‘Just wrong': State government seeks to draft public servants into WFH campaign
Associate Professor William Partlett, an expert in public law at the Melbourne Law School, said the government was treating the public service as an extension of its political party work rather than a provider of independent advice.
'When I see this, I think cartel party,' Partlett said.
'This is part of a pattern, and it is one we should be concerned about. It reflects a broader problem concern – the erosion of Westminster principles and the centralisation of authority.'
Loading
A cartel party, a concept coined by the late Irish political scientist Peter Mair, is where a dominant political party co-opts the apparatus and resources of the state to cement its power.
Dr Colleen Lewis, an honorary professor at the Australian Studies Institute at the Australian National University, was more blunt.
'It is just wrong,' she said.
'The public service is obliged to be non-partisan and governments should respect that requirement. The government should not be canvassing the public sector to support an idea that hasn't been through the parliamentary process.'
Opposition spokesman for financial integrity and budget repair David Davis said he would refer the matter to Victoria's public service watchdog, the Public Sector Commission.
Loading
'It is clear that the Allan Labor government and its senior officers have crossed the line politicising the consultation process of its WFH proposals through a highly political intervention and enlisting the public service to deliberately skew consultation,' Davis said.
'The public service is meant to give frank and fearless advice, not act a spruiker for the Allan Labor government.'
Jiselle Hanna, the Victorian branch secretary of the Community and Public Sector Union, described the material provided to this masthead as 'problematic' and said it appeared the government was using public servants for its political objectives.
Hanna said the requirement for public servants to remain apolitical was inconsistently applied in Victoria, with bureaucrats encouraged to promote the Voice referendum, same-sex marriage plebiscite and working-from-home rights, but gagged from commenting about the war in Gaza.
'Our obligation is to implement the government's agenda because they are the ones elected,' she said. 'This isn't what we are being asked to do in relation to working from home. What we are being asked to do is promote an idea to another person. I think it is a problematic development.
'Are we being used and our networks being used to do a bit of promotion for the government? It certainly looks like it.'
This masthead provided questions to Allan and Victoria's public service chief, Department of Premier and Cabinet secretary Jeremi Moule.
A department spokesperson said government surveys and consultations were regularly promoted between departments. 'The Victorian Public Service is one of the largest employers in Victoria and it is important they have an opportunity to participate in the working from home survey,' the spokesperson said.
Working from home is widely accepted practice across the Victorian Public Service. Under the current enterprise agreement covering the public service, bureaucrats whose jobs can be done from home can do so a minimum of two days a week. Treasurer Jaclyn Symes this week confirmed the true rate of working from home across the public service was likely higher.
Hanna said that as a workplace issue, work from home was settled across the public service. At June 30 last year, 57,345 people were employed in the Victorian Public Service.
Pollster Jim Reed, the founder of the Resolve Political Monitor survey of voting intentions published by this masthead, examined the survey this week and said the results, if and when they are published, should be treated with caution.
'This sort of open survey form can be completed by anyone, and they might be a real Victorian answering honestly, or it might be others completing multiple responses to force a certain result,' Reed said.
'This is why we run statistically sampled polls of the population. It's only then you can be certain that you're getting a true picture, no matter how well the questions are designed.'
Davis described the survey as a faux consultation.
'Labor is seeking to stack the results with favourable comments and few criticisms by sending material to special target audiences likely to support the government's view,' he said.
