Israel-Iran conflict highlights dollar's tarnished safe-haven appeal
ORLANDO, Florida, June 16 (Reuters) - A dramatic spike in the potential for all-out war between Israel and Iran would typically be expected to spark an immediate and strong rally in the U.S. dollar, with investors seeking the safety and liquidity of the world's reserve currency.
That didn't happen on Friday.
The dollar's response to Israel's strikes on Iranian nuclear facilities and military commanders, followed by Tehran's initial threats and retaliation, was pretty feeble. The dollar index, a measure of the currency's value against a basket of major peers, ended the day up only around 0.25%.
To be sure, the dollar fared better than U.S. stocks or Treasuries, which both fell sharply on Friday. But with oil surging over 7% and gold up a solid 1.5%, a strong 'flight to quality' flow would have lifted the dollar more than a quarter of one percent.
The U.S. currency's move was particularly weak given the dollar's starting point on Friday. It was at a three-and-a-half year low, having depreciated 10% year to date, with sentiment and positioning heavily bearish. Yet a significant geopolitical shock generated barely a knee-jerk bounce.
For comparison, the dollar rose more than 2% in both the first week of the 2006 Israel-Lebanon War and in the week following Israel's invasion of Southern Lebanon last year.
The dollar's weak response to this latest Middle East conflict supports the narrative that investors are now reassessing their high exposure to dollars, in light of some of the unorthodox policies put forward by U.S. President Donald Trump in recent months.
The dollar was down slightly early on Monday, and gold and oil were giving back some of Friday's gains too, as markets regained a foothold at the start of a busy week packed with key central bank meetings.
The dollar has historically been one of the best hedges against short-term volatility sparked by geopolitical risk, behind gold and on a par with oil, according to research published last year by Joe Seydl, senior markets economist at JP Morgan Private Bank.
Indeed, a Journal of Monetary Economics paper from last year stated plainly, "The dollar is a safe-haven currency and appreciates when global risk goes up," a trend resulting from the "fundamental asymmetry in a global financial system centered around the dollar" built up over the course of several decades.
That latter part of that argument hasn't changed.
The dollar accounts for almost 60% of the world's $12 trillion FX reserves, with its nearest rival, the euro, accounting for around 20%. Almost two-thirds of global debt is denominated in dollars, and nearly 90% of all FX transactions around the world has the greenback on one side of the trade.
That means traders, financial institutions, businesses, consumers and governments still need to be more exposed to dollars than any other currency, even if they question the direction of current U.S. policy.
However, the dollar's downside 'structural' risks are growing, analysts at Westpac noted on Sunday, as concern over Washington's fiscal health and policy uncertainty erode the dollar's 'safe-haven identity'. Investors are now looking to hedge their large dollar exposure more than ever.
If this dampens their instinctive demand for dollars in periods of sudden geopolitical tension, uncertainty and volatility, then the so-called 'dollar smile' theory could be challenged.
This 'smile' is the idea that the dollar appreciates in periods of financial market stress as well as in 'risk on' periods of strong global growth and investor optimism, but sags in between. This idea was first outlined over 20 years ago by then currency analyst and now hedge fund manager Stephen Jen.
If the Israel-Iran conflict continues to escalate, that dollar smile could get rather lopsided.
