Echo Chamber: So, who's to blame for the cost of living?
Echo Chamber is The Spinoff's dispatch from the press gallery, recapping sessions in the House. Columns are written by politics reporter Lyric Waiwiri-Smith and Wellington editor Joel MacManus.
No one can shut up about the cost of living. And fair enough – butter is, like, a million dollars, and tens of thousands of people who are essential to our health system are walking off the job today because they're still not paid enough for the work we applauded them for doing through the worst years of our lives. With all of this going on, the pro-growth (of the good kind, not the bad kind) government has been very keen to remind the nation of all the great work they've done to improve our lives. But, they're definitely not panicking or anything – they're just setting the record straight, of course.
Which is why Monday's post-cabinet press conference began with ten minutes of prime minister Christopher Luxon and finance minister Nicola Willis rattling off a list of their pro-growth achievements this term. And why the minister kicked off Tuesday's question time session with patsies from National backbencher Suze Redmayne, reminding the House of the government's efforts in tax relief and Family Boost.
But there was this annoying little voice that kept popping up (amid all the other heckling). Was it Karl Marx himself, risen from the dead to personally punish Willis? No, it was just Greens' co-leader Chlöe Swarbrick, on a mission to set her version of the record straight. 'Road user charges!' Swarbrick reminded the minister. How about putting a price-tag back on prescriptions? Or the price of butter? There was a distinct look of disgust from Swarbrick when Willis wrapped up.
Up next was Labour leader Chris Hipkins, who questioned Luxon over – you guessed it – the cost of living crisis and nurses, but when he began a supplementary by using the word 'so', a smart aleck on the front bench thought they'd pull a fast one. 'Point of order, Mr Speaker,' said Act leader David Seymour. 'Speakers have ruled that you cannot begin with a word like 'so' … Usually a question must begin with a question word.'
Well, Gerry Brownlee replied, the member used 'so does', and I've overlooked the 'so', so it does go – and haven't there been occasions when the minister himself has done the same thing? 'I got away with it,' Seymour quipped. 'Yeah, well, guess what's happening here,' Brownlee replied.
Armed with a pile of notes, Luxon rejected Hipkins' characterisations and claims – but he seemed to lose his cool after so much back and forth. 'If you're really serious about the cost of living, will you support a rate cap on councils? Yes or no?' Luxon challenged his counterpart in red, but that earned him a cuff around the ear from the speaker.
The prime minister cannot ask questions, Brownlee reminded him. 'It's a rhetorical one,' Luxon replied. 'Rhetorical or not, it's a question,' Brownlee countered. 'It was just a rhetorical answer,' Luxon grumbled. Not much achieved thus far.
There were fisticuffs again when Labour's finance spokesperson Barbara Edmonds questioned Willis over whether the country was truly 'back on course' – kinda like 'back on track', but just a bit different. And again the minister rattled off a list of figures of where inflation was at in 2022 and 2023 under the Labour government to prove a point that the current state of inflation is simply all inherited and not really her fault, until Brownlee cut her off with 'that's enough'.
'Ruth Richardson would be proud,' Hipkins cried.
Later, famed orator Shane Jones, minister for resources, struggled through his sentences despite NZ First MP Jamie Arbuckle giving him a wide open pass to boast about his portfolio, ahead of the final reading of the Crown Minerals Amendment Bill on Thursday. Though he did find his flow while trashing the 'unicorn-kissing, shallow green ideas' that led to 'the perfidy of the cancellation of the oil and gas industry by Jacinda Ardern' that he is trying to repeal (despite being a cabinet minister in the government which enforced the ban).
But Labour MP Kieran McAnulty wasn't having a bar of it: point of order – but aren't these remarks a clear example of the very thing you've warned this government about multiple times, using questions to express their thoughts on previous policies? McAnulty kept going, but Brownlee cut him off by saying that while he agreed, it was fine to talk about 'factual matters', just as long as they're not attacking the opposition.
