Micah Beckwith's $87K SUV started with a request for 'all the bells and whistles'
When Lt. Gov. Micah Beckwith was criticized for buying a top-trim, $87,000 Chevrolet Tahoe High Country, his office justified the purchase by saying its former SUV "had been in multiple accidents and was suffering from mechanical issues."
But that 2022 Dodge Durango was in good enough shape to be recently reassigned to an agency head in the Braun administration, Indiana Department of Corrections Commissioner Lloyd Arnold.
Public records recently obtained by IndyStar reveal more context behind Beckwith's controversial Tahoe purchase, which along with Secretary of State Diego Morales' new $91,000 SUV, recently inspired legislation at the Indiana Statehouse banning future purchases of top-trim and premium brand vehicles by state officials. Braun recently signed the bill into law.
The records show Beckwith, also a pastor at Life Church in Noblesville, wanted something "newer and larger" than outgoing Lt. Gov. Suzanne Crouch's Durango, according to a Jan. 2 request from the Lieutenant Governor's Office to the Indiana Department of Administration, which handles the state's vehicle fleet. The car had over 150,000 miles on it.
"Can you tell me what is available - he is looking for a black SUV like a Yukon with all the bells and whistles," according to the request to IDOA from the office's operations director, which came in via Teams message over a week before Beckwith was sworn into the role alongside Gov. Mike Braun.
A Black Yukon would have matched the one used by Morales, who drives around in a taxpayer funded, $91,000 2024 GMC Yukon Denali.
Instead, the IDOA presented Beckwith with two options: a Chevrolet Tahoe Premium, which starts at about $73,000, and the top-trim Chevrolet Tahoe High Country, which Beckwith ultimately selected.
The original cost of the vehicle was nearly $91,000, but the state got a $3,000 discount, leading to the final price of $87,672, according to the purchase order for the SUV.
"IDOA contacted several dealerships, and at the time of the request, only two in-stock models met both the color and feature preferences" requested by the office, IDOA said in a statement.
The 2022 Dodge Durango used by Crouch was returned to the state's fleet for a trade-in value of $25,000, and the lieutenant governor's office then reimbursed the IDOA an additional nearly $63,000 for the rest of the cost of the car, according to IDOA.
Beckwith's office did not respond to a request for comment about the office's request for a vehicle with "all the bells and whistles."
SUV now used by IDOC commissioner
Since Beckwith traded the Durango back into the state's fleet to help pay for the new Tahoe, it has been reassigned and is now being used by Arnold, who leads the state's correctional system.
As head of the IDOC, Arnold makes $190,000 annually, slightly less than Beckwith who makes just under $194,000.
The IDOA told IndyStar the vehicle had demonstrated no mechanical problems.
A CarFax report on the vehicle shows that there were two accidents reported on the vehicle back in 2022. One was a "sideswipe collision" with another car, and another incident caused damage to the front right hand side of the car. Airbags did not deploy in either incident, according to the CarFax report.
IDOA said the SUV had been involved in a previous fender bender in which the former lieutenant governor "hit a yellow post at a gas station," which was repaired by IDOA. It did not respond to IndyStar's request for information about a second accident.
Two manufacturer recalls affecting the car's software are associated with the SUV; remedies are available for both, according to the CarFax, which showed the current retail value of the Durango as $35,610.
Beckwith's office referred to the CarFax report as evidence that the SUV had issues as he previously described.
However, Rep. Mitch Gore, D-Indianapolis, said the information from IDOA proved "waste and deception" on Beckwith's part. He's previously called on Morales and Beckwith to return their SUVs for something more modest.
"His previous vehicle wasn't malfunctioning - it's in perfect working order and is currently being used by a state agency head," Gore said. "His top-of-the-line Tahoe wasn't thrust upon him like he said. In fact, he originally asked for something even more expensive."
The debate over CarGate, as it was dubbed, resulted in a dayslong back-and-forth on social media spawning memes and political debate. Beckwith at one point swapped out the Tahoe for a borrowed Tesla Cybertruck, described by a social media user as an "A+ in trolling."
An IDOA official later confirmed that the state didn't own, and wasn't renting, the Tesla. The following day, the Tahoe was back in Beckwith's parking spot.
