logo
What it would look like if the Giants were sellers at the trade deadline

What it would look like if the Giants were sellers at the trade deadline

New York Times21-07-2025
If you're an optimist, you're convinced the Giants are just having a bad week. Here's a better trade deadline article for you. And you might be right. It's been a brutal start to the second half, but it hasn't been a disqualifying one. It's certainly magnified by the long break and anticipation that comes with a new half, but that doesn't mean it's more than a lousy couple of games.
Advertisement
If you're a pessimist, friend, are you in the right spot. Because there's a chance that this team stinks. I'm pretty sure they're a better team than they've been over their last few games. But they also might stink. They might keep stinking over the next two weeks. When the deadline arrives, it's possible that they could be several games back of multiple teams for the final wild-card spot. It would be much harder to pretend that an all-in strategy is viable, and the phone would start to ring.
Oh, how that phone might ring if the Giants keep stinking.
The Giants wouldn't suddenly be the belles of the deadline ball if they decided to sell. They wouldn't want to move a lot of their best players, and a lot of those players are under contracts that would scare teams away in the first place. But they would certainly have players to offer if their season went south.
Here's a look at the roster, sorted roughly according to how close each player is to free agency. The Giants aren't likely to trade franchise cornerstones, but they'll certainly consider proposals for pending free agents in this scenario, for example.
• Rafael Devers
• Willy Adames
• Matt Chapman
• Jung Hoo Lee
• Logan Webb
They're very different players in very different situations having very different seasons. But one thing they have in common is that they aren't getting traded. This is why the rest of the league wouldn't be that excited if the Giants suddenly became sellers. The players who can most help other teams are the same ones who are supposed to help the 2026 Giants. They're all staying.
• Camilo Doval
• Robbie Ray
If you have greedy designs on other teams' prospects, these are the players to consider. Both of them would absolutely interest a lot of contending teams around the league, and considering that Ray is under contract through next season and Doval through the season after that, their value would be relatively … robust? They're not going to rebuild the foundation of the entire Giants organization with the prospects they might get by trading either player.
And that's if they sell. Which they're still really unlikely to do as of now. Feels like a disclaimer every so often will help us catch our breath. If they do, though, Doval and Ray are the players to watch the closest.
• Justin Verlander
• Mike Yastrzemski
• Tyler Rogers
• Wilmer Flores
• Dominic Smith
There would still be plenty of potential value here, too. It would be in the Giants' best interests to sign Tyler Rogers to a five-year deal with five team options after that, but it's possible I'm biased. And you know a lot of teams would like to add him to their bullpen for October.
Advertisement
It's not unthinkable that a team would take Verlander as-is, no money down. He's been unlucky, and the market is going to be thin, with even the half-decent pitchers getting plenty of interest. And the outfield market is even thinner than the pitching market, so Yastrzemski could certainly attract attention.
The clubhouse glue market? It's always booming. Flores would help more than a couple teams.
The Giants are hoping all of the above players will be helping the Giants over the next two weeks and make all of these words unnecessary, of course. It's time for another disclaimer break. Not trying to be a downer with this deadline preview, just a practical service journalist.
• Pretty much everyone else
These are the youngest players, from Heliot Ramos to Patrick Bailey to Randy Rodríguez to Casey Schmitt. The Giants would want more in exchange for them than other teams would give up, and rightfully so. They're supposed to help now and in the near future. There's no rush to trade any of them.
It's certainly not impossible that some of these names come up as the Giants get deeper into trade talks with other teams, but an actual trade remains supremely unlikely.
It would be an interesting trade deadline if the Giants decided to sell, but not enough to turn around the farm system all at once. Plus, don't forget they'd rather win and be buyers at the deadline in the first place.
The Giants would get offered at least one top-100 prospect for Ray, considering he's not a rental. Doval's streakiness might freak out teams that are looking toward October, but he still has an elite arm that a lot of pitching coaches and managers would love to have. Beyond those two are plenty of pending free agents who could help a team. It wouldn't be a boring deadline.
Advertisement
Another idea is for the Giants to start playing better and win a few games. Possibly even a few games in a row. It's way more fun to talk about them acquiring players. Just wait until you read my four-team mock trade involving Carlos Correa coming home to the Giants.
Until then, it would look something like this: A chunk of the core making a lot of money for a long time. Another chunk of the core making a lot less money for a long time. And a sweet spot in the middle, with players who would appeal to contending teams for both this season and possibly next.
Or, again, the Giants could simply pitch better. And hit better. And definitely pitch better in the games when they are hitting better, and vice versa. That's still the preferred option for a lot of folks, and a lot of people are hoping they'll give it the ol' college try.
Prospects would be fun, too. One day, they might be as good as the players the Giants would be trading away, after all. And if 'tis the season to rebuild the farm, here's how the Giants would do it.
Though they would prefer not to try. Feels worth mentioning, at least in passing.
(Top photo of Camilo Doval: Ezra Shaw / Getty Images)
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Pirates sending 3B Ke'Bryan Hayes to Reds for reliever Rogers, prospect Stafura, AP source says
Pirates sending 3B Ke'Bryan Hayes to Reds for reliever Rogers, prospect Stafura, AP source says

