Garda Commissioner role: Long-serving senior members not in running due to pension tax concerns
The deadline for applications to become the next commissioner of
An Garda Síochána
has passed and the longest-serving senior members of the force are understood not to have applied for the job.
None of the serving assistant commissioners who have spent their entire policing careers in the Garda have applied, sources said, with this in large part due to what they see as an onerous tax exposure on their pensions should they succeed
Drew Harris
and serve the full five-year term.
The Irish Times understands Deputy Commissioner Justin Kelly has applied for the position, while sources said Deputy Commissioner
Shawna Coxon
has also done so.
Ms Coxon declined to comment on the matter when asked by journalists at an event in Dublin last week. She was appointed deputy commissioner in April 2021, having previously been
deputy chief officer in the Toronto Police
in Canada.
READ MORE
Deputy Garda Commissioner Justin Kelly. Photograph: Colin Keegan/Collins
The recruitment process is confidential, meaning a list of the candidates who applied will not be disclosed.
The advertisement for the job stated that
applications were welcome from candidates with 'policing, security or civilian backgrounds'
.
But Minister for Justice
Jim O'Callaghan
recently said he would be
unwilling to recommend to Government any candidate
for the commissioner job who does not have previous policing experience.
The deadline for applying for the position passed last Thursday and Mr O'Callaghan said he expected a candidate would be selected by mid-July. He said his intention was that the new commissioner would be in place to take over from Mr Harris when he retires on September 1st.
The recruitment process is being run by Public Jobs, formerly the Public Appointments Service. When a successful candidate emerges from that process, they must be recommended by Mr O'Callaghan to the Cabinet for final approval.
[
Outgoing Garda Commissioner's legacy one of 'mistrust and fear', says GRA head
Opens in new window
]
In reply to queries, the
Department of Justice
said the advertisement for the job stated a 'track record of leadership and success in a policing role is desirable'.
It added that any candidate not currently serving in the Garda – including those from other jurisdictions – would be 'required to attest as a member' before taking up the role of commissioner.
They would also be required to 'make a solemn declaration to uphold the Constitution and the laws of the State' in order to 'provide strong reassurance of commitment to our nation'.
Mr Harris was appointed commissioner in October 2018 for a five-year term, which was extended by a further two years.
More recently, he was offered a second extension, of three months, to facilitate the completion of the recruitment process to find his successor.
That competition was delayed because the Garda oversight agencies with a role in preparing the process – the Garda board and the Policing and Community Safety Authority – did not commence operations until April 1st following a reconfiguration of Garda oversight bodies.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Times
38 minutes ago
- Irish Times
HAP caps should be revised regularly to reflect rental market, Ombudsman says
Overly complex processes and the duplication of work by local authorities causing delays to housing assistance payment (HAP) applications, alongside the refusal of legitimate applications, were among the issues discovered by an Ombudsman investigation. Ombudsman Ger Deering said his office received numerous complaints from the public, and identified shortcomings through voluntary housing and homeless groups regarding the scheme before its investigation. Launched in 2014, the HAP payment to landlords was intended to cover the full cost of a household's rent. Due to significant increases in rent rates, however, two-thirds of HAP households were paying the difference between the HAP cap and the actual cost of rent in 2023. Some 53,742 households were in receipt of HAP at the end of 2024, meaning the same number of rentals have been removed from the private rental sector, the Ombudsman said, contributing to a sustained increase in the rate of rents. READ MORE The availability of rental properties coming under the HAP limits is declining as rents increase, prompting a recommendation from the Ombudsman that caps should be revised on a regular basis to reflect the rental market. [ More than 100 families in Dublin at risk of homelessness as tenant-in-situ applications paused Opens in new window ] Among the findings of its investigation into HAP's administration was a 'duplication of work' being done by local authorities resulting in potential delays. Although households approved for social housing support are immediately eligible for HAP, they must make separate applications, resulting in repetition. The report also highlighted the 'overly complex' requirement for local authorities to seek approval from the HAP shared services centre (SSC) before amendments to HAP records or applications for approval can be made. It noted that the SSC processed 5,821 amendments in one sample month during the investigation. The investigation also found further 'unnecessary delays' when it comes to validating applications and verifying landlords' proof of ownership. Delays increase the risk of inability to secure properties, it said. Separately, the Ombudsman found that some local authorities are refusing HAP applications despite all evidence suggesting a tenancy is legitimate, while others have approved HAP where it should not have been. Local authorities have 'broad discretion' when determining whether a tenancy is genuine, with decisions not always accounting for each case being different or nuanced. In particular, it said local authorities place 'undue weight on family relationships even where all other evidence suggests the tenancy is legitimate'. Separately, despite being legislatively considered socially housed, HAP tenants do not have access to the same benefits as their counterparts in standard social housing such as tailored arrears repayment plans. These inequities pose a risk of HAP tenants falling into a 'poverty trap,' it said. 'This unfairness is compounded by the fact that they do not have the security of tenure that their counterparts in other forms of social housing have,' the Ombudsman said.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
‘Why are there all these mistakes?' Woman laments loss of daughter and unborn grandson as hospital apologises
