Stick to a curbed diet, RBI: Despite weak demand, why central bank should curb its reflationary zeal a bit
The need to fret becomes compelling when inflation prints are seen in conjunction with other indicators, such as loan demand and piles of surplus cash at banks. Credit growth measured year-on-year for June was a little over 9%, and cash surplus reached a peak of ₹9 tn in early July before RBI started mopping it up. The credit growth rate for the same period in June 2024 was, incidentally, over 19%. What lessons should RBI draw from this? Standard business cycle theory would advise it to fear not. The fall in inflation is likely to be the result of past efforts at monetary tightening that are paying off. It is impossible for central banks to get things exactly right. With his oft-quoted 'Arjuna's eye' on inflation, ex-governor Shaktikanta Das might have overdone monetary compression a tad, resulting in the super-low inflation rates.
With inflation seemingly under control, all Sanjay Malhotra needs to do is reverse the process. He seems to have done this in good measure with reductions of half-a-percentage point each in the repo rate and CRR. He might want to do a little more, but the key lesson that business cycle theory offers him is the virtue of patience. Monetary policy works with lags. Malhotra should stop fretting over current growth or demand and wait for his labour to bear fruit - perhaps by the end of the year or a few months later. However, there's a problem if one sees the lack of demand as a long-term structural problem rather than a neat cyclical story. Both consumer demand and private consumption have been flagging, at least since 2017, and the attempt to push them up to levels compatible with a sustained 7%-plus growth rate has been unsuccessful.It is possible to go further back to search for causes of this structural slowdown, but 2020 - the year of Covid - might be a good place to start. The recovery from the consumption drop was robust, but there seems to have been a sizeable element of pent-up or revenge spending that was bound to peter out. Economists might brandish conflicting data to either question or support the view that the economic recovery was uneven or not, but most consumer-facing companies would attest that the recovery was K-shaped, with a bias against the mass market.Besides, post-2020 geopolitical risks ratcheted up with two wars - Ukraine and West Asia. Automation found an upward inflection point as AI made its arrival as a usable, scalable innovation. A new US president and his protectionist policies brought a real risk of a compression in global trade and a domestic American recession.Companies dislike uncertainty in decision matrices as much as weak demand. If, indeed, the private investment rut has continued in India long after Covid waned, it is difficult to blame Indian companies for being too timid. A farm sector recovery in 2024 promised to even out the K-shape of the post-Covid trajectory, but it was replaced by concerns about the 'hollowing out' of the middle class, with white-collar job losses particularly in IT-related sectors. The fear, stoked by some commentators, is that as AI gathers steam, an entire swathe of mid-tier jobs is at risk.What does this mean for RBI? If structural factors are, indeed, the reason for muted credit growth, monetary policy has a somewhat limited role to play. As the current combination of massive excess liquidity and weak credit growth has shown, more accommodation can give the impression of an emerging 'liquidity trap', where interest rates fail to move the needle. This could hurt broader sentiment in the economy if it becomes the dominant economic narrative.The post-Covid period saw a sharp increase in household debt. From an average of 35% in 2019, it climbed to 42% of GDP at the end of 2024. While this might still be lower than levels in other emerging economies, such a sharp increase has challenges. If monetary policy lowers interest rates, it does bring down EMIs of households. However, if banks use easy money to expand their retail portfolios at a time when employment and income flows are uncertain, there is a risk of loans going bad, threatening financial stability.Finally, if we do believe Milton Friedman's claim that inflation is ultimately a monetary phenomenon, leaving too much excess cash in the system might exacerbate inflation pressures if there are supply shocks in food and fuel. RBI might want to curb enthusiasm about reflating the economy a little. (Disclaimer: The opinions expressed in this column are that of the writer. The facts and opinions expressed here do not reflect the views of www.economictimes.com.) Elevate your knowledge and leadership skills at a cost cheaper than your daily tea. Leadership shakeups cloud Ola Electric's revival attempts
Trent trips on the ramp. Is it still worth the splurge or time to change brands?
Just before the Air India crash, did India avert another deadly mishap?
Can Indian IT protect its high valuation as AI takes centre stage?
Stock Radar: Why is Hindustan Zinc looking good for a short-term bounce after falling over 35% from highs?
