KZN Finance MEC highlights says municipalities are paying the price for poor national decisions
Image: Bongani Hans
KwaZulu-Natal Finance MEC Francois Rodgers, who described himself as a straight talker when it comes to money matters, has blamed the national government's 'bad policy decisions' for the suffering of the municipalities and key provincial government departments.
He was addressing mayors, municipal managers, and chief financial officers of seven municipalities who attended a workshop on the implementation of the Cash Management System (CMS) in Pietermaritzburg on Wednesday.
The CMS is expected to help the municipalities monitor and control the movement of money in and out of their fiscal system.
He said most municipalities were not interested in their financial flow until they ran out of money to deliver services, service debts, and pay salaries.
Video Player is loading.
Play Video
Play
Unmute
Current Time
0:00
/
Duration
-:-
Loaded :
0%
Stream Type LIVE
Seek to live, currently behind live
LIVE
Remaining Time
-
0:00
This is a modal window.
Beginning of dialog window. Escape will cancel and close the window.
Text Color White Black Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Background Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Opaque Semi-Transparent Transparent Window Color Black White Red Green Blue Yellow Magenta Cyan
Transparency Transparent Semi-Transparent Opaque
Font Size 50% 75% 100% 125% 150% 175% 200% 300% 400% Text Edge Style None Raised Depressed Uniform Dropshadow Font Family Proportional Sans-Serif Monospace Sans-Serif Proportional Serif Monospace Serif Casual Script Small Caps
Reset
restore all settings to the default values Done
Close Modal Dialog
End of dialog window.
Advertisement
Next
Stay
Close ✕
Ad loading
He said the Government of Provincial Unity (GPU) inherited a process of budgeting that would 'never get us out of trouble.'
He said the province was facing a huge crisis in the education, health and social development, and transport departments.
'Lots of what we are facing now is not out of our own making, [but] it is because post-COVID, and by some really bad policy decisions at the national level, like paying R600 million to state-owned entities when that money could have come to our provincial and local governments.
'We now have R5.7 trillion debt and we have to pay R1.2 billion interest on that debt,' said Rodgers.
He said bad policy decisions led to the government failing to save money, but instead, inequitable shares had to be cut by R70 billion over four years.
He addressed the municipalities a few hours after the provincial cabinet and Premier Thami Ntuli held a meeting about the state of local governments.
'One of the issues that the premier made clear is that both Cooperative Governance and Traditional Affairs, and Treasury, need to ensure that we get clean audits in the entire province,' he said.
Rodgers said when it came to money matters, he makes sure that 'there has to be straight talk'.
'There is no grey area when it comes to money, and if you are gonna spend money and you put politics ahead of principles, you are gonna make the wrong decisions.
'But if you put principles ahead of politics, and you implement your Municipal Finance Management Act and Public Finance Management Act, and any other legislations, then you are deciding for the right reasons,' said the DA provincial leader.