Yahoo

time20 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Pirates sending 3B Ke'Bryan Hayes to Reds for reliever Rogers, prospect Stafura, AP source says

PITTSBURGH (AP) — The Pittsburgh Pirates are trading Gold Glove-winning third baseman Ke'Bryan Hayes to Cincinnati for veteran reliever Taylor Rogers and shortstop prospect Sammy Stafura, a person with knowledge of the deal told The Associated Press on Wednesday. The person spoke to the AP on condition of anonymity because the trade was not official. The swap gives the Reds an elite defender at the hot corner with a manageable contract. The 28-year-old Hayes, a Gold Glove winner in 2023, has five-plus years left on the extension he signed with Pittsburgh in 2022 and will make $7 million in 2026 and 2027, $8 million in 2028 and 2029 before rising to $12 million in 2030. Hayes, the son of former major leaguer Charlie Hayes and a first-round draft pick by the Pirates in 2015, has struggled to find consistency at the plate since his splashy debut during the final month of the COVID-19-shortened season in 2020. He hit .376 with five homers in 24 games immediately after being called up, numbers that he didn't come close to matching while playing a full 162-game schedule. Hayes is hitting .236 with two home runs and 36 RBIs this season for the Pirates, who sit in last place in the NL Central thanks largely to an offense that ranks near the bottom or at the bottom in the majors in most significant statistical categories. The Pirates have several internal option to replace Hayes in the short-term, including Jared Triolo, who won a Gold Glove as a utility infielder in 2024. Isiah Kiner-Falefa, Pittsburgh's everyday shortstop this season, moved over to third for the Pirates' series-finale against San Francisco on Thursday. Rogers remains an effective left-handed option out of the bullpen at 34. The 10-year veteran, an All-Star with Minnesota in 2021, is 2-2 with a 2.45 ERA in 40 appearances with the Reds this season. Stafura, 20, was a second-round pick by Cincinnati in 2023. He is hitting .262 with four home runs and 48 RBIs in 88 games with Class A Daytona this season. ___ AP MLB:

5 takeaways from Day 5 of Broncos training camp
5 takeaways from Day 5 of Broncos training camp