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Indianapolis Star
13 minutes ago
- Indianapolis Star
Take in the sights that make Indianapolis Motor Speedway a racing icon
Grace Hollars Michelle Pemberton Grace Smith Christine Tannous Team Penske driver Josef Newgarden (2) climbs out of his car on the yard of bricks after winning the 107th running of the Indianapolis 500 on Sunday, May 28, 2023, at Indianapolis Motor Speedway. Jenna Watson/IndyStar Racing fans sit in the stands watching the race Sunday, May 26, 2024, ahead of the 108th running of the Indianapolis 500 at Indianapolis Motor Speedway. Grace Hollars/IndyStar Team Penske driver Josef Newgarden celebrates on the victory podium after winning the Indy 500 on Sunday, May 26, 2024, at Indianapolis Motor Speedway. Michelle Pemberton/IndyStar The U.S. Air ForceThunderbirds perform a flyover as Chip Ganassi Racing driver Tony Kanaan (1) and wife Lauren Bohlander listen to the national anthem Sunday, May 29, 2022, prior to the start of the 106th running of the Indianapolis 500 at Indianapolis Motor Speedway. Mykal McEldowney/IndyStar The field takes the green flag Sunday, May 28, 2023, to start the 107th running of the Indianapolis 500 at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway in Indianapolis. Luke Johnson/IndyStar NASCAR Cup Series driver Tyler Reddick (45) qualifies Saturday, Aug. 12, 2023, for the NASCAR Cup Series Verizon 200 at the Brickyard at Indianapolis Motor Speedway. Adam Cairns/Indianapolis Star The cars race down the tack in the last 20 laps Sunday, May 26, 2024, during the 108th running of the Indianapolis 500 at Indianapolis Motor Speedway. Brett Phelps/IndyStar Actors Austin Butler, left, and Jodie Comer wave the green flag on Sunday, May 26, 2024, during the 108th running of the Indianapolis 500 at Indianapolis Motor Speedway. Michelle Pemberton/IndyStar Scott Bogardus of New York adjusts his headphones while watching the Pennzoil 250 from the turn one grandstands, Saturday, July 20, 2024, at Indianapolis Motor Speedway. Grace Smith/IndyStar Fans walk under the pagoda Friday, Aug. 11, 2023, during practice for the Gallagher Grand Prix at Indianapolis Motor Speedway. Adam Cairns/Indianapolis Star Drivers navigate pit road in preparation for stage two racing during the 30th running of the Brickyard 400, Sunday, July 21, 2024, at Indianapolis Motor Speedway. Doug McSchooler/for IndyStar Fans walk behind pit road Saturday, Aug. 12, 2023, during qualifying for the NASCAR Cup Series Verizon 200 at the Brickyard at Indianapolis Motor Speedway. Adam Cairns/Indianapolis Star Meyer Shank Racing driver Helio Castroneves (06) and team climb the fence near the yard of bricks Sunday, May 30, 2021, during the 105th running of the Indianapolis 500 at Indianapolis Motor Speedway. Mykal McEldowney/IndyStar The skyline of Indianapolis is visible as cars enter turn two during the Brickyard 400, Sunday, July 21, 2024, at Indianapolis Motor Speedway. Christine Tannous/IndyStar Spectators walk under the grandstands during the Brickyard 400, Sunday, July 21, 2024, at Indianapolis Motor Speedway. Brett Phelps/IndyStar A video board on the pagoda warns of a weather delay Saturday, Aug. 12, 2023, ahead of a day full of NASCAR and IndyCar events at Indianapolis Motor Speedway. Adam Cairns/Indianapolis Star Fireworks go off behind the pagoda Sunday, May 26, 2024, ahead of the 108th running of the Indianapolis 500 at Indianapolis Motor Speedway. Tyler Ward/For IndyStar Drivers pile up in turn one during the first overtime during the Brickyard 400, Sunday, July 21, 2024, at Indianapolis Motor Speedway. John Chilton/For IndyStar A rainbow appears following a brief shower Saturday, Aug. 12, 2023, during the NASCAR Xfinity Series Pennzoil 150 at Indianapolis Motor Speedway. Adam Cairns/Indianapolis Star NASCAR Cup Series drivers Tyler Reddick (45) and Denny Hamlin (11) lead the field around the first turn after taking the green flag on Sunday, July 21, 2024, during the Brickyard 400 at Indianapolis Motor Speedway. Adam Cairns/Columbus Dispatch Doug McSchooler/For IndyStar A look Monday, March 31, 2025, at the newly renovated Indianapolis Motor Speedway Museum. Mykal McEldowney/IndyStar Racing fans seek shelter during a rain delay Saturday, Aug. 12, 2023, during the NASCAR Xfinity Series Pennzoil 150 at the Indianapolis Motor Speedway in Indianapolis. Grace Hollars/IndyStar The sun rises on Saturday, May 28, 2022, ahead of the 106th running of the Indianapolis 500 at Indianapolis Motor Speedway. Grace Hollars/IndyStar

Yahoo
11 hours ago
- Yahoo
I-65 fiery truck crashes ignite conversation about tolling, expanding highway
Recent fiery truck accidents on Interstate 65 in southern Lake and Jasper counties in the spring resulted in long traffic delays and asphalt repairs, which have resurfaced questions about tolling and expanding I-65. House Enrolled Act 1461, authored by state Rep. Jim Pressel, R-Rolling Prairie, would allow the state to charge tolls on all Indiana interstate highways, including Interstate 80/94 and I-65. Specifically, the law allows the Indiana Department of Transportation to submit a request to the Federal Highway Administration for a waiver to toll lanes on interstate highways. If the waiver is granted, the legislature would not have to enact a statute for the Indiana finance authority to take action on tolling. Indiana uses fuel tax to fund road projects, Braun said at an event in Munster last month, but as vehicles become more fuel efficient drivers have been buying less gas. Braun said he 'probably will' ask for federal approval to toll Indiana highways. 