'We will refer this matter to the Public Sector Commission to ensure rules are obeyed and guidelines for neutrality are observed.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Herald Sun
3 hours ago
- Herald Sun
Steve Price: Brad Battin needs to show some Jeff Kennett showmanship
Filling in on 3AW back in the early 1990s I upset Premier Jeff Kennett so badly he stormed into my office and demanded an apology. My crime was replacing Kennett, on air, with Opposition Leader John Brumby. Jeffrey was on holiday but guarded his regular weekday half-hour spot on the Neil Mitchell show like it was one of his children. The Premier was a lot more volatile back then, during his eight-year reign in the top job, and to say we almost came to blows is not an exaggeration. The pair of us have laughed about it subsequently. He was also, prior to defeating Labor's Joan Kirner in 1992 as Victoria wore the 'rust-bucket state' tag, an exceptional Opposition Leader. John Cain Jr, the predecessor to Kirner, and Labor had driven Victoria into the ground and Victorians were fleeing in great numbers to places like Queensland. Back then the Herald Sun ran a page one that was just black, signifying how bad things had got in the state. Basically, a funeral notice. Kennett was like a dog attacking a bone and he was a daily presence in media whether it was on AW with Mitchell, arguing with the ABC or shovelling dirt at journalists when he finally became premier. Hardly a night passed without Kennett appearing on the nightly news. Kennett was a showman admired and despised in equal parts. Compare that brand of retail politics from a career advertising man with the bland versions of Opposition Leaders Victoria has had to endure through the tortured decade of Labor leaders Daniel Andrews and now Jacinta Allan. Think about this — the Victorian Liberals have been through Matthew Guy twice, Michael O'Brien, John Pesutto and now Brad Battin. Talk about navel gazing and self-destruction. Surely it can't be that hard to find a suitably aggressive, media friendly alternative to two of the most despised political leaders we have ever experienced. It hasn't happened and as steady a hand as he has been, Brad Battin is just not cutting through. Let me prosecute the case that it's not entirely Battin's fault. I'm currently presenting the Peta Credlin Sky News TV program five days a week for five weeks. This week we contacted the Opposition Leader's office to request a live on-air chat about a loosening of the laws around self-protection if someone breaks into your house in the middle of the night armed with a machete. The response from his media team was to suggest we talk instead with David Limbrick of the Libertarian Party. Offered a prime-time spot to prosecute the case that Premier Allan was ruling over a state of lawlessness so bad that people were arguing we should be able to arm ourselves with baseball bats and fight back, instead we were pushed towards an Independent, not even a Liberal. This was not an isolated case, indeed last week we asked the same office to interview Battin about Jacinta Allan's vote grabbing delusion that she would legislate to make it law you can work from home two days a week. Same response. Sorry, Brad's not available. I was prompted to check when the last time Victoria's Opposition Leader had appeared on Sky's top rating four day a week Credlin show and found, according to our records, it was five weeks ago. I present the Friday version of Credlin and can't remember the last time he appeared with me either. Now Battin and his team can choose to appear in the media and with whomever they choose. But to suggest he has a high profile as Opposition Leader is ludicrous. Most Victorians would struggle to even name him. It's a problem the conservative side of politics, both state and federal, struggle with. The NSW Liberal Opposition leader is a bloke called Mark Speakman who as late as this week was facing a leadership challenge over a net-zero bungle. In South Australia a bloke even I have never heard of leads the Liberals – Vincent Tarzia. Vincent took over after former leader David Speirs was forced to resign after pleading guilty to two drug charges and a video showed him snorting a substance from a plate. The best known Liberal Opposition leader in Australia would be WA's Basil Zempilas, who has been in the job five months. Basil, of course, is best known for his football commentary on the Seven Network not for his politics and he leads a team of just seven members of the lower house. Then of course we have the newly minted Federal Liberal leader Sussan Ley who when a poll was taken to identify who she was by showing members of the public a photograph of her, not one person knew who she was. One thought she was Gina Rinehart another a bank executive and to be fair not everyone knew who even Anthony Albanese was. Liberals around the country are searching for leaders that can connect with wider Australia. Ley deserves her shot at the top job and given the Coalition will be in Opposition for the next four years she has plenty of time to get known. Brad Battin doesn't have the luxury of time with a state election just 14 months away and Victorians deserve better than an alternative Premier being hidden away. Unlike most state and federal politicians, he has a work history as an ex-police officer and prison guard – ideal for prosecuting the case in a lawless state overrun by violent crime. Someone needs to tell him to accept every media opportunity offered to him. He should take a leaf out of Kennett's playbook where he insisted on live in-person interviews so he couldn't be edited. Victoria had and still has a love-hate relationship with our most successful recent Liberal Premier, but one thing is for sure you couldn't ignore him. So, media savvy was he that after being confronted by a barbecue wielding union protester out the front of the old AW studios in Bank St he made one more big demand. He asked us to install a landline into his office to conduct live interviews from there. We did it only to regret the decision as Jeff kept dialling in to go on air like some sort of media commentator. At least Victorians knew who he was. Dislikes • Convicted drug and gun criminal Snoop Dogg as the Grand Final entertainment – how does that fit the AFL's family image. • Anthony Albanese promising to recognise a Palestinian State. • Cowardly masked neo-Nazis marching through Melbourne in the dead of night. • ACTU pushing for a four-day week at Canberra's economic roundtable next week. Likes • Reserve Bank cut interest rates for the third time this year. • EV drivers look like being slugged a road user tax – about time. • Ageless Magpie Scott Pendlebury at age 37 going around next year. • Donald Trump doing what our leaders should do cleaning up Washington DC of homeless criminals and drug dealers. Steve Price Saturday Herald Sun columnist Melbourne media personality Steve Price writes a weekly column in the Saturday Herald Sun.
