Calcutta HC MGNREGA order: Govt to seek arrears, BJP says ‘won't change anything'
Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee on Wednesday said that her government will seek arrears from the Centre in the wake of the Calcutta High Court's order for restart of the MGNREGA, the 100-day rural job guarantee scheme, in the state after a gap of three years.
Rajya Sabha MP Bikash Ranjan Bhattacharya, who represented the state government in the High Court, told The Indian Express that the logical next step would be to pay the arrears. 'We have been fighting the case for the last two years, and the Chief Justice came to the finding that it is the statutory obligation of both the Centre and the state government to ensure the 100-day work. And the court has passed an order to that extent, though belatedly. The arrears have to be paid. Under the law, you have to give the job or provide unemployment allowances. They have to pay the arrears to the job seekers who come under the scheme, and secondly, if the state government could justify that some arrears are there, then that will be paid,' the senior counsel said.
The BJP, however, said the restart of the MGNREGA scheme in the state would not 'solve the problems'.
'We welcome the court order, but it will not solve the problem under any circumstances. The disbursement of the funds is in the hands of the Centre, and the Centre has the authority to discontinue projects if there are irregularities or violations of the basic norms. The state government has accepted that there have been irregularities. Neither the Centre, nor the state BJP wanted this project to stop, but due to TMC's institutional corruption and non-cooperation, this situation emerged,' BJP MP Shamik Bhattacharya told The Indian Express.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
22 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Threats by criminal gangs: Haryana struggles to garner revenue from liquor-vend auctions as bidders dry up
With the shadow of criminals looming large over the liquor trade in the state, the BJP led Haryana government faces the challenge of accomplishing its excise revenue target of ₹14,063.91 crore from the sale of liquor for 2025-26 financial year. Even after completion of five rounds of bidding, liquor contractors in 20 districts, reeling from a recent killing and threats by criminal gangs, have shown reluctance to bid for 260 pending retail liquor zones. The reserve price of the pending 260 zones is about ₹3,980 crore. The June 13 killing of a liquor contractor in Kurukshetra by gangsters, indiscriminate firing at a liquor vend in Rohtak on May 26 where the assailants threatened the contractor not to participate in the bidding for allotment of liquor vends for 2025-27, opening of fire outside a liquor vend on April 8 in Yamunanagar have left liquor contractors petrified and thus affected the business sentiment. So far, the state government has been able to allot 934 retail liquor zones across 22 districts. Each zone consisted of a liquor vend each for selling Indian made foreign liquor (IMFL) and country liquor. Chief minister asks DGP to take action against gangsters Chief minister Nayab Saini on Tuesday evening held a high-level review meeting to assess the law-and-order situation in the context of the setbacks during the excise auctions. The chief minister expressed concern over the killing of a liquor contractor in Kurukshetra and directed the director general of police (DGP) to act firmly. The DGP was also asked to take steps to provide security to everyone who gets threats and extortion calls. The chief minister, it seems, realises that a shortfall in the excise duty receipts will adversely affect execution of BJP's poll promise of providing monthly financial assistance of ₹2,100 to every woman in the state under the Lado Lakshmi Yojana. The pre-poll pacifier is likely to cost the state exchequer anything between ₹17,640 crore to ₹23,940 crore. Bijender, uncle of the deceased liquor contractor, Shantanu and a partner in the family's liquor business said that they received calls from criminals who threatened them not to participate in the bidding for liquor vends in Yamunanagar. 'Our partner, Mahender Rana also received such threat calls,' he said. Bijender told HT that his nephew, Shantanu had also received threat calls from gangsters last year. 'He had applied for an arms licence about six months back. The application is still pending with the office of SP, Kurukshetra,' he said. 'Shantanu was asked not to bid for a retail liquor zone in Kurukshetra last year. The gangsters said that they wanted a particular individual, one of their own probably, to get that retail liquor zone allotted. So, we did not participate. But the person who got that zone allotted was never investigated by the police,' said a member of the family of the deceased. Most of the liquor contractors HT spoke to preferred not to be named fearing reprisal by the gangsters. A contractor who was allotted vends in a national capital region (NCR) district said that it was primarily due to huge financial investment and fear of criminals that the contractors are disinclined to take risks by participating in bidding. 'The area of our operation is still trouble free. So, we took a calculated risk,' he said. 'Many contractors are so scared of the threats that they do not even want to report the matter,' said another contractor Excise officials told HT that 794 retail liquor zones were allotted in the first round of bidding from May 26 to May 31. In the second round of bidding from June 3 to June 6, 103 zones were allotted. 'But only 29 zones could be allotted in the third round on June 9, only two zones in the fourth round on June 10 and six zones were allotted in the fifth round on June 13,' said an official expressing dismay at the turn of events. Statistics tells a different story Excise officials, however, said they expect that the pending 260 retail liquor zones will also get allotted. An official spokesperson on Tuesday said the state government has been able to auction majority of the excise zones (934) so far and secure significantly higher revenue of ₹11,054 crore as compared to last year's ₹5,037 crores. 'The excise auctions have so far attracted good response,' the spokesperson said. However, liquor trade analysts said that it is irrational to compare the licence fee realised for 2025-27 policy with the revenue receipts earned from licence fee of corresponding zones in 2024-25. 'The present policy is applicable for 21 months and 20 days starting from June 12, 2025 to March 31, 2027 and the licence fee of ₹11,054 crore earned in the five rounds of auctions is for the same period spread over two financial years. So, this amount cannot be compared with the 2024-25 revenue earned from licence fee which was for a 12-month period. The ₹11,054 crore earned so far as licence fee will be paid in monthly instalments over 21 months,'' said a trade analyst not willing to be quoted. The excise policy lays down that 91% of the bid money shall be payable by the successful contractor in monthly instalments. Sensing the difficult situation, the state government had on May 20 amended the 2025-27 excise policy approved by the Council of Ministers on May 5 to ease the bidding process. The amended policy relaxed the stipulation of depositing 15% of the bid money or licence fee as security fee by reducing it to 11%.
