality were through the roof. I thought last year's All-Ireland final had gone up another level but it went up another one again. Henry Shefflin among GAA stars at Oasis gigs where Man City tradition made its Croke Park debut 'It's great for camogie and, in fairness to the referee, he allowed for that and it contributed to the game that it was. We've obviously been calling on it for quite a while now. 'As players, all of us are a lot stronger, fitter, faster — we're able for it. It's definitely something we'd be looking for.' Murray hit out at 'insulting' commentary surrounding his team as he insisted they were 'given no chance' of killing Cork's three-in-a-row bid. But Donohue, camogie's PwC GPA Player of the Month for July/August, said: 'As players, you kind of block out all that noise. 'I don't think we were given much of a chance, so Cathal was probably a little bit riled over it. But none of that really mattered to us as players.'
Irish Times
14 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Fergus Finlay sought Labour Party run for presidency
Labour Party grandee Fergus Finlay asked Ivana Bacik in January if he could run for President for the party. Mr Finlay, who had also sought the party's nomination for the 2011 contest and considered a run in 2018, said he was 'very disappointed' to see Labour supporting Catherine Connolly. The former head of Mary Robinson's historic 1990 campaign said he did not know what Ms Connolly had done to 'deserve' the Labour Party's support. Speaking on RTÉ's Behind The Story podcast this week, Mr Finlay revealed he had approached party leader Ms Bacik in January indicating he was open to running for President. READ MORE 'I wanted to say that Labour should contest, must contest, must do everything we possibly can to contest, recognising all the difficulties that we don't have 20 Oireachtas votes sewn up there. But there were a lot of Oireachtas votes in play at that time,' Mr Finlay said. 'There was no other left-wing candidate in the field at that time – I wanted to say that Labour should contest, and I wanted to be considered as a candidate.' Mr Finlay, who added he felt no 'entitlement to anything', said it quickly became clear to him that his proposal was 'going nowhere'. 'I think [Ms Bacik] felt that this was not a winnable situation for Labour. Maybe she felt it wasn't winnable for Labour with me. Maybe she felt that I was a burned-out waste of space! I have no idea. She's far too polite ever to say anything like that, but it became clear to me very quickly that it was going nowhere.' Mr Finlay had lost out on the Labour Party's nomination in 2010, ahead of Michael D Higgins winning his first term. Mr Finlay would also later reveal he had also considered putting himself forward in 2018, before it became clear to him that President Higgins would seek a second term. Mr Finlay said he believed in the role of the President to 'get the best out of people', and that if he had a criticism of President Higgins it was that 'he didn't do enough of that', particularly in terms of national morale during the Covid-19 pandemic. Mr Finlay said he was 'very disappointed' that Labour had decided to row in behind Independent left-wing candidate Ms Connolly. 'There's a lot of stuff I don't agree with Catherine Connolly about, there's a lot of stuff I admire her for. But Catherine Connolly left the Labour Party because we wouldn't give her a nomination to run alongside Michael D Higgins, and she has never had a good word to say about the Labour Party from that moment on,' he said. Mr Finlay said it would have been a 'crazy, suicidal decision' to give Ms Connolly a nomination, which would have meant there was 'no chance of anybody winning that seat'. He said Ms Connolly 'couldn't bring herself to accept that', and she 'has never had a good word to say about the Labour Party since'. 'And now we're backing her. And I have no problem with members of the Labour Party going out and voting for Catherine Connolly, none in the wide, Earthly world. But I don't know what she's done to deserve our support, to be absolutely honest with you.'
