Gabby Petito's AI-faked voice in new Netflix documentary sparks viewer backlash
Petito's disappearance and death made headlines in September 2021, with authorities launching a nationwide search for the 22-year-old after she'd documented a cross-country road trip with her fiancé, Brian Laundrie, on social media.
Laundrie was considered a 'person of interest' before he disappeared. He later died by suicide, and a note was found in which he claimed responsibility, officials said.
The three-part series, released this week, features interviews with Petito's loved ones, as well as photographs, video footage, maps and writing excerpts. A disclaimer in the first episode notes that Petito's journal entries and text messages were 'brought to life in this series in her own voice, using voice recreation technology.'
While directors and executive producers Julia Willoughby Nason and Michael Gasparro told Us Weekly that Petito's family gave their 'blessing' to recreate her voice in the film, viewers online expressed their distaste for the creative choice. Some X users called it 'unsettling,' 'deeply uncomfortable,' and 'wholly unnecessary.' One TikTok video, which has garnered nearly 500,000 views, described the decision as a 'step too far.'
A representative for Gasparro and Nason did not immediately respond to a request for comment Friday. A spokesperson for Netflix also did not immediately respond.
The use of AI technology like this in documentaries is not new. But audiences appear to remain conflicted about hearing recreations of the voices of people who have died.
In 2021, after AI voice recreation was used to bring written notes to life in 'Roadrunner: A Film About Anthony Bourdain,' many fans of the food host, who died in 2018, had similar issues with director Morgan Neville's creative choice. The filmmaker used a software company to create an 'AI model' of Bourdain's voice. He told The New Yorker that viewers 'probably don't know' which lines are spoken by the AI model.
In his statement to Us Weekly, Gasparro said the filmmakers "had so much material from her parents that we were able to get."
"All of her journals since she was young and there was so much of her writing. She documented her trips and most of her life from a young age. We thought it was really important to bring that to life,' Gasparro told the publication. 'At the end of the day, we wanted to tell the story as much through Gabby as possible. It's her story.'
Merve Hickok, president and policy director at the Center for AI and Digital Policy, a nonprofit research group, said the general use of voice recreation is not inherently unethical.
Voice cloning to bring to life already public elements to amplify or make them more accessible is an 'OK use,' according to Hickok. But issues can arise when filmmakers share confidential content in a deeply personal way.
'The person made a decision to keep that private,' Hickok said. 'And it is not up to us. It's not up to any of us to make that decision on their behalf after they passed away.'
"I think especially in a murder case, this person's voice is taken away against her will, so to come back and recreate that after her for commercial reasons is not ethical, regardless of whether there was a family approval or not,' Hickok added.
Some of Petito's family members have since spoken to The Independent about the reaction to the voice recreation, reflecting on their decision to give filmmakers permission.
'I think it's weird and because we know her actual voice, [it] is a little off,' Nichole Schmidt, Petito's mom, told the publication. 'It's just hard to hear.'
'AI or her real voice, I still get upset hearing it knowing she's gone,' her stepfather, Jim Schmidt, added.
In the future, Hickok, who is also the founder of AIethicist.org, does see the potential benefits of voice cloning for family to make 'pre-existing arrangements to use voice as a remembrance after a family member passes away.'
But, she urged filmmakers to think of the 'negative risks,' adding that 'there aren't any regulations to put penalties around this.'
'I think the film industry has been around for a very long time, and they have very creative ways of creating that emotional reaction," Hickok said. 'So just because there's a new technology in town doesn't mean that it has to be used for such purposes.'