He said only political will would help the municipalities to transform their pattern of expenditure and patterns of poor fiscal control.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Citizen
2 hours ago
- The Citizen
Responses to US tariff increases may trigger closer tax scrutiny
Graphene Economics says even Mauritius is looking into intra-group transactions more closely. Global crises – such as the 2008 financial crisis, the Covid-19 pandemic, and the recent international trade tensions created by US President Donald Trump – generally result in renewed focus on tax collection, particularly from multinational companies. Tax authorities will take a closer look at companies' transfer pricing policies and whether prices are being adjusted because of outside shocks, or whether the tariff increases are a convenient opportunity to shift profits to head office countries, warns Michael Hewson, director at Graphene Economics. Transfer pricing is the price set when different parts of the same company, like its branches or subsidiaries, buy and sell things from each other – whether it is products, services, or ideas. Transfer pricing policies influence how much tax a company pays in the countries where it operate. ALSO READ: US tariffs: SA sends new proposal but no changes to laws Reduced prices Hewson says companies may react to the punitive tariffs introduced by the US by reducing the price of goods they export to the US in order to remain competitive. The risk is that they will lose market share if they do not make price adjustments to respond to the increased tariffs. This, says Hewson, may attract the attention of revenue authorities. 'The South African Revenue Service [Sars] may challenge why prices to a related party in the US are now lower than prices to third parties in other countries,' he explains. Hewson gives the example of a local manufacturer. If a global retailer, which manufacturers in China and other markets affected by high tariffs, sells more into SA, the demand for the local manufacturer's products may reduce. Especially if the prices charged by the global retailer reduce. This would impact the profitability of the local manufacturer. 'These reduced profits may cause Sars to ask whether the lower profits are due to its transfer pricing policy, even though it's actually impacted by external commercial factors.' ALSO READ: US tariff an existential threat for a third of metals and engineering sector Commercial rational Companies need to carefully record their decisions for making pricing adjustments, along with the commercial rationale behind them. When a dispute arises, it may be years after the actual event, and it can be quite a challenge to find the right documentation – or even people who were involved in the decision-making at the time. Hewson says Graphene Economics is increasingly receiving transfer pricing queries from countries it had not previously heard from. It has seen a notable increased focus on transfer pricing policies from East and West Africa. 'Governments are seeing transfer pricing as a big opportunity for revenue collections and the global shocks are proliferating the attention.' The work done by institutions such as the African Tax Administration Forum (Ataf), the Organisation for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), the United Nations, and the World Bank have assisted with capacity building, training, and the introduction of transfer pricing legislation into Africa. There has also been increased information sharing between Sars and revenue authorities in East Africa and West Africa. Mauritius, too, has recently been scrutinising intra-group transactions more closely and the number of audits has increased – something that has been unheard of in the recent past, notes Hewson. ALSO READ: Transfer pricing: 'Days of pleading ignorance are over' Reducing risk and costs Important tools to mitigate disputes with tax authorities include advanced pricing agreements (APAs) and mutual agreement procedures (MAPs). Hewson says there are several companies in SA that are keen to enter into APAs with the tax authorities. The main aim of an APA is to establish how prices will be set for future transactions, thereby reducing the risk of disputes following an audit, and the possibility of double taxation. Draft legislation for a proposed APA Programme was introduced in 2023 and according to ENSafrica, the draft bill included a clause indicating that a chapter on the APA programme will be inserted into the Income Tax Act. 'The introduction of the APA programme is a positive and significant development in South Africa's efforts to enhance its tax administration system. It provides taxpayers with an alternative, binding arrangement with Sars, and it will also offer upfront certainty on transfer pricing positions for a defined period,' the firm said at the time. Hewson notes that companies generally do not care where their profits are taxed, but they want to avoid double taxation. Several countries in Africa are using APAs. MAPs, on the other hand, offer a safety net when double taxation has already occurred due to tax authorities taking different positions. The key differences between APAs and MAPs Source: Microsoft Co-Pilot This article was republished from Moneyweb. Read the original here.
