logo
BMC bleeds crores on defunct cycle track

BMC bleeds crores on defunct cycle track

Hindustan Times09-05-2025
MUMBAI: Once hailed as a bold step towards a greener, fitter city, a 39-km cycling track from Sion to Mulund now lies in shambles. Never used by cyclists, it has been draining crores of rupees in maintenance costs each year – hard-earned taxpayers' money – while serving as a den for all kinds of illicit activities, a refuge for encroachers, and a dumping ground for locals.
The latest maintenance tender, a ₹9.5-crore contract for two years, is pending issuance to BB Infratech, the same firm awarded a ₹3.7-crore maintenance contract last year.
Built in 2020, along the Tansa pipeline that supplies water to the city, the track snakes through Sion, Kurla, Ghatkopar and Saki Naka, before ending in Mulund. It cost the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) a staggering ₹500 crore to build.
Local residents are becoming increasingly vocal about the track's decline. 'The design was flawed from the start – uneven surfaces, steps, boulders and encroachments make it unsuitable for cyclists. Repeated calls to convert it into parking space, which Mumbai desperately needs, have fallen on deaf ears,' said Payal Shah, representing the HB & JY Marg Forum.
Alleging mismanagement of funds, Shah said the BMC is now considering CSR funds and NGO involvement to cover costs, indicating budget constraints in one of India's richest municipal bodies. She also criticised the BMC's Hydraulic Engineering department, which owns the land, for failing to deploy security guards or manage the site effectively.
Residents say the track has become a public hazard. Hardeep Singh, a shop owner near Gandhi Market, said, 'It's become a dumping ground. People litter after visiting Shanmukananda Hall, and by evening it turns into a den for drinking and gambling. It should be repurposed for parking, especially with hospitals and malls in the area.'
The cycling track, a flagship project of Shiv Sena UBT leader Aaditya Thackeray, is a symbol of poor planning and mismanagement. The project has its origins in 2017, in a series of massive demolition drives to remove more than 16,000 encroachments for the security of the Tansa pipeline following a Bombay High Court order.
To make sure that encroachers did not return, the BMC designed a project called 'Green Wheels Along Blue Lines' – a 10-metre-wide cycling and jogging track on the land cleared of encroachments. In 2018, the municipality decided to build the track along the Tansa pipeline between Sion and Mulund, connecting the suburban railway stations in between, at a cost of ₹300 crore. Within two years, the cost rose to nearly ₹500 crore.
Purshottam Malawade, chief engineer of the BMC's Hydraulic Engineering department, said there are no plans to dismantle the track. 'We have floated a ₹9.5-crore tender for two years, covering cleanliness, plantation and security. It awaits approval from the municipal commissioner,' he said.
BB Infratech, who had bagged the maintenance contract last year, claimed it fulfilled its contractual duties, but lacked the authority to address encroachments or provide security. 'We're still waiting for the new work order. Meanwhile, BMC is exploring CSR partnerships to fund the maintenance,' a representative of the contractor said.
'The only place where the track is being used is in Mulund. The rest is a disaster. The area should be beautified for people's recreation. Spending more money on maintenance is a waste of taxpayers' money,' said Ravi Raja, former leader of the opposition in the BMC.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Minister Suresh Pujari meets Amit Shah, seeks Rs 10,500 crore aid for cyclone resilient infrastructure
Minister Suresh Pujari meets Amit Shah, seeks Rs 10,500 crore aid for cyclone resilient infrastructure

New Indian Express

time8 hours ago

  • New Indian Express

Minister Suresh Pujari meets Amit Shah, seeks Rs 10,500 crore aid for cyclone resilient infrastructure

