There is a way to unblock Ireland's infrastructural logjam
Economic and Social Research Institute
(ESRI), and member of the Government's infrastructure taskforce, interviewed recently raised my hopes for a dawning realisation at Government level of the infrastructural crisis we face. Our administrative and legal procedures simply cannot overcome or unlock the logjam in time to prevent very serious damage to the Irish economy and Irish society.
O'Driscoll, a very experienced private sector chief executive, spoke plainly and truthfully about a number of issues including capital spending cutbacks. He observed that the Irish planning process had developed from a two-tier system involving local planning authorities and an appeal board process, to a three-tier one encompassing
a veritable legal industry grounded on judicial review
.
I would go much farther than O'Driscoll in predicting the crisis for economic infrastructure. The recently enacted Planning and Development Act redesignating
An Bord Pleanála
as An Comisiún Pleanala – the largest-by-volume enactment ever made by the Oireachtas – will compound rather than mitigate our disastrous planning process and Government's dismal record. The new commission is to be chaired by Paul Reid, formerly head of
Fingal County Council
and of the Health Service Executive. Frankly, it really doesn't matter who stands on the bridge of the new planning commission that increasingly resembles a governmental RMS Titanic.
The commission,
as I have written here
, is to be a single competent agency to decide on appeal matters as trivial as whether a bin shelter can be constructed in a front garden or the height of an extension to a family home. At the same time it could rule on decisions as far reaching as whether Metrolink should be built; whether offshore wind farms should be permitted in the Atlantic; all major State and local authority compulsory purchase orders; the number of flights to be allowed into Dublin Airport; whether a Shannon-Dublin water supply project or new Cork-Limerick motorway should be allowed to proceed.
READ MORE
What is it about Ireland that all of these massively different functions are vested in a single non-governmental agency? How is it hoped that such a vast range of powers and functions can be exercised by a single body entirely free from the curse of lengthy judicial review proceedings?
There is another way. Challenges to legislation enacted by the Oireachtas, as distinct from decisions made by non-governmental agencies including the planning commission, are far less likely to be brought or to succeed. The Victorian model of having the legislature authorise major infrastructural development by statute is the answer – subject to modification to take account of EU legal requirements.
When the fledgling Irish Free State determined to harness the Shannon's hydroelectric potential, it enacted, even before the establishment of the ESB, a law in 1925 providing for the construction at Ardnacrusha. This law also provided for the canals involved, the compulsory purchase of land and legal interests affected, and State financing of what was then a massive piece of national infrastructure.
[
Ardnacrusha at 100: What could happen if Ireland showed similar ambition today and invested 20% of national budget in energy?
Opens in new window
]
For 30 years, the construction of a Shannon-Dublin water supply scheme has been acknowledged as necessary at Government level. But nothing has happened.
Uisce Éireann
believes the project might take 10 more years for completion, even if it was given the Government's green light today.
Why not, instead, pass a 'Shannon-Dublin Water Supply Scheme Act'? It would have the following features: the promoter, Uisce Éireann, would submit detailed plans, including compulsory acquisition of wayleaves and other land. It would set out environmental impact assessments required by European law. Receipt and consideration of any third-party submissions would be completed by a select committee of the Oireachtas and the committee would authorise the works, as varied or approved, to be completed.
Subsequent challenge to the construction of the project would face the hurdle of proving the unconstitutionality of the measure. Judicial review would simply not arise.
The government of the day could kick-start and see through to completion major infrastructural projects if this model, like Victorian legislative infrastructural projects, were adopted.
The same could apply to the national power grid, major sewage disposal facilities and major rail projects. The legislative option incorporating such approval could even address passenger numbers at
Dublin Airport
.
Only a handful of Senators opposed central features of the Planning and Development Act, which has created monstrous new planning legal processes centred on the new planning commission, along with national development policies and guidelines, and the wholly unnecessary
Office of the Planning Regulator
.
