Pepsi Is Launching Its Own Prebiotic Soda, but Does a 'Healthy' Soda Really Exist? 6 Experts Answer
Along with the homemade healthy Coke trend and people's increasing avoidance of artificial sweeteners like aspartame, this is yet another sign that the healthy beverage movement isn't stopping anytime soon. However, the question remains: Are these "healthy sodas" that promise prebiotic fiber, low sugar and more actually healthy? This is what experts have to say.
What is in prebiotic soda?
Poppi
Prebiotic drinks are having a hot moment. Coming alongside fast-growing brands like Poppi and Olipop, Coca-Cola launched a new prebiotic soda called Simply Pop. With five flavors based on natural ingredients, it might look like a healthy alternative to soda like Coke or Pepsi.
Other brands have also rushed to enter this growing market. Those include:
Wildwonder
Culture Pop
Turveda
Mighty Pop
SunSip (from the kombucha brand Health-Ade).
David Clarke, a board-certified internist, gastroenterologist and president of the Association for Treatment of Neuroplastic Symptoms, explains, "Emerging 'functional' sodas attempt to redefine the category. Prebiotic varieties like Poppi and Olipop incorporate ingredients such as agave inulin and chicory root fiber, which theoretically stimulate beneficial gut bacteria. These beverages often contain fewer calories -- 25 to 50 per can -- and reduced sugar content -- 4 to 7 grams -- compared to traditional sodas."
However, he adds, "Nevertheless, their health benefits remain uncertain."
This was underscored by a recent lawsuit brought against Poppi. In Cobbs v. Vngr Beverage LLC (US District Court for the Northern District of California, 2024), a consumer brought a class action suit against the brand. The filing says that Poppi "only contains two grams of prebiotic fiber, an amount too low to cause meaningful gut health benefits for the consumer from just one can." As Clarke explains, "Its two grams of prebiotic fiber per can fall short of the five-gram threshold required for measurable gut health improvements."
Plus, these prebiotic soda options can come with drawbacks. Some contain apple cider vinegar, for example, which can be bad for your teeth due to its acidity. (While ACV can have some health benefits -- as is evidenced by the number of drinks that include it -- it's best to brush your teeth after consuming it.)
Are Poppi sodas and similar brands actually healthy?Prebiotic drinks are being propped up as a healthy alternative to soda. But are they? We asked some experts if this is really a healthy soda option.
Let's review some of their responses here:
Anastasiia Kaliga , nutritionist and biologist at the app Luvly, answered, "It depends on what we mean by 'healthy.' Compared to traditional sodas, which are loaded with sugar and artificial ingredients, prebiotic sodas seem like a better option."
, nutritionist and biologist at the app Luvly, answered, "It depends on what we mean by 'healthy.' Compared to traditional sodas, which are loaded with sugar and artificial ingredients, prebiotic sodas seem like a better option." Dr. Raphael Cuomo , a professor and biomedical scientist at the University of California San Diego School of Medicine and a clinical cancer epidemiologist, weighed in. He says, "From the perspective of preventing life-threatening diseases like cancer and heart disease, the key consideration is reducing intake of sugar. Some newer sodas are formulated with lower sugar and added fiber and so are a better option than traditional sodas. However, they should not be considered a health food."
, a professor and biomedical scientist at the University of California San Diego School of Medicine and a clinical cancer epidemiologist, weighed in. He says, "From the perspective of preventing life-threatening diseases like cancer and heart disease, the key consideration is reducing intake of sugar. Some newer sodas are formulated with lower sugar and added fiber and so are a better option than traditional sodas. However, they should not be considered a health food." Brian Bethke, founder of Bear Maple Farms, says, "We need more research. The benefits of eating whole-food sources of prebiotics are well-known, but there is a lack of peer-reviewed studies on prebiotic sodas. Plus, some sweeteners like stevia and erythritol may impact the microbiome in ways we don't fully understand. Bottom line: It's complicated."
The key issue is that what's marketed as a gut-healthy soda might not deliver the benefits you'd expect. The health benefits of prebiotics are well-documented (Health Effects and Sources of Prebiotic Dietary Fiber, 2018; Prebiotics: Definition, Types, Sources, Mechanisms, and Clinical Applications, 2019). However, many of these prebiotic soda options contain only trace amounts of these fiber-based nutrients. They really can't measure up to the benefits you get from whole-food sources of prebiotics.
