Did Kumar Dharmasena Secretly Help England? Umpires DRS Signal In IND Vs ENG 5th Test Sparks Cheating Controversy
https://t.co/04PYjgM7su pic.twitter.com/LJuKFV5Own — Star Sports (@StarSportsIndia) July 31, 2025
The incident unfolded in the 13th over of India's innings, when Josh Tongue bowled a lethal inswinging yorker to Sai Sudharsan. The ball struck Sudharsan low on the pad, and England immediately went up in a loud LBW appeal. While it initially appeared the delivery was going down leg, Dharmasena's response added a layer of confusion—and controversy.
Suspicious Gesture Raises Eyebrows
Instead of a neutral stance, Dharmasena subtly pointed to his finger, appearing to indicate an inside edge. This small but significant gesture saw England refrain from taking the review—a move that would later prove crucial, as replays confirmed that the ball had indeed nicked Sudharsan's bat before hitting the pad.
This moment, seemingly minor in real-time, set the cricketing world abuzz. Many fans and former players questioned whether an umpire's job was to impartially adjudicate or to subtly guide teams during DRS decisions—especially when each team only has three unsuccessful reviews per innings.
History Repeats? Similarities with the 2008 Sydney Test
The controversy reminded cricket followers of the infamous 2008 Sydney Test, where umpires Steve Bucknor and Mark Benson were heavily criticised for a series of poor decisions against India. Eight incorrect calls were recorded in that Test, many of which tilted the momentum in Australia's favour, leading to widespread outrage and a formal complaint from the BCCI.
While Dharmasena's case isn't as dramatic or deliberate, the integrity of umpiring once again finds itself under scrutiny. The rise of DRS was meant to minimise human error—but when umpires subtly hint at what they've seen, it raises ethical concerns about indirectly influencing the game's outcome.
Sanjay Bangar Slams 'Second Nature Habits'
Reacting to the incident on Star Sports, former India all-rounder Sanjay Bangar minced no words in criticising Dharmasena. 'These habits don't go away easily,' Bangar said. 'Back when Dharmasena started umpiring, there was no DRS. But today, such gestures are not acceptable. The umpire's body language should remain neutral, especially during that critical 15-second window.'
Bangar's frustration echoed that of fans who felt India might have been disadvantaged by the umpire's subtle prompt to England.
Anil Chaudhary Defends Dharmasena: 'It Happens in Flow'
Amid the criticism, Indian umpire Anil Chaudhary came to Dharmasena's defence. In an interview with MyKhel, Chaudhary said, 'It just happens by mistake. No umpire at this level will do it deliberately. Sometimes, in the flow of the game, we forget the presence of DRS and react instinctively.'
While his defence was measured and empathetic, it still underscores the need for stricter adherence to umpiring protocol in the DRS era, especially in high-stakes games.
Impact on the Series & Cricketing Trust
This wasn't just a flashpoint for social media outrage—it added fuel to the broader conversation about trust in umpiring. With the IND vs ENG Test series already full of heated moments, this controversy further heightened tensions. While India ended Day 1 with a steady top-order start, the DRS drama could've easily altered the course of the innings had England opted to review.
As cricket evolves with technology, incidents like these emphasize that human influence, even unintentional, still shapes the game. The ICC may now have to revisit protocols and training for umpires, particularly regarding non-verbal communication during reviews.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
India.com
4 hours ago
- India.com
Ideally Not For Surgery For Now But...: Chris Woakes Gives Major Update On His Dislocated Shoulder Ahead Of Ashes Series
After a gruelling Test series against India which ended in 2-2 draw, England will shift their attention to the Ashes Down Under later this year and experienced pacer Chris Woakes has shared a major update on his shoulder injury. Woakes, who sustained a dislocated shoulder while fielding during the fifth Test against India earlier this month, believes he's recovering better than he anticipated. Speaking on the sidelines of The Hundred, the England quick made an appearance without an arm sling. "Certainly good news for me. That's the best way to look at it. Obviously out of the sling and feel like I can move it a lot better now which is good two weeks down the line," Woakes told Sky Sports. "I suppose once you get a little bit more movement into it, feels little bit more normal. But still a lot of work to do. Going to try and (stay) focused on the rehab and get it as strong as possible. Ideally not for surgery for now but we'll see how that goes and hopefully we can get it nice and strong again," he added. Read Also: Moeen Ali Hits Back At David Warner For His 'Surfboard' Remark On Joe Root Update On Chris Woakes' Recovery The update from Woakes comes after he shared with the BBC Sport earlier this month that he was still looking to opt between a surgery and a rehab to deal with the injury. The 36-year-old Woakes had picked up a nasty injury on the opening day of the series decider against India at The Oval, London. Despite being ruled out of action for the remainder of the Test, Woakes walked out to bat with his left arm in a sling on a tense final morning as England chased a series-clinching victory, but fell short by six runs. After the series against India, Ben Stokes-led England have another five-Test series assignment against arch-rivals Australia, starting November 21.