The 42
43 minutes ago
- The 42
'In that stage of my Tipperary career, I needed to remind myself and others what I was capable of'
IN THE EXTENSIVE search to rediscover his top form, John McGrath doesn't reckon he tried anything too off the wall to get back in the Tipperary team. He was always tinkering with his approach, though. In the aftermath of a torn Achilles, which flared up on occasion since 2022, it was feared that the Loughmore-Castleiney star's best days in blue and gold were behind him. Indeed, prior to this year, his only championship start under Liam Cahill came in the manager's Munster debut with Tipp in April 2023. 'You do go a bit mad with it at times,' said McGrath, who has been named the PwC GAA/GPA Hurler of the Month for July. 'The club form was probably one of the huge things that kept me going. In the back of your mind, you know it's there. 'You're trying to train extra, and maybe that's not working, and next thing you're trying everything to maybe recover better. 'It's funny, I saw very little League time, and it's not as if I was tearing up trees or anything in training either.' Did he have any sense that Cahill was holding him back for the Munster Championship? PwC GAA/GPA Hurler of the Month for July John McGrath. Photo by Ramsey Cardy/Sportsfile 'No, nothing like that. I played a small bit, didn't see any action in our last League game against Clare or the League final with Cork. Advertisement 'You certainly have conversations with lads. Frustration, at times, not playing, being left out. Look, there's 37 or 38 lads, and a lot of lads are probably asking them the same questions. 'But no, there was certainly never anything like that we're going to hold on to him for championship. 'Maybe I got into a little bit of training form at the right time, and the lads took a bit of a chance on me coming into that Limerick game. 'They said we're going to put you in, you've been there, you have the bit of experience, so it just went well for me that day and kicked on from there.' McGrath consistently stood up in the biggest games on their route to All-Ireland glory, scoring a goal against Kilkenny and two each against Limerick, Clare, and Cork, where he also won the clinching penalty. The 31-year-old doesn't think he arrived with a different approach, just a 're-found appreciation' for being back involved in those showpiece days. He did put a major emphasis on that first day out against Limerick, though. Tipperary's John McGrath to the field before playing Limerick at FBD Semple Stadium. James Crombie / INPHO James Crombie / INPHO / INPHO 'I remember Liam coming to me a couple of days before that game, and saying they were going to put me in. I put a lot of pressure on myself in that game. I probably made it out to be a bigger game in my own head than it actually was. 'The couple of previous years I had were on and off. Off more than on. In that stage of my Tipperary career, I needed to do something to remind myself and to remind others what I was capable of. 'Thank God it worked out for me a bit that day, and we'd a brilliant battle, but just to be back stuck in it, it's something you don't want to let go of.' In McGrath's own words, it was far from the best game he'd ever played, but he felt at the right level physically and departed filled with confidence. Off the back of a winless 2024, it was a sense he carried throughout the summer. 'We were losing games by double figures more than once, so it was just about getting back and being competitive. 'From the journey that we've come on this year, and where we've come from in the last couple of years, it's just been unreal. To be honest, it's hard to believe at times. 'I'm living in Thurles and you're going down the town and the flags and colour are still up and in some ways, it feels like a bit of a dream 'It's massively special and for something that you thought maybe wasn't going to come again, or maybe that at this level you were done, or weren't going to get to this level again, the satisfaction of it is just unreal.' McGrath admits there was 'an element of shock' in the manner that Tipp prevailed over Cork in the second half of the final. John McGrath celebrates scoring a goal against Cork. Laszlo Geczo / INPHO Laszlo Geczo / INPHO / INPHO He feels everything started to go right for them, while the Rebels experienced the exact opposite when hitting the woodwork four times. The biggest satisfaction was the rare achievement of saving 'the best 35 minutes of the year' for the final part of the season. With that Celtic Cross in the back pocket, did McGrath's conversations turn to doing back-to-back at any stage during the celebrations? 'As the year ticks on and it gets into the winter, those sorts of thoughts will be coming to lads. You certainly don't want to just win one and go away for a couple of years again. 'Like Tipp, we want and aim to be very competitive every year. That's not always going to lead to winning Munster Championships or All-Ireland Championships or League finals, but on any given year, Tipp should feel that there's a real chance. 'It's probably for a couple of weeks and months down the line when that kind of talk starts up. We wanted to enjoy the year we had and to celebrate that when we had the chance.'
