Stormont MLA Remuneration Board Bill passes despite opposition
It will replace the previous Independent Financial Review Panel which has been defunct for a number of years.
Currently, the basic salary for an MLA is £51,500, but this can rise with position including chairing some committees or serving as a minister, with the First and deputy First Ministers receiving a salary of £123,500.
A report alongside the Bill showed MLA salaries are lower than those received by Members of the Scottish Parliament (£72,196), Assembly Members at the Welsh Assembly (£72,057) and Members of the Irish Parliament (113,679 euros/£94,537).
The Bill, put forward by the Assembly Commission, was passed by an oral vote by MLAs on Monday, with the sole MLAs representing the TUV and People Before Profit both opposing the Bill.
TUV MLA Timothy Gaston claimed it is 'nothing more than a vehicle to enable MLAs to award themselves a substantial pay rise', and objected to former MLAs being entitled to sit on the new board.
People Before Profit MLA Gerry Carroll also criticised that former MLAs could sit on the board, and said that a pay rise for MLAs amid 'rising rates of poverty' would be 'completely tone deaf'.
However UUP MLA Andy Allen, who sits on the Assembly Commission, described a 'technical Bill' to deal with the process of how salaries and pensions are set.
Closing the debate Sinn Fein MLA Sinead Ennis slammed what she termed 'inaccuracies and misunderstandings' over the Bill.
She also warned that if the Bill did not pass the Assembly 'will have failed' to ensure legal clarity and leave no structure in place to determine the salaries and pensions of MLAs.
'In passing this Bill today, future discussions and decisions around the salaries and pensions of members will shift to the independent remuneration board,' she told MLAs.
'That board has independence in deciding what factors it wants to consider before determining its view on the appropriate level of salaries and pensions for members.
'That is the appropriate way of dealing with these matters.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The National
18 minutes ago
- The National
Who is Kate Forbes? Deputy First Minister standing down at election
The Deputy First Minister was selected to contest the Skye, Lochaber and Badenoch constituency in 2026, but now the party will have to rerun the contest and find a new candidate. Party members and politicians expressed shock at the news, while opposition politicians used it as an excuse to take shots at the SNP. Forbes was first elected to Holyrood in 2016, aged 26, having previously worked as an accountant in the banking industry and for former MSP Dave Thompson in the same constituency. READ MORE: Kate Forbes to quit Holyrood in 2026 – read her statements in full The MSP studied history at Cambridge before completing an MSc in diaspora and migration history at the University of Edinburgh. Born in Dingwall, she spent part of her childhood in India and Glasgow, and attended a Gaelic school. She quickly rose through the ranks, first as public finance minister in 2018 before becoming Scotland's first female finance secretary under Nicola Sturgeon in 2020. Forbes was praised for delivering the budget speech at short notice, taking on the role the night before after her predecessor Derek Mackay was forced to stand down when it emerged he had sent inappropriate messages to a teenager. During her time as a backbencher, she delivered the first speech in the Holyrood chamber entirely in Gaelic, later becoming the first Cabinet Secretary for the language, alongside responsibilities for the economy, when she was appointed DFM. (Image: PA) Forbes narrowly lost out on the SNP leadership contest after Sturgeon resigned to Humza Yousaf, who is also set to leave [[Holyrood]] when the parliamentary term ends. She fought the contest while on maternity leave, coming second in the first round of voting with 40.7%, to Yousaf's 48.2%. The second round saw Yousaf win with 52.1%, compared to Forbes' 47.9%. During the campaign, Forbes came under fire for her views on abortion, gay marriage and trans rights. A member of the Free Church of Scotland, she said that having children outside of marriage was 'wrong' and that she would not have supported equal marriage as a 'matter of conscience'. Forbes was on maternity leave while the Scottish Parliament voted on the Gender Recognition Reform (Scotland) Bill, which would have allowed transgender people to self-identify. In 2019, she joined 15 other SNP politicians in writing an open letter to Sturgeon calling for a delay to the reforms, and would later reiterate her concerns during the leadership campaign. READ MORE: Keith Brown: UK can't ignore independence demand with SNP majority On independence, she said during the contest that the party should use the Westminster election to win a mandate and demand powers to allow a referendum to go ahead. After the contest, she told the New Statesman she would have been 'haunted' if she had not stayed true to her religious beliefs during the campaign. Leaving the cabinet in 2023 after Yousaf offered her the rural affairs brief, seen as a major demotion by some, Forbes spent a year on the backbenches. When Yousaf resigned as first minister, following the collapse of the Bute House Agreement with the Scottish Greens, Forbes took on the deputy first minister role when John Swinney took over leadership of the party and government. She was given responsibilities for the economy and [[Gaelic]], and last week welcomed the approval of a massive offshore wind farm off the coast of East Lothian. Forbes had been considered a potential successor to Swinney, prior to her shock announcement and will continue in her MSP role for the next nine months. She added on social media that despite standing down, she is looking forward to campaigning at the election to 'lead Scotland to independence'.