Tipperary University Hospital has apologised to the family of a woman for shortcomings in care which led to her death and that of her unborn baby. Caroline Kavanagh was 22 weeks pregnant with her second child when she first presented at the Clonmel hospital's emergency department with chest pain. Dr John O'Mahony SC, for Ms Kavanagh's family, told the High Court the 37-year-old was misdiagnosed and her heart attack symptoms were not identified or addressed before she was discharged home. In what counsel described as a 'heartbreaking and extremely sad case', Ms Kavanagh was found unresponsive five days later in bed at her home in Kilmallock, Co Limerick and was later pronounced dead. READ MORE 'Her mother came to her home and found her daughter motionless in bed. Caroline had died and the baby she was carrying died with his mother,' counsel said. Dr O'Mahony, instructed by Ciaran O'Keeffe solicitor, said there was unfortunately a misdiagnosis at the hospital. He said there was a mistaken belief that an elevated level of the protein Troponin in the blood was due to pregnancy when it can also point to cardiovascular issues. Margaret Kavanagh holds a Mass card for her daughter Caroline and unborn grandson TJ outside the High Court in Dublin. Photograph: Collins Courts The letter of apology was read in court as Ms Kavnagh's mother Margaret Kavanagh, of Cashel, Co Tipperary, settled a High Court action against the HSE over her daughter's death on February 11th, 2015. In the letter, interim hospital manager Ailish Delaney expressed 'our profound sympathy and condolences to you on the loss of your daughter Caroline and her unborn child'. It added: 'The management and staff of the hospital apologise sincerely for the shortcomings in the care which was provided to Caroline and which led to her tragic death. The hospital wishes to acknowledge the heartache and distress suffered by her family because of her premature passing and to express our sincere sympathy and regret.' A breach of duty was admitted by the HSE in the case. Noting the settlement, and the division of the statutory €35,000 mental distress payment, Mr Justice Paul Coffey extended his deepest sympathy to the family. At the time of her death, Ms Kavanagh's daughter Megan was just nine-months-old. Speaking outside the court, Margaret Kavanagh said it had taken the family 10 years to get justice for Caroline, but the apology would not bring back her daughter or her unborn baby. 'While we acknowledge the apology from the HSE, as a family we believe that if the past mistakes that were made had had been corrected we would not be here today,' she said. She said Caroline was very much looking forward to the birth of her second child, to be named Thomas James (TJ) and was 'a great mother, daughter, sister and just a great person'. 'Why are there all these mistakes? We are in the 21st century and we seem to be going backwards,' Mrs Kavanagh added, clutching a picture of her daughter worn in a pendant around her neck. She said she dhe hoped no family would in future have to go through 'the pain and loss we have experienced in the last 10 years'. In the proceedings it was claimed a correct diagnosis of acute heart attack was not made and Caroline Kavanagh was not offered appropriate cardiac care to significantly improve her chances of survival when she attended the hospital on February 6th, 2015. She died of complications of heart attack on February 11th, 2015. It was claimed substandard care was provided and she did not have an echocardiogram. She was started on cardioprotective medication on admission to hospital but these were stopped on discharge.
Irish Times
an hour ago
- Irish Times
Protest announced following Wicklow County Council decision not to repaint rainbow crossing
A rainbow crossing on the Main Street of Arklow, Co Wicklow , will be allowed to fade away after Wicklow County Council said it would not repaint the colours. The crossing, featuring rainbow colours painted on each side of a standard pedestrian crossing, symbolises an inclusive and safe space for members of the LGBTQ+ community and others. In recent years, a number of local authorities have painted rainbow crossings, sometimes called Pride crossings, to show support for the LGBTQ+ community. This was done, at least in part, as a response to physical attacks on members of the LGBTQ+ community. Arklow was among the first towns in Ireland to install a 'permanent' rainbow crossing in December 2021. It followed Dublin City Council's painting of a rainbow crossing outside Pantibar on Capel Street, Dublin city centre. Similar crossings have been installed in Limerick , Cork , Galway , Carlow, Portlaoise, Co Laois, and Edenderry, Co Offaly, among other locations. READ MORE Dublin has multiple rainbow crossings, particularly along a route in the city which Fáilte Ireland calls the 'Rainbow Mile', taking in Dame Street, George's Street and Parliament Street. In its annual report for 2021, Wicklow County Council said: 'Arklow leads the way by installing the first Pride crossing in the Republic of Ireland.' The report said the 'Arklow Municipal District, Arklow town team and its elected members are very proud to show their support for the LGBTQ+ community'... with 'the installation of a Pride crossing on Main Street'. The remarks were repeated in the council's 2022 annual report. However, at a recent meeting of the Arklow Municipal District, members were told the crossing will not be repainted and will be allowed to fade away. We cannot allow Ireland's first permanent Pride rainbow crossing to be scrubbed from existence — Dave Thomas In response to questions from The Irish Times, the council said support for the community would instead be shown through other actions, possibly a painted bench. In a statement, the council said: 'Arklow Municipal District have no plans to remove the crossing, however they are not in a position to refresh the paint having regard to current legislation.' The council said it continues to support diversity and inclusion, but added that 'pedestrian crossings are regulatory road markings and as such, it is not open to Wicklow County Council to ignore the detailed specifications set out'. [ Forget hope. Be a hopeful pessimist instead Opens in new window ] [ The Macron shove is not a sign of a very French love story, but something more disturbing Opens in new window ] Filmmaker and Wicklow Pride co-founder Dave Thomas, who led a five-year campaign to have the crossing installed, said the relevant legislation relates to safety and this had been audited before the rainbow crossing was put in. Mr Thomas said: 'We are asking the public, our allies and our leaders to speak up. We cannot allow Ireland's first permanent Pride rainbow crossing to be scrubbed from existence. To do so would be an act of erasure – not just of colour on tarmac, but of the lives, identities and contributions of LGBTQIA+ people across this country." A demonstration in support of retaining the rainbow crossing will be held at the band stand in Arklow this Saturday, June 7th, at 2pm.