The Age
7 hours ago
- The Age
Progress thwarted by educational inequities
To submit a letter to The Age, email letters@ Please include your home address and telephone number below your letter. No attachments. See here for our rules and tips on getting your letter published. WESTERN SUBURBS Re ″ Young tradies like Dylan and western suburbs professionals have this in common ″, 15/8. Congratulations to Dylan D'Emanuele for his perseverance and determination to enter a trade, assisted by Youth Projects. It certainly shouldn't be so hard for young people to gain a foothold in their own society. Two adverse factors have primary responsibility for this. First, the Victorian government lost the plot in closing around 120 technical secondary schools, expecting high schools to somehow cater for academic and non-academic students, and ″warehouse″ unemployed youth to keep them off the streets. I'd previously observed teachers in a now-closed technical school in the inner-west, witnessing how engaged students were in mechanical, construction and myriad other tasks, supplemented by classes in basic skills. The students who flourish in technical schools need those educational opportunities to learn skilled trades which can take them straight into work. The second major factor disadvantaging today's youth is the exportation of entry level work to cheaper labour countries. Those jobs used to go to school-leavers after Year 10. High levels of youth unemployment are inevitably detrimental to those young people and to the society as a whole. Barbara Chapman, South Yarra New insights needed Accolades to The Age for co-presenting the upcoming 'West of Melbourne Summit', and its continuing advocacy by their journalists for people living in the west side of Melbourne. The spoken word cannot be ignored. New insights are desperately needed. Both sides of Victorian parliament need to listen. Addressing the various needs of people choosing to live and raise their children in the west could address problems facing the inner city Melbourne congestion. Christine Baker, Rosanna Melbourne infrastructure delays have history My heart goes out to those folk in the west who pine for improved transport infrastructure. I can only hope they do better than their brethren in Doncaster. Soon after World War II ended, it was proposed to extend tram route 48 from North Balwyn to Doncaster, thereby servicing the residents of housing replacing the fast-disappearing orchards. Successive political parties seeking to retain or reclaim the state's treasury benches eagerly supported the proposal. As is the fate of certain current infrastructure proposals, once elected, assorted reasons for deferment were trotted out. The latest is that the hill to Doncaster Shoppingtown is too steep to enable disabled access. Any suggestion that the route be extended further to Box Hill via Tram Road, thereby looping the city with a significant chunk of the eastern suburbs, can only be described as a figment in the imagination of those living there. (By contrast, Australia's first electric tram service existed in Doncaster from 1889 to 1896 when Victoria was a colony!) Jim Lamborn, Doncaster THE FORUM Buried report As reported by The Age this week, the government has refused to make the outcome of the 2022 Property Market Review″ public. According to both Premier Jacinta Allan and Consumer Affairs Minister Nick Staikos, the review is 'a cabinet document from the last term of government' and therefore does not have to be made public. What nonsense! Like many others, I responded to a personal invitation to provide a written submission to the review. My comprehensive submission subsequently included, again by invitation, a one-hour presentation to the Nous Group who were commissioned to conduct the review for the government. My submission concentrated on the need for auction rules to be reformed to stamp out the insidious practice of underquoting. This can be achieved by introducing a simple, new, easily policed rule that would require agents to publish their vendors' reserve prices in all auction advertising. The REIV this week has finally agreed, after 20 years' resistance and following exposure of underquoting by The Age, that vendors' reserve prices should be advertised before auctions and it has also called for the review to be made public. There's something very concerning about why the review is not being made public. Why should anybody spend valuable hours of their time preparing well-researched submissions on important issues of wide public interest, only for their input to be buried? John Keating, real estate agent and auctioneer, Woodend Rebalance tax system The articles ' We've worked hard ... but it's not enough ' (14/8) and ' Spender calls for new income tax system ' (14/8), highlight the gross unfairness of our tax system. Work, not property investment, should be rewarded by governments. Current property investor tax breaks are inequitable and they elevate house prices, further disadvantaging prospective homeowners. It's time for Labor to rebalance our tax system and give younger generations a fair go. Lyn Shiells, Glen Iris Bendigo festival no-show Re: ″ Authors ditch Bendigo festival over freedom of speech concerns ″, (15/8). As a Bendigo resident, the Bendigo Writers Festival is an annual event on my calendar. Claire Wright, Jess Hill, Thomas Mayo and Randa Abdel-Fattah are the very writers and thinkers I would be attending to hear, in expectation of respectful, intelligent, informed and balanced perspectives. I congratulate them on taking such a principled stance in withdrawing from a public forum which curtails their ability to do this, even though it means no writers' festival in Bendigo for me this year. Michelle Goldsmith, Eaglehawk AI flooding zone Two years ago, I was offered a free trial for one of the artificial intelligence (AI) content generation platforms. I tried it and immediately cancelled my subscription. Even then, I could see the dangers of this technology. The information delivered by the platform on the topic I gave it was just good enough to provide a viable alternative mechanism for busy professionals to generate documents. But it also contained numerous errors and pieces of misinformation. My colleagues laughed at my concerns. 