ABC and CBS settlements with Trump are dangerous step toward the commander in chief becoming editor-in-chief
It was a surrender widely foreseen. For months, rumors abounded that Paramount would eventually settle the seemingly frivolous lawsuit brought by President Donald Trump concerning editorial decisions in the production of a CBS interview with Democratic presidential nominee Kamala Harris in 2024.
On July 2, those rumors proved true: The settlement between Paramount and Trump's legal team resulted in CBS's parent company agreeing to pay $16 million to the future Donald Trump Library – the $16 million included Trump's legal fees – in exchange for ending the lawsuit. Despite the opinion of many media law scholars and practicing attorneys who considered the lawsuit meritless, Shari Redstone, the largest shareholder of Paramount, yielded to Trump.
Redstone had been trying to sell Paramount to Skydance Media since July 2024, but the transaction was delayed by issues involving government approval.
Specifically, when the Trump administration assumed power in January 2025, the new Federal Communications Commission had no legal obligation to facilitate, without scrutiny, the transfer of the CBS network's broadcast licenses for its owned-and-operated TV stations to new ownership.
The FCC, under newly installed Republican Chairman Brendan Carr, was fully aware of the issues in the legal conflict between Trump and CBS at the time Paramount needed FCC approval for the license transfers. Without a settlement, the Paramount-Skydance deal remained in jeopardy.
Until it wasn't.
At that point, Paramount joined Disney in implicitly apologizing for journalism produced by their TV news divisions.
Earlier in 2025, Disney had settled a different Trump lawsuit with ABC News in exchange for a $15 million donation to the future Trump Library. That lawsuit involved a dispute over the wording of the actions for which Trump was found liable in a civil lawsuit brought by E. Jean Carroll.
It's not certain what the ABC and CBS settlements portend, but many are predicting they will produce a 'chilling effect' within the network news divisions. Such an outcome would arise from fear of new litigation, and it would install a form of internal self-censorship that would influence network journalists when deciding whether the pursuit of investigative stories involving the Trump administration would be worth the risk.
Trump has apparently succeeded where earlier presidents failed.
Presidential pressure
From Jimmy Carter trying to get CBS anchor Walter Cronkite to stop ending his evening newscasts with the number of days American hostages were being held in Iran to Richard Nixon's administration threatening the broadcast licenses of The Washington Post's TV stations to weaken Watergate reporting, previous presidents sought to apply editorial pressure on broadcast journalists.
But in the cases of Carter and Nixon, it didn't work. The broadcast networks' focus on both Watergate and the Iran hostage crisis remained unrelenting.
Nor were Nixon and Carter the first presidents seeking to influence, and possibly control, network news.
President Lyndon Johnson, who owned local TV and radio stations in Austin, Texas, regularly complained to his old friend, CBS President Frank Stanton, about what he perceived as biased TV coverage. Johnson was so furious with the CBS and NBC reporting from Vietnam, he once argued that their newscasts seemed 'controlled by the Vietcong.'
Yet none of these earlier presidents won millions from the corporations that aired ethical news reporting in the public interest.
Before Trump, these conflicts mostly occurred backstage and informally, allowing the broadcasters to sidestep the damage to their credibility should any surrender to White House administrations be made public. In a 'Reporter's Notebook' on the CBS Evening News the night of the Trump settlement, anchor John Dickerson summarized the new dilemma succinctly: 'Can you hold power to account when you've paid it millions? Can an audience trust you when it thinks you've traded away that trust?'
'The audience will decide that,' Dickerson continued, concluding: 'Our job is to show up to honor what we witness on behalf of the people we witness it for.'
Holding power to account
There's an adage in TV news: 'You're only as good as your last show.'
Soon, SkyDance Media will assume control over the Paramount properties, and the new CBS will be on the airwaves.
When the licenses for KCBS in Los Angeles, WCBS in New York and the other CBS-owned-and-operated stations are transferred, we'll learn the long-term legacy of corporate capitulation. But for now, it remains too early to judge tomorrow's newscasts.
As a scholar of broadcast journalism and a former broadcast journalist, I recommend evaluating programs like '60 Minutes' and the 'CBS Evening News' on the record they will compile over the next three years – and the record they compiled over the past 50. The same goes for 'ABC World News Tonight' and other ABC News programs.
A major complicating factor for the Paramount-Skydance deal was the fact that '60 Minutes' has, over the past six months, broken major scoops embarrassing to the Trump administration, which led to additional scrutiny by its corporate ownership. Judged by its reporting in the first half of 2025, '60 Minutes' has upheld its record of critical and independent reporting in the public interest.
If audience members want to see ethical, independent and professional broadcast journalism that holds power to account, then it's the audience's responsibility to tune it in. The only way to learn the consequences of these settlements is by watching future programming rather than dismissing it beforehand.
The journalists working at ABC News and CBS News understand the legacy of their organizations, and they are also aware of how their owners have cast suspicion on the news divisions' professionalism and credibility. As Dickerson asserted, they plan to 'show up' regardless of the stain, and I'd bet they're more motivated to redeem their reputations than we expect.
