'They helped keep the lights on': 22 states sue New York for its Big Oil-financed climate fund
22 US states filed a lawsuit on Thursday contending that the new law is unconstitutional.
While the complainants say this could lead America into an energy crisis, New York spokesperson argue it will help the state's climate resilience plans - and the entire nation to transition away from fossil fuels.
The climate fund is to make fossil fuels company pay for historic GHG emissions
New York state developed a Climate Change Superfund Act, which requires payments of $75 billion (€72 bn) for damage allegedly done by energy companies from 2000 to 2018.
The new law requires major fossil fuel companies to pay into the damages fund over the next 25 years, based on their historic greenhouse gas emissions.
However West Virginia Attorney General JB McCuskey is leading a coalition of 22 states against the fund.
The lawsuit says the state law is 'an ugly example of the chaos that can result when States overreach' and highlights that coal, oil, and natural gas were once fundamental to New York.
"They helped keep the lights on in Albany, manufacture the steel that supported New York City's iconic skyscrapers, and fuel the industry that keeps New York ports humming,' the lawsuit further says.
McCuskey said in statement that he was "proud" to lead the coalition it what he alleges is an "unconstitutional" law.
"This lawsuit is to ensure that these misguided policies, being forced from one state onto the entire nation, will not lead America into the doldrums of an energy crisis, allowing China, India and Russia to overtake our energy independence,' McCuskey said.
"If we allow New York to get away with this, it will only be a matter of time before other states follow suit – wrecking our nation's power grid.'
The other named states are Alabama, Arkansas, Georgia, Idaho, Iowa, Kansas, Kentucky, Louisiana, Mississippi, Missouri, Montana, Nebraska, North Dakota, Ohio, Oklahoma, South Carolina, South Dakota, Tennessee, Texas, Utah, and Wyoming.
The New York law could set an example in other states to "defeat Big Oil"
The lawsuit accuses New York state of trying to force energy producers and consumers in other states 'to subsidise certain New York-based ' infrastructure ' projects, such as a new sewer system in New York City.'
The current sewage system is described by experts as "archaic" and not fit to cope with increasing climate-related storm surges and extreme rainfall.
Last September, state highways and one of the subway lines flooded when the remnants of storm Ophelia blew through the city, according to Inside Climate News.
The state that put forward the law believes that the environmental fund is an important part of its climate resilience and energy transition and is prepared to fight.
In 2021, New York City launched the largest urban climate resiliency project in America. Experts fear that rising sea levels by 2050 could put some of New York underwater, particularly the island of Manhattan.
'We look forward to defending this landmark legislation in court and defeating Big Oil once again,' Paul DeMichele, a spokesperson for Democratic New York governor, Kathy Hochul's office, says.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Euronews
a day ago
- Euronews
Fact checking Fox News claims on crime rates and migration in Ireland
A segment that aired on conservative US news channel Fox News in early August has sparked a controversial debate in Ireland, leading the country's former Prime Minister Leo Varadkar to post on X, directing his followers to a thread fact-checking the broadcaster's claims. In the TV piece, Fox News alleged that Dublin has gone from being one of the safest cities in Europe in 2003 to one of the most dangerous in 2024. To support this claim, Fox News showed a screenshot of an article published in 2024 by the Irish newspaper Sunday World titled "Dublin ranks among the top ten most dangerous major cities in Europe, survey claims." However, when investigating the claim, EuroVerify found that the article uses data sourced from a survey carried out by online betting platform the OLBG (Online Betting Guide). "The main reason why this research was conducted was to reveal the best cities in Europe for nightlife, and as part of the study, safety scores for each city were analysed", a spokesperson for the OLBG told EuroVerify. The reliability of the survey is questionable given that OLBG sourced its data from Numbeo, a platform which relies on crowd-sourced data and warns there is no "assurance that any statement on the website is correct or precise." Meanwhile, the Global Peace Index, which is produced by the Australian-based NGO, the Institute for Economics & Peace, has consistently ranked Ireland as one of the safest countries in the world, placing it in second position in 2025. Rising crime in Ireland During the piece, the channel aired two graphs side by side on screen — on the left one showing rising immigration in Ireland, while the one on the right displayed figures for rising crime — in turn implying that there is a causal link between migration and crime. Contacted by EuroVerify, Ireland's Department of Justice said that it was not "aware of any credible evidence that would suggest a causal link between immigration and crime in Ireland." "Over the past 10 years there has been a large increase in the numbers of non-Irish people employed in Ireland. They bring essential skills and experience that are much needed in the current labour market. There has been no corresponding change in crime levels over this period," the spokesperson added. Ireland experienced unprecedented levels of immigration in the year leading up to April 2024, with a population increase of 98,700, which amounts to positive net