
Zohran Mamdani cannot be boxed in
Although the journalistic ethics of the article were widely questioned, it was immediately picked up by opponents in an attempt to discredit Mamdani.
Did Mamdani really try to 'exploit' an African American identity to get into college, as opponents have claimed?
It's worth noting that the two boxes he checked did not assist him to get into Columbia, where his father, Professor Mahmood Mamdani, is teaching African studies.
Was he wrong to tick the 'African American' box?
There are several issues that should be brought up when considering the answer to this question.
First, Mamdani was born in Uganda to a Ugandan father of Asian origin and an Indian American mother. He lived in Africa for seven years before moving to the United States. He had only a Ugandan passport until he was naturalised as a US citizen in 2018.
On the Columbia University application form, like with many US universities, there is a section for voluntary self-identification of race and ethnicity. It asks if you are Hispanic or Latino (regardless of race) and then lists five other options to select one's 'race': 'American Indian or Alaskan Native', 'Asian', 'Black or African American', 'Native Hawaiian or Other Pacific Islander' or 'white'. There is a further section for 'additional optional information'.
These categories are arbitrary and reductionist and cannot capture the full complexity of identity that many people around the world have, including Mamdani and myself.
As a British Zambian of Asian origin whose family have lived in Zambia for three generations, I feel anxiety and frustration when having to select ethnicity checkboxes. I am regularly interrogated about my identity, which cannot be squeezed into one box on a form, or even two or three.
As Mamdani himself told The New York Times: 'Most college applications don't have a box for Indian Ugandans, so I checked multiple boxes trying to capture the fullness of my background.' He also explained that he wrote 'Ugandan' in the application, which allowed students to provide 'more specific information where relevant'.
The second issue we need to keep in mind is that the history of Asian Africans – and how we fit into African societies – is complex. Between the 1860s and 1890s, the British Empire brought thousands of indentured labourers from its colony in the subcontinent to its colonies in Southern and East Africa.
In the following decades, many other South Asians followed as merchants. And then, as the British partitioned the subcontinent along religious lines in the 1940s, thousands more fled the impending chaos to Africa.
Once on the continent, the Asian population largely occupied a kind of middle position in which they were both victims and agents of colonial racism. In East Africa, many functioned as a subordinate ruling class, employed by the colonial police and administrators as part of a divide-and-rule strategy. In many countries, Asians enjoyed success in business during the colonial period and gained significant control of the economy.
This, alongside a lack of integration, contributed to widespread anti-Asian sentiment in East Africa, seen most prominently by the expulsion of Ugandan Asians by Idi Amin in 1972.
In apartheid South Africa, people of Indian descent, the majority of whom were descendants of indentured labourers forcibly transferred by the British, were also subjected to discrimination. Prominent members of the community, such as Ahmed Kathrada, who was jailed for life in 1964 along with Nelson Mandela, played a key role in the anti-apartheid struggle.
Today, younger generations are still grappling with these complex identities and histories, including Mamdani himself. In his twenties, he was part of a rap duo – Young Cardamon & HAB – with a Ugandan of Nubian descent. They rapped in six languages, including Luganda, Hindi and Nubi, and confronted social issues such as racism and inclusion.
As a mayoral candidate of one of the most diverse cities in the world, Mamdani has much to do to address persistent anti-Blackness among Asian communities. Many Asian Africans, and other Asian communities, have internalised the white supremacy of the colonial era and the belief that being closer to whiteness offers more opportunities and privilege.
Mamdani's mother, Mira Nair, is the filmmaker behind Mississippi Masala, one of the first films to address this issue more than 30 years ago, with its rare depiction of an interracial relationship between a Black man and Asian African woman in the US. Her son credits this film for his existence: His mother met his father in Uganda at Makerere University while she was conducting research for the film.
The third issue that needs to be considered is that this hacked information seems aimed at discrediting Mamdani, who secured fewer votes in Black neighbourhoods during the mayoral Democratic primary election.
