Asian Paints aims to quash CCI probe, saying investigation order mishandled
Asian Paints
, is seeking to quash an antitrust inquiry by
CCI
, arguing that officials damaged its
reputation
by publishing, and then deleting, allegations against its
CEO
from the investigation order, legal papers show.
Rapid infrastructure and real estate growth in India, one of the world's fastest-growing economies, has made the paints business a lucrative sector worth around $9.5 billion.
Explore courses from Top Institutes in
Please select course:
Select a Course Category
others
PGDM
Technology
Project Management
Artificial Intelligence
Others
Finance
MCA
Cybersecurity
Public Policy
Data Analytics
Degree
Operations Management
Design Thinking
Data Science
CXO
Healthcare
MBA
Leadership
healthcare
Management
Product Management
Digital Marketing
Data Science
Skills you'll gain:
Duration:
16 Weeks
Indian School of Business
CERT - ISB Cybersecurity for Leaders Program India
Starts on
undefined
Get Details
The
Competition Commission of India
is investigating Asian Paints, which has a 52% market share, after officials found merit in a complaint filed by rival
Birla Opus
that Asian Paints had abused its dominant position by offering discounts and incentives to dealers.
In a court challenge, Asian Paints told Mumbai judges the CCI's July 1 order contained an allegation that its CEO warned
raw material suppliers
in a meeting that they would get less business from the company if they dealt with Birla.
Within 24 hours, the reference was deleted and a new modified order was issued by the CCI, Asian Paints said in the filing, adding that both orders were still online and such an unexplained change was against legal procedures.
Live Events
"The concurrent existence of two different orders ... has undermined the integrity of the proceedings, creating confusion in the market," Asian Paints said in its July 14
high court
filing, seen by Reuters.
"The contents of the first impugned order have also caused grave reputational damage to the petitioner and to its CEO."
The CCI did not respond to queries on
Asian Paints' lawsuit
or why the changes were made to its order.
Asian Paints, its CEO Amit Syngle and Birla Opus, the paints arm of billionaire Kumar Mangalam Birla's
Grasim Industries
, also did not respond to queries.
Reuters is first to report the contents of Asian Paints' 250-page lawsuit, which is not public.
Birla has dented some of Asian Paints' dominance after it launched in February 2024 and grew rapidly to garner a near 7% market share by March this year, Elara Capital data shows.
Asian Paints also presented a table to the judge citing other changes made in the revised order, including the deletion of a reference that its representatives were allegedly concerned about some dealers using Birla's specialist paint devices.
Making such changes indicates the CCI took its decision with a "pre-meditated mind", Asian Paints' filing said.
Ahead of the CCI's decision to investigate, Reuters on June 6 first reported Birla's confidential antitrust complaint against Asian Paints. Asian Paints submitted that story to the CCI and also inquired about the case, the filing shows.
Asian Paints' court challenge will be heard on August 6.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
9 hours ago
- Time of India
WinZO disputes Google's CCI proposal on Play Store rules
Bengaluru: Real‑money gaming platform WinZO has raised concerns over Google's latest proposal to the Competition Commission of India (CCI), arguing that it does not adequately address the anti‑competitive issues flagged in an ongoing investigation. The case originates from WinZO's December 2022 complaint alleging that Google abused its dominant position by restricting Play Store access to only fantasy sports and rummy apps while excluding other real‑money gaming categories. With Google controlling 96% of India's app distribution market, WinZO said this policy inflated user acquisition costs by 'at least 10x' for apps distributed outside the Play Store. Acting on the complaint, the CCI in November 2024 ordered a formal investigation, citing prima facie violations of competition law, including the imposition of unfair conditions, denial of market access and limiting of market development. The Commission had noted Google's lack of clear criteria for its pilot programme, inconsistent enforcement of its ads policy and 'misleading payment warnings' shown to users sideloading apps, which it said artificially deterred usage. In a public notice issued recently the CCI invited comments on Google's commitment offer. Google's proposal includes allowing all real‑money games that are certified by recognised third‑party bodies, replacing its pilot programme for fantasy sports and rummy apps and permitting certified skill‑based games to advertise on Google Ads. If approved, Google has committed to implement the Play Store changes within 120 days and its advertising changes within 150 days of the CCI's order. The deadline for public comments is August 20, 2025. Responding to WinZO's objections, a Google spokesperson said the company welcomed the CCI's market testing of its proposed framework, describing it as the result of 'constructive discussions' with the regulator and Indian developers. Google added that it is confident the proposal will create 'a more open and safe ecosystem' for real‑money gaming apps, empower local developers and prioritise user safety. In its statement, WinZO said Google's commitments 'must be robust and genuinely eliminate the discriminatory practices identified,' adding that the proposed framework's reference to 'developing' a commercial model for real‑money gaming lacked clear timelines or objective criteria. WinZO, which reported a 70% rise in revenue to Rs 1,055 crore and a 151% increase in profit to Rs 315 crore in FY24, said it will continue to participate in the consultation process 'to ensure fairness, transparency and a level playing field in India's digital economy.' AI Masterclass for Students. Upskill Young Ones Today!– Join Now
Time of India
9 hours ago
- Time of India
WinZO disputes Google's plea over Play Store rules