'It's going to have to be considered because otherwise, I don't think we can maintain our main arteries,' Braun said. 'Asking for the ability to do it doesn't mean you're going to do it comprehensively. You do it selectively, where the need is the greatest.' Indiana Department of Transportation spokeswoman Cassandra Bajek said Monday that the department hasn't received information from the governor's office or the legislature about beginning to toll roads in Indiana. 'That question is still being answered. We're still waiting to hear what their intent was with that one,' Bajek said. Expanding I-65 to three lanes, for both northbound and southbound traffic, 'is always a topic of conversation' at INDOT, 'however we do not currently have a project in place to do so' in Northwest Indiana, Bajek said. A truck fire in April led to paint cans exploding from the vehicle and halting traffic on I-65 southbound. A truck driver pulled over near mile-marker 231 on I-65 southbound around 1 p.m. April 21. The driver noticed the brakes on one side of the tractor were glowing red and started on fire, according to an Indiana State Police news release. The driver ran to get a fire extinguisher from the cab, but when she returned the fire had spread to the trailer, which was filled with paint cans, according to the release. The paint cans 'ignited and caused an intense fire that quickly spread to the adjacent trees and even caught the asphalt roadway surface on fire,' according to the release. As crews worked to put out the fire, there was a moment when north and southbound lanes were closed because of the smoke. When the scene was cleared, a large section of asphalt had to be replaced, according to the release. The highway was closed for approximately 16 hours, Bajek said. A semi-truck crash in May led to a fire, closed I-65 near Lowell for hours and needed asphalt repair. A UPS truck crashed while headed northbound on I-65 near mile-marker 238.8 May 17 after exiting a construction zone lane restriction. The truck 'experienced a sudden tire failure on one of the steer tires' which resulted in the driver losing control of the truck, according to an Indiana State Police news release. The truck and trailer overturned, which blocked the entire roadway, and caught fire. The driver was able to get out of the truck but was taken to the hospital for non-life-threatening injuries, according to the release. The asphalt was damaged and deemed unsafe for traffic, according to the release, so it had to be replaced and refilled. The road was closed for approximately 10 hours, Bajek said. As a result, beginning in June, the Lake County Sheriff's Department Traffic Unit began enforcing operations targeting overweight vehicles that are damaging roadways and impacting driver safety along the state line in southwest Lake County, according to a Lake County Sheriff's Department news release. The department will send out more than 60 warning notices to companies and drivers of vehicles in violation of weight limits. Drivers will receive tickets if they continue to ignore weight restrictions on county roadways, according to the sheriff's release. In Lake County, there is a 15-ton limit on 197th, 185th and 151st from U.S. 41 west to State Line Road, according to the sheriff's release. 'We are taking this proactive approach to help reduce the kind of heavy traffic on weight restricted roads that causes significant wear and tear on the roads,' Lake County Sheriff Oscar Martinez said in the release. 'The accelerated degradation of the roads leads to increased maintenance costs for taxpayers.' akukulka@


Indianapolis Star
11 hours ago
- Indianapolis Star
'We won't allow facts to be buried': Hogsett investigative report omissions raise concerns
Republicans and a few Democrats on the Indianapolis City-County Council want answers about why the investigation probing misconduct in Mayor Joe Hogsett's administration omitted any mention of the mayor's late-night and personal text messages to two female junior staffers in its final report. IndyStar reported last week that Caroline Ellert and Lauren Roberts — two former Hogsett staffers who alleged Hogsett's former chief of staff Thomas Cook harassed and assaulted them — provided information to the law firm investigators compiling the report that did not appear in it. Some councilors are arguing to withhold the $450,000 payment for the report until the law firm, Chicago-based Fishers Phillips, answers questions about the omission. The text messages the women provided to investigators contradicted some of what appears in the final report — including Hogsett's assertion that he knew nothing about Roberts' personal life. Instead, the text messages showed that Hogsett knew Roberts' then-partner's name and joked that she needed his permission to date the partner. Council Democrat John Barth called June 9 for the city to withhold payments to the law firm Fisher Phillips until the investigators address why they did not include this information in the report. In addition, Barth raised concerns about "clear discrepancies" between the mayor's public statements and the "documented evidence shared by two survivors." "Their accounts suggest that the culture of inappropriate conduct extended to the highest levels of city leadership," Barth said. "It appears that the 'tone at the top' was set by the mayor