IOL News
18 hours ago
- IOL News
Online and unafraid: LGBTQIA+ Africans push back against colonial-era hate
In numerous African countries, including Ghana (above) and Zimbabwe, colonial-era anti-homosexuality laws continue to do great harm to LGBTQIA+ communities. In a push against these inherited laws and attitudes, queer Africans are utilising social media as a tool to foster greater acceptance. Image: Carl Collison Golden Moyo* is a lay preacher in rural Zimbabwe. In 2018, after decades of hiding his sexual orientation, Moyo came out to his family and friends and his parish as gay. Attitudes to sexual and gender minorities in Zimbabwe are highly conservative. Those found guilty of consensual same-sex sexual activity could face up to one years imprisonment and a fine. The southern African country's anti-homosexuality law was first introduced by the British during its colonisation of Zimbabwe. According to Human Dignity Trust, the country has noted 'consistent reports of discrimination and violence being committed against LGBTQIA+ people in recent years, including assault, sexual violence, harassment, blackmail, and the denial of basic rights and services'. Moyo's decision has not been without consequence. News of his sexuality soon 'went viral… (with) people deliberating upon it', he says. There was also a protest at the church's headquarters. Says Moyo: 'They were saying things like this is against our culture. This is against our religion. This is against our laws…They say it is strange. It is not part of us and did not originate from our own people. (That) it's a Western thing. When the noise started, (with) people protesting, you really need people who stand up to say, 'No, this thing is not Western'. It's our own thing. It has always been in our midst.' For Moyo, as with an increasing number of LGBTQIA+ persons across the country, social media is an essential tool in a continued push for a break from the narrative that homosexuality - and queerness, more broadly - is a Western import. Moyo's social media accounts on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok and X (formerly, Twitter) has a combined following of just under 10 000 people. He also uses Clubhouse 'for the (weekly) LGBTQIA+ fellowship'. Moyo says he first realised the power of social media during the Covid-19 pandemic. 'We could not gather as Christians, so we used to worship via social media. I realised that this is a thing that can quickly spread the message to others…I thought of it as a way that my voice can also be heard.' Tanatswa Gumbo, communications officer for the country's largest queer rights organisation, Gays and Lesbians of Zimbabwe, says LGBTQIA+ people 'definitely have become more visible on social media'. Image: Supplied Tanatswa Gumbo, communications officer for the country's largest queer rights organisation, Gays and Lesbians of Zimbabwe (GALZ), says LGBTQIA+ people 'definitely have become more visible on social media'. 'LGBTQIA+ persons, particularly activists, have really been visible and have really become more outspoken in terms of challenging conservative attitudes towards LGBTQIA+ people. Especially the claims of homosexuality being un-African; not being Christian,' says Gumbo. Research conducted by Princess Sibanda and Gibson Ncube found that, for queer Zimbabweans, online 'spaces represent a powerful act of resistance, a way for queer Zimbabweans to claim their right to exist and express themselves…. It's like they're sending love letters to the world, saying that queer love is just as important and beautiful as any other kind of love.' Zimbabwe is, of course, only one of numerous African states to have inherited homophobic laws and attitudes as a result of colonisation. The end of colonial rule has, however, seen some countries (such as Uganda, Nigeria, Kenya and Namibia) place added restrictions on the rights of LGBTQIA+ persons. Ghana is one such country. The West African state inherited its first anti-homosexuality law during British rule. Section 104 of the country's Criminal Code of 1960 - seen largely as 'an after-effect of the colonial era' - carries with it a sentence of up to three years' imprisonment for men found guilty of consensual same-sex relations. Ghana's latest anti-LGBT law, the Promotion of Proper Human Sexual Rights and Ghanaian Family Values Bill (commonly known as the Anti-LGBT Bill), is particularly draconian and has been described as 'brutal, harsh, and unjust'. In 2021, Angel Maxine, Ghana's only openly transgender musician and queer rights activist, penned a song, titled Kill the Bill, in protest against the Anti-LGBT Bill. In addition to using her music as a tool for awareness-raising, Maxine also relies heavily on social media to try and effect change. 'If social media was available…during the colonial days, I'm sure a lot of people would have been educated by now, and we would (not be in) this era that we are in,' Maxine says, in reference to the increasing queerphobic rhetoric sweeping across the continent. 