Scotsman
38 minutes ago
- Scotsman
UEFA give Hearts the all-clear over EPL conflict as Tony Bloom reveals his plan for this season at Tynecastle
Europe's governing body told Bloom there is no issue with Brighton and Hove Albion Sign up to our Hearts newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to Edinburgh News, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Tony Bloom sits in a quiet room inside the Tynecastle Park Hotel poring over his plans for Heart of Midlothian. He discusses them openly with selected media after finalising a £9.86m investment deal with the Edinburgh club. Just hours before Hearts begin their 2025/26 Premiership campaign out on the pitch against Aberdeen, Bloom is setting out his expectations for the coming months. He is confident Derek McInnes' side have 'a very good chance of at least being second' come next May. That would involve splitting Rangers and Celtic and upsetting the long-standing Glasgow duopoly of Scottish football. Bloom is unfazed. He sits and shrugs his shoulders. The long-term plan is to win the title and automatically take Hearts into the league phase of the Champions League. This is a man with bold ideas who is motivated to deliver on them, as he has done as chairman of Brighton and Hove Albion in England, and a minority shareholder at the Belgian champions Union Saint-Gilloise. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Bloom, 55, finalised a deal in June this year to obtain a 29 per cent shareholding in Hearts. He will attend his first match at Tynecastle this evening after declaring at a fan event on Sunday evening that the club can win the Scottish league title within 10 years. For his first season involved in Gorgie, he would be content with second place. 'It's a very long-term project,' explains Bloom. 'I hope to be an investor in Hearts for a very long time. We all know what it's like in football, there's a lot of volatility even over a season. I genuinely believe that this current Hearts squad is very strong and every season it will develop and get stronger. So I think we can, even from this season, challenge for every tournament that we're in. 'I think Hearts will have an excellent season. I truly believe in the squad of players that has been assembled. I've got every faith in Derek's ability to get the best out of them and to improve them. I think we've got a very good chance of at least being second this season. I don't want to have too many expectations for any one season. Longer-term, I have high expectations of challenging for trophies year in and year out, continually improving as a club and as a squad of players, and I don't think Hearts should have a ceiling. I think it can be fairly unlimited. From Brighton to Belgium - now Scotland with Hearts 'At Brighton, when I took over the club 16 years ago, we just avoided relegation to League Two. Now we're coming in - not hoping - but with a high expectation of finishing in the top 10, pushing for Europe every season. At Union Saint-Gilloise, I took over seven years ago. We just avoided relegation to the third division, which really is very amateur football, and within three years we got promoted to the top division. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'There's no great shakes in that because it's not that strong a division. Then, for the four seasons in the Belgian top division, we've been challenging for the title in each of those seasons. In each one of them, at some point in the season, we've been odds-on to win the league. For the first three seasons it didn't quite happen but brilliantly last season we managed to get the championship. 'I can only talk from a Hearts point of view. I want to make sure that we are in the talk to win the title at the start of each season and hopefully we won't just talk the talk but we walk the walk. Not being in the bubble, I think it's easier for me. I'm not just saying that as somebody who is coming along and putting some investment in. I've seen what we've done at Brighton, I've seen what we've done at Union Saint-Gilloise, hence the confidence in where I think Hearts can go.' Inevitably, Bloom's comments over the last 24 hours have prompted plenty derision around the Scottish football community. No club other than Celtic or Rangers have won the league since Aberdeen in 1985. 'I'm totally fine,' replies Bloom when asked about sceptics. 'I understand there will be a lot of Celtic Rangers fans who will be laughing and saying: 'Well, I've heard it all before.' Maybe Hibs and Aberdeen as well, and that's fine. I'm just saying it as I see it. I'm not saying it's going to be straight-line success, I'm not saying we're going to win trophies this season, that season, or next season - but I genuinely believe that we will be a significant factor in Scottish football right here, right now and for the long term. Celtic and Rangers money dwarfs everything in the SPFL 'I do understand how difficult it is. I mean Celtic and Rangers' budgets are perhaps six or seven times those of Hearts, Hibs and Aberdeen. That is a big obstacle to overcome. The significant advantage Hearts now have is they have access to Jamestown Analytics, so that can massively help close the gap. I like a challenge and, as you've heard me, I am confident that Hearts will make a difference and it will be shown over the coming seasons on the pitch. Hopefully we can grow as a club because, if we get success on the pitch, the club grows in totality.