As Cuomo explains, "Prebiotic sodas may contribute small amounts of fiber, but they are not a primary source of meaningful prebiotic intake. A diet rich in vegetables, legumes and whole grains provides significantly greater benefits for gut health, which is linked to decreased risk of heart disease and several cancers."
Dr. Amy Eloheim, a board-certified functional health practitioner, licensed holistic health practitioner and master herbalist, sums it up nicely: "A prebiotic soda can be a convenient way to support gut health, but it shouldn't be your only source of prebiotics."
What experts have to say about finding healthy soda alternatives
When you're looking for a healthy alternative to soda, you can keep an eye out for certain things.
Amy Lee, medical nutritionist and founder of Nucific, suggests, "Read the ingredients word by word and look for buzzwords that reflect sugar. There are over 70 names for sugar that can be found in processed foods. Also, look for preservatives used to keep soda fresh and retain color to give it the desired look and a certain flavor. I personally am not a fan of artificial sweeteners but noticed a lot of that being added to replace processed sugars."
Cuomo recommends avoiding artificial sweeteners altogether, along with "phosphoric acid, caramel coloring and preservatives, which may contribute to inflammation or metabolic disruption." He adds, "Consumers should prioritize low sugar content, ideally under 5 grams per serving, and check for actual fiber content."
Coca-Cola launched a new prebiotic soda, Simply Pop.
Coca-Cola Company
Clarke adds more specificity to what you should look for if you want your healthy soda to support gut health. "Check for specific fiber types (e.g., inulin, galactooligosaccharides [GOS]) and amounts. Brands advertising gut benefits should disclose fiber content prominently, ideally exceeding 4 to 5 grams per serving."
Let's distill that down into a checklist you can use as you shop for a healthy alternative to soda:
Less than 5 grams of sugar
Four or more grams of fiber, ideally with the specific types of fiber listed
No artificial sweeteners
No artificial coloring
No preservatives
No phosphoric acid
"Prebiotic sodas can be a fun and refreshing way to support gut health, but let's keep it in perspective -- they're not a replacement for a high-fiber diet or a panacea for digestion," Kaliga says. "Enjoy them as an occasional addition to your routine, but don't rely on them as your primary strategy for improving digestion."
How to make a healthy soda at homeThat prebiotic soda you were thinking about picking up might not work wonders for your gut health. If you're still searching for a better option, you can whip one up on your own. We tapped the experts to come up with some ingredients you can mix together to make a good alternative at home.
Soda water
Lee suggests starting with a base of soda water, to which you can add natural flavors. Since water is one of the nutrients the body critically needs, this helps your hydration levels. Clarke also points out that using unflavored sparkling water helps you avoid excess sodium and additives.
Prebiotic fibers
If you're looking to make a gut-healthy soda, add prebiotic fibers. Eloheim suggests chicory or acacia fiber. Cuomo also recommends chicory root and says inulin works. Clark says resistant potato starch can also mimic commercial prebiotics.
If you don't have any of those specific kinds of fiber on hand, Kaliga says you can use a bit of blended fiber-rich fruit like kiwi or banana.
Add enough to bring your homemade healthy soda to a meaningful amount of prebiotics. Aim for 5 grams or more.
Natural sweeteners
Plenty of natural sugar alternatives can sweeten your soda without harming your health. "Opt for 1 to 2 teaspoons of raw honey or maple syrup, which provide antioxidants and trace minerals without spiking glycemic levels," Clarke suggests.
Citrus juice
Some fresh citrus juice, like lemon or lime juice, can flavor your healthy soda and deliver benefits. Cuomo says these introduce some antioxidants, which protect your cells.
Herbs and spices
Eloheim suggests adding herbs and spices like cinnamon or mint "to enhance flavor and digestion." This can make your health soda taste more interesting without adding any excess sugar.
Kombucha
If you want to get some probiotic benefits with your prebiotic, Eloheim recommends adding a splash of kombucha to your drink. This introduces more "good" bacteria to support your gut health.
Roots
Several of our experts recommended adding ginger or turmeric. Cuomo says these ingredients will not only flavor your healthy soda but also deliver anti-inflammatory effects.
A sample healthy soda recipe
Clarke provided us with a sample recipe you can use to make a healthy alternative to soda at home. He says to combine:
8 ounces sparkling water
1 tablespoon lemon juice
1 teaspoon grated ginger
1 teaspoon honey
A pinch of sea salt
He recommends a final step for added health benefits: "Ferment for 12 to 24 hours to cultivate probiotics."
