Ex-BBC boss says most staff seek to be impartial amid Gaza documentary row
While people make mistakes, as in any large institution, Lord Birt argued the corporation was 'the single most respected news organisation in the whole world from Scunthorpe to the Sudan'.
The independent crossbencher made his comments at Westminster after the BBC removed the documentary Gaza: How To Survive A Warzone from its on demand service when it emerged that the child narrator is the son of Ayman Alyazouri, who has worked as Hamas's deputy minister of agriculture.
The broadcaster apologised last week for 'serious flaws' in the making of the programme after conducting an initial review and it has launched a further internal probe.
In a letter to the BBC on Monday, Ofcom chairman Lord Grade said the regulator could step in if an internal inquiry into the making of the documentary is not satisfactory.
Lord Grade, a non-affiliated peer, said Ofcom has 'ongoing concerns about the nature and gravity of these failings and the negative impact they have on the trust audiences place in the BBC's journalism'.
Speaking in Parliament, Lord Birt, who was director-general of the BBC from 1992 to 2000, said: 'Like in any major organisation, people working for the BBC make mistakes and mistakes must be exposed when they happen and the lessons learnt.
'But would the minister agree that the reason why the BBC is the single most respected news organisation in the whole world from Scunthorpe to the Sudan is that almost everyone who works for the BBC is wholly committed and is doing their best to be fair, accurate and impartial?'
Responding, media minister Baroness Twycross said: 'It is a really important point he makes that when we get these incidents it can be hugely demoralising for people who are working really hard to get that accurate, impartial information.'
She added: 'We do have to make sure that we understand exactly what went wrong and the BBC is undertaking a thorough investigation into that and Ofcom and the Secretary of State are very cognisant of the issues and also wanting answers.'
Earlier, she told peers: 'It's right that the BBC is conducting a thorough investigation into what happened and who knew what when.
'I won't prejudge the outcome of the BBC's investigation.'
While former lord speaker Lord Fowler shared the criticism of the programme at the centre of the row, he added: 'But I think we should recognise that that does not in any way describe the BBC's general coverage of Gaza.'
Speaking as a former journalist who had covered the Middle East conflict, the independent crossbencher told peers: 'What struck me was the way that BBC journalists strived for impartiality in all their reporting and as far as I can see that is the same today.'
Lady Twycross said: 'We do expect to have that high standard of journalism, which is why the BBC has traditionally been a trusted source of news both in this country and overseas and that is one of the reasons why this incident is so serious.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
San Francisco Chronicle
an hour ago
- San Francisco Chronicle
Israel is in talks to possibly resettle Palestinians from Gaza in South Sudan
TEL AVIV, Israel (AP) — Israel is in discussions with South Sudan about the possibility of resettling Palestinians from the Gaza Strip to the war-torn East African country, part of a wider effort by Israel to facilitate mass emigration from the territory left in ruins by its 22-month offensive against Hamas. Six people familiar with the matter confirmed the talks to The Associated Press. It's unclear how far the talks have advanced, but if implemented, the plans would amount to transferring people from one war-ravaged land at risk of famine to another, and raise human rights concerns. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu says he wants to realize U.S. President Donald Trump's vision of relocating much of Gaza's population through what Netanyahu refers to as 'voluntary migration.' Israel has floated similar resettlement proposals with other African nations. 'I think that the right thing to do, even according to the laws of war as I know them, is to allow the population to leave, and then you go in with all your might against the enemy who remains there,' Netanyahu said Tuesday in an interview with i24, and Israeli TV station. He did not make reference to South Sudan. Palestinians, rights groups, and much of the international community have rejected the proposals as a blueprint for forcible expulsion in violation of international law. For South Sudan, such a deal could help it build closer ties to Israel, now the almost unchallenged military power in the Middle East. It is also a potential inroad to Trump, who broached the idea of resettling Gaza's population in February but appears to have backed away in recent months. Israel's Foreign Ministry declined to comment and South Sudan's foreign minister did not respond to questions about the talks. A U.S. State Department spokesperson said it doesn't comment on private diplomatic conversations. Joe Szlavik, the founder of a U.S. lobbying firm working with South Sudan, said he was briefed by South Sudanese officials on the talks. He said an Israeli delegation plans to visit the country to look into the possibility of setting up camps for Palestinians there. No known date has been set for the visit. Israel did not immediately respond to a request for confirmation of the visit. Szlavik said Israel would likely pay for makeshift camps. Edmund Yakani, who heads a South Sudanese civil society group, said he had also spoken to South Sudanese officials about the talks. Four additional officials with knowledge of the discussions confirmed talks were taking place on condition of anonymity because they were not authorized to discuss them publicly. Two of the officials, both from Egypt, told AP they've known for months about Israel's efforts to find a country to accept Palestinians, including its contact with South Sudan. They said they've been lobbying South Sudan against taking the Palestinians. Egypt is deeply opposed to plans to transfer Palestinians out of Gaza, with which it shares a border, fearing an influx of refugees into its own territory. The AP previously reported on similar talks initiated by Israel and the U.S. with Sudan and Somalia, countries that are also grappling with war and hunger, and the breakaway region of Somalia known as Somaliland. The status of those discussions is not known. 