Yahoo

time20 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

5 takeaways from Day 5 of Broncos training camp

The Denver Broncos had a special guest at training camp on Wednesday. Emmanuel Sanders, who played for the club from 2014-2019, visited Broncos Park Powered by CommonSpirit with his son for Day 5 of practice. Sanders, who retired in 2022, played under Sean Payton with the New Orleans Saints in 2020. A two-time Pro Bowler and a Super Bowl 50 champion, Sanders hauled in 704 receptions for 9,245 yards and 51 touchdowns during his 12-year career in the NFL. He also rushed for 202 yards and a score and went 3-of-3 passing for 78 yards and two touchdowns. Sanders ranks 10th on Denver's all-time receiving list with 5,361 yards, and his 28 touchdown catches rank 13th in franchise history. Now, here are five quick takeaways from Wednesday's practice. Broncos training camp takeaways Day 5 1. Broncos injury report: Wide receiver A.T. Perry (ankle; PUP) and linebackers Drew Sanders (foot) and Alex Singleton (thumb) are still sidelined. Additionally, receiver Devaughn Vele and rookie outside linebacker Que Robinson did not practice. Payton did not speak to the media Wednesday, so there's no update on the status of Vele and Robinson. 2. Blake Watson adds intrigue to running back battle: J.K. Dobbins and RJ Harvey are the obvious top two options in Denver's backfield. Behind them? Good luck trying to guess Payton's depth chart. Audric Estime was just drafted last year, Jaleel McLaughlin was one of the team's most productive RBs last fall and the team has praised Tyler Badie this offseason. Oh, yeah, there's Watson, too! The second-year undrafted RB took a big hit from undrafted rookie linebacker Jordan Turner on Wednesday, but he also drew strong reviews for his day on the ground overall. How many RBs will Denver carry on the 53-man roster? Is there room for Watson? We'll find out in late August. 3. Two young linebackers stepping up: We noted yesterday that Levelle Bailey has impressed with Sanders (foot) and Singleton (thumb) injured. Bailey continues to look sharp, but he's not alone. Jordan Turner, a UDFA out of Michigan State, has also stood out at linebacker. It sounds like the Broncos will have a very interesting linebacker battle during preseason this summer. 4. Trent Sherfield buzz continues to grow: When Denver signed Sherfield this spring, the expectation was that he was primarily brought in for his special teams contributions. The 29-year-old receiver continues to make plays on offense, though, and the hype is growing. 'He's tough, and he can run," Payton said of Sherfield last weekend. "The other thing he can do is block, and so we've always had a handful of receivers that can run and stretch the field and when you get one that can do that and then block also, you can set up play action, marries well to the run game. He's pretty competitive.' After losing Lil'Jordan Humphrey this offseason, the Broncos might have found their replacement in Sherfield. 5. Bo Nix's mobility remains a strength: Nix rushed for 430 yards and four touchdowns on 92 carries last season, averaging 4.7 yards per tote. "It's a strength," Payton said Tuesday when asked about Nix's mobility. "I mentioned this before, when the combine came, he didn't shuttle. He didn't do a number of these drills that I thought he would be exceptional at. Later, he told me he had a turf toe, and it made sense. But when you watched him, you thought, 'This guy is tough to sack.' He won a lot of downs for us last year with his feet." Nix only took 24 sacks last season -- an impressive total for a rookie -- as he proved to be an elusive NFL quarterback. The Broncos will be back on the field tomorrow (Thursday) as they continue camp (view the full schedule). Social: Follow Broncos Wire on Facebook and Twitter/X! Did you know: These 25 celebrities are Broncos fans. This article originally appeared on Broncos Wire: Denver Broncos: 5 takeaways from Day 5 of training camp

Pittsburgh Pirates trade Ke'Bryan Hayes to Reds for reliever, infield prospect
Pittsburgh Pirates trade Ke'Bryan Hayes to Reds for reliever, infield prospect

Yahoo

time20 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Pittsburgh Pirates trade Ke'Bryan Hayes to Reds for reliever, infield prospect

This article originally appeared on The Pittsburgh Pirates have traded Gold Glove third baseman Ke'Bryan Hayes to the division-rival Cincinnati Reds, a source confirmed to Pittsburgh Baseball Now. Hayes, is in the fourth year of an eight-year, $70 million contract extension signed shortly after the start of the 2022 season. The 28-year-old was in his sixth overall season with the Pirates after they selected him with the 32nd pick of the 2015 draft out of Concordia Lutheran High School in Texas. In 576 career games with the Pirates, Hayes posted a .254/.307/.369 batting line with 101 doubles, 16 triples, 39 home runs, 212 RBI and 61 stolen bases. His best season came in 2023, when he hit .271 with a .762 OPS while setting career-highs in doubles (31), triples (7), home runs (15) and RBI (61). In return for Hayes, the Pirates will get left-handed reliever Taylor Rogers and infield prospect Sammy Stafura. Click here to read more from Download the FREE WPXI News app for breaking news alerts. Follow Channel 11 News on Facebook and Twitter. | Watch WPXI NOW

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store