'People will check the content and correct any errors before they use it,' they told me. And perhaps, initially they did. My concern was that after a while, everyone would just assume the information is correct and not bother to check any more. The content is so quickly and easily produced, it would eventually 'flood the zone' and drown out the work produced through careful research and due consideration. Fast-forward two years and we read that defence lawyers filed error-filled AI-generated documents with the Victorian Supreme Court (15/8). The lawyers were too busy to check the materials before they filed them and the prosecutors didn't bother checking either. Heaven help us if AI is the future of our society. Donna Cohen, Southbank
The Age
8 hours ago
- The Age
‘Just wrong': State government seeks to draft public servants into WFH campaign
This masthead was provided the material by senior public servants who cannot comment publicly as a condition of their employment but privately expressed frustration they were being asked to promote government policy. Associate Professor William Partlett, an expert in public law at the Melbourne Law School, said the government was treating the public service as an extension of its political party work rather than a provider of independent advice. 'When I see this, I think cartel party,' Partlett said. 'This is part of a pattern, and it is one we should be concerned about. It reflects a broader problem concern – the erosion of Westminster principles and the centralisation of authority.' Loading A cartel party, a concept coined by the late Irish political scientist Peter Mair, is where a dominant political party co-opts the apparatus and resources of the state to cement its power. Dr Colleen Lewis, an honorary professor at the Australian Studies Institute at the Australian National University, was more blunt. 'It is just wrong,' she said. 'The public service is obliged to be non-partisan and governments should respect that requirement. The government should not be canvassing the public sector to support an idea that hasn't been through the parliamentary process.' Opposition spokesman for financial integrity and budget repair David Davis said he would refer the matter to Victoria's public service watchdog, the Public Sector Commission. Loading 'It is clear that the Allan Labor government and its senior officers have crossed the line politicising the consultation process of its WFH proposals through a highly political intervention and enlisting the public service to deliberately skew consultation,' Davis said. 'The public service is meant to give frank and fearless advice, not act a spruiker for the Allan Labor government.' Jiselle Hanna, the Victorian branch secretary of the Community and Public Sector Union, described the material provided to this masthead as 'problematic' and said it appeared the government was using public servants for its political objectives. Hanna said the requirement for public servants to remain apolitical was inconsistently applied in Victoria, with bureaucrats encouraged to promote the Voice referendum, same-sex marriage plebiscite and working-from-home rights, but gagged from commenting about the war in Gaza. 'Our obligation is to implement the government's agenda because they are the ones elected,' she said. 'This isn't what we are being asked to do in relation to working from home. What we are being asked to do is promote an idea to another person. I think it is a problematic development. 'Are we being used and our networks being used to do a bit of promotion for the government? It certainly looks like it.' This masthead provided questions to Allan and Victoria's public service chief, Department of Premier and Cabinet secretary Jeremi Moule. A department spokesperson said government surveys and consultations were regularly promoted between departments. 'The Victorian Public Service is one of the largest employers in Victoria and it is important they have an opportunity to participate in the working from home survey,' the spokesperson said. Working from home is widely accepted practice across the Victorian Public Service. Under the current enterprise agreement covering the public service, bureaucrats whose jobs can be done from home can do so a minimum of two days a week. Treasurer Jaclyn Symes this week confirmed the true rate of working from home across the public service was likely higher. Hanna said that as a workplace issue, work from home was settled across the public service. At June 30 last year, 57,345 people were employed in the Victorian Public Service. Pollster Jim Reed, the founder of the Resolve Political Monitor survey of voting intentions published by this masthead, examined the survey this week and said the results, if and when they are published, should be treated with caution. 'This sort of open survey form can be completed by anyone, and they might be a real Victorian answering honestly, or it might be others completing multiple responses to force a certain result,' Reed said. 'This is why we run statistically sampled polls of the population. It's only then you can be certain that you're getting a true picture, no matter how well the questions are designed.' Davis described the survey as a faux consultation. 'Labor is seeking to stack the results with favourable comments and few criticisms by sending material to special target audiences likely to support the government's view,' he said. 'We will refer this matter to the Public Sector Commission to ensure rules are obeyed and guidelines for neutrality are observed.'