These large-caps have 'strong buy' & 'buy' recos and an upside potential of more than 25%
Buy, Sell or Hold: Motilal Oswal maintains buy rating on HCL Tech; ICICI Securities maintains sell call on Tata Technologies
Consolidation: An opportunity or threat? Depends on…. 5 mid-cap stocks from different sectors with upside potential of over 26%
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
11 minutes ago
- Business Standard
Customer complaints rising fast, bankers lacking empathy, says RBI DG
Reserve Bank Deputy Governor Swaminathan J has rued a "lack of empathy" among bankers, even in the face of rising number of customer complaints around serious aspects like fraud. Speaking at an event of RBI-promoted NIBM (National Institute of Bank Management) on July 12, Swaminathan said there is "increasing automation but decreasing ownership", and customers have to contend with template emails and helplines loop back "endlessly". He made it clear that addressing these issues will be essential if bankers were to sustain people's trust in the system. The Reserve Bank's website published the speech on Tuesday. "The number of customer complaints -- especially through digital channels -- has risen significantly in recent years. From social engineering frauds to poor grievance redressal, the loss and frustration is real. Often, the problem is not the product or service, but, as I see it, the real issue is a lack of empathy," the commercial banker-turned-regulator said in his valedictory address to the students. Nowadays, KYC (know your customer) is often reduced to a "periodic ritual", he said, exhorting bankers to find a way to bring back that personal awareness and responsibility even in a digital context. Enlisting instances like senior citizen's struggles with ATM PIN, a rural area borrower's challenges to repay a loan online or the worries of a small business owner over UPI payments, Swaminathan said these are not mere service requests, but opportunities to earn trust by giving time and patience, and showing professionalism. "Technology will enable the transaction. But only you can build the relationship and only you can earn the customer's trust for your institution," he said, stressing that this is what will distinguish a banker from an app. The DG said a banker has to act quickly, endure uncertainty, recover from setbacks, and stay focused over the long run. "You will face moments of rapid change -- crises, deadlines, audits, policy shifts -- but you will also need the discipline and stamina to navigate slow, complex processes that unfold over months or years," he told the students beginning a two-year post graduation course in banking. Empathy, curiosity, and integrity will define success for the students over a long term, he said. "What will truly shape you as a banker is your ability to blend knowledge with judgment, law with convention, and theory with practice," he said. Things will not go as planned, but the ability to embrace the unfamiliar and turn unexpected situations into learning experiences will set a student apart, he said, asking them to stay alert and course-correct early. Banking today is more complex than ever, he said, adding that there are also new vulnerabilities like cyber threats, phishing, synthetic identities, deepfakes, and third-party risks. (Only the headline and picture of this report may have been reworked by the Business Standard staff; the rest of the content is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)
NDTV
23 minutes ago
- NDTV
Who Is Gita Gopinath, IMF's No 2 Economist Set To Return To Harvard
Indian-origin economist Gita Gopinath will step down as the First Deputy Managing Director of the International Monetary Fund (IMF) at the end of August. She will return to Harvard University as a professor of economics, the IMF said on Monday. Calling her stint at the IMF a "once in a lifetime opportunity," Ms Gopinath thanked IMF Managing Director Kristalina Georgieva and her predecessor, Christine Lagarde, who appointed her as chief economist. "I now return to my roots in academia," she said, "to continue pushing the research frontier in international finance and macroeconomics." Who Is Gita Gopinath? Gita Gopinath was born on December 8, 1971 in Kolkata, India, into a Malayali Hindu Nair family from Kannur, Kerala. She is related to the late communist party politician A K Gopalan. Ms Gopinath studied at Nirmala Convent School in Mysuru and earned her BA in Economics from Lady Shri Ram College in 1992, followed by an MA from the Delhi School of Economics in 1994. She received a second MA from the University of Washington in 1996 and completed her PhD in Economics at Princeton in 2001. In 2001, she joined the University of Chicago Booth School of Business as an assistant professor. In 2005, she moved to Harvard University's economics department, where she later became the John Zwanstra Professor of International Studies and Economics. Gita Gopinath became the first woman to serve as Chief Economist of the IMF in October 2018. During the COVID-19 crisis, she co-authored the Fund's "Pandemic Paper," which led to the formation of a Multilateral Task Force with the World Bank, WHO, and WTO. In June 2021, she joined the World Bank-IMF High-Level Advisory Group on Sustainable and Inclusive Recovery. The IMF promoted her to First Deputy Managing Director in December 2021. She also co-directed the International Finance and Macroeconomics Programme at NBER and advised the Federal Reserve Banks of Boston and New York. Ms Gopinath served as economic adviser to Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan. She was appointed to this honorary role in July 2016. Ms Gopinath is a naturalised American citizen and holds Overseas Citizen of India (OCI) status. She is married to Iqbal Singh Dhaliwal, a classmate from the Delhi School of Economics, and they have a son named Rohil, born in 2002.
News18
36 minutes ago
- News18
Customer complaints rising fast, bankers lacking empathy: RBI DG
Mumbai, Jul 22 (PTI) Reserve Bank Deputy Governor Swaminathan J has rued a 'lack of empathy" among bankers, even in the face of rising number of customer complaints around serious aspects like fraud. Speaking at an event of RBI-promoted NIBM (National Institute of Bank Management) on July 12, Swaminathan said there is 'increasing automation but decreasing ownership", and customers have to contend with template emails and helplines loop back 'endlessly". He made it clear that addressing these issues will be essential if bankers were to sustain people's trust in the system. The Reserve Bank's website published the speech on Tuesday. 'The number of customer complaints — especially through digital channels — has risen significantly in recent years. From social engineering frauds to poor grievance redressal, the loss and frustration is real. Often, the problem is not the product or service, but, as I see it, the real issue is a lack of empathy," the commercial banker-turned-regulator said in his valedictory address to the students. Nowadays, KYC (know your customer) is often reduced to a 'periodic ritual", he said, exhorting bankers to find a way to bring back that personal awareness and responsibility even in a digital context. Enlisting instances like senior citizen's struggles with ATM PIN, a rural area borrower's challenges to repay a loan online or the worries of a small business owner over UPI payments, Swaminathan said these are not mere service requests, but opportunities to earn trust by giving time and patience, and showing professionalism. 'Technology will enable the transaction. But only you can build the relationship and only you can earn the customer's trust for your institution," he said, stressing that this is what will distinguish a banker from an app. The DG said a banker has to act quickly, endure uncertainty, recover from setbacks, and stay focused over the long run. 'You will face moments of rapid change — crises, deadlines, audits, policy shifts — but you will also need the discipline and stamina to navigate slow, complex processes that unfold over months or years," he told the students beginning a two-year post graduation course in banking. Empathy, curiosity, and integrity will define success for the students over a long term, he said. 'What will truly shape you as a banker is your ability to blend knowledge with judgment, law with convention, and theory with practice," he said. Things will not go as planned, but the ability to embrace the unfamiliar and turn unexpected situations into learning experiences will set a student apart, he said, asking them to stay alert and course-correct early. Banking today is more complex than ever, he said, adding that there are also new vulnerabilities like cyber threats, phishing, synthetic identities, deepfakes, and third-party risks. PTI AA HVA view comments First Published: July 22, 2025, 16:30 IST Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