News18
6 hours ago
- News18
Surya Or Gill? BCCI Source Gives Big Update About India Captain For Asia Cup 2025
Last Updated: Surya led Team India when they last played a T20I match against England in Mumbai on February 2, 2025, whereas Gill is the current captain of India's Test team. Suryakumar Yadav is the current captain of India's T20I team, but Test captain Shubman Gill's super show with the bat in the recently concluded five-match Test series against England has raised calls for his promotion as India's captain in all three formats of the game. Many fans and experts of the game feel that the 25-year-old right-handed batter from Punjab should be given the leadership role, keeping the future in mind. It was reported earlier this week that Gill could be asked to lead the Indian team in the Asia Cup 2025, but a fresh report in the Times of India on Thursday (August 14) has indicated that Surya will continue to lead the Indian team in the eight-team tournament, which is set to be played from September 9 to 28 in Dubai and Abu Dhabi. As per TOI, the 34-year-old right-handed batter from Mumbai, who is currently undergoing rehab at the BCCI Centre of Excellence, will fly to Mumbai from Bengaluru to attend the selection committee's meeting for Asia Cup 2025 on August 19. 'The selection meeting will be attended by India's T20 captain Suryakumar Yadav, who will fly to Mumbai from Bengaluru, where he is currently stationed at the BCCI's Centre of Excellence (CoE) while recuperating after a sports hernia surgery. This development confirms that SKY will continue as India's T20 captain, thus quashing all rumours around India's new Test captain, Shubman Gill, also being given the T20 captaincy now," the TOI report read. It has also been reported that India's Test opener Yashasvi Jaiswal and middle-order batter Shreyas Iyer won't be picked for the Asia Cup. As per TOI, Jaiswal has been told by the selectors to focus on red-ball cricket. 'With India looking to persist with the opening pair of Sanju Samson and Abhishek Sharma, Gill is currently struggling to even make it to the side. Even Yashasvi Jaiswal, who had a great series in England, and middle-order bat Shreys Iyer are likely not to be picked for the T20 side. Jaiswal has been told by the selectors to focus on red-ball cricket," a BCCI source was quoted as saying by TOI. view comments First Published: Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
News18
7 hours ago
- News18
Chris Woakes shares key injury update ahead of Ashes
London [UK], August 14 (ANI): After a gruelling Test series against India, England shift their attention to the Ashes in Australia later this year, and all-rounder Chris Woakes has conceded positive news with regards to his recovery, as per the official website of news would come as a positive for England, who have another five-Test series assignment against arch-rivals Australia starting November 21. Woakes, who sustained a dislocated shoulder while fielding during the fifth Test against India earlier this month, believes he's recovering better than he anticipated.'Certainly good news for me. That's the best way to look at it," Woakes told Sky Sports, as quoted from the official website of ICC.'Obviously out of the sling and feel like I can move it a lot better now, which is good two weeks down the line," he noted.'I suppose once you get a little bit more movement into it, feels little bit more normal. But still a lot of work to do," he added.'Going to try and (stay) focused on the rehab and get it as strong as possible. Ideally, not for surgery for now, but we'll see how that goes, and hopefully we can get it nice and strong again," Woakes had picked up a nasty injury on the opening day of the series decider against India at The being ruled out of action for the remainder of the Test, Woakes would walk out to bat with his left arm in a sling on a tense final morning as England chased a series-clinching victory, but fell short by six runs. (ANI)
