Hazel Stewart: Double murderer was under coercive control, court told
Convicted double murderer Hazel Stewart was under the coercive control of her former lover when they plotted their partners' deaths, the Court of Appeal has heard.The former Sunday school teacher appeared before the court via video link from prison, where she is serving a minimum of 18 years for killing her policeman husband and the wife of her ex-lover Colin Howell.She is seeking permission to mount a fresh bid for an earlier release from jail.Howell, a former dentist, pleaded guilty to the murders in 2010.
Depression and PTSD
On Friday, the court heard "new evidence" in the case concerning Stewart's mental health at the time of her offending.Brendan Kelly KC, acting on her behalf, told the court new evidence had come to light from a psychiatrist who believed Stewart had been suffering from depression and PTSD at the time of the murders of Constable Trevor Buchanan, 32, and Howell's 31-year-old wife Lesley Howell in 1991.He told the court: "At the time of the killings, there is evidence that the applicant was suffering from two forms of mental health - depression and PTSD - and coupled to the coercive behaviour of the co-defendant, these are features that ought to have been taken into account when determining the minimum term of the life sentence."That's what is at the core of this application."
Psychiatrist's view a 'minority one'
He argued at the time of Stewart's sentencing in 2011, the issue of coercive control was not fully understood, in particular in the context of mental health.He suggested had it been understood at the time of Stewart's sentencing, the new evidence would have been admissible.However, Philip Henry KC for the Crown told the court the opinion of Dr Harding, the psychiatrist cited by Stewart's legal team, was a "minority" one "without any support from other doctors".He referred to reports compiled by five other psychiatrists, none of whom, he said, identified mental illness in Stewart.He said those reports had been compiled closer to the time of the trial and sentencing, and were based on the same information that Dr Harding had based his more recent report on."None of them had any concerns about mental illness at the time of the offending," he said.The court also heard submissions regarding whether or not it had jurisdiction to hear an appeal in this case.
The bodies of Constable Buchanan and Lesley Howell were found in a fume-filled garage in Castlerock, County Londonderry, in 1991.Police originally thought they had killed themselves in a suicide pact after discovering their partners were having an affair.They were, in fact, murdered before their bodies were arranged to make it look like they had taken their own lives.It took nearly two decades for the truth to emerge when Howell, 52, suddenly confessed to both killings.He was subsequently sentenced to a minimum of 21 years in prison.Howell also implicated his former lover in the plot and gave evidence against her at her trial.During the trial the court heard that Howell had planned and carried out the killings and Stewart had facilitated them - by drugging her husband, allowing Howell into her house and disposing of a hose pipe used in the murder.On Friday, Lady Chief Justice Siobhan Keegan said the court would reserve its decision in the bid for appeal.She said the court would have to consider all that was said to the court and would await additional information from Stewart's team and the Crown.She said the court would make its ruling in June.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
8 minutes ago
- BBC News
Police officers in Derby played 'crass' game with sex worker photos
Police officers used photos of sex workers to play a "crass and inappropriate" game of "snog, marry or avoid", an employment tribunal game came to light as part of an unsuccessful claim of racial discrimination brought by former probationary police constable Shafarat Mohammed against Derbyshire Mohammed sued the force claiming colleagues had discriminated against him when he served as an officer in Derby between March 2022 and his resignation in October that year.A report on the findings of the tribunal, published on Thursday, said Mr Mohammed, an Asian Muslim, alleged he was subjected to acts of direct discrimination because of his race and religious beliefs. Among his claims were that, in May or June 2023, a colleague asked him to look at pictures of black female sex workers and comment on whether he liked claimant said the game, where players pick people they would prefer to kiss, marry or avoid, left him offended and embarrassed and was racially a report, tribunal judge Stephen Shore said the game could have constituted sexual harassment but Mr Mohammed had not made such a judge said: "The 'game' was crass and inappropriate. It casts no one who participated in it in a good light." A panel, led by the judge, dismissed all of the Mr Mohammed's claims which also included that he had been ostracised and excluded from team and social events and that colleagues ordered and ate bacon sandwiches, knowing he was a Muslim, to further exclude Mohammed said he had also been called a "Road Man", a slang term for a drug dealer, by a colleague during one of his first shifts at Pear Tree Police Station in Derby in March panel heard evidence from the complainant during a five-day hearing at the Nottingham Tribunal Hearing Centre, in July last year."Our analysis of the facts of each, claim led us to the conclusion that many of the claims were weak and not founded in fact," the panel's report panel report said Mr Mohammed had "weakened his case by withdrawing allegations" and had retrospectively refitted facts to fit his discrimination panel also found he had fabricated facts to bolster his claims, some of which were contradicted by his own contemporaneous panel said evidence presented to the tribunal found the claimant "struggled" as a probationary officer while working at a "pressurised" police Police has been contacted for comment.
