Dáil told government has ‘betrayed' students amid calls for clarification on college fees
The student contribution fee has been temporarily reduced for the past three years as part of cost-of-living packages accompanying the budget.
The fees had been €3,000 before being temporarily reduced to €2,000 euros.
But last week, Higher Education Minister James Lawless said that a
cost-of-living package will not form part of Budget 2026, meaning the temporary drop in the student contribution fee would 'reset' and revert back to €3,000 per academic year.
'All of us in any walk of life have to play the hands we're dealt,' Lawless told RTÉ on Sunday.
Higher Education Minister James Lawless
Alamy Stock Photo
Alamy Stock Photo
He added: 'If I don't have a cost-of-living package. I can't do those kind of measures that were done last year.'
Opposition politicians have been criticising the mooted increase and have repeatedly asked the Government to give clarity to parents ahead of the upcoming academic year.
'Bombshell'
Speaking in the Dáil today during Leaders' Questions, Social Democrats TD Jennifer Whitmore said Lawless had 'dropped a bombshell' and called on the government to 'level with parents and students'.
She added that Lawless's comments on 'playing the hands we're dealt' were 'utterly galling' and 'incredibly tone-deaf'.
Whitmore also said that Lawless had 'actively stacked the deck' against students and families and 'essentially told them to suck it up'.
She added that people 'believed promises in the Programme for Government to reduce student fees' and they have been 'betrayed'.
'They don't have this money down the back of a sofa. They'll have to scrimp and save and sacrifice to cover this increase, do you not understand that Minister?' Whitmore asked Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe, who was taking Leaders' Questions.
File image of Jennifer Whitmore
Alamy Stock Photo
Alamy Stock Photo
Donohoe however hit out at Whitmore for saying the government had 'stacked the deck' against students.
He added that supports are available and that over 140,000 students benefit from Free-Fees and that 60,000 students benefit from lower forms of student contribution fees.
'All of that is in place because of our desire to ensure supports are in place to help,' said Donohoe.
He added that as the government works to move towards a 'normal budget', the government will also look at how progress can be made on the affordability and access to higher and further education.
Donohoe also remarked that the student contribution fee would be 'outlined' in October's budget.
Advertisement
However, Whitmore said Donohoe was 'clearly not listening to what parents and students are saying'.
'They believed you when you said your government would continue to reduce student fees, it really couldn't be any simpler,' said Whitmore.
'Will parents be paying €2,000 in September, or €3,000?'
Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe
Alamy Stock Photo
Alamy Stock Photo
Donohoe said he was providing a 'clear and honest answer' and that the government 'has to make decisions as part of our budget process so we can ensure that the changes that we make are affordable, sustainable, and can be built upon in the years ahead'.
He added: 'We'll be in a position to give a clear answer to that when our budgetary work is done.'
Government 'all over the place'
Earlier, Donohoe had been pressed on the issue by Sinn Féin's Matt Carthy, who said the government was 'all over the place'.
Carthy said he had 'one simple question, when students get their bill in September will they be paying €2,000 or €3,000?'
However, Donohoe began by remarking that the question provided an opportunity to 'outline what the government is already doing'.
He said half of students are supported through the SUSI grant (Student Universal Support Ireland) and that the threshold has been increased by 15% to ensure more students can avail of it.
He added that the grant is now also available to students in part-time or hybrid education.
Donohoe said the budgets put in place measures for students that 'we know is affordable and that we can build upon in the years ahead'.
He added that there is a need to 'look at other measures' following the temporary reduction in student contribution fees.
'Your question may have been brief but the answer to it is longer, outlining the supports and the difference that we already make and we want to build upon,' said Donohoe.
Sinn Féin's Matt Carthy
Alamy Stock Photo
Alamy Stock Photo
However, Carthy said a line of minister have been 'unable to answer a simple question'.
'They don't want to hear what politicians are planning to do in the future, I'll ask you one more time, are fees going to be €2,000 or will they be higher?
'Come down from your ivory tower and answer that question.'
Donohoe replied that 'it is exactly because this issue of life-defining for so any that the government already has supports in place that you will never acknowledge'.
He added that the government is 'interested in solutions rather than soundbites' and that the answer is 'the same as the answer that has been given at any other points in recent years'.
'It's an issue that has to be decided budget-by-budget and this government wants to help in a permanent way and we will outline our answer to that serious question, as we will with many others, when the budget is complete.'
