Nat Barr erupts over 'ridiculous' ambulance crisis after just 'one per cent' of the fleet were able to respond to calls and dozens of patients left stranded
Nat Barr has lashed out at the ambulance crisis in Victoria and labelled it 'ridiculous' after it emerged just one per cent of the fleet were able to respond to calls.
The Sunrise host demanded authorities fix the issue immediately following revelations that 50 people were left waiting for emergency transport on Monday night.
Ambulance data showed more than 25 crews were off the roads across Melbourne due to staff shortages, while at least another 110 crews were stuck ramped at hospitals by 7.15pm.
Paramedics were forced to care for patients in the vehicle while waiting for a hospital bed to become available, meaning they couldn't get back out on the road and respond to more calls for help.
Danny Hill, from the Victorian Ambulance Union, described it as 'the perfect storm'.
'We had a lot of dropped resources,' he told Barr.
'We had 22 advanced life support and eight mobile intensive care ambulances that actually didn't run on Monday night.
'Compounding that, we had a very busy workload and the hospitals were overwhelmed and, at one point, we believe about 100 crews were ramped at metropolitan hospitals across Melbourne, sometimes for up to ten hours.
'I'm informed it left one per cent of the metropolitan Melbourne ambulance fleet able to respond to anyone in an emergency.'
Barr was stunned by the situation and said it needed fixing right away.
'This is an absolute cluster, this is absolutely ridiculous,' she said before asking Mr Hill what would be done about the problem.
'Taxpayers pay for their ambulance service to be there in a time of emergency,' Mr Hill said.
'Too often we see them logged off emergency work to work in hospital corridors, to organise GP appointments and to do social work instead of being free to respond to genuine emergencies.
'Just the other night an ambulance was called to someone complaining of gaming addiction. Paramedics don't have anything to offer that person.'
Barr asked why paramedics were receiving calls like the one about the person with a gaming addiction.
'Why isn't someone saying "no" and redirecting them, surely?' she asked.
'Correct, and they're being sent to those calls, that's the problem,' Mr Hill said.
'The calls are coming through, and always will, and some of these patients do need help but not from ambulance paramedics.'
Barr said a common-sense approach needed to be taken towards the unforgivable situation Ambulance Victoria found itself in on Monday night.
'Surely someone can fix this, it's just absolutely ridiculous,' she said.
Data leaked to the Herald Sun exposed that more than ten major hospitals had wait times of more than two hours by 8pm, with some as high as ten hours.
Premier Jacinta Allan said winter was to blame for the spike in demand for ambulances.
'We are clearly in the depths of winter where many people are suffering from the impacts of flus, and Covid is still around, and a lot of respiratory illnesses,' she said.
Two Victorians died waiting for ambulances in June alone, including an elderly Blackburn man who bled to death after falling and hitting his head.
He phoned for an ambulance twice, but it took almost five hours for one to arrive, while six crews were ramped at Box Hill Hospital, just one suburb away.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
an hour ago
- Telegraph
Streeting to hand working class areas greater share of NHS funds
Working-class areas will get a greater share of NHS funds under plans to help places with the worst health. Wes Streeting will say on Wednesday that billions of pounds will be diverted to coastal towns and deprived places, with extra cash to boost GP provision. It follows repeated criticism from Red Wall voters about the impact of Labour's policies – including welfare reform and winter fuel payments – on northern England. In a speech in Blackpool, Mr Streeting will say that the 10-year health plan will 'restore the promise of the NHS, to provide first-class healthcare for everyone in our country'. Think tanks and patients' groups welcomed the attempt to bring more GPs into areas which were short of them, but warned against creating a new kind of two-tier system, reflecting 'class-based politics'. Meanwhile, resident doctors – formerly known as junior doctors – have said they are 'excited to go again' on another round of strikes in an effort to derail the 10-year plan. Consultants and specialist doctors will also vote on their appetite to strike despite all having agreed to end industrial action last year after receiving bumper pay rises. They warned that the Government could not deliver its reforms without them. In his speech, Mr Streeting will say that £2.2 billion previously set aside to write off NHS deficits will instead go to some of the poorest areas, which have the worst health. He has already vowed to end a culture of 'overspending', which has seen trusts requiring bailouts after building up deficits. And he will say the GP funding formula – which gives more to more affluent areas – will be rewritten to divert more to the poor. The plan, due next week, will promise a review of the way funds are allocated as part of efforts to address health inequalities. In the speech today, Mr Streeting is expected to say: 'The truth is, those in greatest need often receive the worst quality healthcare. It flies in the face of the values the NHS was founded on. 'The circumstances of your birth shouldn't determine your worth. A core ambition of our 10-year plan will be to restore the promise of the NHS, to provide first class healthcare for everyone in our country and end the postcode lottery.' Dr Sean Phillips, head of health and social care at the Policy Exchange, said getting GP funding on a fair footing was crucial. But he said: 'Explicitly targeting 'working class communities' raises questions. One of the principles of the NHS constitution is that 'everyone counts'. 'This sense of fairness is fundamental given we've seen declining satisfaction with the NHS in recent years. Reforms should be based on clinical need, not class-based politics – which runs the risk of creating the perception of another type of two-tier service.' Dennis Reed, from patient group Silver Voices, said: 'If you focus on areas purely based on poverty you can end up forgetting about some of those with the greatest health needs, which can include elderly people living in affluent areas.' 'Equity is a founding principle of the NHS and it's absolutely right to aim for it. But I think when you are talking about shifting money to what are essentially Red Wall seats you have to be very careful that there isn't a whiff that money is being targeted for electoral reasons. 