Daily Mail
26 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE Alleged killer cop Beau Lamarre-Condon reveals the biggest mystery over what happened to the two men he's accused of shooting dead - and the 'two person disposal job' in the aftermath
A woman accused of helping dispose of the bodies of two men allegedly shot dead by ex-NSW cop Beau Lamarre-Condon is a longtime friend he met through her partner, Daily Mail Australia can reveal. Lamarre-Condon has been charged with the murders of television presenter Jesse Baird, 26, and his Qantas flight attendant boyfriend Luke Davies, 29, at Paddington in Sydney 's eastern suburbs in February 2024. The 29-year-old has not entered pleas to two counts of murder but says he has offered to provide information about a second person he claims helped dump Mr Davies and Mr Baird's remains. A source close to Lamarre-Condon told Daily Mail Australia he had made the offer to police and the Director of Public Prosecutions but they had not responded to his approach. '[He] wants to do the right thing for the families and is happy to assist investigators with information about who else played a part in the incident,' the source claimed. 'So far both the DPP and the officer in charge have failed to reply to the offer made by [Lamarre-Condon's] legal team for assistance.' Lamarre-Condon is accused of bundling Mr Davies and Mr Baird's bodies into surfboard bags after he allegedly killed the couple and dumping them about 180km south-west of Sydney. The source said Lamarre-Condon disputed a witness's statement to investigators that she had waited at the fence line of a Bungonia property where the bodies were first dumped for 15 to 20 minutes. Phone records indicated Lamarre-Condon and the witness, previously described by police as 'an innocent agent', were at the farm for almost two hours, the source claimed. 'Police also located two sets of white overalls at the scene where bodies were located which indicates it was a two-person job,' the source said. A NSW Police spokeswoman said: 'As this matter is before the court, we are unable to comment.' A spokeswoman for the DPP said the same thing. The woman Lamarre-Condon claims helped dispose of the bodies lives in Sydney and got to know him through her partner, who had been a schoolmate. Police located Mr Davies and Mr Baird's remains on February 27 last year, eight days after Lamarre-Condon allegedly shot them dead with his Glock service pistol. A day before the bodies were found, Deputy Commissioner Dave Hudson revealed an alleged timeline of events leading up to and following the men's deaths. Mr Hudson said gunshots were heard coming from Mr Baird's home on the morning of February 19. Later that evening, Lamarre-Condon allegedly hired a Toyota HiAce van from Sydney Airport and on February 21 drove the vehicle to the Southern Tablelands with a female companion. The woman allegedly helped Lamarre-Condon buy an angle grinder and padlock from a hardware store then the pair drove to a property at Bungonia. Mr Hudson said the angle grinder was used to cut a padlock from a gate and that padlock was then replaced. 'The acquaintance was left at the top of the property for a period of 30 minutes,' he told reporters at a press conference. 'The accused disappeared for that period in the HiAce van, returning to pick up the acquaintance and then they returned to Sydney later that afternoon. Mr Hudson said Lamarre-Condon's companion was not involved in the alleged murders and was merely an 'innocent agent'. 'The acquaintance is not a suspect in this matter,' he said. 'We don't believe that she was fully aware of what had taken place.' Mr Hudson alleged Lamarre-Condon later returned to the Bungonia property carrying two torches provided by the woman, having bought weights from a department store about 11pm. Police allege Lamarre-Condon moved the bodies from their original location to another Bungonia property because he became concerned his female friend was suspicious of him. Lamarre-Condon allegedly left the property about 4.30am and drove to Newcastle where he asked a former policewoman if he could borrow a hose to clean the van. She is not accused of any wrongdoing and had spoken to police when her suspicions were raised. About 10.30am the next day, February 23, Lamarre-Condon walked into Bondi police station and was arrested. The bodies of Mr Davies and Mr Baird were found at the second Bungonia location on February 27 several hours after detectives spoke with Lamarre-Condon in the Metropolitan Remand and Reception Centre in Silverwater. Lamarre-Condon has spent more than a year in prison since the shootings, which were allegedly the result of a months-long campaign of 'predatory behaviour' targeting Mr Baird. The former celebrity chaser reportedly briefly dated Mr Baird before the Studio Ten and Totally Wild presenter began a relationship with Mr Davies. The case returned to Downing Centre Local Court last month after confidential discussions between prosecutors and the alleged killer's Legal Aid lawyer Alex Curnick. Both sides agreed 'things are progressing,' magistrate Megan Greenwood was told. A forensic psychiatrist's report was also tendered after Lamarre-Condon was assessed in previous weeks. Lamarre-Condon, who was sacked from the police force in March last year, is also charged with breaking and entering with intent to commit an indictable offence. Before becoming a police officer, Lamarre-Condon ran a celebrity blog, posing in photos with dozens of celebrities including Taylor Swift, Selena Gomez, Miley Cyrus, Harry Styles and Katy Perry. Lamarre-Condon is expected to appear via an audiovisual link when his case returns to court on June 17.