'Point of order,' Jones rose again. 'I'm very happy that you used the word 'factual'. It is a fact that the oil and gas industry was chilled, halted, as a consequence of a decision announced by so said woman' (aka his former colleague, Jacinda Ardern).
A groan rippled through the House after that one. Jones is a minister who likes to bark out words like 'fiction!' when his opponents across the aisle are speaking about climate change, and 'mining!' at random intervals to remind the House of his dedication to the kaupapa. So Swarbrick gave Jones a taste of his own medicine when he came to boast about his plans to travel to Taupō – 'the heart of geothermal potential' – today to begin consultations to identify what 'red tape' might be 'blighting' the acceleration of the industry.
'Are you talking about the lobbyists?' she called. 'Tell us about your fossil fuel lobbyist mates.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
NZ Herald
15 hours ago
- NZ Herald
Christopher Luxon and Anthony Albanese talks focus on 30-year problem: Lifting living standards
'You must remember that it is Russia and Vladimir Putin who is the aggressor here, who has breached international law, who has engaged in an illegal and immoral invasion of Ukraine, who has taken action which has resulted in death and destruction in Ukraine. 'And Vladimir Putin can end all this tomorrow. He can just withdraw behind his boundaries of Russia.' Australian Prime Minister Anthony Albanese (front, second from left), his partner Jodie Haydon (front left) with New Zealand Prime Minister Christopher Luxon (third from front left) and his wife Amanda at a wreath-laying ceremony at the War Memorial in Arrowtown. Photo / Derek Cheng Following their helicopter ride, Luxon told media the transtasman relationship was 'as strong as it's ever been'. 'That helps a lot, when you've got good chemistry with the leader. We're very aligned.' Last night, they met with business leaders to hear about how to make it easier to do business on both sides of the Tasman. 'We want to be as frictionless as possible,' Luxon said, citing building products as an example. 'There's a lot that we could actually simplify, some of our standards, across both markets.' He said improving productivity was a 'big focus' of their conversation. 'It's been a problem for 30 years in both countries actually under successive Governments. Everyone's working hard, but we haven't been able to lift everyone's collective living standards sufficiently.' Anthony Albanese (left) and Christopher Luxon in Queenstown for annual transtasman talks. Photo / Derek Cheng It was Luxon and Albanese's fourth face-to-face meeting as Prime Ministers. Yesterday, they released a joint statement urging Israel to reconsider its plan to take full control of Gaza. The annual transtasman talks follow Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu's announcement on Friday that Israel plans to take full control of Gaza. 'Any attempt by Israel to escalate hostilities, including by taking control of Gaza City, would be wrong, risk violating international law and exacerbate the human catastrophe already unfolding inside the Gaza Strip,' a joint statement from Luxon and Albanese following their meeting said. Luxon also brought up the controversial and ongoing issue of 501 deportees to New Zealand from Australia, though there was no indication of Australia softening its stance. Albanese and Luxon also discussed recognising the state of Palestine, and their shared respective positions that it's a matter of when, not if. Australia has recently suggested it may be willing to make the recognition sooner rather than later, with Foreign Minister Penny Wong warning of a risk 'there will be no Palestine left to recognise'. Derek Cheng is a senior journalist who started at the Herald in 2004. He has worked several stints in the press gallery team and is a former deputy political editor.