I don't think reporters, editors and producers plan to let Donald Trump become their editor-in-chief over the next three years. But we'll only know by watching.
Michael J Socolow is Professor of Communication and Journalism, University of Maine.
The Conversation is an independent and nonprofit source of news, analysis and commentary from academic experts.
External Link
https://theconversation.com/abcs-and-cbss-settlements-with-trump-are-a-dangerous-step-toward-the-commander-in-chief-becoming-the-editor-in-chief-261006
© The Conversation
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Japan Today
an hour ago
- Japan Today
Asian shares retreat after Alphabet and AI stocks nudge Wall Street to more records
People walk in front of an electronic stock board showing Japan's Nikkei index at a securities firm Friday, July 25, 2025, in Tokyo. (AP Photo/Eugene Hoshiko) By TERESA CEROJANO Asian shares retreated on Friday after Wall Street inched to more records as gains for Alphabet and artificial-intelligence stocks helped offset a steep tumble for EV-maker Tesla. Japan's Nikkei 225 fell 0.9% to 41,456.23 after two days of gains following President Donald Trump's announcement of a trade deal that would place a 15% tax on imports from Japan. That's lower than the 25% rate that Trump had earlier said would kick in on Aug. 1. Data released on Friday showed the inflation rate in Japan's capital Tokyo rose 2.9% year-on-year in July, down from 3.1% in June. Japanese government efforts to moderate inflation are working, though underlying Tokyo price pressures remain elevated, ING Economics said in a commentary. It expects the Bank of Japan to hold interest rates steady at its July 30-31 meeting, but said the central bank would likely raise its forecast for inflation. In the Chinese markets, Hong Kong's Hang Seng shed 1.1% to 25,381.85 and the Shanghai Composite index slid 0.4% to 3,591.79. Next week, U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent has said he will meet with Chinese officials in Stockholm, Sweden, to work toward a deal with Beijing ahead of a tariff truce that expires on Aug. 12. Trump has said a China trip 'is not too distant' as trade tensions ease. 'One big question for markets is whether the tariff ceasefire is extended. We expect that an agreement will be attainable, but, in the interim, markets will watch closely to see if there are adjustments to current tariff rates in either direction,' ING Economics said. In South Korea, the Kospi picked up 0.2% to 3,196.05, while Australia's S&P/ASX 200 shed 0.5% to 8,666.90. Taiwan's Taiex edged less than 0.1% lower, and in India, the Sensex fell 0.8%. On Thursday, the S&P 500 added 0.1% to its all-time high set the day before, closing at 6,363.35. The Dow Jones Industrial Average fell 0.7% to 44,693.91, while the Nasdaq composite rose 0.2% to a record 21,057.96. Alphabet climbed 1% after the company behind Google and YouTube delivered a fatter profit for the latest quarter than analysts expected. It's leaning more into artificial-intelligence technology and said it's increasing its budget for AI chips and other investments this year by $10 billion to $85 billion. That helped push up other stocks in the AI industry, including a 1.7% rise for Nvidia. The chip company was the strongest single force lifting the S&P 500 because it's the largest on Wall Street in terms of value. But an 8.2% drop for Tesla kept the market in check. Elon Musk's electric-vehicle company reported results for the spring that were roughly in line with or above analysts' expectations, and Musk is trying to highlight Tesla's moves into AI and robotaxis. The focus, though, remains on how Musk's foray into politics is turning off potential customers, and he said several rough quarters may be ahead as 'we're in this weird transition period where we'll lose a lot of incentives in the U.S.' Stocks have broadly been rallying for weeks on hopes that President Donald Trump will reach trade deals with other countries that will lower his stiff proposed tariffs, along with the risk that they could cause a recession and drive up inflation. In other dealings on Friday, U.S. benchmark crude oil added 51 cents to $66.54 per barrel. Brent crude, the international standard, rose 48 cents to $68.84 per barrel. The U.S. dollar was nearly unchanged at 147.01 Japanese yen. The euro rose to $1.1759 from $1.1748. © Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without permission.
