
Pune Porsche Case: Drunk Teen Escapes Adult Trial. What Happened In Court?
The main accused in the Pune Porsche crash case - 17 years old and drunk when he rammed his father's Rs 2.5 crore electric supercar into a motorcyle, and killed two people, last year - escaped trial as an adult because the charges he faces do not attract minimum jail terms of seven years or more.
That, the Juvenile Justice Board ruled Tuesday, is the threshold beyond which a minor - a 'Child in Conflict with the Law' - can be accused of committing a "heinous offence" and be tried as an adult.
The boy - the son of a prominent Pune realtor who was also arrested, as was the boy's mother, for tampering with evidence - was booked under multiple sections of the Indian Penal Code.
These include Section 304 (culpable homicide not amounting to murder), and also faces charges under the Prevention of Corruption Act and sections of the Motor Vehicles Act.
However, the Board concluded that none of these charges, individually or collectively, fulfill the critera to declare his crimes a "heinous" offence under the Juvenile Justice Act, and said "... the preliminary assessment under Section 15 - for declaring the child to be tried as an adult - is not maintainable".
What The Prosecution Said
Special Public Prosecutor Shishir Hiray pointed to the gruesome nature of the incident - the boy drove the supercar at nearly 180 km per hour into the two-wheeler - and argued he (and his family) knew the consequences since they influenced the police and tampered with evidence.
The Porsche electric supercar driven by the teen belonged to his father.
These acts, he said, displayed "maturity" and "criminal intent", and attempts to manipulate the legal system. A "strong message" should be sent to others contemplating similar actions, he argued..
What The Defence Said
Appearing for the minor, Prashant Patil pointed to the Supreme Court's ruling in a 2020 case that specified the seven-year jail term threshold to identify "heinous" crimes.
Since none of the charges invoked in this case prescribe that level of punishment, the offences fall under the "serious" category, under which a minor accused cannot be seen as an adult.
Mr Patil also pointed out the focus of the Juvenile Justice Act is reformative and not punitive, and that psychological assessments showed no signs of criminal tendencies in the boy.
He said pushing the accused into the the adult criminal justice system would risk permanently damaging any prospects for his rehabilitation.
What The Juvenile Board Said
The Board - which came under heavy fire last year after giving the boy bail within 15 hours of the accident, on conditions as flimsy as ' write a 300-word essay on road accidents ' - acknowledged Mr Patil's argument and the precedent set by the Supreme Court in refusing the prosecution.
What Next In Pune Porsche Case
The accused will continue, for now, to be treated as a minor.
CCTV footage from a Pune bar showed the minor accused drinking alcohol.
However, sources told NDTV the prosecution will pursue this point and is likely to challenge the Board's order in a higher court, possibly the Bombay High Court.
What Crash Victims' Family Said
Meanwhile, Suresh Koshta, the father of Ashwini Koshta, one of the two people killed told NDTV the decision was another example of how money and power subvert the delivery of justice.
"(From the) beginning the whole country pointed fingers at the functioning of the Juvenile Justice Board. A person who was drinking... driving a car... how can he be considered a 'juvenile'?"
READ | "Rich People": Pune Porsche Victim's Father On Accused's 'Juvenile' Tag
"I think there should have been no question about treating him as an adult," he said.
Om Prakash Awadhiya, the father of Aneesh Awadhiya, the other person who was killed, said "it (the Board's questionable decision) was clear from the beginning what we would get".
"This entire year has been painful for me, my wife, and our whole family. Not a single day goes by without us remembering him and cherishing his beautiful memories. After Anish's tragic death, our world has come crashing down," Mr Awadhiya, who lives in Madhya Pradesh, said.
Pune Porsche Car Crash Case
The main accused - the 17-year-old boy - out 'celebrating' exam results by heavy underage drinking at a city bar. He reportedly ran up a bill of Rs 48,000 in just 90 minutes.
The bar has since been shut down and its owners and staff also arrested.
At the time of the incident the boy was four months short of the legal age for driving and eight years shy of Maharashtra's legal drinking age, which is 25.
The police's handling of the case has also been questioned; the first cops on the scene have been accused of deliberately mishandling critical evidence to ensure the boy's release.
READ | Big Twist In Pune Porsche Crash: Cops To Probe Cops In Burger Row
This included feeding him burgers after the crash to hide or dilute the alcohol in his bloodstream. They reportedly also did not alert their superiors, as required by law.
There were also questions asked of the medical professionals involved, including doctors tasked with extracting and securing samples from the accused to test for blood alcohol levels.
It transpired the samples had been replaced with those of his mother - who was arrested and then released in April - in a crude attempt to conceal the fact he was driving while drunk.
Who Is In Jail, Who Is Not
At present the boy's father, doctors Ajay Taware and Shrihari Halnor, hospital employee Atul Ghatkamble, and two middlemen are in jail in connection with this case.
The boy remains with his family.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