The bottom line
FrancescoHealthy soda brands' claims might be overhyped, especially when it comes to gut health. While prebiotic drinks can introduce some of these nutrients, they can't compete with whole foods.
You might still want to enjoy prebiotic soda as a little treat -- and a healthier alternative to traditional soda. To find the best one, make sure you read the label carefully. You want to see a lot of fiber and only a little bit of sugar.
But remember, as Clarke says, "Consumers should view these products as occasional supplements rather than substitutes for fiber-rich diets."
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Elle
a day ago
- Elle
I Tried Dozens of Shampoos—These Were the Only Ones That Fixed My Oily Hair
We've all heard people wax poetic about how not washing their hair every day has changed their lives. If you have oily hair, all you can really do is nod, smile, and congratulate them on their revelation. Truth is, when you have a scalp that churns out enough sebum to make your strands look greasy and lifeless just hours after you've shampooed, it feels like you have no choice but to cleanse every single day. 'Like our skin, our scalp naturally produces oil at varying degrees depending on the person. When a scalp produces oil, it moves down the hair shaft, creating a noticeable oily look,' says Tom Smith, the creative director of Evo Hair. Sure, dry shampoo can help, but that only disguises the issue rather than solving it. What if we told you that there's a solution that can get to the root of the problem? The best shampoos for oily hair are designed to cut through the grease and buildup. One rinse of the right formula can give your hair a new lease on life, ensuring your mane retains volume, restores movement, and remains oil-free for beyond 24 hours. After speaking with Smith, testing formulas on our own oily scalps, and analyzing customer reviews, we determined the 12 best shampoos for oily hair. Keep scrolling to discover your newest shower caddy staples. Apple cider vinegar has long been touted as a staple ingredient for detoxing your strands. Fekkai mixed ACV with ginger extract, pomegranate seed oil, vitamins, and more to nourish your hair as oils are washed away. Size: 8.5 fl oz Key ingredients: Apple cider vinegar How to use: Wet hair, use hands to lather product, apply to roots before massaging into scalp, rinse Ulta rating: 4.6/5 stars An Ulta reviewer said: 'I've been using this for over a year now and it's THE ONLY THING that combats my oily scalp and hair. It's gentle enough but gets the job done. I only use a tiny bit of it, and it's more than enough!' Hårklinikken is all about improving the hair by supporting the scalp. This shampoo from the Danish brand is formulated to break down excess sebum and maintain the health of the scalp's microbiome simultaneously. Your hair will be clean and fresh, but never stripped. Reviewers report that the product solved their itchy scalp issues as well. Key ingredients: Burdock root, glycosides How to use: Wet hair, apply to scalp, massage for 30 seconds, rinse Hårklinikken rating: 4.7/5 stars A Hårklinikken reviewer says: 'I love this shampoo! My scalp has stopped any itching but doesn't feel tight, and my hair never feels or looks greasy.' Kérastase's shampoo rids your hair of all oil and build-up without leaving your hair feeling stripped bare. Made with fine hair in mind, it nourishes from roots to ends and leaves strands soft and shiny. Size: 8.5 fl oz Key ingredients: Amino acids, vitamin B6 How to use: Wet hair, massage into scalp and strands, rinse, repeat one more time while focusing on mid-lengths and ends Sephora rating: 3.9/5 stars A Sephora reviewer said: 'I have oily scalp and had been using this since giving birth. This shampoo has helped my hair feel so soft, and scalp is still fresh after a day of not washing it. I've finally found my go-to shampoo!' If body and shine are what you're looking for, Ouai delivers that in one bottle. As one reviewer puts it, 'Your hair needs that reset from all the crap we put on our scalps, and this is the product to take you back to your natural shine and bounce.' Size: 10 fl oz Key ingredient: Apple cider vinegar How to use: Wet hair, squeeze out excess water, apply a quarter-size amount to scalp before letting it sit for 1–3 minutes, rinse Amazon rating: 4.6/5 stars An ELLE editor says: 'While I may not struggle with oily hair, I always reach for my Ouai Detox Shampoo after a busy weekend filled with hair styling, re-styling, dry shampoo, and hairspray. With just one wash, any oil and product buildup is completely gone, leaving my hair feeling oh so fresh and clean.'