Sydney Dural caravan-anti hate inquiry to be referred to NSW parliamentary ethics committee
Emails tendered during the second hearing of the NSW Legislative Council inquiry on Thursday reveal NSW Premier Chris Minns wrote to Legislative Assembly Speaker Greg Piper on May 15 with concerns about the inquiry's terms of reference.
Mr Minns expressed concerns that the parliamentary privilege of the Legislative Assembly, where he spoke about the caravan on March 18, might be infringed as well as the 'observance of comity' between the two houses.
Mr Minns said the state government would introduce a motion 'at the earliest available opportunity' to refer the select committee's terms of reference to the Standing Committee on Parliamentary Privilege and Ethics for inquiry.
The revelations come after leading figures behind the scenes at the Premier's office and at the Legislative Council appeared before the inquiry to give evidence, including in relation to the earliest briefings Mr Minns received from police about the caravan.
The discovery of the explosive-laden caravan at Dural in Sydney's northwest was made public after it was leaked to the media on January 29, having been found earlier on January 19 by police, who Mr Minns later said had stopped 'a potential mass casualty event'.
It wasn't until March that the Australian Federal Police, working with NSW Police, revealed that it now alleged that the caravan, which included a note referencing Sydney Great Synagogue, was instead part of an elaborate criminal con job.
That revelation came after the NSW parliament passed a suite of new anti-hate and anti-protest laws in February that outlawed most protests outside places of worship among other measures and critics claimed were rammed through.
The inquiry was subsequently set up to investigate the relationship between the caravan and the proposed laws, including what Mr Minns and Police Minister Yasmin Catley knew and when and any reference to the van in briefings for the proposed laws.
The inquiry will also examine any statements made during debate of the proposed laws by members of the executive government, as well as the provision of information to parliament and the impact of any decision to withhold or release information.
Mr Piper wrote back to Mr Minns on May 16, noting that the motion would not be heard before Thursday's inquiry and it would be 'inappropriate' for the Assembly to accede requests from the Council for the witnesses to appear at the hearing.
That was 'without the House first having the opportunity to consider any implications for exclusive cognisance and other rights and privileges of the Legislative Assembly, arising from the notice of the motion of referral' to the ethics panel.
Informed of the correspondence, Legislative Council General Counsel deputy secretary Matt Richards wrote to the inquiry's chair, independent MLC Rod Roberts, on May 19 to say that the witnesses from the government would not be attending.
'In light of the Speaker's concerns, staff of the Premier's Department and The Cabinet Office would prefer that their appearance before the Committee be postponed until after these serious issues have been resolved by the parliament,' Mr Richards said.
'Accordingly, staff of the Premier's Department and The Cabinet Office do not propose to attend the hearing on May 22, 2025.
'On behalf of these staff, I respectfully request that the Committee refrain from pressing the invitation for them to appear before the Committee until there has been time for the matters referred to in the Speaker's letter to be addressed.'
Ultimately, Premier's Department secretary Simon Draper and deputy secretary Kate Meagher and The Cabinet Office secretary Kate Boyd did appear before the committee, with Nationals MLC Wes Fang tabling the email exchange.
Of the email from Mr Richards, Ms Boyd told the inquiry: 'I don't think we were seeking not to appear.