1News
19 hours ago
- 1News
Luxon, Albanese speak about Palestinian statehood in Queenstown visit
Prime Minister Christopher Luxon and his Australian counterpart Anthony Albanese have reiterated their positions on recognising Palestinian statehood, but neither would shed light on a possible timeframe for that move. Other Western nations, including France, the United Kingdom, and Canada, have recently declared an intention to recognise a state of Palestine at an upcoming United Nations summit next month. That consideration also comes at the same time as the United States - a staunch ally of Israel - conducts trade negotiations over its roll-out of tariffs - including 15% on New Zealand goods. But, speaking from Queenstown after their annual Australia-New Zealand Leaders' Meeting, both Luxon and Albanese said they would make their own calculations and decisions about Palestine "independent" of such considerations. "We make our own assessments in... our own economic and our security interests," Luxon said. ADVERTISEMENT New Zealand's Prime Minister Christopher Luxon welcoming Australia's Prime Minister Anthony Albanese to Queenstown. Photo: RNZ / Katie Todd (Source: "Australia has exactly the same position," Albanese added. "As a sovereign nation, we make our decisions." NZ, Aus advocate for diplomacy over military action in Gaza Behind closed doors at Taramea - a private retreat built by Xero founder Rod Drury - the two men discussed the "ongoing humanitarian crisis in Gaza", as well as a range of other geopolitical tensions, relationships and conflicts. In response to questions from media, both leaders laid out their expectations and hopes for the crisis. "[Australians] want to see a ceasefire," Albanese said. "They want to see the killing stop. They want to see hostages released. They want to see peace in the region. Anthony Albanese and Christopher Luxon speaking in Queenstown. Photo: RNZ/Katie Todd (Source: ADVERTISEMENT "They don't want conflict brought to Australia either." Luxon said New Zealand's position was clear: "We want to see hostages released. We want to see unfettered humanitarian aid flooding into Gaza. And we want to see a ceasefire. "The military action that we've seen is not the way to solve this problem. It requires diplomacy. It requires dialogue." Luxon said both New Zealand and Australia were "a long way away" from the conflict and had "limited influence", but they did what they could to advocate for their values, including by signing up to a new joint statement on Saturday. Earlier on Saturday, the foreign ministers of New Zealand, Australia, Germany, Italy, and the United Kingdom issued a joint statement condemning Israel's latest large-scale military operation in Gaza. They warned the plans risked violating international law and would aggravate the "catastrophic humanitarian situation". Anthony Albanese arriving on Saturday. Photo: RNZ / Katie Todd (Source: ADVERTISEMENT The statement also reaffirmed support for a negotiated two-state solution, contingent on a demilitarised Hamas having no role in the governance of Gaza. No breakthrough in 501 impasse Both leaders reiterated their unchanged positions on a longstanding Trans-Tasman disagreement over the issue of 501 deportees. Responding to a question from RNZ, Albanese said "you won't be surprised" that Luxon had once again raised the matter with him. "I'd expect him to," Albanese said. "But as Australia's Prime Minister, you'd expect me to say that the issue of Australia's national interest is what we put first in all of our relations." Following up, Luxon said he accepted Australia's right to make its own border rules, but that many of those returning deportees had "very little connection to New Zealand". ADVERTISEMENT The 501 impasse goes back to the early 2010s when Australia started cancelling visas of New Zealanders under its character test, even those who had spent nearly all their lives in Australia. In 2022, Albanese emerged from talks with former PM Jacinda Ardern to promise a more compassionate approach, but in 2024, facing domestic political pressure, he reversed course and reinstated stricter deportation policies. The two leaders also announced a new partnership between their national standards bodies, which they said would make trade even easier and support economic growth on both sides of the Tasman. Both men joked during the media conference about the frigid temperatures in Queenstown. Luxon quipped that he was losing 40% of his body heat through his "bullet-shaped head". At the close of questions, Albanese said they were now going back inside "for a cuddle". Albanese reflects on his last visit to Queenstown as a backpacker ADVERTISEMENT The summit opened on Saturday afternoon with a pōwhiri by Ngai Tahu, which Albanese described as "very moving". Albanese is accompanied on the visit by fiancée Jodie Haydon. In his opening remarks, Albanese thanked Luxon and his wife Amanda for the "warm generous welcome" and said it was a "delight" to be back in New Zealand - his third visit as prime minister, but one of many over the years. He recalled last visiting Queenstown as a backpacker "last century" and said holding the meeting in such a location