—Emma Aerin Becker, associate beauty e-commerce writer If you want your scalp to feel squeaky clean and your hair to smell like a dream, Cécred's Clarifying Shampoo & Scalp Scrub is your girl. The formula harnesses the cleansing powers of tea tree oil and gentle physical exfoliators as well as the scalp-supporting abilities of fermented willow bark and niacinamide to deep clean your roots whenever you need it. Key ingredients: Fermented purple willow bark, tea tree oil, microcrystalline cellulose, niacinamide How to use: Wet hair, massage into scalp for 2 minutes, work into hair, rinse Cécred rating: 4.9/5 stars An expert says: 'My hair has been oily all my life, and I inevitably end up washing my hair every day, even if I'm able to resist for a few months. This is the one shampoo I can always rely on to reset my scalp and get me back to cleansing my hair every few days instead of every 24 hours. I know that once I go in with this formula, any buildup or excess oils on my face will wash down the drain.' —Carol Lee, beauty writer Clarifying shampoos don't need to be packed with a slew of fancy ingredients for them to be effective. Sans any sulfates, Evo's formula tackles stubborn dirt and grease, making each wash better than the last. Size: 10.1 fl oz Key ingredients: Peppermint oil How to use: Wet hair, massage into scalp and strands, rinse Amazon rating: 4.2/5 stars An Amazon reviewer said: 'I asked my stylist to recommend something cruelty-free, that would be okay for my colored hair, and that would leave my scalp without any buildup. Definitely a fan!' Aside from targeting greasy hair, this gem from Ogx alleviates dry, itchy scalp. The shampoo is gentle enough for daily use and costs less than your typical clarifying shampoos. Size: 13 fl oz Key ingredients: Tea tree, peppermint oil, witch hazel How to use: Wet hair, massage product into scalp and strands, rinse Amazon rating: 4.5/5 stars An Amazon reviewer said: 'My hair recently started getting very oily again. This has definitely helped calm it down. I can actually go two days without washing my hair again.' Crack open this bottle and your bathroom will smell like luxury. This shampoo has every type of mint you can think of—peppermint, spearmint, and rosemary mint—to soothe the scalp and purify the hair from root to tip. Size: 8.5 fl oz Key ingredients: Rosemary, peppermint, and spearmint How to use: Wet hair, massage product into scalp and strands, rinse Nordstrom rating: 4.6/5 stars A Nordstrom reviewer said: 'My all time favorite shampoo. Gentle yet removes all the product build up. Wonderful, invigorating fragrance.' You'll be surprised (and freaked out) at how much gunk and oil can accumulate under your protective styles. The African Pride Braid & Scalp Cleansing Rinse is the antidote. Formulated with micellar water to break down dirt, as well as castor oil, coconut oil, and peppermint oil for nourishment and scalp stimulation, your hair and scalp get the TLC they need. Size: 12 oz Key ingredients: Black castor oil, micellar water, coconut oil, peppermint oil How to use: Adjust braids or weave to expose scalp, use nozzle to directly apply product onto scalp before massaging it in, rinse Amazon rating: 4.5/5 stars An ELLE editor says: 'I never want to return to a life before this scalp rinse was introduced to me. This is what I use before, during, and after my protective styles, mainly because I know my hair is getting a thorough cleanse while being properly nourished. Micellar water eliminates the gunk, and a blend of oils imparts moisture.'