Bengaluru: Real-money gaming platform WinZO has raised concerns over Google's plea to the Competition Commission of India (CCI), arguing that it does not adequately address the anti-competitive issues flagged in an ongoing investigation. The case originates from WinZO's 2022 complaint alleging that Google abused its dominant position by restricting Play Store access to only fantasy sports and rummy apps while excluding other real-money gaming categories. With Google controlling 96% of India's app distribution market, WinZO said this policy inflated user acquisition costs by "at least 10x" for apps distributed outside the Play Store. Acting on the complaint, the CCI in Nov last year ordered a formal investigation, citing prima facie violations of competition law, including the imposition of unfair conditions, denial of market access, and limiting of market development. The Commission noted Google's lack of clear criteria for its pilot programme, inconsistent enforcement of its ads policy, and "misleading payment warnings" shown to users sideloading apps, which it said artificially deterred usage. In a public notice issued recently, the CCI invited comments on Google's commitment offer. Google's proposal includes allowing all real-money games that are certified by recognised third-party bodies, replacing its pilot programme for fantasy sports and rummy apps, and permitting certified skill-based games to advertise on Google Ads. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Tarxien: unsold sofas are almost being donated (check it out) Couches & Sofas | Search Ads Search Now Undo If approved, Google has committed to implement the Play Store changes within 120 days and its advertising changes within 150 days of the CCI's order. You Can Also Check: Bengaluru AQI | Weather in Bengaluru | Bank Holidays in Bengaluru | Public Holidays in Bengaluru The deadline for public comments is August 20. Responding to WinZO's objections, a Google spokesperson said the company welcomed the CCI's market testing of its proposed framework, describing it as the result of "constructive discussions" with the regulator and Indian developers. Google added that it is confident the proposal will create "a more open and safe ecosystem" for real-money gaming apps, empower local developers, and prioritise user safety. In its statement, WinZO said Google's commitments "must be robust and genuinely eliminate the discriminatory practices identified," adding that the proposed framework's reference to "developing" a commercial model for real-money gaming lacked clear timelines or objective criteria.
Hindustan Times
15 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Google Play proposes real money games in India, with suggested changes to ads policy
Google has proposed to allow real money games on Google Play in India as part of addressing anti-competition concerns. Google clarified that payment warnings are developer agnostic, applied in a uniform and transparent manner.(Pixabay/representational) Besides, the technology major has suggested changes to Google Ads Policy and permits games of skill to be advertised in India, subject to certain conditions. In November 2024, the Competition Commission of India (CCI) had ordered an investigation against Google on a complaint filed by Winzo Games Pvt Ltd. Against this backdrop, Google has submitted a commitment proposal to the regulator. "The Play Commitment Proposal, along with the Ads Commitment Proposal, addresses the Hon'ble Commission's concerns by ensuring inclusive access to Google Play and Google Ads for all compliant RMGs, eliminating any alleged competitive disadvantages, and standardising policies to prevent any adverse effects on competition," Google said in the proposal. RMGs refer to Real Money Games. In its order, CCI had mentioned the alleged exclusion of certain RMG apps from Google Play could result in a denial of market access. and also that the selective onboarding of DFS (Daily Fantasy Sports) and Rummy apps allegedly distorts the competitive landscape. It was also flagged that the prolonged duration of the pilot program, which includes only DFS and Rummy apps, is said to perpetuate advantages for these apps, creating barriers for new entrants. "Google will replace the current pilot program by allowing the distribution of all RMGs self-declared by developers as permissible online real money games as per applicable laws/jurisprudence, on Google Play in India," the company said. Also, the company is finalising its approach for an appropriate business model which considers developer commercial models in the RMG industry. With respect to its Ads Policy, Google said it will allow games of skill to be advertised in India where the advertiser provides proof that it is in good standing with a recognised third party and certain other conditions. Besides, it needs to be ensured that the "recognised third party has provided a third party certification that the game it intends to advertise is a permissible game of skill, and the advertiser otherwise complies with the Google Ads Policies," the proposal said. Among other aspects, Google clarified that payment warnings are developer agnostic, applied in a uniform and transparent manner and are objectively necessary for user safety, as mandated by several directives of the Reserve Bank of India and the National Payments Corporation of India. "They are not specific to any consumer, individual merchant, or a particular product 'class' (e.g. RMG vs non-RMG apps), nor do they differentiate between developers distributed on Google Play (by way of a pilot program or otherwise) or outside of Google Play. They are applied in a uniform and transparent manner and may be triggered by objective parameters that apply to all transactions alike," it noted. The watchdog has sought public comments on the commitment proposal till August 20. In a statement on Friday, Winzo said Google has now sought to resolve the matter by offering its third commitment. "Any commitments must be robust and genuinely eliminate the discriminatory practices identified. "Winzo is carefully reviewing the details of Google's new proposal and will continue to participate actively in the CCI's consultation process. Google's vague reference to 'developing' a commercial model for Real Money Gaming, without any clear framework, timeline, or objective criteria, is what we would watch out for," it added.