himself." Council Minority Leader Michael-Paul Hart, a Republican, also said in a statement that the public "deserves transparency, and survivors deserve accountability." "We won't allow facts to be buried or voices to be ignored," Hart said. Council Republicans also called for several additional action steps, including an oversight hearing, more documentation from Fisher Phillips and a public addendum to the report "documenting evidence and findings omitted from the official version." Hogsett did not dispute the accuracy of the text messages but declined to answer IndyStar's specific questions about them. Instead, he said in a June 5 statement that "there have been many lessons learned and I believe working together we can continue to move our city forward." Meanwhile, two other council members—Democratic Socialist Jesse Brown and Democrat Andy Nielsen — have so far both called on Hogsett to resign. After the law firm's report release but before the two women publicly shared their texts from the mayor, Nielsen said the mayor's actions constituted a leadership failure. The Fisher Phillips report found that despite a recommendation from Human Resources that Cook be fired from his city job in 2020, Hogsett allowed Cook to stay on for 68 days to work on economic development projects and then resign. Cook was also heavily involved in his 2023 mayoral campaign. The rest of the Democratic caucus —led by Democratic Council President Vop Osili, Vice President Ali Brown, and Majority Leader Maggie Lewis — did not immediately respond to IndyStar's request for comment on the omissions from the report. Democrats have a supermajority on the council. Barth's statement didn't address whether the mayor should stay in office but said there should be "accountability at every level." As a matter of process, it's not up to the City-County Council whether Hogsett stays in office. An impeachment process exists, but is largely controlled by the Indiana General Assembly. Recall elections also don't exist here. More: Can Indiana mayors be removed from office? There's a law, but it's rare, experts say. But the calls for accountability are politically significant, even if councilors can't take direct action. The mayor losing political support on the City-County Council could impact his ability to effectively govern. As one of two Republicans on the council's seven-member Investigative Committee that hired Fisher Phillips to investigate Hogsett, Councilor Joshua Bain said the firm's lawyers wouldn't answer the committee's questions about their findings throughout the monthslong investigation. Now councilors are left with what feels like an incomplete report, Bain said. 'I felt like this report is actually going to end up making things worse and people are going to continue to not feel heard," Bain said. "People are going to continue to think things are getting swept under the rug." In a February Council meeting, Fisher Phillips lawyers reviewed their investigative methods in a presentation to councilors but kept their specific findings secret. Bain and fellow Republican Brian Mowery said they asked multiple follow-up questions about the hundreds of pages of documents the lawyers said they had gathered, their meetings with city leaders and any search terms that lawyers were singling out in text messages. "Because this is an interim report, we prefer to keep the details of what's been discussed and what we've found very high-level," Fisher Phillips Danielle Kays responded at the time, "because disclosing information could affect the integrity of our investigation and what information is provided to us or told to us." To restore public trust, Bain called on the lawyers to answer questions about their process now. Fisher Phillips did not answer multiple questions from IndyStar sent last week about why the text messages that contradict assertions in the report were not included. "Fisher Phillips is being paid $450,000," Bain said. "I think the least they can do is set some time aside and do a follow-up hearing with us." Committee Chairwoman Crista Carlino did not respond to IndyStar's request for comment on Monday, though council members indicated on May 29 that their work to stop future abuse from happening to city workers was just beginning. The ordinance that created the investigative committee indicates the council would prepare its own report that would detail "the conclusion of their investigation, including the method of their investigation and any evidence discovered." The Hogsett administration previously also said it would seek to work with the council on recommendations from the report, which included dissolving the city's current HR department in favor of an independent structure. Meanwhile, an impending June 9 evening City-County Council meeting has garnered interest by those calling for Hogsett's resignation. The group Indiana Progressive Democrats has called on Hogsett to resign and urged people to show up to the Monday evening meeting. "Stand with survivors, workers and every resident who believes in a better Indianapolis," according to the group's Facebook post. "Our presence shows that we will not accept silence or complicity any longer." Democrats also met privately over the weekend to discuss the situation, according to someone close to the caucus who asked to remain anonymous because they were not authorized to disclose Democratic caucus meetings. They did not share any conclusions that were reached or any details of that meeting.