—Nerisha Penrose, beauty commerce editor Sachajuan's shampoo treats your scalp just as well as you treat your face. With salicylic acid, your scalp gets a good clean that gets rid of dandruff and dryness. Size: 8.4 fl oz Key ingredients: Salicylic acid How to use: Wet hair, massage into scalp and hair, leave in for 1–2 minutes before rinsing Dermstore rating: 4.5/5 stars A Dermstore reviewer said: 'This is the only shampoo I keep coming back to for the past 20 or so years. Nothing compares to the clean, bouncy feel of my hair, but the main attraction is the absolutely delicious fragrance. Any time I hug someone, they exclaim how good my hair smells. It cheers me up every time I wash my hair.' Good hair starts with a healthy scalp, which is why the nozzle on this bottle is a godsend. Using the nozzle, apply the product directly to your scalp and lather it down your strands to remove any build-up from root to tip. Size: 16.9 fl ozKey ingredient: Aloe How to use: Wet hair, apply directly onto scalp, massage product into scalp and strands, rinse Amazon rating: 4.5/5 starsAn Amazon reviewer said: 'My hair usually gets really greasy, and this product helps my hair feel squeaky clean. I used to have issues with my scalp smelling weird, but this liquid shampoo really helped me with that. I don't use this daily though, because I feel like it dries out your scalp. So I only use it once my hair is really greasy.' If you're yearning for fresh hair that lasts, Oribe's Serene Scalp Oil Control Shampoo may be the shampoo for you. The brand's biome balancing complex regulates and rebalances the scalp's microbiome to reduce sebum production and promote a healthy scalp. Key ingredients: Rosebay extract, green marine algae, biomimetic amino acid How to use: Wet hair, massage into scalp and hair, rinse Amazon rating: 4.2/5 An Amazon reviewer said: 'The Oribe Serene Scalp Oil Control Shampoo and Conditioner are game-changers! They leave my scalp feeling clean and refreshed without over-drying, and my hair stays oil-free for much longer. The scent is luxurious, and my hair feels soft, light, and healthy. Worth every penny!' Tom Smith is the creative director of Evo Hair. Because the hair has so much build-up, you should opt for shampoos that can properly cleanse greasy hair while also being gentle enough to maintain the hair's health. Smith says, 'I recommend using a gentle but deep cleansing shampoo. If you have oily hair, shampooing the hair properly is also essential. Shampoo twice and make sure you work it into an even lather on the scalp. Rinse for about 30 seconds longer than you think you need to so that all the product really washes out.' 'Cheaper drugstore shampoos tend to use low-grade silicones and waxes to make your hair feel really soft, but what these ingredients actually do is build upon the hair and suffocate the cuticle, which makes the hair feel slimy over time,' Smith adds. The number of times you wash your hair depends on your routine and hair type. 'Some people's scalps produce more oil than others, so it can take a lot of trial and error to figure out the best schedule for you. It is ok to wash your hair every day if you need to, as long as you're using good quality products that aren't going to leave a residue on your hair,' Smith says. As a leading publisher of fashion, lifestyle, and beauty content, is committed to highlighting the best products in various categories by personally testing the latest and most innovative products, interviewing countless experts, and vetting customer-loved items. For this piece, ELLE editors spoke to a hair expert, tested formulas, and combed through customer reviews to find the best shampoos for oily hair.
Fox News
a day ago
- Fox News
Poppi Settles "Gut Healthy" Lawsuit
Popular 'bad soda' alternative 'Poppi' isn't as good for you as they had you believe… I'm Tomi Lahren, more next. So we all know soda pop isn't the best for ya, but what about those cleverly marketed 'better for you' brands like Poppi? Well, not so fast. Plaintiffs claim in their class action lawsuit that the actual amount of prebiotic fiber present in one can of the Poppi beverage is 'too low to cause meaningful gut health benefits.' And now, the company has agreed to a nearly $9 million dollar settlement over those claims the soda is 'gut healthy.' So, that means, if you've purchased a Poppi soda since 2020, you can submit a claim to receive a portion of the settlement. But don't get too excited, you can only receive up to $16 per household – unless you show proof of purchase But hey, $16 bucks is still $16 bucks! With that you can buy yourself some good ole fashioned Diet Coke or maybe a couple gallons of milk! I'm Tomi Lahren and you can watch my show 'Tomi Lahren is Fearless' at Learn more about your ad choices. Visit
USA Today
a day ago
- USA Today
What's the difference between Diet Coke and Coke Zero?