Hindustan Times
35 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
Himachal BJP leaders hold protest over FIR against Bindal, others
Targeting the Sukhvinder Singh Sukhu led Congress government in the state, former chief minister Jai Ram Thakur accused it of targeting Hindus. 'Sukhu is conspiring to trap people belonging to Hindu society and send them to jail. He is trying to crush the sentiments of Hindutva and humiliate them,' said leader of opposition Jai Ram, during the Viksit Bharat Sankalp Sabha at Paonta Sahib in Sirmaur district on Wednesday. The statement was made during the protest organised by the BJP against the registration of attempt to murder case against 100 protestors, including party's state president Rajiv Bindal and MLA Sukhram Chaudhary, after they held protest seeking action against the accused involved in alleged abduction of a 18-year-old. Thakur said, 'The case filed against the Hindu community should be withdrawn. The police and administration should stop working under the protection of the government.' Congress government is harassing rivals: Bindal Bindal said that the present Congress government in the state has been harassing political rivals. Bindal alleged that on the orders of the Congress government, at the behest of local Congress leaders, the police and administration are harassing the people of the Hindu community, arresting them, creating an atmosphere of terror and filing cases of attempted murder against everyone, while not taking any action against those who pelted bricks and because of whom this matter started. 'This is the vote bank policy of the Congress and the atmosphere of the area is being spoiled for its sake,' said Bindal.
Hans India
39 minutes ago
- Hans India
Stop Banakacharla or let us meet in court: CM Revanth to Naidu
Hyderabad: Chief Minister A Revanth Reddy demanded his AP counterpart N Chandrababu Naidu to put on hold further construction of the Godavari-Banakacharla project until the water sharing dispute between the two Telugu states is resolved. Reddy appealed to Naidu to use his good offices and clout with the Centre to solve the water sharing disputes amicably. Holding former chief minister K Chandrashekar Rao responsible for Andhra Pradesh taking up the Banakacharla project, Reddy also blasted Union minister G Kishan Reddy for not supporting Telangana for stalling the controversial project as a means to protect the state's interests. Addressing the press after a power point presentation on the Banakacharla project at the Secretariat, the Chief minister said that the government would lodge complaint with the central government against the project and subsequently approach courts if the Centre did not respond to their demand. Revanth Reddy urged Naidu to issue a NOC to the extent that Telangana could utilise 1000 TMC of flood water in river Godavari and 500 TMC in Krishna. He added that if AP agreed, the TG government would support the Banakacharla project. Meanwhile, Reddy strongly objected to Andhra Pradesh lifting flood waters from Godavari without any allocations. Exposing the double standards of BRS on the Banakacharla project, the Chief Minister disclosed the details of the apex council meeting held in September 2016, and said that it was KCR, who had consented to AP lifting Godavari waters. KCR had informed that 3,000 TMCs of water was going waste into the sea from river Godavari, he pointed out. During meeting with YS Jagan Mohan Reddy, KCR on August 13, 2019 announced that Rayalaseema would be made 'Ratanala Seema' again. KCR and Jagan met four times at Pragathi Bhavan and decided to transfer Godavari waters to Rayalaseema, he said. Details of the meeting of the two CMs were also disclosed by the then ministers Eatala Rajender and Buggana Rajendra Prasad, Revanth explained and added that using these meeting minutes as a reference, Andhra Pradesh was constructing the Banakacharla project. The Chief Minister fired a salvo at KCR and former Irrigation minister T Harish Rao on giving assurance to AP as regards Godavari water utilization without specific allocations in the apex council meeting. 'KCR and Harish should be hanged to death for not protecting the interests of Telangana state. He also criticized KCR for not completing any project despite spending more than Rs 2 lakh crores on irrigation during the BRS rule", he said. Revanth Reddy said that he will seek appointments of Prime Minister Narendra Modi and union ministers during the Parliament session and brief them about the Banakacharla project and the problems being faced by Telangana state. 'We are ready to fight legally if justice is not rendered,' he said. The Chief minister wondered why Kishan Reddy had skipped such a crucial meeting and suspected that the union minister was playing a foul play to protect the union government from the threat of withdrawal of Naidu 's support in case the project was stalled.