'If there is any hint of pork barrel politics, shifting money to your supporters, that really can undermine any efforts to achieve equity, it is really important that we treat the NHS as a shared national endeavour rather than pit any one group against another.' Dr Becks Fisher, director of research and policy for the Nuffield Trust, said: 'The government has rightly recognised that tackling health inequalities will be impossible unless this is changed – and today's announcement is a positive step.' However she said it was the fourth promise since 2004 to reform the system, adding: 'The true test will be whether this new review results in meaningful change through fairer funding across general practice. 'It's good that the government recognises that they'll need to make money available to realise these general practice reforms, but tight finances mean there may be some difficult decisions to weigh up.' Last year Mr Streeting ordered the NHS to prioritise clearing backlogs in parts of the country with the highest levels of worklessness. Specialist teams were sent to the 20 hospital trusts in the areas with the highest waits and biggest rates of economic inactivity. The move has seen waiting lists in those areas falling twice as fast as the rest of the country, 'helping get sick Brits back to health and back to work,' he will say today. 'Thanks to the reforms we've made to bear down on wasteful spending, we can now invest the savings in working class communities that need it most. Where towns have the greatest health needs and the fewest GPs, we will prioritise investment to rebuild your NHS and rebuild the health of your community.' Currently, GP surgeries which serve working class areas receive on average 10 per cent less funding per patient than practices in more affluent areas. Figures from the Royal College of General Practitioners show that practices in the most deprived areas have around 300 more patients per GP than the most affluent regions, with around 2,450 patients per head. Officials said the new policy was an attempt to tackle a phenomenon dubbed 'the inverse care law' with those most in need likely to get the least help, and suffer the longest waits. People in working class areas and coastal towns spend more of their lives in ill health. And life expectancy among women with the lowest incomes has fallen in recent years, after decades of progress. The policy will be funded by improved financial discipline, officials said. Over the past 14 years, NHS trusts have relied heavily on deficit support, with the taxpayer forced to cover the shortfall in their budgets. This year, systems that fail to meet agreed financial plans will not be bailed out, with such funding phased out entirely from 2026/27, in an attempt to end a culture of 'rewards for failure'.
The Independent
2 hours ago
- The Independent
Three-year-old becomes youngest patient to receive groundbreaking gene therapy
Ella Pickover Wednesday 25 June 2025 06:33 BST Gunreet Kaur is the youngest person in the UK to be given a groundbreaking gene therapy for a rare condition (Handout/PA) Three-year-old Gunreet Kaur became the youngest person in the UK to receive a groundbreaking gene therapy for a rare, life-threatening inherited condition. Gunreet, diagnosed with aromatic l-amino acid decarboxylase (AADC) deficiency, received the Upstaza treatment in February 2024 at Great Ormond Street children's hospital (GOSH). AADC deficiency is a rare and often deadly condition caused by a gene mutation that prevents the production of dopamine, leading to severe developmental and movement issues. The Gene therapy, eladocagene exuparvovec, involves delivering a working AADC gene directly into the brain to enable the production of the missing enzyme. Since receiving the treatment, Gunreet has made significant progress, including improved coordination, new movements, and vocalisation, with hopes for further development. In full
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Expert reveals footy star could have DIED from horrific injuries he suffered during match: 'It's car crash-type stuff'
A leading sports physiotherapist has exposed the full seriousness of Fletcher Sharpe's injuries after the Newcastle star suffered a ruptured spleen and lacerated kidney on Saturday. Sharpe reported abdominal soreness after suffering a concussion in the Knights' 26-20 win over the Dolphins - and scans later revealed the full extent of the damage. It is understood he suffered the injury when his body hit the ground and landed on his elbow in the same tackle that gave him the concussion. Physiotherapist Brien Seeney - better known as the NRL Physio on X - told his 56,000-plus followers about the potentially life-threatening nature of Sharpe's condition. 'Genuine car crash type stuff for Fletcher Sharpe, with news he has suffered a ruptured spleen to go along with a lacerated kidney,' he posted. 'Injuries of this magnitude are considered a medical emergency - require immediate medical attention & can lead to life threatening internal bleeding. Tackle didnt appear too high force at the time, but it was reportedly Sharpe falling on his own elbow that did the damage. Thankfully he is said to be recovering well under observation in Perth, but an expected date for his return to the field is obviously very uncertain. — NRL PHYSIO (@nrlphysio) June 23, 2025 'Tackle didn't appear too high force at the time, but it was reportedly Sharpe falling on his own elbow that did the damage. 'Thankfully he is said to be recovering well under observation in Perth, but an expected date for his return to the field is obviously very uncertain.' The five-eighth has been joined by his family in Perth as he continues to receive medical attention. Sharpe would already have missed Friday night's clash with Canberra due to concussion issues. The Knights have a bye the following week. Newcastle do not yet have a timeline on how much longer they expect the 21-year-old to miss, but he could be out for the entire season. Sharpe has been one of Newcastle's best threats this year, scoring 11 tries and setting up another three in a side that has the worst attacking record in the NRL. Newcastle have several back-up options in the halves, with Tyson Gamble available again and Jackson Hastings having returned to the NRL against Manly this month. Elsewhere, there are fears Dolphins winger Jack Bostock suffered a dreaded ACL rupture in the Perth match. The potentially season-ending injury comes just a week after the flyer scored four tries against North Queensland last Saturday. The Warriors are also waiting on scans on halfback Luke Metcalf's quad and winger Dallin Watene-Zelezniak's ankle after their loss to Penrith.