Most of us know how refreshing and satisfying a Coke can be. Whether it's poured over ice on a hot summer day, is accompanying a burger and fries at lunch or is sipped alongside a tub of buttery popcorn during a blockbuster movie, it's a beverage that has a way of hitting the spot. But no one drinks a can of cola thinking it's actually good for them. Among the many Coca-Cola varieties that include Classic, Diet, Zero Sugar and flavored options like Cherry Coke and Vanilla Coke, one is probably better for your health than the others. Here's what's different and similar between the most popular varieties of Coca-Cola, plus which ones are likely to cause the fewest issues for your health goals in the long run. What is Coca-Cola? Is there a difference between Coca-Cola and Coke? Coca-Cola is more than just a soft drink; it's a global brand empire. Founded in 1886 in Atlanta, the company has grown into the world's largest beverage corporation, boasting over 200 iconic brands. In addition to its flagship cola, Coca-Cola owns well-known drinks like Sprite, Fanta, Powerade, Minute Maid, and even the bottled water brand Dasani. Its most iconic product, Coca-Cola Classic (usually just called Coke), is a carbonated soft drink made primarily of carbonated water, high-fructose corn syrup (or cane sugar in some countries), caramel coloring, phosphoric acid, caffeine and unspecified 'natural flavors,' according to its nutrition label. Sometimes cherry- or vanilla-flavored syrup are also added to the formulation for Cherry Coke and Vanilla Coke varieties. Thanks to its sweetness, distinct flavor, caffeine content and fizz, Classic Coke has become one of the most consumed beverages worldwide. But its high sugar content has also made it and other sugary drinks a frequent target of health experts. 'Regular sodas are one of the leading sources of added sugars in the American diet,' says Caroline Susie, a registered dietitian and national spokesperson for the Academy of Nutrition and Dietetics. Indeed, a single 20-ounce bottle of Classic Coke contains a staggering 65 grams of added sugars, which is about 130% the recommended daily limit. In response to growing concerns over sugar intake, Coca-Cola introduced Diet Coke in 1982 and Coke Zero in 2005. (The same drink was rebranded as Coca-Cola Zero Sugar in 2017, though it's still often called Coke Zero). Both options are sugar-free, using artificial sweeteners instead. But both varieties do differ in formulation: Diet Coke uses only aspartame and has its own distinct flavor, while Coke Zero combines aspartame with acesulfame potassium – and sometimes stevia – giving it a flavor profile some consumers feel is closer to Coca-Cola Classic, explains Kristina Cooke, a licensed nutritionist specializing in diabetes treatment and prevention. 'Healthiest' sugar substitute? What to know after new aspartame, erythritol studies. Is Diet Coke bad for you? No dietitian, nutritionist or physician would classify either Diet Coke or Coke Zero as healthy, but many would call them healthier alternatives to regular soda. At the same time, even as they eliminate added sugars, some of the sugar substitutes they contain come with controversies of their own. For instance, in 2023, the World Health Organization's International Agency for Research on Cancer classified aspartame as 'possibly carcinogenic to humans,' citing limited evidence linking high intake to liver cancer in some studies. Despite this, major regulatory agencies including the U.S. Food & Drug Administration (FDA) and the European Food Safety Authority (EFSA) continue to deem aspartame safe when consumed in moderation. Still, the science isn't settled. And there are other considerations as well including additional research that has raised concerns that high consumption of artificial sweeteners may increase appetite, disrupt gut bacteria and even contribute to insulin resistance. Though these effects tend to be subtle and depend heavily on individual factors, they cast some doubt on the assumption that diet soda supports weight loss or is better for overall health. Meanwhile, the health concerns surrounding Classic, Cherry and Vanilla Coke's high sugar content are more clear-cut. Excess sugar intake is strongly linked to obesity, type 2 diabetes, fatty liver disease and heart disease. Regardless of the variety being diet or otherwise, Susie emphasizes that soda offers 'zero essential nutrients' and often displaces healthier beverage options like water, milk or unsweetened tea. Noted: Americans drink a staggering amount of Diet Coke, other sodas. What does it do to our stomachs? What is the healthiest Coke? If you're looking to choose between all these less-than-ideal options, the 'healthiest' Coke is probably Coke Zero Sugar, but only by a small margin. That's largely because Classic Coke (and its flavored Cherry and Vanilla varieties) are not only loaded with added sugars but also has a significant number of empty calories. A 20-ounce bottle of Classic Coke contains about 240 calories, energy that's quickly burned without the benefit of fiber or other nutrients and sometimes leading to glucose spikes, sugar crashes and weight gain. Both Diet Coke and Coke Zero Sugar sidestep these problems by being both calorie- and sugar-free. 'That alone makes them better choices,' Cooke says. And since both contain the same amount of aspartame, the risks associated with artificial sweeteners are similar either way. Where Coke Zero has a slight edge though is in its lower caffeine content: 34 milligrams per 12-ounce can compared to 46 milligrams of caffeine in Diet Coke. While moderate amounts of caffeine are generally considered safe, excessive intake may contribute to anxiety, disrupted sleep and elevated heart rate and blood pressure. Despite this edge, either Diet Coke or Coke Zero is almost certainly a smarter pick than the classic or flavored varieties. 'For those aiming to reduce added sugar intake, especially for weight management or diabetes, diet soda can be a reasonable alternative to regular soda,' Susie says. But quantity may ultimately matter more than whichever variety you choose. 'Rather than focusing on which of these beverage options someone chooses, I help people focus on how often they drink soda and how much they consume as part of their overall eating pattern,' says Shelley Rael, a registered dietitian and nutritionist based in Albuquerque, New Mexico. 'A Coke or a Diet Coke here and there isn't a dealbreaker for health; it's daily or excessive intake that is the bigger concern."