migration of 79,300, meaning that more people have been arriving in Ireland, than those leaving. Fox News also stated that robberies had increased by 18% and violent crime by 10%. However, these selected crime and robbery statistics are misleading because the country's statistics office does not classify crimes under the broad labels of "robbery" and "violent crime." More specifically, the 18% figure cited by Fox News appears to refer to an increase in "robbery, Extortion & Hijacking" from the first quarter of 2023 to the first quarter of 2024, while the 10% figures refer to an increase in crime incidents involving "weapons and explosives offences." What the segment fails to mention is that other crimes decreased between the first quarter of 2023 and the same period of 2024, with homicide and sexual offences dropping by 8% and 12% respectively. How disinformation is fuelling hate crimes in Ireland Over the course of the summer, a spate of brutal attacks predominantly targeting South Asian migrants occurred in Ireland. "A series of highly publicised, very violent attacks targeting members of Ireland's Indian community have spread fear. A lot of the attacks were initiated by misinformation and disinformation, for instance through lies spread about crime", Teresa Buczkowska, the CEO of Immigrant Council of Ireland told Euronews. On 19 July, an Indian man was attacked by a group of men in southwest Dublin, who beat him and accused him of inappropriate behaviour with children. While Irish authorities stated that the allegations against him were unfounded, footage of the aftermath of the attack spread online according to Irish broadcast RTE, leading the footage to gain traction as anti-immigration accounts reshared it. This led the country's Indian embassy to issue a safety warning to its citizens following what it qualified as "an increase in the instances of physical attacks reported against Indian citizens in Ireland recently." "Everything changed after the Dublin riot in 2023, when we saw a huge level of violence erupting in Dublin city centre against migrants and that really kind of was the starting point for the physical violence we are seeing today", said Buczkowska. "The shifting narrative we are hearing in politics and false allegations that migrants are raising crime rates are leaking into everyday conversations and opinions, which is a worrying trend", added Buczkowska.
Euronews
a day ago
- Euronews
Fact checking Fox News about crime rates and migration in Ireland
A segment that aired on right-wing American channel Fox News in early August has sparked a controversial debate in Ireland, leading the country's former Prime Minister Leo Varadkar to post on X, directing his followers to a thread fact-checking the broadcaster's claims. In the TV piece, Fox alleged that Dublin has gone from being one of the safest cities in Europe in 2003, to one of the most dangerous in 2024. To support this claim, Fox showed a screenshot of an article published in 2024 by the Irish newspaper Sunday World titled "Dublin ranks among the top ten most dangerous major cities in Europe, survey claims." However, when investigating the claim, EuroVerify found that the article uses data sourced from a survey carried out by online betting platform the OLBG (Online Betting Guide). "The main reason why this research was conducted was to reveal the best cities in Europe for nightlife, and as part of the study, safety scores for each city were analysed", a spokesperson for the OLBG told EuroVerify. The reliability of the survey is questionable given that OLBG sourced its data from Numbeo, a platform which relies on crowd-sourced data and warns there is no "assurance that any statement on the website is correct or precise." Meanwhile, the Global Peace Index, which is produced by the Australian-based NGO, the Institute for Economics & Peace, has consistently ranked Ireland as one of the safest countries in the world, placing it in second position in 2025. Rising crime in Ireland During the piece, the channel aired two graphs side by side on screen — on the left one showing rising immigration in Ireland, while the one on the right displayed figures for rising crime — in turn implying that there is a causal link between migration and crime. Contacted by EuroVerify, Ireland's Department of Justice said that it was not "aware of any credible evidence that would suggest a causal link between immigration and crime in Ireland." "Over the past 10 years there has been a large increase in the numbers of non-Irish people employed in Ireland. They bring essential skills and experience that are much needed in the current labour market. There has been no corresponding change in crime levels over this period," the spokesperson added. Ireland experienced unprecedented levels of immigration in the year leading up to April 2024, with a population increase of 98,700, which amounts to positive net migration of 79,300, meaning that more people have been arriving in Ireland, than those leaving. Fox News also stated that robberies had increased by 18% and violent crime by 10%. However, these selected crime and robbery statistics are misleading because the country's statistics office does not classify crimes under the broad labels of "robbery" and "violent crime." More specifically, the 18% figure cited by Fox appears to refer to an increase in "robbery, Extortion & Hijacking" from the first quarter of 2023 to the first quarter of 2024, while the 10% figures refer to an increase in crime incidents involving "weapons and explosives offences." What the segment fails to mention is that other crimes decreased between the first quarter of 2023 and the same period of 2024, with homicide and sexual offences dropping by 8% and 12% respectively. How disinformation