This article was originally published on NBCNews.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
44 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Natalie Dormer set to star in Netflix's 'Extraction' spinoff
Aug. 18 (UPI) -- Natalie Dormer of Elementary, The Tudors and Game of Thrones fame has signed on to star in Netflix's new eight-part series set in the Extraction universe. The ensemble for the as-yet-untitled thriller will include the previously announced cast members Omar Sy and Boyd Holbrook. Glen Mazzara is showrunner, writer, and executive producer. "A mercenary (Omar Sy) embarks on a dangerous mission to rescue hostages in Libya," the streaming service said in a press release Monday. "Trapped between warring factions and ruthless killers, he must navigate life-or-death choices while confronting deep emotional wounds. The series explores the trauma, betrayal, and moral conflicts of characters pushed to the edge." The show is connected to Chris Hemsworth's 2020 film Extraction and its 2023 sequel, Extraction 2. Solve the daily Crossword
Chicago Tribune
an hour ago
- Chicago Tribune
Cambridge Dictionary adds ‘skibidi' and ‘tradwife' among 6,000 new words
LONDON — What the skibidi is happening to the English language? 'Skibidi,' pronounced SKIH-bih-dee, is one of the slang terms popularized by social media that are among more than 6,000 additions this year to the Cambridge Dictionary. 'Internet culture is changing the English language and the effect is fascinating to observe and capture in the dictionary,' said Colin McIntosh, lexical program manager at Cambridge Dictionary, the world's largest online dictionary. 'Skibidi' is a gibberish term coined by the creator of an animated YouTube series and can mean 'cool' or 'bad' or be used with no real meaning as a joke. Other planned additions include 'tradwife,' a contraction of 'traditional wife' referring to a married mother who cooks, cleans and posts on social media, and 'delulu,' a shortening of the word delusional that means 'believing things that are not real or true, usually because you choose to.' Christian Ilbury, senior lecturer in sociolinguistics at the University of Edinburgh, said many of the new words are tied to social media platforms like TikTok because that is how most young people communicate. However, Ilbury said some of the words, including 'delulu,' have longer histories than people might think and have been used by speech communities for years. 'It's really just the increase in visibility and potential uptake amongst communities who may not have engaged with those words before,' he explained. An increase in remote working since the pandemic has created the new dictionary entry 'mouse jiggler,' a device or piece of software used to make it seem like you are working when you are not. Environmental concerns are behind the addition of 'forever chemical,' a harmful substance that remains in the environment for a long time. Cambridge Dictionary uses the Cambridge English Corpus, a database of more than 2 billion words of written and spoken English, to monitor how new words are used by different people, how often and in what contexts they are used, the company said. 'If you look at what a dictionary's function is, it's a public record of how people use language and so if people are now using words like 'skibidi' or 'delulu,' then the dictionary should take account of that,' Ilbury said. McIntosh added the dictionary has only added words it thinks have 'staying power.'
Newsweek
an hour ago
- Newsweek
Karrion Kross Releases New Theme Song After WWE Exit
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Newsweek AI is in beta. Translations may contain inaccuracies—please refer to the original content. In the strongest sign yet that his departure from WWE is legitimate, Karrion Kross has released a brand-new entrance theme. The former NXT Champion debuted the new music and an accompanying cinematic video on his YouTube channel this past Sunday, August 17th. The move is the latest development in a chaotic saga surrounding his and his wife Scarlett's exit from the company. Their WWE contracts officially expired on August 10th. Karrion Kross' New Chapter Begins Kross teased the new theme on his social media, telling fans he had heard their disappointment about his WWE music no longer being available. The new video features Kross in a dark, atmospheric setting, arguing with his own reflection and ending with the cryptic message, "When one door closes." For a professional wrestler, their entrance music is a crucial part of their identity. When a superstar leaves WWE, they must also leave behind their WWE-produced theme. The release of a new, independent theme is one of the first and most important steps in establishing a new, post-WWE persona for the independent circuit or another major promotion. Karrion Kross' Week of Chaos and Confusion This new music follows a whirlwind two weeks of speculation and conflicting reports about Kross's status. After initial reports stated his contract would expire without a new deal, a subsequent report claimed an offer had been made. Kross himself then added to the mystery, stating in a podcast interview that much of what was being written was "not true." INGLEWOOD, CALIFORNIA - JANUARY 06: (L-R) Karrion Kross and Scarlett Bordeaux attend Netflix's Debut of WWE Monday Night Raw at Intuit Dome on January 06, 2025 in Inglewood, California. INGLEWOOD, CALIFORNIA - JANUARY 06: (L-R) Karrion Kross and Scarlett Bordeaux attend Netflix's Debut of WWE Monday Night Raw at Intuit Dome on January 06, 2025 in Inglewood, Netflix The speculation culminated in a tell-all interview with Ariel Helwani last week. In that interview, Kross gave a blow-by-blow account of his failed contract negotiations and insisted thathis departure was legitimate and not an elaborate storyline, or "work." More news: WWE Superstar Announces Retirement Match Despite Kross's insistence, some fans have remained skeptical, pointing to WWE's recent history of "worked shoot" storylines, like the one involving R-Truth's contract status. However, this new theme song is the most compelling evidence yet that his exit is real. Commissioning, producing, and releasing a new theme is a significant investment of time and money that a performer would not likely make if they were part of a short-term storyline. While a small chance of a swerve always remains in the unpredictable world of wrestling, all signs now point to Karrion Kross and Scarlett beginning a new chapter of their careers. More WWE News: For more on WWE, head to Newsweek Sports.