(The opinions expressed here are those of the author, a columnist for Reuters)
Enjoying this column? Check out Reuters Open Interest (ROI), your essential new source for global financial commentary. ROI delivers thought-provoking, data-driven analysis. Markets are moving faster than ever. ROI can help you keep up. Follow ROI on LinkedIn and X.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
40 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE Experts reveal biggest challenge to Trump's Canada-funded $175B 'Golden Dome' defense dream
When President Donald Trump first rolled out his plan for a new 'Golden Dome' to 'protect our homeland' he described it as a space age shield against growing threats. 'Ronald Reagan wanted it many years ago, but they didn't have the technology,' Trump said at the time, invoking Reagan's 'Strategic Defense Initiative or ' Star Wars ' missile defense system. He even told Canada the tab would be $61 billion if they wanted in on the project. Now, as Trump shuttles through meetings with G7 partners including Canada, some defense experts are questioning the origins of the plan and whether it can provide the security Trump claims. 'Trump thinks its cool. That's what's driving it,' Justin Logan, Director of Defense and Foreign Policy Studies at the libertarian Cato Institute told the Daily Mail. 'To me, the whole thing was undercooked,' he said. The idea, at a time when global powers like China and Russia are developing hypersonic missiles while 'rogue' states refine their own missile programs, is to use a network of space satellites and ground-based sensors to identify and blow up incoming threats to the U.S. It's a concept with considerable appeal at a time when Iran is lobbing missiles at Israel in response to a bombing campaign targeting their nuclear facilities and military leaders. But key elements of the satellite role are already coming into question, following a report that SpaceX head Elon Musk's role is now in doubt. Amid Trump's epic feud with the world's richest man, planners are now looking at a 'new framework' which would scrap the need for Musk's network of orbiting satellites. Instead the plan would be to focus on 'existing ground systems for missile defense instead,' according to one report. Musk's company had been expected to play a vital role in launching space sensors and even armed satellites that could play a role in defense. 'The Trump Administration is committed to a rigorous review process for all bids and contracts, prioritizing the best deal for America and leveraging the most advanced and innovative technology. Decisions will be made at the appropriate time, based on thorough evaluation, and will not be previewed in the press,' White House principal deputy press secretary Harrison Fields told the Daily Mail amid the uncertainty. There is already $25 billion for Golden Dome in the House tax reconciliation bill, but if Trump's 'big, beautiful' bill fails in the Senate, the program couldn't get off the ground. Sen. Rand Paul (R-Ky.) is already demanding more spending cuts, as Trump seeks to win his vote. It could be a heavy lift to really get the Canadians on board for paying for it. A new poll shows more than 60 percent of Canadians are against the idea. Canada's ambassador to the UN compared Trump's call for Canadian funding to a 'protection racket.' Trump had posted: 'I told Canada, which very much wants to be part of our fabulous Golden Dome System, that it will cost $61 Billion Dollars if they remain a separate, but unequal, Nation, but will cost ZERO DOLLARS if they become our cherished 51st State. They are considering the offer!' Trump posted. 'In another context, this would (be) called a 'protection racket,' Rae said. Comparison to Isreal's 'Iron Dome' are proving inexact. Wrote Paul Meyer, an professor of international studies at Simon Fraser University in British Columbia: 'The President seems to have failed to grasp that Israel's 'Iron Dome' system (which inspired his vision) has succeeded as a result of the relatively small size of its territory that has to be defended and the relatively slow re-entry speed of the short and medium range ballistic missiles it has countered. 'These advantages would not pertain to the territory of the US (let alone North America) against intercontinental ballistic missiles (ICBMs) with re-entry speeds of 7 kilometres a second.' Joe Cirincione of the Center for International Policy called national missile defense 'the longest-running scam in the history of the Department of Defense.' And even that system is experiencing occasional 'leakage,' with comparatively slow and easier-to-track Iranian missiles breaking through defenses to cause civilian deaths. 'The idea that you're going to model something on Iron Dome that's going to protect the us from Russia and China is just not a thing,' said Logan. 'In this case, it was like, Israel has Iron Dome. It's kind of cool. We should do the Golden Dome. And then a lot of people rush to fill the gaps without specifying what 'Golden Dome' was,' he said. There are also questions about how it might alter Cold War calculations on deterrence. If foreign adversaries conclude the Americans think they are protected, it could put the US in a more aggressive posture – which could in turn motivate foreign adversaries to strike first before it is too late. In what could be a telling sign, a senior administration official sketching out priorities for the G7 summit that gets underway Monday in Kananaskis mentioned trade, minerals, migration, drugs, wildfires, international security, AI, and energy.'