Daily Mail
an hour ago
- Daily Mail
EXCLUSIVE The 'lawless' UK estate where residents claim they have been 'left to rot' and are terrorised by 'balaclava-clad wannabe gangsters causing carnage'
It is early evening on Bradford's notorious Holme Wood estate - and it feels like the frontline of a battlefield. The streets echo with the whine of revving mopeds and the screech of teenage yobs hurling foul-mouthed threats. Balaclava-clad gangs tear through the roads on scooters, pulling reckless wheelies and shouting abuse at terrified passers-by. Others - barely in their teens with acne-pocked faces - loiter on corners with hammers in hand and pockets full of eggs, ready to smash car windows or pelt shops just for the thrill of it. What was once a tight-knit, working-class community has become a lawless wasteland - where decent families say they've been left to fend for themselves against a new wave of 'wannabe gangsters'. Tracy Litherland, 42, has lived in Holme Wood for most of her life. She told MailOnline: 'The older lot are all right. It's the younger ones - the wannabe gangsters - that are causing carnage. It's like a new generation of troublemakers. 'They think nothing of smashing up a taxi or hanging around shops intimidating people or causing trouble. 'They just roam around, causing chaos and there's nothing really to stop them. 'A lot of it comes down to parenting. People are having kids, who shouldn't. They don't know how to raise them or discipline them.' She added: 'When we were kids, we had stuff to do. We had a youth centre where for 20p, you could get in, play pool, football, do art - it kept us off the streets. 'Now there's nothing. No youth clubs, no support. The funding's all been cut. The estate's just been forgotten about - just left to rot. There's no hope for a lot of the kids. 'I've lived here 30 years. No one's ever started on me, but I keep to myself. If you carry yourself right, you're usually okay. But it's intimidating for newcomers.' When MailOnline visited the estate at dusk, the chaos was already in full swing. Teenagers raced scooters across the estate, popping wheelies with their faces covered. One boy wielded a lump hammer, smashing it against the shutters of a local corner shop - before turning his attention to a nearby bin. The streets are strewn with fly-tipped rubbish - scorched mattresses, broken fridges, car parts and smashed glass. Burnt-out containers and graffitied shopfronts, near to where a 20-year-old man was stabbed in a suspected attempted murder, paint a bleak picture. Even CCTV hasn't deterred the criminals. In May, three cameras were installed by a housing association to crack down on antisocial behaviour. They didn't even last a day before all three were ripped down. One previous security camera, installed by the council, was cut down just 12 hours after being put up - after a thug used an angle grinder to bring the entire pole crashing into the road. One lifelong resident, in his 60s, told MailOnline: 'I've lived here all my life and it's got so much worse. 'You can't have anything nice around here, it just disappears.' His daughter, who grew up on the estate but was 'thankful' to have since moved away, added: 'The good news is burglaries and car thefts have come down. 'The bad news is you're more likely to be stabbed or murdered.' A building which appears to have been left abandoned projects the idea that the estate has been left to rot When MailOnline visited the area a smashed window was spotted with a seemingly broken chair left dumped on top of a building Myles Duffy, 57, has lived in Holme Wood all his life. He said: 'There's always something going on. 'It's mainly based around the shops. It's all the young ones - they've not grown up and there's nowt for them. 'I don't really get bothered but you still hear about a lot of carry-on. 'I feel a bit sorry for them because they've got nothing to do. 'That's when they turn to crime, or drugs, or whatever else. It's not right, but that's the reality. 'Loads of young girls end up getting pregnant just so they can get a flat and some benefits. It's not even about wanting a baby. 'That's a sad state of affairs.' Mr Duffy, with his friend Jack Miles, 64, blamed successive governments for failing the youth. He added: 'Back in the day, we had community programmes - government schemes that gave you opportunities. 'They paid you proper wages for 12-month work placements. If you didn't get a job after that, you could go again. 'That's how I got my first job - working with a housing caretaker. It gave me a start. 'But now, there's nothing. You need that first step on the ladder. If you can't even get that, how do you move forward?' In February, West Yorkshire Police revealed the results of a two-year crackdown on Holme Wood: nearly 400 arrests, 73 cannabis farms shut down and 151 vehicles seized. Eviction notices were handed to nearly 30 households linked to crime and antisocial behaviour. Yet despite the blitz, many say little has changed on the ground. One woman, in her 50s, said on condition of anonymity: ''It's not just antisocial – it's terrifying. 'You step outside and don't know if you'll get caught in some madness. 'Kids running around with knives, smashing up shops, setting bins on fire - it's like a jungle. 'I don't open my door after dark. You hear screaming, sirens, engines revving, and you just pray it's not outside your house.' Newcomer Sarah Dobson, 41, who moved to the estate last week from Scotland, admitted the area felt 'intimidating' — but insisted she wasn't fazed. 'First day I got here, I saw a couple chasing a lad down the street,' she said. 'People can find it intimidating, but I don't. 'I'm from somewhere rougher than this. I'm born and bred in Willenhall, Coventry - so this is nothing to me, mate.' A West Yorkshire Police Spokesperson said: 'We continue to work closely alongside our partner agencies to reduce crime and anti-social behaviour in Holme Wood and to increase trust and confidence in the community. 'There have been significant positive results from the Operation Sweetgill team in the last 12 months. 166 people have been arrested and 129 of them have been dealt with positively. 'We know crime and anti-social behaviour is a concern for residents and I hope these results show we are committed to tacking them. 'We will continue to work tirelessly with our partners to tackle the problem and make Holme Wood a safer place to live.'