was "a great honour". Albanese spoke of the "uncertain world" the two nations face; the one certainty, he said, was that "Australia and New Zealand stand together", a relationship going back to the ANZACs. Luxon's comments reflected a similar sentiment: "The world seems really uncertain and fractious, and actually, we have no greater friend than Australia." He and Albanese have known each other since Luxon's time at Air New Zealand, when Albanese was Australia's transport minister. The yearly fixture alternates between the two countries and allows the prime ministers to discuss bilateral ties and set priorities for the year ahead. ADVERTISEMENT Luxon has called the trans-Tasman relationship "the best it's ever been". Two-way trade is worth $32 billion, and ministers on both sides have been meeting regularly to strengthen ties. Later today, the leaders will lay a wreath at Arrowtown War Memorial Park before Albanese departs. By Katie Todd and Craig McCulloch of
Otago Daily Times
a day ago
- Otago Daily Times
New era of trans-Tasman co-operation in turbulent world
Australia and New Zealand are entering a new era of co-operation as leaders from both nations embrace shared values in an increasingly turbulent world. Prime Minister Anthony Albanese is in Queenstown for a two-day meeting with his New Zealand counterpart Christopher Luxon, marking his second time crossing the Tasman as leader after last visiting in 2023. In a show of the bond between the two nations, Mr Luxon warmly embraced the Australian prime minister as they met on Saturday for leadership talks. The first day centred on unity between the two nations and how they can co-operate on various issues, including safeguarding security and prosperity in an increasingly uncertain geo-strategic environment. This included committing to further integrating the two nations' economies in the "most unpredictable and dangerous" strategic environment in decades. Foreign policy challenges relating to dealing with China, the United States and China's encroachment in the South Pacific region would be agenda-topping issues, University of Otago politics researcher Nicholas Khoo said. Both leaders agreed that competition between the world's superpowers, China and the US, needed to be managed, and continued dialogue was important to reduce risks of misunderstanding, miscalculation, escalation and conflict in the Pacific region. China was the main topic on everyone's lips, with the pair discussing their grave concerns over its increasingly "dangerous and provocative" behaviour in the South China Sea. Mr Luxon said the Asian superpower was a significant player in the world and a permanent feature of global affairs. "We have an approach which is about co-operating where we can ... We disagree where we must. We have different systems, different values," he said, which Mr Albanese echoed. Both leaders praised work to strengthen military co-operation, which Prof Khoo said was appropriate given the increasing uncertainty in international politics. "It's an area where we could legitimately expect to see very real progress," he told AAP. Prof Khoo said this meeting showed the two neighbours' "steady build-up" of co-operation, which he said didn't exist until two years ago. '"This is, in some aspects, a new era of co-operation, which is a positive development for both sides." Prof Khoo said New Zealand only had one alliance partner in Australia, and this summit showed its investment in that relationship. "In these very turbulent times, this is one of the linchpins of regional security that deserves the attention," he said. The Australian and New Zealand standards bodies have also announced a new agreement to renew joint standards arrangements, which will streamline regulations for certain sectors, including construction, healthcare and manufacturing, to boost economic growth. In a sign of closer ties, Mr Albanese joked about going for a "cuddle" as both leaders sauntered off after the media conference arm-in-arm, laughing. No breakthrough on 501 But both leaders reiterated their unchanged positions on a longstanding Trans-Tasman disagreement over the issue of 501 deportees. Responding to a question from RNZ, Mr Albanese said: "you won't be surprised" that Mr Luxon had once again raised the matter with him. "I'd expect him to," Mr Albanese said. "But as Australia's Prime Minister, you'd expect me to say that the issue of Australia's national interest is what we put first in all of our relations." Following up, Mr Luxon said he accepted Australia's right to make its own border rules, but that many of those returning deportees had "very little connection to New Zealand". The 501 impasse goes back to the early 2010s when Australia started cancelling visas of New Zealanders under its character test, even those who had spent nearly all their lives in Australia. In 2022, Albanese emerged from talks with former prime minister Dame Jacinda Ardern to promise a more compassionate approach, but in 2024, facing domestic political pressure, he reversed course and reinstated stricter deportation policies. On Sunday, the leaders will lay a wreath at Arrowtown War Memorial Park before Mr Albanese departs. - AAP and RNZ