'I think the letter makes clear that we were happy to postpone or delay our appearance pending the resolution of these serious matters between the houses, so I think that's how I would paraphrase it.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
3 minutes ago
- ABC News
Dean Winter hopeful he will become Tasmanian premier, despite stalled negotiations with the Greens
Labor leader Dean Winter is still hopeful his bid to become Tasmania's premier will be successful, despite the Greens saying they cannot support a Labor government "at this stage" due to a lack of policy compromises. A motion of no confidence in Premier Jeremy Rockliff's government, and confidence in a Labor minority government, will be moved when state parliament resumes on Tuesday, August 19. Labor won 10 seats at last month's state election, meaning it needs the support of the five Greens MPs and three other crossbenchers to be successful. Mr Winter said conversations with the crossbench MPs had been "mostly really positive", including at a meeting on Tuesday, that he claimed the Greens chose not to attend. "They had accepted to come along to the meeting and then decided instead of participating they would go out and make a media statement instead," he said. Greens leader Rosalie Woodruff said on Tuesday that Labor's lack of compromise on policy positions meant she could not support Mr Winter becoming premier "at this stage", following a second meeting in two days with the Labor leader. Mr Winter defended his bargaining position, arguing this term of state parliament needed to work differently if it was to last the full four years after three consecutive early elections. "If it's about horse trading at the start where we're giving away policy and we're asking them to compromise as well then it's not going to last very long," he said. "This is much more serious than one or two policies early, it has to be about a lasting parliament. Mr Winter has indicated he is open to discussing policy compromise once Labor has formed government — including on measures to protect the environment, which he said was "really important to me". He committed to a "policy framework" that would see ideas from all members of parliament considered in detail. Mr Winter also said all ideas to improve the state's budget position would be considered as part of the party's budget roundtable process, including ideas to generate additional revenue by increasing current taxes or imposing new ones. But he has refused to agree to the Greens' demand that he provide concessions up front. "I'd like to sit down and discuss where we can find common ground and there are areas around housing, around budget repair, around integrity where we can work together," Mr Winter said. "But what Rosalie has effectively said, she's issued an ultimatum, unless we do X, Y and Z then it's a no, and I don't think issuing ultimatums is the way to work together and no-one else on the crossbench has done the ultimatum approach either. "The conversations have been really positive with the independents and the Shooters, Fishers and Farmers, that's the kind of engagement I want to have. A Greens spokesperson said the decision to not attend Tuesday's meeting with Labor and crossbench MPs was also agreed to by Mr Winter. "It was jointly acknowledged that the conversation between Labor and the Greens had not progressed far enough," the spokesperson said. "It's hardly good faith for Mr Winter to claim otherwise. "The Greens' door is still open. We hope Labor comes back to the table to negotiate tangible outcomes for the people of Tasmania."
ABC News
3 minutes ago
- ABC News
'Sharp rise' in kids in custody in NSW, data shows 60 per cent of children in youth detention are Indigenous
The number of children in NSW detention has risen by more than 30 per cent and the number of Indigenous children in custody is "really problematic", a government agency warns. The assessment from NSW Bureau of Crime Statistics and Research (BOSCAR) executive director Jackie Fitzgerald comes just months after the state government strengthened bail laws for minors. According to data from BOSCAR, the state now houses 234 children in detention centres across NSW. In the past two years data showed the number of juveniles in state detention has risen by 34 per cent, Ms Fitzgerald told the ABC. "Aboriginal children make up 60 per cent of the youth detention population now. That's a considerable increase, its amongst the highest number we've ever seen. "And we can see that the increase is really considerable — 36 per cent over the past two years for Aboriginal young people." Three out of four children on remand in the state are being held in custody after being denied bail, according to BOSCAR. Ms Fitzgerald said the system for juveniles had now become "a space for young people waiting for court as opposed to a sanction for an offence". "Were moving in the wrong direction absolutely for that, and quite considerably off track to meet that [closing the gap] target now," she said. Redfern Legal Centre chief executive officer Camilla Pandolfini said new bail laws introduced in NSW last year, and renewed this year, have made it harder for children to remain in the community while facing criminal charges. "I'm shocked, it's a shocking statistic," she said. "All of us should be concerned. Especially when the Australian government and the NSW government have committed to closing the gap. The NSW government extended strict bail laws for young offenders accused of repeat car thefts and home invasions in March this year. At the time, it claimed the change was "crucial to reduce youth crime and minimise young people's long-term contact with the justice system". The changes restricted bail for minors between 14 and 18 if they are charged with car theft or break and enter if they were already on bail for similar offences at the time. It was originally introduced in April 2024, in conjunction with a $26 million community safety package for youth outreach programs. "We can see this law is working and that's why we've extended it — to make sure we break the cycle of youth offending and strengthen community safety," Attorney General Michael Daley said at the time.
News.com.au
3 minutes ago
- News.com.au
Body of man, 43, found river in outback Queensland
A man has been found dead in a river in outback Queensland, with police now trying to piece together the days before his death. A man's body has been found in a river in outback Queensland. The 43-year-old was found unresponsive in the Nicholson River near Doomadgee at about 1.15pm on Sunday. He was soon declared dead. A Queensland Police Service spokesman said the man was last seen in Doomadgee five days before his body was located. 'Police are urging anyone with information or anyone who saw the man between August 5 and 10 to contact the Doomadgee Police Station on 4742 9090 or call Crime Stoppers,' police have said. Doomadgee is about 2180km northwest of Brisbane, and is located 140km the Northern Territory border. It is mostly an Aboriginal community with an estimated population of 1380 people.