BHUBANESWAR : Revenue and Disaster Management Minister Suresh Pujari met Union Home Minister Amit Shah in New Delhi and requested him for central assistance of Rs 10,500 crore to the state to build cyclone resilient infrastructures. Pujari met Shah at his Parliament office on Tuesday and submitted a memorandum focused on strengthening the state's infrastructure to combat frequent natural calamities. Pujari submitted five proposals to Shah, emphasising the need for enhanced financial and technical supports to make the state disaster resilient and ensure safety of life and property of people in the vulnerable coastal regions. The proposals include construction of 500 cyclone/flood shelters across disaster-prone districts involving a cost of Rs 2,000 crore, Rs 8,363 crore for developing disaster-resilient electricity infrastructure crucial for maintaining power during the time of disaster and Rs 200 crore towards upgradation of the existing early warning systems. Pujari further requested Shah for facilitating financial grant either from central schemes or through Asian Development Bank for prevention of coastal erosion and protection of livelihoods of people in the coastal region. He requested for central government's approval for appointment of a national-level organisation for undertaking scientific survey in strategic locations of Odisha coast, cost-benefit analysis of the proposed projects and arranging funds for execution of these projects. Pujari also met Union Minister of Agriculture, Farmers Welfare and Rural Development Shivraj Singh Chouhan on the day and briefed him about the steps taken by the state government on the the implementation of the Digital India Land Records Modernisation Programme (DILRMP). He submitted a project proposal worth Rs 984 crore to Chouhan with a request for necessary technical support by the central government to expedite survey and geo-referencing of cadastral maps in Odisha.

Cheating scam: Mumbai bizwoman alleges Rs 3.23 crore fraud by five firms; FIR registered
Cheating scam: Mumbai bizwoman alleges Rs 3.23 crore fraud by five firms; FIR registered

Time of India

time11 hours ago

  • Time of India

Cheating scam: Mumbai bizwoman alleges Rs 3.23 crore fraud by five firms; FIR registered

MUMBAI: The Parksite police have registered an FIR in a cheating case involving alleged fraud of over Rs 3.23 crore, based on a complaint by businesswoman Shital Hitesh Shah (45), a Ghatkopar-based trader in metal coils and sheets. According to the complaint, Shah runs her trading firm, Sheetal Enterprises, from her residence in Amritnagar, Ghatkopar (West), with her husband Hitesh Shah (46) managing operations. In April 2025, Hitesh Shah was contacted by Deepak Rathod, who introduced himself as the director of Kedivya Industries Pvt. Ltd., offering to procure steel goods on credit. Rathod initially made a part payment of Rs 2.5 lakh to gain trust. Following Rathod's recommendation, multiple other firms and individuals – Karan Soneri (D.K. Enterprises), Deep Patel and Mehul Bhat (Silver Span Fab Pvt. Ltd.), Hitesh Gangaram Panchal (Manibhadra Fabricators) on behalf of Prof. Rituja Panchal, and A.D. Enterprises – also placed large orders with Sheetal Enterprises between 15 April and 27 May 2025. You Can Also Check: Mumbai AQI | Weather in Mumbai | Bank Holidays in Mumbai | Public Holidays in Mumbai | Gold Rates Today in Mumbai | Silver Rates Today in Mumbai The goods were procured from suppliers in Mumbai and Navi Mumbai and dispatched through transporters to Ahmedabad and Palghar. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like AirSense 11 – Smart tech for deep sleep ResMed Buy Now Undo While partial payments were made initially, the accused later defaulted, collectively failing to pay Rs 3.23 crore for the supplied steel. Despite repeated reminders, the accused allegedly lured Shah's husband to Ahmedabad with false assurances of settlement, but no payments were made. The complainant further alleged that some firms, including D.K. Enterprises, Manibhadra Fabricators, and A.D. Enterprises, did not exist at their registered GST addresses, indicating fraudulent intent. Shital Shah alleged that all accused colluded to procure goods, resell them in the open market, and deliberately avoid payments. The police have registered the case under relevant sections of the Indian Penal Code for cheating and criminal conspiracy, and investigations are ongoing. Stay updated with the latest local news from your city on Times of India (TOI). Check upcoming bank holidays , public holidays , and current gold rates and silver prices in your area.