Far from being an answer to the coming crisis identified by O'Driscoll, the 2024 Act is a charter for its continuation. It is a recipe for ongoing failure, even with its legally flimsy restriction on future judicial reviews. If the Government's infrastructural taskforce doesn't understand this, it too will fail.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
4 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Tony Holohan's reluctance to admit mistakes sits badly with the national mood
Prof Tony Holohan's withdrawal from the presidential race is a mercy – not just for him, but for the rest of us. We are spared the bear-baiting with the cervical-cancer controversy and the pandemic, the performative outrage and vile social media that would have plunged all concerned into a sewer stripped of nuance and context. That Covid still scratches the national psyche hardly helps. A recent five-year anniversary Mass for a Kildare man who died during lockdown morphed into the warm, crowded service denied to his family in 2020. His favourite music was sung and the same eulogies given by his adult children five years ago at his lonely graveside were delivered to a packed congregation. What was surprising for a five-year memorial was how immediate and raw it felt. READ MORE It was an experience hardly unique to Ireland, but it is Holohan's burden to be forever associated with it. That his wife Emer was also buried under the harshest Covid rules would not have spared him from the vitriol. Inevitably, some were salivating at the idea of using his appearances as Covid inquisitions. Which raises the question – again – of why people put their heads above the presidential parapet. Holohan must have felt he had done the state some service. He had answered the call for a calm, firm, trustworthy medical leader to guide Ireland through an unprecedented public health crisis, while attending to his dying wife – all of which surely made him the very definition of a president. But no leader survives those multiple levels of hell without making mistakes – and Holohan's reluctance to admit to any mistakes sits badly with the mood of the times. Issues can be argued – as he did in his memoir – but few will listen. They don't want to hear ifs or buts or blame being ascribed elsewhere, even if it belongs there. They want to hear humility and unconditional admissions: 'Yes, I made a mistake.' Ill-wishers will grab it as vindication of course – 'Hah, told you he had blood on his hands.' But unlike other hapless hopefuls, Holohan would have known all the questions about to be catapulted at him. His USP would have been that of someone intimately familiar with the ferocity, filthy betrayals and short-termism of politics without being an actual politician. Even before his withdrawal, the weekend's media was distinguished by the startling number of pundits trotting out several of those same points as reasons Bertie Ahern should proceed with confidence. He has the experience, the likability and the peace process in his arms, they say. He has been interrogated to the max. No question on earth would surprise the one who – to quote the revered Blackadder – is as cunning as a fox who's just been appointed professor of cunning at Oxford University. And time, as we know, can soften even the sharpest memories. It's 17 years since he was taoiseach, 13 since he resigned from Fianna Fáil following the Mahon tribunal finding that he failed to account truthfully for payments of IR£165,000 made to accounts connected to him. Anyone seeking signs of contrition might catch a 2018 Deutsche Welle 'Conflict Zone' interview which sees him happily answering questions about the peace negotiations – until asked about the tribunal. 'Did you clear your name?' the interviewer asks. 'Yes, I did. I'm quite happy I cleared my name', he answers. But that wasn't 'truthful', the interviewer says. 'The tribunal gave its views … and I gave my evidence. I was very happy with my evidence', he replies, as if it were all just a matter of opinion. He ends it by getting up and leaving. 'A first on dwZone,' as DW's Twitter link described it. Since then, Micheál Martin – who sought to kick Ahern out of the party before he resigned – has consulted him about issues around the Northern Ireland protocol, acknowledging his 'invaluable insights' and range of contacts. When reminded of that threatened expulsion a few years ago, Martin said: 'It's 10 years on, I'm conscious of the contribution he has made to peace in the country. He made a very significant contribution.' Leo Varadkar , who in the Dáil once described Ahern's claims of wins on the horses as 'a defence for drug dealers and pimps', had also ratcheted down his tone by 2023, saying the remarks were made 'at a particular point in time and if you look at the totality of Bertie Ahern's career, you know, let's not forget that he was one of the architects of the Good Friday Agreement … I don't think anyone can diminish the role that he played'. Just a month ago, Ahern was at 5 per cent in an Irish Times/IpsosB&A presidency poll. Last Sunday he was up at 14 per cent, tying for third place with Mary Lou McDonald in a Sunday Independent/Ireland Thinks poll. Which brings us back to the old question: is there an optimum time for society to say, enough punishment, all that was at a particular point in time, look at the balance of his life? How many years? Does it matter if the offender has never acknowledged they did wrong in the first place? As one professor leaves the stage, the professor of cunning hovers, batting his eyelashes, saying nothing, waiting, smiling and waiting.