India.com
7 minutes ago
- India.com
She Cried, They Threatened, He Paid Rs 2 Lakh: How Bengaluru Techie Trapped In Bumble Blackmail Plot
Bengaluru: What began as just another Bumble match turned into one of those nights the man will never forget, not for romance but for a twisted spiral that started with a latte and ended with a police complaint. The Bengaluru tech professional, who had spent nearly a month chatting casually with a woman named Sangeetha over texts and video calls, finally decided to meet her in person. Their plan was to catch up over coffee and maybe share a drink later. The vibes were good, the conversation flowed and nothing seemed out of the ordinary. Later that evening, Sangeetha suggested they unwind with a drink at a room she had arranged. He agreed. But what happened next did not feel like a bad date. It felt scripted. Within minutes of them settling in, four men barged into the room. Without explanation, they accused the man of being involved in a drug-fueled party. They claimed they were about to call the police. They searched the woman's bag and dramatically pulled out a few packets of white powder. The techie froze. Sangeetha, the woman he had just shared coffee and laughter with, suddenly began sobbing uncontrollably. She rushed into another room and threatened to end her life, claiming she could not bear the shame. The gang circled in. They demanded hush money. A mind-numbing Rs 15 lakh or the man would be dragged into a police case. Panicked and overwhelmed, he begged them to let him go. Hours of pleading followed. Finally, the sum was negotiated down. He handed them Rs 2 lakh and walked out shaken and heart pounding. For three days, he remained silent. But then he went to the police. That single complaint pulled the curtain back on what investigators now call a full-blown extortion racket. Sangeetha was not a random match. She was part of an organised gang that used dating apps to lure targets, stage emotional breakdowns, fake drug busts and squeeze victims for lakhs. The powder that looked like drugs? Just baking soda. The police arrested six people who were identified as Sharanabasappa, Raju Mane, Shyam Sundar, Abhishek, Birbal and the woman, Sangeetha. Deputy Commissioner of Police (North East Division) Sajeeth V J said, 'One of the accused has a prior case for a similar offence in Bengaluru. We are verifying the criminal background of the others. We have learnt that the woman hails from Uttar Pradesh and was working in a dance bar before this.' 'We are investigating further and trying to ascertain how many such victims there are. They have confessed to having done it before, too. We will contact victims and get more details,' he said. Officials now believe this may not be an isolated case. The gang allegedly used dating apps as a hunting ground. Authorities are urging anyone who might have encountered similar situations to step forward. For the techie, the ordeal is over. But the emotional scars and the chilling idea that a friendly match could turn into a trap are likely to stay for much longer.


Time of India
21 minutes ago
- Time of India
Harish questions delay in extending aid to Sigachi blast victims
Hyderabad: Senior BRS leader T Harish Rao on Monday alleged that the families of Sigachi blast victims were yet to receive the promised Rs 1 crore ex gratia. The former minister, along with the victims' families, led a rally to the Sangareddy district additional collector's office and spoke to the official about the reasons for the delay in disbursing the compensation to the kin of the victims. He demanded Rs 50 lakh as compensation for those grievously injured and Rs 25 lakh for others injured. He also submitted a representation on behalf of the victims' families to the additional collector Chandrasekhar Badugu. Later, addressing the media, Harish Rao said that although the company announced it would disburse the ex gratia to the victims' kin within 15 days, there was no response from either the firm or the govt. He said that 14 people were still undergoing treatment in various hospitals, and only Rs 50,000 was paid to each of the injured. You Can Also Check: Hyderabad AQI | Weather in Hyderabad | Bank Holidays in Hyderabad | Public Holidays in Hyderabad "The state govt has not revealed the exact reason for the explosion at Sigachi Industries. Eight persons are still missing, and even death certificates have not been issued for some of the victims," Harish said. He also mentioned that the fate of six workers who died in the roof collapse at the Srisailam Left Bank Canal (SLBC) is still unknown. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like No annual fees for life UnionBank Credit Card Apply Now Undo "When there was a similar accident in Anakapally in Andhra Pradesh last August, the compensation was paid to both the families of the deceased and the injured within three days," he recalled. Harish Rao demanded the govt to hand over the death certificate, panchanama copy, and FIR copy to each of the victims' families and warned that if they did not receive the ex gratia amount, the BRS would stage a dharna at the collectorate in the next couple of days.


Time of India
36 minutes ago
- Time of India
‘Mastermind' of Rs 1.10cr Delhi burglary held in Balasore
Balasore: Delhi Police on Monday arrested a man from Nilagiri area in Balasore district for alleged involvement in the burglary of over Rs 1.10 crore from a builder's residence in the national capital. The accused, Kashinath Mallik (32), of Bhimei village under Iswarpur police outpost, was nabbed after he fled to Odisha with a substantial share of the stolen cash. Police sources said Kashinath, who was employed as a cook at the builder's residence, conspired with two other individuals from his village — Ashutosh Mallick (27) and Jagabandhu Mallick (30) — both working as domestic help in the same house. The trio allegedly committed the theft and planned their escape to Odisha with the money. The case began to unravel when Ashutosh was arrested at Delhi railway station while trying to flee. Shortly after, Jagabandhu was apprehended at Patna bus stand with Rs 45 lakh. Following their interrogation, police found the location of Kashinath's hideout. A Delhi Police team reached Nilagiri and arrested Kashinath from Bhimei. During the operation, officials recovered Rs 30.5 lakh from him. IIC of Nilagiri police station, Gobardhan Nayak, said, "Kashinath was the mastermind of the burglary. He orchestrated the entire plan and roped in the two other accused to carry out the theft." He added that Kasinath was produced before a local court, after which he was taken on transit remand by Delhi Police.