
Crypto, Startups and Banking Make a Scary Mix
Stablecoin issuer Circle Internet Group Inc. and tech billionaire Peter Thiel are among the names linked with trust bank charter applications in recent days. The backdrop to this is a White House pushing for regulators to help innovation and growth in the economy and finance. Some of that is down to the backing Donald Trump got from Silicon Valley billionaires and crypto moguls in last year's presidential race, plus his personal financial interests in memecoins and digital assets.
But it is also down to frustrations with a long drought in new bank formations since the financial crisis of 2008. Before that, many years had seen 100-200 new banks each, according to the Federal Deposit Insurance Corp. Since then, most years have barely seen 10 or 15 lenders open for business. Ultra-low rates have made simple banking less profitable, but campaigners for small banks also blame heavy-handed regulation and tough capital rules.
Michelle Bowman, the Trump-appointed chief regulator at the Federal Reserve, has spoken often about this dearth in new banks and promised to bring back more tailoring of supervision and regulation to make life easier for small banks.
Stoking the system with banks heavily linked to venture capital and crypto could be a terrible idea, however. These two industries were at the heart of the mini-banking crisis in spring 2023 — and not by coincidence. 'These are the most macroeconomically sensitive parts of the economy,' Steven Kelly, associate director of research at Yale School of Management's Program on Financial Stability, told me. 'When interest rates go up, they are the first sectors to turn down.'
Ripple Labs Inc. and BitGo Inc. have recently begun trust bank charter applications, according to Bloomberg News, following the lead of stablecoin issuer Circle, which started its bid to become a bank hot on the heels of its $8 billion initial public offering last month. These national charters don't allow banks to collect deposits or make loans directly, but they can use technology and correspondent banking partners to accomplish the same services. Only one crypto company has gained this kind of national license previously, Anchorage Digital Bank in 2021. But other lenders have become deeply entwined with the industry: The best known, Silvergate Bank and Signature Bank, both failed in March 2023.
Another hopeful is Erebor, a digital bank startup backed by an all-star cast of JRR Tolkien fans, including Thiel and Palmer Luckey, according to several reports last week. Their bank, named for a dragon's mountain home in The Lord of the Rings, will focus on the 'innovation economy' including tech businesses and digital currencies. It aims to fill a gap in the market left by the failure of Silicon Valley Bank.
The 2023 crisis was concentrated around the West Coast tech scene similar to the way Texas suffered a wave of bank failures in the 1980s, as I wrote at the time. The boom and bust of a dominant local industry (oil in the Texas case) caused irreparable harm to the banks most exposed to it. With Silvergate and Signature (the New York-based exception to the West Coast rule), the problem was that a dominant share of their deposits was there only as a gateway to crypto markets: When prices tumbled and trading dried up, the money left, ruining the banks.
At SVB, its funding was mainly cash raised by startup companies. When rising interest rates hit valuations and froze venture capital fundraising, the bank's funds began to shrink too. Startup cash burn became SVB's deposit burn, exposing cracks in its business months before the faster run that killed it off.
These banks were focused on economically sensitive industries that are highly correlated to each other, and they lacked diversification of funding. That's a bad business model and it is much more significant in explaining the 2023 failures than depositor fears about unrealized losses on bonds, or the role of social media in transmitting panic, according to Kelly and Jonathan Rose, a senior economist at the Fed Bank of Chicago, in a paper(1) they co-authored on the 2023 blowups.
Circle, Erebor and the rest look like they're running straight back toward this bad business model trap. The more successful they are and the bigger they grow, the more dangerous they could be. It's worth remembering that Silvergate and Signature were still small when they created fears of a rolling disaster.
As Bowman has discussed in several speeches, the tailoring of bank rules isn't just about size but also complexity and business models. The last of these is what should be ringing alarm bells over these wannabe bankers. The last thing the US needs is a whole new group of banks with a hyper focus on stablecoins, crypto and startups.
More From Bloomberg Opinion:
(1) Rushing to Judgment and the Banking Crisis of 2023. Steven Kelly and Jonathan Rose. Working paper for the Federal Reserve Bank of Chicago, March 2025
This column reflects the personal views of the author and does not necessarily reflect the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its owners.
Paul J. Davies is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist covering banking and finance. Previously, he was a reporter for the Wall Street Journal and the Financial Times.
More stories like this are available on bloomberg.com/opinion
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles

Time of India
14 minutes ago
- Time of India
Trump Declares 'ECONOMIC EMERGENCY'; Strikes Top Asian Allies Of U.S. With Steep 25% Tariffs
President Donald Trump on Monday placed a 25% tax on goods imported from Japan and South Korea, citing persistent trade imbalances with the two crucial U.S. allies in Asia. Trump provided notice of the tariffs to begin on Aug. 1 by posting letters on Truth Social that were addressed to the leaders of both countries. The letters warned both countries to not retaliate by increasing their own import taxes, or else the Trump administration would further increase tariffs. 'If for any reason you decide to raise your Tariffs, then, whatever the number you choose to raise them by, will be added onto the 25% that we charge,' Trump wrote in the letters to Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba and South Korean President Lee Jae-myung. Read More


News18
18 minutes ago
- News18
Epstein Was 'Not Murdered' Trump Administration Debunks Theories, MAGA Stunned, Musk Mocks
President Donald Trump's Justice Department and FBI have concluded they have no evidence that convicted sex offender and disgraced financier Jeffrey Epstein blackmailed powerful figures, kept a "client list" or was murdered. The MAGA movement erupted in disbelief over the news. Their distrust of the "deep state" sparked years of conspiracy theories over Epstein's suicide in prison. Meanwhile Elon Musk trolled President Trump with a post knocking the administration for making no arrests related to the Jeffrey Epstein Trump's former ally-turned-foe, posted an image to his social platform X of 'The Official Jeffrey Epstein Pedophile Arrest Counter,' set to '0000.' n18oc_world n18oc_crux


NDTV
23 minutes ago
- NDTV
"Witch Hunt": Trump, Brazil's Lula Clash Over Bolsonaro Coup Trial
Washington: US-Brazil relations slid into crisis Monday after President Donald Trump criticized the high-profile coup trial of his right-wing ally, ex-president Jair Bolsonaro. Trump accused Brazilian authorities of carrying out a "WITCH HUNT" against the 70-year-old firebrand, warning they should "LEAVE BOLSONARO ALONE." His comments drew a quick and sharp rebuke. Brazil's leftist President Luiz Inacio Lula da Silva set diplomatic niceties aside and hit back at Trump's "interference," adding that "no one is above the law." Bolsonaro is facing trial, accused of leading a "criminal organization" that plotted a coup to keep him in power after his 2022 election loss. He faces up to 40 years in prison if found guilty. According to prosecutors, the alleged coup plot failed due to a lack of support from the military high command. The case carries echoes of Trump's prosecution over the January 6, 2021, attacks, when his supporters overran the US Congress to try to reverse his election loss. Trump pleaded not guilty, and the case was abandoned when he was reelected president -- giving him immunity from prosecution. Bolsonaro has similarly protested his innocence, while trying to rally supporters with a series of protests that have further polarized Brazilian politics. - Repercussions - The cases have drawn the Trump and Bolsonaro families together, with the Brazilian ex-leader's sons lobbying hard to have a Supreme Court judge hit with US sanctions and for Trump to weigh in. That effort now appears to have succeeded, with unclear repercussions for relations between the largest economies in North and South America. Bolsonaro's son Eduardo praised Trump's post and said it "would not be the only news coming from the United States in the near future." Trump addressed the case at length in a social media post and suggested Bolsonaro was the favorite in next year's election -- despite being banned from running because he spread misinformation about the voting system. "I have watched, as has the World, as they have done nothing but come after him, day after day, night after night, month after month, year after year!" Trump said in the Truth Social post. "It happened to me, times 10," Trump said. "I have gotten to know Jair Bolsonaro, and he was a strong Leader, who truly loved his Country -- Also, a very tough negotiator on TRADE," Trump said. Like Trump, Bolsonaro claims to be the victim of political persecution. Bolsonaro senior thanked Trump for his support and his defense of "peace, justice and liberty" in a social media post. Trump's comments came as Lula hosted representatives from China, Russia, Iran, and other nations for a BRICS summit in Rio de Janeiro. Leaders attending the summit criticized Trump's tariffs and his bombing of Iran, drawing the US president's ire and a threat of 10 percent additional tariffs on each BRICS-aligned country. In a sign of how fraught US-Brazil ties are, Lula insisted BRICS members were independent and did not want an "emperor." (Except for the headline, this story has not been edited by NDTV staff and is published from a syndicated feed.)