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Government rules out cost-of-living package despite another surge in corporation tax receipts
The Government has ruled out a cost-of-living package for households facing soaring food bills, high energy costs and elevated mortgage rates despite another surge in corporation tax receipts. The exchequer returns, published on Thursday, show a strong surplus of €4.5bn for the first six months of the year, as wrangling over the budget is due to kick off in the coming weeks with the publication of the summer economic statement. The Government has already warned the next budget will be more restrained than previous years, as global economic uncertainty means it will be taking a cautious approach after a giveaway budget ahead of last year's general election. Exchequer returns for the first half of 2025 show corporation tax generated €7.4bn last month, up 25% on the same month last year. The Government pointed out that the overall surplus drops to €1.2bn when the proceeds from the EU Apple Tax case are excluded. The Coalition's proposed cautious approach to the next budget comes as households face increased financial challenges. Food prices are now rising by 4%, more than twice the general inflation rate. Households also face some of the largest electricity bills in Europe, and mortgage interest rates, while coming down, remain among the highest across the EU. Defending the decision not to include another cost-of-living package in the next budget to help families cope with soaring prices, Jack Chambers, the public expenditure minister, said the Government is aware of pressures on households but said there are other ways to support people aside from one-off giveaways. 'We need to balance the risks, which are real in terms of the economic context we are in, with the pressing needs that citizens have,' he said. 'Central to the decisions we make in Government would be the improvement of living standards and supporting greater affordability of public services.' Paschal Donohoe, the finance minister, said he had not anticipated the international volatility around trade rules and US tariffs. 'The way things are settling at the moment means there will be a new normal to come to terms with as global trade is going to look very different,' he said. Mr Donohoe also warned of a potential future decline in the corporation tax receipts that have helped the economy to record surpluses. Both ministers emphasised the need for a 'careful, sensible, and sustainable' approach to Budget 2026. The overall amount collected in tax in the first half of the year rose almost 7% to €47.7bn despite fears over the impact of US tariffs. Total spending was €58.2bn, which included payments of €3bn to the State's two long-term savings funds: The Future Ireland Fund and the Infrastructure, Climate, and Nature Fund. During an event last month, Mr Donohoe said that, in the event of an economic downturn, he would make every effort possible to protect capital expenditure, including using the money set aside in these two funds. In June, €2.9bn was collected in income tax, bringing the total receipts so far this year to €17.4bn — up €700m year on year. Corporation tax receipts of €7.4bn were collected last month, bringing the total for the year to €14.8bn. However, this drops to €13.1bn when the Apple tax case proceeds are excluded. This is still €900m higher than last year and 'slightly ahead of profile' for this year, according to the Department of Finance. Vat receipts were also ahead of projections at €11.6bn, which is 5.6% up on the same period last year. Excise duty receipts during June stood at €500m — up by €100m. Exchequer debt service expenditure in the year to the end of June was €2.2bn, down by €300m compared to last year. Read More Budget should focus on infrastructure and tax measures, says Central Bank governor
The Journal
12 hours ago
- The Journal
Taoiseach warns trade ban on Israeli settlements could hit Irish companies under US anti-boycott laws
TAOISEACH MICHEÁL MARTIN has said the government must tread carefully when considering the expansion of its proposed trade ban with Israeli settlements, stressing that including services could inadvertently harm Irish-based multinational companies due to US anti-boycott legislation. His comments come after Tánaiste Simon Harris last week published a fresh outline of the Occupied Territories Bill, which seeks to prohibit the import of goods produced in illegal Israeli settlements. The bill will affect imports from the West Bank, East Jerusalem, Gaza Strip and Golan Heights – territories occupied since 1967 and widely recognised under international law as illegally held. While the current draft focuses on goods only, Harris has signalled that he wants to include services in a future version of the bill. However, Martin expressed concern about the legal and economic risks of doing so. 'That's an issue we have to factor in, because we don't want any companies or multinationals in Ireland inadvertently being caught up in this,' he said, referring to US anti-boycott laws. Martin made the comments today during a visit to Japan. Alamy Stock Photo Alamy Stock Photo 'We do have to factor in the presence of American legislation, the boycotting divestment legislation, which is already passed by numerous states in America, which would penalise any company that, from an American perspective, participates in boycotts.' Martin said that several US states have passed anti-Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions (BDS) laws, which penalise companies seen as boycotting Israel or Israeli-controlled areas. More than 30 US states have passed so-called anti-BDS laws that penalise companies or entities seen to be boycotting Israel or Israeli-controlled territories. These laws often apply regardless of whether the boycott targets Israel itself or the settlements specifically – something Martin said poses a risk of misinterpretation. 