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
Kevin Durant's tenure in Phoenix looks finished as Suns 'make major trade decision' on future Hall of Famer
Kevin Durant may want to play in South Florida or Texas next season, but that doesn't matter much in Arizona 's Salt River valley. As previously reported by ESPN's Shams Charania, the Phoenix Suns star wants to be traded to the Miami Heat, San Antonio Spurs or Houston Rockets this summer. However, on Monday, NBA insider Jake Fischer reported on Marc Stein's Substack page the Suns will seek the best trade they can find for Durant and not necessarily a move to one of his preferred destinations. Daily Mail has reached out to Suns spokespeople and Durant's agent Rich Kleiman for comment. This would open up considerably more possibilities for Durant, who is eyeing a move to a potential fifth franchise for a chance at a third NBA title at age 36. He remained effective in 2024-25 despite his advancing age by ranking seventh in scoring at 26.6 points a game thanks to 43-percent accuracy from beyond the arc – better than all but 10 players in 2024-25. Although it's unclear who the Suns are speaking with about Durant, The Athletic's Kelly Iko reported earlier this month that Phoenix has gradually reduced its asking price for the Olympic gold medalist. Durant was the crown jewel of the team makeover after owner Mat Ishbia bought the Suns in 2022. The former Texas Longhorns star did not come cheaply, however, as Phoenix surrendered four unprotected first-round picks and a future pick swap as well as Mikal Bridges and Cameron Johnson to the Brooklyn Nets in the deal. At the time, then-ESPN NBA insider Adrian Wojnarowski reported the trade was Ishbia's idea, writing it was 'very much on the ownership level' between the Suns boss and Nets governor Joe Tsai. Ishbia pushed back on that reporting soon after, saying the decision was unanimous. 'It wasn't a tough decision,' he told reporters in Phoenix. 'We really didn't want to give up some of the guys, because we love those guys. They were winners and we didn't want to give them up. 'But at the end of the day the right decision was, what do we do to maximize our team for today and for the next three to four years? This is going to be what the Phoenix Suns are about.' The Suns would go on to add high-scoring Washington Wizards guard Bradley Beal to a core that already included Devin Booker, while Ishbia reiterated his desire to keep Durant in Phoenix. Ishbia shot down any trade speculation in 2024 when the Rockets were reportedly interested. 'Everyone talking about the drama and storylines, some are right and some are just wrong,' Ishbia wrote on social media. 'My turn. Phoenix loves Kevin Durant and Kevin Durant loves Phoenix, and we are competing for a championship this year because we have the team to do it.' The billionaire even told reporters in November he expected to sign Durant to a contract extension. Then the Suns fell off the map, missing the playoffs at 36-46 as Durant, Booker and Beal once again struggled to gel under coach Mike Budenholzer, who was fired after the season. Ishbia owned up to the debacle with reporters after the season finale. 'Embarrassing season, right?' Ishbia said. 'Disappointing. Awful. I watch every game like all you guys do and no one's proud of it, no one's happy with it, from me, to the front office, to the coaches and players, to the marketing executives to the security guards. 'It was a failure.' If Ishbia did have one success in 2024-25, it was his popular decision to reduce concessions prices with a new $2 menu. Although they don't currently have their own first-round pick, the Suns do have the 29th selection in this month's NBA Draft. As for the head-coach vacancy, the Suns have brought in Jordan Ott, whom Ishbia said 'embodies the culture of excellence and accountability we're going to prioritize.' Ott had worked under 2025 NBA Coach of the Year Kenny Atkinson in Cleveland after the two previously worked together in Brooklyn
The Independent
an hour ago
- The Independent
Airports close across the Mideast as the Israel-Iran conflict shutters the region's airspace
After Israeli strikes landed near the hotel where he was staying in the Iranian province of Qom, Aimal Hussein desperately wanted to return home. But the 55-year-old Afghan businessman couldn't find a way, with Iranian airspace completely shut down. He fled to Tehran after the strike Sunday, but no taxi would take him to the border as the conflict between Iran and Israel intensified. 