PPP must drive India's infrastructure funding: Experts at BS Infra Summit
PPP must drive India's infrastructure funding: Experts at BS Infra Summit

Business Standard

time12 hours ago

  • Business Standard

PPP must drive India's infrastructure funding: Experts at BS Infra Summit

Public-Private Partnership (PPP) should be the default approach in India's infrastructure development, as government resources alone cannot meet the scale of competing demands, experts said at the Business Standard Infrastructure Summit on Thursday on the theme 'Infra for Viksit Bharat: Planning, funding and building". In a panel discussion moderated by Dhruvaksh Saha, Kuljit Singh, EY India Investment Banking Partner, said that private investment must increasingly fund projects that would otherwise rely on government capital expenditure. 'There is a lot of scope for PPP in India, for the simple reason that India is source-constrained. We don't have enough resources. Somebody has to get clean water for free, somebody has to get housing for free or subsidised. So by default, I think in India, what needs to happen is that if there is a possibility to undertake private investment to fund what would have been otherwise funded by the government on a CapEx basis, you should always go down that path without fail,' he said. Funding challenges and PPP opportunities Singh pointed out that while debt funding is no longer a bottleneck in India, the terms of financing remain a challenge. 'It's rarely difficult to find a project in India now from the debt perspective. 99 per cent of projects now get funded in India; the question is, who funds you? Banks are very happy to fund highway projects. Ports and airports also get funding easily. Where we may struggle to get funding is on what terms we get the debt," he said. He further added that foreign investors are increasingly open to greenfield renewable projects and willing to take construction risk. He also called for replicating successful models from the central government across states. 'You have to see why the central government is successful and state governments falter? Because the central government picks up one sector, does a lot of research, and freezes documents after detailed consultations. NHAI, why is it successful? It replicates the same process for every project,' Singh added. For sectors like waste management and railways, Singh suggested that PPPs should focus on new asset creation rather than legacy projects, as 'it is very difficult to do something with what already exists, but not so difficult to do something new". Cities unprepared for growth Jagan Shah, CEO of Infravision Foundation, underlined the stress on India's cities due to unplanned growth since liberalisation. 'Our cities are reeling under growth. What we are facing is the consequences of not having planned our cities well enough. Most cities have fairly well-planned neighbourhoods which are legacies of the past, but the kind of spurt of growth since 1991, we have been unprepared for that,' Shah said. Calling cities 'systems of systems", Shah said that urban planning must be future-driven and technology-enabled. 'We need an enormous shift in technologies, and we need to do it on the best of home-made innovations. That is why you need a complete ecosystem to support the kind of evolution that we need in our services,' he said. Shah highlighted the importance of procurement and collaborations across industry, academia, and government to provide benchmarks for decision-making. He cited sanitation projects as an example where research outputs could guide officers. On PPP in cities, Shah said local projects remain small and financially dependent on state governments and urban local bodies. 'Across the entire territory, the urban infrastructure projects are small, subservient to how the state and ULB functions financially, and therefore you're not able to attract the kind of PPP that you want,' he added. He, however, praised the Urban Challenge Fund for pushing cities to bring forward their own projects, with PPP expected to contribute up to half of the financing. 'That is a transformative idea,' Shah said. Planning is the core of infrastructure Rahul Mithal, Chairman and Managing Director of RITES, emphasised that planning remains the most critical aspect of infrastructure development. 'Out of the three elements of infrastructure, which is planning, funding, and execution, planning is the core,' he said. Mithal stressed the need for adopting the QCBS (Quality and Cost Based Selection) system in project preparation. 'Detailed Project Report (DPR) needs a concentrated focus, and you should choose DPR entities only by using QCBS. In QCBS, you need to make a decision, which is the most difficult part,' he said, adding that relying only on technical credentials was the easiest but least effective approach. He also underlined the importance of strong field entities to ensure that designs are executed properly and of leveraging technology to assess vulnerabilities in infrastructure systems.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store