'Whilst we're just involved in the Occupied Territories, not Israel as a country, there's a concerted campaign in terms of misrepresenting the Irish position, so that's an issue we have to factor in,' Martin said. Advertisement Martin also addressed criticism that the government is backing away from the moral argument in favour of protecting economic interests. 'It's not commercial, like it's putting bread and butter on people's table,' he said, noting the presence of 'hundreds of thousands' of jobs in Ireland linked to multinational employers. 'The object of the exercise here is to put pressure on Israel, not to disadvantage Ireland unduly and that's a factor.' The Taoiseach acknowledged the symbolic importance of the legislation, but said it was important to be 'clear-eyed' about its potential impact. 'There's no point in Ireland coming out worse if it has no impact on Israel. That's the only point I'm making, we have to be clear-eyed in terms of the impact. People should know about the impact.' He also raised practical concerns about how a ban on services would even be enforced. 'How do you actually detect, how do you punish the offence, the practicalities around all of that. Those are real and the bill is fundamentally symbolic, it's important.' The Occupied Territories Bill, first introduced in 2018, proposed banning the import and sale of goods and services originating in illegal settlements, as well as the extraction of resources from those areas. The revised version of the bill, now known as the Israeli Settlements in the Occupied Palestinian Territory (Prohibition of Importation of Goods) Bill, would criminalise only the importation of goods, under the Customs Act 2015. Services are not currently covered, though Tánaiste Simon Harris has said he is seeking further legal advice and wants to bring services into scope where possible. 'There isn't another country in the European Union that you can visit today and ask a government minister about their bill to ban trade and the detail of it, because they don't have one,' Harris said last Wednesday. 'Ireland is leading – but we have to do this properly.' The bill is expected to go before an Oireachtas committee for pre-legislative scrutiny later this year. Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Independent
16 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Another big tax boost for the Exchequer
Overall, tax revenues amounted to €47.7bn in the first half of the year, not including the Apple settlement ordered by the European Court of Justice. This was €3bn ahead of the same period last year. Income tax continues to be a stellar performing, reflecting an economy with virtually full employment. Receipts of €17.4bn in this category are also up on last year, by €0.7bn. Vat receipts of €11.6bn are up by €0.6bn, while corporation tax at €13.1bn is over 7pc, or almost €1bn, ahead of where it was at this time in 2024. Expenditure continues to keep pace with tax receipts, however. Total gross voted expenditure in the first half of the year amounted to € up by €3.8bn or 8.2pc on last year, and ahead of profile by €0.3bn. Excluding the Apple tax receipts, an underlying Exchequer surplus of €1.2bn was recorded to end-June, compared with a surplus of €3.1bn in the first half of last year. Tax receipts of €49.5bn were collected in the first six months of the year, up by €4.7bn, or over 10pc, and ahead of expectations by €0.5bn, with the overshoot largely due to corporation tax receipts. The Minister for Finance, Paschal Donohoe, said: 'June is a key month for tax receipts. The steady performance across most revenue streams in the first half of the year is a positive sign of the strength of our economy as we navigate a deeply uncertain period. 'Corporation tax receipts in June have seen a sharp increase, which follows a sharp decline last month. This serves as a reminder of the extreme volatility in this revenue stream, and of its inherent unsuitability as a basis for permanent spending commitments. 'That is why we have established the Future Ireland Fund and the Infrastructure, Climate and Nature Fund to set aside some of this potentially temporary revenue to help further protect us in the future. Last month, Government transferred some €3 billion into the two funds, and when the remaining transfers are made towards the end of this year, there will be around €16 billion in the FIF and ICNF. 'We have also committed to investing the once-off proceeds from the Court of Justice of the European Union ruling in the critical areas of housing, water, energy and transport – these are the strategically important areas that will underpin economic growth into the future. 'As we draft the fiscal parameters for Budget 2026 and beyond, we will ensure that we approach it in a sustainable way, with an approach that protects our economy, supports and protects jobs, underpins our ability to invest in public services and keeps our public finances safe.'