Irish Times
4 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Government to blame for hundreds of food businesses going under, restaurants say
More than 300 businesses in the food services sector closed in the first seven months of the year, according to the Restaurants Association of Ireland (RAI), which has laid the blame for the 'severe' pressure the sector is under squarely at the feet of the Government. The association, which is to meet Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe next week, published a report on Tuesday which presented its case for cutting VAT in the sector from 13.5 per cent to 9 per cent in October's budget. The reduction would cost the State about €674 million, the latest Tax Strategy Group papers show, a figure the report described as 'small' in the context of the €9.4 billion budget package. It added the estimate does not account for the 'positive economic impact' of the measure. READ MORE The report flatly rejected commentary in recent months suggesting the sector is 'booming', and outlined its rationale as to why headline figures on which such assertions have been based ought to be treated with caution. Speaking at the launch of the report in Dublin, RAI chief executive Adrian Cummins said most businesses in the sector, which encompasses restaurants, takeaways, pubs, and coffee shops, are operating with profit margins in the region of one to two per cent. He said businesses in the sector have been 'blacklisted by the banks', relying on data from the Central Bank showing gross new lending 'collapsed' from €17 million to €6 million in March compared with the same period last year to support his argument. Restaurants Association of Ireland chief executive Adrian Cummins and economist Anthony Foley at the launch of the report. The RAI's report, which was based on research from former Dublin City University (DCU) economics professor Anthony Foley, identified 546 business closures last year, and 306 in the first seven months of 2025. 'We are confident we do not identify all closures,' the report said. The report pointed to Government measures such as minimum wage increases, the move to the living wage, higher employer PRSI, pension auto-enrolment, additional bank holidays, leave regulations, sick pay regulations, and water charges, as aggravating factors. 'It has to be recognised that, apart from market generated cost increases, the Government is responsible for much of the cost increases faced, and still to be faced,' the report said. 'The Government policies have significantly added to the sector's difficulties. It has paused some of the still-to-come measures but we recognise that this pause is temporary and short-term and these cost increasing measures will quickly come back.' Hospitality in Dublin: 'stress and burnout are getting worse in the industry' Listen | 27:20 The report said failure by the Government to cut VAT would lead to job cuts as well as 'unsustainable costs', which would in turn result in 'mass closures' across the sector. One 'solution' put forward by the report was to 'simply increase prices to customers', something it accepted would 'reduce consumer demand, downsize the sector, and negatively affect the appeal of Ireland for tourists'. [ 'These are huge, huge costs and we don't sell gold bars, we sell food,' says Kinara restaurant co-founder Opens in new window ] The report said cost pressures faced by the sector have already forced it to impose price increases, more of which will face 'significant consumer resistance' with 'adverse consequences' for individual enterprises and the sector as a whole. Additionally, the report suggested many business owners are relying on personal savings to stay afloat. 'Businesses are cutting back on opening hours, reducing staff hours, deferring maintenance, and postponing investment in upgrades or innovation,' it said. 'Many are drawing down personal savings or using short-term credit to keep doors open.' Only 7 per cent of restaurants had an increase in revenue in 2025 compared with the same period in 2024, while 69 per cent had a decline, the report said. Average payroll costs have increased as share of total turnover from 32 per cent to 39 per cent since 2022, while food costs as a share have increased from 28 per cent to 34 per cent over the same period.
Irish Times
34 minutes ago
- Irish Times
Heather Humphreys takes large lead over Seán Kelly in race to seek Fine Gael presidential election nomination
Former Fine Gael minister Heather Humphreys has taken a large lead over Ireland South MEP Seán Kelly in the battle to seek the party's nomination to contest the upcoming presidential election . Both Ms Humphreys and Mr Kelly announced their intention to run for president for Fine Gael on Tuesday morning. Each will require the backing of 20 members of the parliamentary party, as well as 25 councillors and five members of the executive council. By Tuesday afternoon, Ms Humphreys had at least 29 nominations from TDs and senators, and was widely expected to have over 30 by the end of the day. So far, Mr Kelly has the backing of at least six parliamentary party members. READ MORE The 29 parliamentary party declarations for for Heather Humphreys so far includes ministers Peter Burke and Patrick O'Donovan, junior ministers Neale Richmond, Hildegarde Naughton, Colm Brophy and Emer Higgins, TDs Emer Currie, John Paul O'Shea, David Maxwell, Jerry Buttimer, Paula Butterly, Grace Boland, Frank Feighan, Naoise O'Muirí, Catherine Callaghan, Alan Dillon, Keira Keogh, James Geoghegan, Colm Burke, John Clendennan and Micheal Carrigy, Barry Ward and senators Sean Kyne, Maria Byrne, Nikki Bradley, Joe O'Reilly, Mark Duffy, Cathal Byrne, Manus Boyle. Joe Cooney, the Fine Gael TD for Clare, said as a Munster man and a 'GAA man' he would be proudly supporting Mr Kelly. So far Mr Kelly also has the support of Senators Michael Kennelly and Garrett Ahearn and TDs Noel McCarthy, Brian Brennan and Michael Murphy. Announcing her candidacy on Tuesday, Ms Humphreys said she had been 'genuinely humbled' by the support in recent days. 