'Because even though some of us are on social media, we are still living in our colonial days; still carrying the colonial thinking. But there are also people who are using social media who have broken free from this colonialism. In Africa, we have made use of social media positively to educate people.' Maxine is now living in Berlin, having fled Ghana as a result of persecution based on her gender identity and her queer rights activism. The distance from her home country makes her rely on social media even more. 'Sometimes when the grounds become very hard and difficult for us to meet in person, social media is where we can meet. I am currently in Germany, but I'm communicating with people in Ghana through social media.' Alex Kofi Donkor, the executive director of LGBT Rights Ghana, says LGBTQIA+ Ghanaians are creating social media content that challenges the narrative that queerness is a Western import. Image: Supplied Alex Kofi Donkor is the founder and executive director of LGBT Rights Ghana. 'I would say most of the mobilisation and most of the engagement at the initial stages (of establishing LGBT Rights Ghana)] was through social media. Even as of now, most of the mobilisation is done via various social media platforms,' says Donkor. Aside from activists utilising social media for policy and attitude reforms, there are also individual members of Ghana's LGBTQIA+ communities who, Donkor says, are 'putting content out there that challenges the status quo and challenges so many thoughts that Ghanaians have around LGBTQIA+ issues…that it's a Western import'. As could be expected, given the repressive contexts in which this content is created, there are downsides to proudly sharing pro-LGBTQIA+ content. A recent example of this was when a queer South African undertook the social media campaign, #ShowGhanaLove. Ostensibly meant as a show of solidarity with queer Ghanaians, the campaign had the opposite effect, as anti-queer politicians used the resultant public outrage to add pressure on the Ghanaian government to expedite the passing of the Anti-LGBT Bill. Says Donkor: 'People tend to react quickly when (LGBTQIA+ content) is openly or obviously put out there. People tend to react in a very negative way.' Ghanaian human rights activist, Angel Maxine, sees social media as an integral tool in raising awareness. Image: Eemmax Experience
The Citizen
21 hours ago
- The Citizen
New smoking laws will drive illicit tobacco market, warns industry leader
The proposed tobacco bill could change the way smokers access and enjoy cigarettes British American Tobacco South Africa (Batsa) has warned that the pending tobacco bill could make life easier for illicit traders. The tobacco giant gave a presentation to parliament's portfolio committee on health on Tuesday, where it outlined its opposition to the bill. The Tobacco Products and Electronic Delivery Systems Conrtol Bill could introduce a host of changes to the way smokers access and enjoy their vice of choice. Illicit trade doubles in 10 years Batsa's presentation explained how South Africa saw a excise tax loss of over R4 billion while smoking was banned during the 2020 government-mandated Covid lockdowns. Head of Corporate and Regulatory Affairs at the company's sub-Saharan Africa office, Johnny Moloto, said the industry was now dominated by illicit trade. Moloto highlighted how, in the space of 10 years, the illicit trade has gone from 35% of the market to roughly 75% currently. ALSO READ: Sars fights on, as illicit trade 'devastates' SA's fiscus He stated that the trend was cemented during the 2020 cigarette sales ban that saw smokers hunting for alternatives. Batsa's footprint in South Africa includes a factory exporting to eight markets, 35 000 industry-related jobs and 1 600 employees and a GDP contribution of R14.8 billion. 'We as Batsa contribute R8 billion annually in taxes to the fiscus, yet we are expected to compete against criminal syndicates,' Moloto said. Plain packaging an own-goal He explained that Batsa believes the bill is 'fundamentally flawed' due to a lack of both compliance and enforcement. 'This impact will only be felt by a small, compliant minority while the illicit majority thrive,' said Moloto. 'Every measure that we believe makes legal products less accessible or more expensive, we believe will drive more consumers towards the illicit market, where government has zero control over the contents, quality and age restrictions.' Some of the key outcomes of the bill aim to convert all indoor public spaces into smoke-free zones, mandatory plain packaging and a ban on cigarette vending machines and product displays. Moloto stressed that forcing manufacturers to release products in plain packaging would aid illicit sales as it would make it harder to detect counterfeit goods. Additionally, removing product displays at points of sale would deny consumers the ability to make informed decisions. The bill would also regulate vaping, with Moloto urging the committee to consider changes that would differentiate between combustibles and smokeless products based on risk levels. NOW READ: Tobacco Bill bans sale of loose cigarettes – informal traders fear bankruptcy