Pitting communities of colour against each other is a classic divide-and-rule tactic and a cornerstone of colonialism used to fracture alliances and weaken resistance. Its remnants can still be seen today in my country, Zambia, in areas that were historically segregated on the basis of colour.
Opponents attempting to frame Mamdani as a mayor solely for South Asians – or worse, playing into and exacerbating Islamophobic sentiment – are weaponising identity to sow division and fear. Such attempts must be resisted, especially now, when the US and much of the world are facing growing authoritarianism, xenophobia and inequality.
New York City is one of the places where I have some feeling of belonging; it thrives and shines in part due to its diversity and the fusion of so many cultures.
In a city made up of countless stories and backgrounds, perhaps having a mayor who understands what it means to navigate multiple identities, and to live at the crossroads of belonging, might offer the kind of perspective that does not weaken leadership, but strengthens it.
The story of New York has always been about reinvention. Whoever becomes mayor has the chance, and the responsibility, to redefine what progress means in one of the most diverse but unequal cities in the country. Whatever happens next, pitting communities of colour against each other serves no one.
The views expressed in this article are the author's own and do not necessarily reflect Al Jazeera's editorial stance.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Qatar Tribune
a day ago
- Qatar Tribune
Spanish black olive exporters face more hurdles with new US tariffs
Agencies Spanish black olive exporters, already subject to harsh tariffs since U.S. President Donald Trump's first term, are warning it will be difficult to survive an extra 15% they now face after the European Union reached a trade deal with the U.S. EU goods now face import tariffs of 15% – half of Trump's threatened rate, but much more than Europeans had hoped for – after striking a trade deal with Trump on Sunday. Spain, the world's top table olive exporter, has seen its share of the U.S. black olive market plummet from 49% in 2017 to 19% in 2024 after Trump imposed tariffs of more than 30% at the request of Californian olive growers. The measures only affected black olives and don't apply to green olives, olive oil or semi-processed farmers have taken steps to increase green olive sales and to diversify their markets since the tariffs were first imposed, but warn that the additional increase will be hard to swallow. 'It would be unviable (for black table olives),' said Eduardo Martin, secretary of Asaja, a Spanish local farmers' association in southern Seville province, a region that produces the most olives. The initial trade measures coincided with a severe drought that forced Spanish producers to cut around 400,000 work shifts for pickers out of a total of 2.5 million, according to industry estimates. Sales of Spanish black olives to the U.S. dropped by 70% in the first year.'The worst was the first year,' said Gabriel Cabello, president of Andalusia's Federation of Agricultural Cooperatives in Seville province. 'In the second year, we learned that this was here to stay and that we had to do things differently.' To mitigate losses, Spanish exporters shifted focus to Europe and the Middle East, regions with a tradition of consuming table olives. They also ventured into Asian markets, while switching to shipping more green olives to the U.S. because they are subject to lower tariffs. Tariffs also spurred innovation, with some Spanish exporters selling black olives stuffed with salmon or cheese for the first time, which helped boost sales in Europe and Asia, Cabello said. Still, the Spanish Ministry of Agriculture estimates it has lost 239.6 million euros ($278.51 million) in black olive sales since the tariffs were introduced, nearly a third of the 707 million euro total export value from the last harvest. Among the 25 Spanish exporters active before the tariffs, only four major players remain, according to Asemesa, Spain's Association of Table Olive Sevilla, one of the larger players with the financial resources to lobby the U.S. for lower rates, expanded green olive exports and successfully reduced black olive tariffs to 10% from 31%. The company successfully demonstrated that it received fewer European subsidies than the U.S. had estimated. Its U.S. sales have been gradually growing since 2023. 'We cannot give up on the world's largest consumer market for black olives,' said Agro Sevilla CEO Julio Roda. In a twist, Aceitunas Guadalquivir, another major Spanish olive producer, acquired Bell-Carter Foods, one of the two leading U.S. companies that had advocated for the tariffs, according to a statement issued in 2022. The company is among several Californian companies that have imported raw olives from Spain, which are exempt from the tariffs, according to Asemesa. Aceitunas Guadalquivir did not reply to a Reuters request for comment about such exports. 'When California has low production, they import raw olives to finish processing them in the U.S., mostly from Spain,' said Asemesa's Secretary General Antonio de Mora. Spain exported 6,300 tons of semi-processed olives in 2024 alongside 36,000 tons of green olives and 9,800 tons of black olives.