'Flights, markets, everything is closed, and I am living in the basement of a small hotel,' Hussein told The Associated Press by cellphone on Monday. "I am trying to get to the border by taxi, but they are hard to find, and no one is taking us.' Israel launched a major attack Friday with strikes in the Iranian capital of Tehran and elsewhere, killing senior military officials, nuclear scientists, and destroying critical infrastructure. Among the targets was a nuclear enrichment facility about 18 miles from Qom. Iran has retaliated with hundreds of drones and missiles. The dayslong attacks between the two bitter enemies have opened a new chapter in their turbulent recent history. Many in the region fear a wider conflict as they watch waves of attacks across their skies every night. The conflict has forced most countries in the Middle East to close their airspace. Dozens of airports have stopped all flights or severely reduced operations, leaving tens of thousands of passengers stranded and others unable to flee the conflict or travel home. Airport closures create 'massive' domino, tens of thousands stranded 'The domino effect here is massive,' said retired pilot and aviation safety expert John Cox, who said the disruptions will have a huge price tag. 'You've got thousands of passengers suddenly that are not where they're supposed to be, crews that are not where they are supposed to be, airplanes that are not where they're supposed to be,' he said. Zvika Berg was on an El Al flight to Israel from New York when an unexpected message came from the pilot as they began their descent: 'Sorry, we've been rerouted to Larnaca.' The 50-year-old Berg saw other Israel-bound El Al flights from Berlin and elsewhere landing at the airport in Cyprus. Now he's waiting at a Larnaca hotel while speaking to his wife in Jerusalem. 'I'm debating what to do,' Berg said. Israel has closed its main international Ben Gurion Airport 'until further notice,' leaving more than 50,000 Israeli travelers stranded abroad. The jets of the country's three airlines have been moved to Larnaca. In Israel, Mahala Finkleman was stuck in a Tel Aviv hotel after her Air Canada flight was canceled, trying to reassure her worried family back home while she shelters in the hotel's underground bunker during waves of overnight Iranian attacks. 'We hear the booms. Sometimes there's shaking,' she said. 'The truth, I think it's even scarier … to see from TV what happened above our heads while we were underneath in a bomb shelter.' Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's office warned Israelis not to flee the country through any of the three crossings with Jordan and Egypt that are open to the Israeli public. Despite having diplomatic ties with Israel, the statement said those countries are considered a 'high risk of threat' to Israeli travelers. Iran on Friday suspended flights to and from the country's main Khomeini International Airport on the outskirts of Tehran. Israel said Saturday that it bombed Mehrabad Airport in an early attack, a facility in Tehran for Iran's air force and domestic commercial flights. Many students unable to leave Iran, Iraq and elsewhere Arsalan Ahmed is one of thousands of Indian university students stuck in Iran, with no way out. The medical student and other students in Tehran are not leaving the hostels where they live, horrified by the attacks with no idea of when they'll find safety. 'It is very scary what we watch on television,' Ahmed said. 'But scarier are some of the deafening explosions.' Universities have helped relocate many students to safer places in Iran, but the Indian government has not yet issued an evacuation plan for them. Though airspace is still partially open in Lebanon and Jordan, the situation is chaotic at airports, with many passengers stranded locally and abroad with delayed and canceled flights even as the busy summer tourism season begins. Many airlines have reduced flights or stopped them altogether, and authorities have closed airports overnight when attacks are at their most intense. Syria, under new leadership, had just renovated its battered airports and begun restoring diplomatic ties when the conflict began. Neighboring Iraq's airports have all closed due to its close proximity to Iran. Israel reportedly used Iraqi airspace, in part, to launch its strikes on Iran, while Iranian drones and missiles flying the other way have been downed over Iraq. Baghdad has reached a deal with Turkey that would allow Iraqis abroad to travel to Turkey — if they can afford it — and return home overland through their shared border. Some Iraqis stranded in Iran opted to leave by land. College student Yahia al-Suraifi was studying in the northwestern Iranian city of Tabriz, where Israel bombed the airport and an oil refinery over the weekend. Al-Suraifi and dozens of other Iraqi students pooled together their money to pay taxi drivers to drive 200 miles (320 kilometers) overnight to the border with northern Iraq with drones and airstrikes around them. 'It looked like fireworks in the night sky,' al-Suraifi said. 'I was very scared.' By the time they reached the northern Iraqi city of Irbil, it was another 440 miles (710 kilometers) to get to his hometown of Nasiriyah in southern Iraq. Back in Tehran, Hussein said the conflict brought back bitter memories of 20 years of war back home in Afghanistan. 'This is the second time I have been trapped in such a difficult war and situation," he said, "once in Kabul and now in Iran.' — Abdul-Zahra reported from Baghdad. Associated Press journalists Riazat Butt in Islamabad, Moshe Edri in Tel Aviv, Israel; Aijaz Hussain Srinagar, India; Menelaos Hadjicostis in Nicosia, Cyprus, and Adam Suderman in Richmond, Virginia, contributed to this report.