'Cash-strapped South Sudan needs any ally' Szlavik, who's been hired by South Sudan to improve its relations with the United States, said the U.S. is aware of the discussions with Israel but is not directly involved. South Sudan wants the Trump administration to lift a travel ban on the country and remove sanctions from some South Sudanese elites, said Szlavik. It has already accepted eight individuals swept up in the administration's mass deportations, in what may have been an effort to curry favor. The Trump administration has pressured a number of countries to help facilitate deportations. 'Cash-strapped South Sudan needs any ally, financial gain and diplomatic security it can get,' said Peter Martell, a journalist and author of a book about the country, 'First Raise a Flag.' Israel's Mossad spy agency provided aid to the South Sudanese during their decades-long civil war against the Arab-dominated government in Khartoum ahead of independence in 2011, according to the book. The State Department, asked if there was any quid pro quo with South Sudan, said decisions on the issuing of visas are made 'in a way that prioritizes upholding the highest standards for U.S. national security, public safety, and the enforcement of our immigration laws.' From one hunger-stricken conflict zone to another Many Palestinians might want to leave Gaza, at least temporarily, to escape the war and a hunger crisis bordering on famine. But they have roundly rejected any permanent resettlement from what they see as an integral part of their national homeland. They fear that Israel will never allow them to return, and that a mass departure would allow it to annex Gaza and reestablish Jewish settlements there, as called for by far-right ministers in the Israeli government. Still, even those Palestinians who want to leave are unlikely to take their chances in South Sudan, among the world's most unstable and conflict-ridden countries. South Sudan has struggled to recover from a civil war that broke out after independence, and which killed nearly 400,000 people and plunged pockets of the country into famine. The oil-rich country is plagued by corruption and relies on international aid to help feed its 11 million people – a challenge that has only grown since the Trump administration made sweeping cuts to foreign assistance. A peace deal reached seven years ago has been fragile and incomplete, and the threat of war returned when the main opposition leader was placed under house arrest this year. Palestinians in particular could find themselves unwelcome. The long war for independence from Sudan pitted the mostly Christian and animist south against the predominantly Arab and Muslim north. Yakani, of the civil society group, said South Sudanese would need to know who is coming and how long they plan to stay, or there could be hostilities due to the 'historical issues with Muslims and Arabs.' 'South Sudan should not become a dumping ground for people,' he said. 'And it should not accept to take people as negotiating chips to improve relations.'
Washington Post
2 hours ago
- Washington Post
Netanyahu's plan to take over Gaza City
Israel has announced a plan that could eventually allow it to take military control of the entire Gaza Strip. But the announcement has been met with widespread criticism inside and outside Israel. Foreign leaders and protesters say this approach lacks clarity and will prolong the suffering of Palestinian civilians and endanger hostages still held by Hamas. Host Colby Itkowitz speaks with Tel Aviv- based correspondent Shira Rubin about the consequences of this tactical shift and why Netanyahu has seemed unswayed by international pressure. Today's show was produced by Rennie Svirnovskiy with help from Sabby Robinson. It was edited by Maggie Penman and mixed by Sam Bair. Thank you to Lior Siroka and Alan Sipress. Subscribe to The Washington Post here, or check out our new one-week pass at
Wall Street Journal
2 hours ago
- Wall Street Journal
How Hamas Fools the World
Regarding 'Kill Jews, Get Your Own State' (Review & Outlook, Aug. 6): Hamas has perfected the war-crimes playbook on how to win antisemitic friends and influence useful idiots: Deliberately kill civilians, launch missiles at civilians, kidnap civilian hostages, build tunnels with resources intended for civilian structures, use civilians as human shields, hide in civilian schools and hospitals, disguise yourself in civilian clothing, loot trucks with aid meant for civilians and refuse to negotiate a cease-fire to relieve civilian suffering. In response, Western leaders are once again calling for the so-called two-state solution that will magically usher in lasting peace and security for both Israelis and Palestinians. Never mind that Hamas is hell-bent on a 'final solution.' Last year when Saudi Arabia's Al Arabiya network asked Hamas official Ghazi Hamad whether he accepted co-existence with Israel, he replied: 'No, no. We never said that we accept the two-state solution. [Israel] is an occupier. How can we possibly accept it?'