'I have decided to go for it,' she told the Joe Finnegan Show on Cavan-Monaghan radio station Northern Sound. She said it was 'fair' to ask why she had changed her mind, having ruled herself out of the contest in May and saying she would be supporting her 'friend' Ms McGuinness instead. 'But as we know, everything has changed with Mairead's news last week and I would just like to wish her well in her recovery.' Ms Humphreys said she was a 'bit burned out' and was probably 'running on empty' when she decided to step down from politics at the end of last year, having sat at Cabinet for a decade. 'I've said to myself more than once: 'you could do a bit more Heather',' she said. 'Really, I've had a good rest, the tank is full again. And you know timing is a funny thing because I have never felt as good about taking on the challenge.' [ Áras race picks up speed as Humphreys and Kelly join Fine Gael field Opens in new window ] Her announcement came a little over an hour after Mr Kelly, a former GAA president, said he also intends to seek the party's nomination. He said he believes that there should be a contest between him and Ms Humphreys. She and Mr Kelly had previously ruled themselves out of the contest, when it was believed that Ms McGuinness would be Fine Gael's candidate. Ms Humphreys in May ruled herself out of running for the presidency, citing her decision to leave politics altogether at the last general election. 'I said at that time that I wanted to spend more time with the family and that my time in public life was over,' she said at that time. In July, Mr Kelly also ruled himself out of the contest. He said that the presidency was largely a ceremonial role. 'You don't have that much power or influence even though you can dress it up whatever way you like and I like to be involved politically,' he said then. The MEP appeared to walk these comments back on Tuesday, saying that his comment 'was in comparison to presidents around the world' who have executive powers. 'But I think actually there's a huge potential in the job, it is the highest honour in Ireland.' Mr Kelly said having spent time in Ireland over the last few weeks, he understood that he had grassroots support as many people had told him they were disappointed he was not running for the Áras. In the days following Mairead McGuinness' unfortunate withdrawal as Fine Gael's candidate for President of Ireland on health grounds, I have reflected and given serious consideration to the possibility of seeking the After discussing it with my family and… — Seán Kelly MEP (@SeanKellyMEP) Mr Kelly said he believes Fine Gael's base would like to see a contest for its presidential nomination as they are good for parties and for democracies. Minister for Culture Patrick O'Donovan on Tuesday said he would be supporting Ms Humphreys. He said she had 'all of the qualities and attributes' needed to be president. 'There isn't a parish or a crossroads in this country that she hasn't touched in some way,' he said. Junior ministers Hildegarde Naughton and Emer Higgins, senator Manus Boyle and TDs John Clendennen and Micheal Carrigy have also said that the former minister will have their support, as have Minister of State Neale Richmond and Senator Maria Byrne. Fine Gael TD Noel McCarthy on Tuesday endorsed Mr Kelly's candidacy. The Cork East deputy said Mr Kelly had done 'marvellous work' in his time as an MEP, highlighted by him polling 125,000 first-preference votes in last year's European election. Fine Gael senator and Kerryman Michael Kennelly also said he will be supporting Mr Kelly. 'He's made a huge contribution for the people of Kerry and the people of Ireland in his role as an MEP. He's someone that has always stayed grounded, and that's a trait that the person who is going to fill the Áras will need,' Mr Kennelly said. 'He is a proud GAA man, he is a proud cultural man, he is a proud Irish speaker, he is a gem, he's been a real Kerry hero.' Fine Gael Senator Cathal Byrne said he was backing Ms Humphreys and had already sent in nomination papers for her on Tuesday morning. 'I always found her very supportive of projects across Wexford, and she's visited so many parts of Wexford as a minister, and I always found her as somebody who, on those visits, displayed enormous empathy and a great connection to people,' Mr Byrne said. Mark Duffy, a Fine Gael senator based in Mayo, said that he was also supporting Ms Humphreys. 'With her proven leadership as Minister for Rural and Community Development and her deep commitment to public service, she has the vision and experience to serve Ireland with distinction,' Mr Duffy said. Senator Joe O'Reilly also told The Irish Times that he was supporting the former minister, as did Senator Sean Kyne and James Geoghegan, the Fine Gael TD for Dublin Bay South. Mr Geoghegan said she was a candidate of 'enormous integrity, and someone who understands as well as values the importance of community.' Fine TD Alan Dillon is also backing Ms Humphreys, who he described as a 'strong, grounded leader who connects with people across all divides.' Fine Gael senator Nikki Bradley and veteran TD Frank Feighan also confirmed they will be supporting Ms Humphreys, while Minister for Enterprise Peter Burke said he is 'honoured' to nominate Ms Humphreys, adding that 'with over a decade in cabinet, she has shown real leadership, uniting communities and leaving a lasting impact nationwide.' TDs Paula Butterly, David Maxwell and John Paul O'Shea have all indicated their support for Ms Humphreys on social media, as has Senator Jerry Buttimer.