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad He doesn't expect the Celtic manager Brendan Rodgers to be overly intimidated just yet. 'I don't think Brendan's going to be too concerned about what I'm saying,' smiles Bloom. 'I'm not sure he's not going to be too concerned about Hearts right now. But hopefully, over the course of the season, it would be great. It would be great for Scottish football if he is worried about Hearts. As I said, I don't think he's going to be too concerned right now.' The idea is that Hearts hold an advantage over other Scottish clubs because they get access to the world-renowned player data from Jamestown Analytics. Good players equal good teams, and good teams generally lead clubs to success. 'It's all about recruitment,' says Bloom. 'There are lots of things at a football club, you need really good people, community, fans, facilities - both training facilities and the stadium, which I know are superb here. If you haven't got the players I can talk to the cows come home but there's no chance of success. It may take some time but I think the players Graeme [Jones, sporting director], backed by the board and working with Derek, has got done over the last few months have been really strong. I think we'll all see that in games to come.' The British entrepreneur's Tynecastle entrance was always going to be high-profile, even more so because of his comments on winning titles. He won't be a regular at Hearts matches - Brighton remain his first love - but will closely monitor events here from the south of England. He won't be doing too many press conferences or Q&As with fans, either. 'When I took over in Belgium, I had a one-off press conference and I was probably more guarded,' explains Bloom. 'Seven years ago, things were a lot less proven so I wasn't as bullish. We were privately, but not so publicly confident about what we could do at Union. Here, I've just got a lot more confidence in what Hearts can do, where we are right now, compared to when I did a first press conference at Union seven years ago.' Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Bloom has not ruled out investing in other clubs in future. He also owns a stake in the Australian side Melbourne Victory. In Europe, he is mindful of UEFA regulations on multi-club ownership. His attention to detail is such that he personally contacted UEFA officials to check rules before putting money into Hearts. His concern was whether Hearts and Brighton would be in conflict in UEFA's eyes were the two clubs ever to qualify for the same European competition. Bloom's UEFA chat and why no more Hearts investment 'It's a one-off investment, I've got 29 per cent of the shares in Hearts,' says Bloom. 'The main reason for that is because of the UEFA rules. They have made it quite clear in the last 12 months that if you own 30 per cent or more of two clubs, they can't play in the same European competition. That's clear. I've spoken directly to UEFA to absolutely 100 per cent clarify it, so that if Brighton and Hearts do get drawn in the same tournament then both clubs can play. That's the absolute priority, which is why there won't be any more investment from me, certainly while the UEFA rules stay as they are.' You get the impression that UEFA business consumes a lot of Bloom's thoughts. He wants Hearts to improve Scotland's coefficient so that - whisper it - when Hearts win the league, they avoid qualifying rounds and qualify directly for the Champions League's lucrative league phase. That is where the serious cash resides. Domestic prize money in Scotland is fractional by comparison. 'I'm aware that prize money is very low and obviously, coming from the Premier League, it is pitifully low,' acknowledges Bloom. 'But that is the reality and I don't think we should be crying about it. We need to improve the situation. How do we improve it? We need the quality on the pitch. We need the tournament to be more competitive and I think that's what Hearts will bring to the table. I genuinely believe that this would be really good for Scottish football. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'The fact that the Scottish coefficient has reduced so much that the Champions have to win two games to qualify for the group stage of the Champions League is a terrible situation for Scottish football. I'm very confident that will change because I can't speak for other clubs, but Hearts will be a force. When we get into Europe we'll be winning games and we will help lift that coefficient. It takes time, given the way the system works, but I think all of Scottish football and other clubs should be happy about that. 