Japan Today
2 hours ago
- Japan Today
'South Park' co-creator jokes he's 'terribly sorry' over premiere that drew White House anger
By ANDREW DALTON 'South Park' co-creator Trey Parker had the briefest of responses Thursday to anger from the White House over the season premiere of the animated institution, which showed a naked President Donald Trump in bed with Satan. 'We're terribly sorry,' Parker said, followed by a long, deadpan-comic stare. Parker was asked for his reaction to the fracas as he sat on the stage at San Diego's Comic-Con International at the beginning of a Comedy Central animation panel that also included his 'South Park' partner Matt Stone, 'Beavis and Butt-Head' creator Mike Judge, and actor Andy Samberg, who co-created the animated 'Digman!' Earlier in the day, the White House issued a statement on the 27th season premiere, which aired Wednesday night. 'This show hasn't been relevant for over 20 years and is hanging on by a thread with uninspired ideas in a desperate attempt for attention,' White House spokesperson Taylor Rogers said in the statement. 'President Trump has delivered on more promises in just six months than any other president in our country's history – and no fourth-rate show can derail President Trump's hot streak.' Later in the panel, Parker said they did get a note from their producers on Tuesday night's episode. 'They said, 'OK, but we're gonna blur the penis,' and I said, 'No you're not gonna blur the penis,'' Parker said. The premiere also took aim at Paramount and its $16 million recent settlement with Trump just hours after Parker and Stone signed a five-year deal with the company for 50 new episodes and streaming rights to previous seasons. The Los Angeles Times and other outlets report the deal was worth $1.5 billion. In the episode, Trump sues the town of South Park when its residents challenge the presence of Jesus Christ – the actual person – in its elementary school. Jesus tells them they ought to settle. 'You guys saw what happened to CBS? Yeah, well, guess who owns CBS? Paramount,' Jesus says. 'Do you really want to end up like Colbert?' CBS and parent Paramount Global canceled Stephen Colbert's 'Late Show' last week, days after Colbert sharply criticized Paramount's settlement of Trump's lawsuit over a '60 Minutes' interview. CBS and Paramount executives said it was a financial decision to axe 'The Late Show.' The efficiency of 'South Park' production, and the brinksmanship of its creators, allow it to stay incredibly current for an animated series. 'I don't know what next week's episode is going to be,' Parker said at Comic-Con. 'Even just three days ago, we were like, 'I don't know if people are going to like this.'' © Copyright 2025 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten or redistributed without permission.
Kyodo News
3 hours ago
- Kyodo News
FOCUS: Trade deal with U.S. still weighs on Japan's inflation-hit economy
TOKYO - The Japan-U.S. trade deal provides only a brief relief, as tariffs remain at higher levels than before, threatening to hinder Japan's inflation-plagued economy from recovering, analysts say. While Japan offered an increased $550 billion investment in the U.S. market, according to a social media post by U.S. President Donald Trump, worries remain about the impact of tariffs on Japanese businesses. Shinichiro Kobayashi, principal economist at Mitsubishi UFJ Research and Consulting, said the deal is positive in a sense that uncertainty was removed for Japanese companies to make business plans. But "the tariff rates have been raised significantly since President Trump took office, and the situation remains the same," he said. The increasing risk of a U.S. economic slowdown means the agreement is not expected to guarantee a boost to Japan's exports, Kobayashi said. Tariffs on steel and aluminum products remain at 50 percent and Trump said he would impose a 50 percent tariff on copper imports and reiterated he will soon unleash sector-based duties, including some aimed at protecting the American pharmaceutical and semiconductor industries. Hideo Kumano, an executive chief economist at Dai-ichi Life Research Institute, said as far as the 15-percent reciprocal tariffs levied on Japanese goods are concerned, "it is difficult to say whether the risk of an economic slowdown for Japan has been removed." Japan's economy shrank an annualized real 0.2 percent in the January-March period, the first contraction in four quarters, as inflation bit into private consumption. Economists expect the Japanese economy to rebound in the April-June quarter but it is unclear whether companies will be able to offer high wage increases next year as seen in recent years if they are suffering from slowing exports to the U.S. market. Higher wages are expected to play a key role for Japan to get back on a steady growth path. A recent surge in long-term interest rates in financial markets also clouds the outlook for Japan's smooth economy recovery, as the move could dent corporate investment and consumer spending. Takahide Kiuchi, executive economist at Nomura Research Institute, said the Japan-U.S. tariff deal is expected to reduce Japan's gross domestic product by 0.55 percentage point in 2025. He had earlier projected the Japanese economy would be cut by 0.85 point under the assumption the reciprocal tariffs would be imposed at 25 percent. On the bright side, Japan and the United States did agree on 15 percent tariffs on Japanese cars and other products in the last-minute trade talks with the Trump administration on Tuesday in Washington. Japanese Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba urged chief tariff negotiator Ryosei Akazawa to convince the U.S. administration of the benefit of Japan's massive investment plans. According to Akazawa, the prime minister said "What will benefit both Japan and the U.S. is investment rather than tariffs. Don't be afraid and don't give in. Push the point thoroughly." A senior Japanese government official said, "Mr. Trump was insisting on 20 percent (for the car tariff) until the very end. It was eventually dropped to 15 percent, and Mr. Trump seemed dissatisfied." A source close to the matter said Japan's strategy to identify U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick as the key negotiator and convince him of the advantages of Japanese investment rather than imposing tariffs on Japan-made goods paid off. Starting in April, the Trump administration imposed a total tariff of 27.5 percent on foreign-made cars, and the president said earlier in the month the United States would impose 25 percent tariffs on imports from Japan starting Aug. 1 under "reciprocal" tariffs. The lower auto tariff, which will have a very large impact on the Japanese economy, is an important achievement," said Mieko Nakabayashi, professor at Waseda University specializing in U.S. politics. "Going forward, the government will be required to provide support to domestic companies in order to cope with the new tariff rates."