Al Jazeera
a day ago
- Al Jazeera
Trump administration moves to nix key finding on greenhouse gas emissions
The United States Environmental Protection Agency (EPA) has announced it plans to revoke a scientific finding on climate change that has served as the basis for key environmental and pollution regulations. In an interview on Tuesday, Lee Zeldin, President Donald Trump's pick to head the EPA, said that the agency would nix the 2009 'endangerment finding' that links emissions from motor vehicles to climate change and negative health impacts. Zeldin added that those who seek to reduce carbon emissions only highlight the negative effects. 'With regard to the endangerment finding, they'll say carbon dioxide is a pollutant and that's the end of it. They'll never acknowledge any type of benefit or need for carbon dioxide,' Zeldin told a right-wing podcast, Ruthless. 'It's important to note, and they don't, how important it is for the planet.' The 'endangerment finding' has been central to the justifications for regulating greenhouse gas emissions, including through vehicle emissions standards. The finding, issued under Democratic President Barack Obama, has become a frequent target of conservative lawmakers and fossil fuel companies, which have sought its repeal. Nevertheless, the 'endangerment finding' has withstood several legal challenges in court. Its revocation would be a continuation of the Trump administration's push to roll back environmental protections and slash regulations in the name of boosting the economy. The news agency Reuters reported last week that the EPA is also planning to scrap all greenhouse gas emissions standards on light-duty, medium-duty and heavy-duty vehicles. In Tuesday's interview, Zeldin likewise positioned the repeal of the 'endangerment finding' as a boon to business. 'There are people who, in the name of climate change, are willing to bankrupt the country,' Zeldin said. 'They created this endangerment finding and then they are able to put all these regulations on vehicles, on airplanes, on stationary sources, to basically regulate out of existence, in many cases, a lot of segments of our economy.' Zeldin also touted the finding's revocation as the 'largest deregulatory action' in US history — and a potentially fatal blow to efforts to curb climate change. 'This has been referred to as basically driving a dagger into the heart of the climate change religion,' Zeldin said. A 2021 study from Harvard University's TH Chan School of Public Health found that a decrease in vehicle emissions helped bring the number of yearly deaths attributed to air pollution down from 27,700 in 2008 to 19,800 in 2017. The researchers credited that decline to a combination of federal regulations and technological improvements. They also noted that, if emissions had remained at the 2008 levels, the number of deaths would have instead risen to 48,200 by 2017. Supporters consider air pollution regulations to be a vital part of the effort to slow climate change and minimise adverse health effects. Trump, however, has defied scientific consensus on climate change and referred to it as a 'hoax'. Instead, he has pushed for the US to ramp up fossil fuel production, considered the primary contributor to climate change. Earlier this month, his energy secretary, Chris Wright, wrote a column for The Economist magazine arguing that climate change is 'not an existential crisis' but a 'byproduct of progress'. 'I am willing to take the modest negative trade-off for this legacy of human advancement,' Wright wrote. The United Nations has estimated that, between 2030 and 2050, climate change would contribute to 250,000 additional deaths per year, from issues related to tropical diseases like malaria, heat stress and food security.


Qatar Tribune
4 days ago
- Qatar Tribune
Al Khulaifi meets under secretary of State for Africa at UK Foreign Office
Minister of State at the Ministry of Foreign Affairs HE Dr Mohammed bin Abdulaziz bin Saleh Al Khulaifi met on Friday with Parliamentary Under Secretary of State for Africa at the UK Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office, HE Lord Collins of Highbury. During the meeting, they reviewed cooperation relations between the two countries and means to support and enhance them. They also discussed the latest regional and international developments, particularly in the African continent.