is fuelling hate crimes in Ireland Over the course of the summer, a spate of brutal attacks predominantly targeting South Asian migrants occurred in Ireland. "A series of highly publicised, very violent attacks targeting members of Ireland's Indian community have spread fear. A lot of the attacks were initiated by misinformation and disinformation, for instance through lies spread about crime", Teresa Buczkowsa, the CEO of Immigrant Council of Ireland told Euronews. On 19 July, an Indian man was attacked by a group of men in southwest Dublin, who beat him and accused the man of inappropriate behaviour with children. While Irish authorities stated that the allegations against him were unfounded, footage of the aftermath of the attack spread online according to Irish broadcast RTE, leading the footage to gain traction as anti-immigration accounts reshared it. This led the country's Indian embassy to issue a safety warning to its citizens following what it qualified as "an increase in the instances of physical attacks reported against Indian citizens in Ireland recently." "Everything changed after the Dublin riot in 2023, when we saw a huge level of violence erupting in Dublin city centre against migrants and that really kind of was the starting point for the physical violence we are seeing today", said Buczkowsa. "The shifting narrative we are hearing in politics and false allegations that migrants are raising crime rates are leaking into everyday conversations and opinions, which is a worrying trend", added Buczkowsa.
France 24
2 days ago
- France 24
US denounces Europe on speech in pared-down rights report
The State Department's congressionally required report historically has offered extensive accounts of all nations' records, documenting in dispassionate detail issues from unjust detention to extrajudicial killing to personal freedoms. For the first report under Secretary of State Marco Rubio, the State Department trimmed sections and took particular aim at countries that have been in the crosshairs of Trump, including Brazil and South Africa. On China, which the United States across administrations has identified as a top adversary, the State Department report said that "genocide" was ongoing against the mostly Muslim Uyghur people, whose plight Rubio took up as a senator. But the report also took striking aim at some of the closest allies of the United States, saying that human rights had worsened in Britain, France and Germany due to regulations on online hate speech. In Britain, following the stabbing deaths of three young girls, authorities took action against internet users who falsely alleged that a migrant was responsible and urged revenge. The State Department report described the British efforts as officials having "repeatedly intervened to chill speech" and said that the close US ally had experienced "credible reports of serious restrictions on freedom of expression." The criticism comes despite Rubio moving aggressively in the United States to deny or strip visas of foreign nationals over their statements and social media postings, especially student activists who have criticized Israel. Trump is an avid social media user who frequently berates opponents in personal tones. His administration has repeatedly taken on Europe over restrictions on social media platforms, many of which are US-based. In February, Vice President JD Vance used a visit to Germany to champion the far-right AfD party after the country's spy agency called it extremist. Brazil denounced but not El Salvador The report also said that rights deteriorated in 2024 in Brazil, where Trump has pressed against prosecution of former president Jair Bolsonaro, his ally accused of a coup attempt with echoes of the January 6, 2021 riot at the US Capitol by Trump's supporters. Brazil, the report said, has "undermined democratic debate by restricting access to online content deemed to 'undermine democracy,' the report said. The State Department said that rights "significantly worsened" in South Africa, where Trump has embraced the cause of the white minority. The report accused the post-apartheid government of taking "substantially worrying steps towards land expropriation" of Afrikaners and other minorities. By contrast, the State Department said there were "no credible reports of significant human rights abuses" in El Salvador and noted a "historic low" in crime. President Nayib Bukele has unleashed a sweeping crackdown on crime in which rights groups say many innocent people have wound up in detention. Bukele took in migrants sent from the United States in Trump's mass deportation drive, some of whom have since reported mistreatment during nearly round-the-clock confinement in a maximum-security prison, which took place after the time covered by the report. Kilmar Armando Abrego Garcia, who the Trump administration admits was wrongly deported, filed a lawsuit alleging severe beatings, sleep deprivation and inadequate nutrition in El Salvador's CECOT prison. The latest report trimmed down its section on Israel, the West Bank and Gaza. It acknowledged cases of arbitrary arrests and killings by Israel but said that authorities took "credible steps" to identify officials responsible. In a letter earlier this year, Democratic senators led by Jeanne Shaheen, the top Democrat on the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, voiced alarm over changes to the report that they said damaged US credibility. "When the United States conveniently wields human rights principles as a political cudgel against our adversaries, but does not apply those same standards to our allies, countries like China and Russia are quick to point out such hypocrisy, and American influence on the world stage drops precipitously," they wrote.