'For example, Celtic fans should be wanting the other teams [to win] in Europe. I know they're not exactly going to be cheering on Rangers, that's obvious, but certainly it's really good for Celtic if teams like Dundee United and Aberdeen do well in Europe. That lifts the coefficient and it's really not good that the top team, the champions of Scotland, have got a good chance of not playing in the group stage of the Champions League. As and when Hearts win the league, we want to go straight into the Champions League, we do not want to have two [qualifying] games.' Champions League games in Edinburgh He is unequivocal about Tynecastle hosting Champions League football in the coming years. 'Absolutely. I hope that, as and when Hearts do win the league, the coefficient is such that we go straight into the Champions League group stages,' he reiterates. 'Just like Union Saint-Gilloise have. By winning the league, they've gone straight into this season's group stages of the Champions League.' Bloom's interest in Scottish football stems from his childhood in the 1970s and 80s. He reminisces about the halcyon days in Scotland and states categorically that the level of the SPFL Premiership is currently not good enough. 'I do have an interest in Scottish football. I've been following Scottish football from a young age when I was growing up. Outside of England, the only other country that you could read about or was really in your face was Scottish football. It has changed now for the youngsters, obviously. That would not be the case now. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad 'On betting coupons, it's just the full English leagues and the Scottish teams. I used to know the 92 English clubs where they were. I can't say I knew that on Scottish football, but you knew the names. Because you've got Grandstand, it's just in your face, so I was interested in Scottish football. I used to bet on Scottish football when I was young. There's always been that interest. Not that I watched that much of it, but there's always been that interest. 'Looking from afar, looking at the success we've had with Union Saint-Gilloise, I just thought there was an opportunity here to shake things up in Scotland. Because for the level of turnover the clubs get, the level of interest, with the amount of obsession by the people of Scotland, Scottish football is not nearly good enough. I thought there was an opportunity and that's why I'm here. I won't talk about what the odds are. I would just like to say that if we have not won the league title in the next 10 years, I will be very disappointed.' READ MORE: Police and SPFL on alert for Hearts match
Daily Record
38 minutes ago
- Daily Record
Joanna Cherry warns Kate Forbes quitting Holyrood is a 'disaster' for the SNP
The former SNP paid tribute to Forbes and her contribution to the SNP Cabinet. A former SNP MP has said the decision by Kate Forbes to quit Holyrood is a 'disaster' for her party. Joanna Cherry said the Deputy First Minister was leaving to spend more time with her young family, but claimed there is 'probably a bit more to it than meets the eye'. Forbes, one of John Swinney's closest colleagues in Government, surprised political observers with her announcement that she would stand down at the next election. She lost a bruising leadership contest against Humza Yousaf in 2023 but was still tipped as a potential First Minister. In a statement, Forbes said she did not want to "miss any more of the precious early years of family life". Cherry, a fierce critic of Nicola Sturgeon, was asked during an interview at the Edinburgh International festival about the decision. She told broadcaster Iain Dale that Forbes is the 'hardest working' member of the SNP Cabinet and a person of 'principle' and "integrity". Cherry added: 'I sent her a text this morning to say how sorry I was that she was leaving but I suspect there is probably a bit more to it than meets the eye.' She also said: 'I have the utmost respect for her and I think it's a bit of a disaster for the SNP.' In her resignation statement, the Deputy First Minister also said: "It has been a great honour to serve Highland communities for almost a decade. I am grateful to every voter who re-elected me at the last election with the biggest majority in Scotland. "As I reflected over recess, I have concluded that I do not wish to seek re-election for another five year term in the Scottish Parliament. 'All politicians face a choice at every election to stay on the same path or not. Quite simply, I've decided on the latter. I remain wholly supportive of the First Minister just as when I backed him to be leader of the SNP and I look forward to campaigning for the SNP at the next election – to lead Scotland to independence. 'I was first elected in my mid-twenties, dedicating my most formative adult years to public service. In that time, I presented multiple Budgets, supported thousands of businesses and workers during Covid-19 and launched Scotland's most ambitious business start up network TechScaler. I now wish to step back from my public duties and focus on new opportunities to serve people. 'I have grown up in the public eye, getting married, having a baby and raising a young family. I have consistently put the public's needs ahead of my family's during that time. I am grateful to them for accommodating the heavy demands of being a political figure. Looking ahead to the future, I do not want to miss any more of the precious early years of family life – which can never be rewound.'
