Ecuador approves controversial law on protected areas, sparking legal threats
The law, which passed on Wednesday in the 151-seat National Assembly with 80-23 votes in favor , with remaining lawmakers absent during the vote, allows private entities, including foreign companies, to participate in managing conservation zones.
Government officials have defended the measure, arguing that it will strengthen oversight of protected lands, help improve park security, promote ecotourism and combat illegal mining without allowing extractive activity.
Critics say it could lead to displacement, increased resource extraction and the rollback of hard-won environmental and Indigenous protections enshrined in Ecuador's 2008 Constitution.
'This is constitutional vandalism,' said Oscar Soria, co-CEO of the international policy group The Common Initiative. ' Ecuador has shattered its international credibility and invited isolation from the global community.'
Opponents also say the law violates at least 15 international agreements — including the ILO Convention 169, the Escazú Agreement, and the U.N. Declaration on the Rights of Indigenous Peoples — and that the lawmakers failed to consult with affected communities as required by law.
'The legislators of Ecuador reopened a historic wound,' said Justino Piaguaje, leader of the Siekopai peoples and head of the NASIEPAI Indigenous organization.
Piaguaje slammed the law as 'dangerous and unconstitutional" and said it not only reinforces systemic violations of Indigenous rights but 'actively perpetuates a legacy of dispossession and violence that stretches back to the colonial era.'
"It threatens our survival and desecrates the dignity of the Ecuadorian people,' he said.
Valentina Centeno, president of the parliament's Economic Development Commission, insisted the law does not open the door to extractive industries — and that here is a provision 'that explicitly prohibits' them.
She asked for an applause in the National Assembly after the law was passed.
Still, Indigenous leaders say the process lacked transparency and bypassed meaningful dialogue with their communities. Legal challenges are already underway, with Indigenous organizations vowing to take the case to Ecuador's Constitutional Court and international forums.
The law was passed under an 'economic urgency' designation linked to a national internal conflict declaration, a move that accelerated debate and limited legislative scrutiny.
___
Follow Steven Grattan on Instagram: @steven.grattan
___
The Associated Press' climate and environmental coverage receives financial support from multiple private foundations. AP is solely responsible for all content. Find AP's standards for working with philanthropies, a list of supporters and funded coverage areas at AP.org.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Uruguay's lower house of parliament votes in favor of euthanasia
MONTEVIDEO, Aug 13 (Reuters) - Uruguay's lower house of parliament voted on Wednesday to legalize euthanasia, emulating Cuba, Colombia and Ecuador in a societal shift around predominantly Catholic Latin America. The bill to decriminalize assisted dying passed by 64 votes in the 99-seat Chamber of Representatives after an emotional overnight debate. It now moves to the senate, which is widely expected to approve legislation before year-end. Under the new law, mentally competent adults suffering from terminal or incurable illnesses can request euthanasia. One key amendment appeared to help win over Uruguayan lawmakers against the original 2022 proposal by requiring a medical board to review a case if the two doctors involved disagree. Legislator Luis Gallo, who opened the debate, recalled deceased patients who had inspired the bill. "Let's not forget that the request is strictly personal: it respects the free and individual will of the patient, without interference, because it concerns their life, their suffering, their decision not to continue living," said Gallo of the center-left Broad Front ruling coalition. Opinion polls show widespread public support for euthanasia from President Yamandu Orsi down. Uruguay also pioneered legalizing gay marriage, abortion and cannabis use. The national conversation around euthanasia was brought to the political mainstream in 2019 by a former sports official, Fernando Sureda, who was diagnosed with a degenerative disease. Sureda, who headed Uruguay's football association, publicly advocated for the right to die. Uruguay joins a growing list of countries, including Canada, Spain, and New Zealand, that have legalized some form of assisted dying. Britain is also doing so.
The Guardian
4 hours ago
- The Guardian
The ‘European capital of Brazil' moves to expel Black politician from office
In the more than 300-year history of the Brazilian city of Curitiba, no city councillor had ever been removed from office until 2022, when a promising young Black local politician was forced out. Renato Freitas had been accused of 'breaching parliamentary decorum' by leading an anti-racism protest that ended inside a Catholic church – ironically named Church of the Black Men and built by enslaved people in the 18th century. The expulsion was eventually overturned by the supreme court, but it was far from the last case brought against the 41-year-old Freitas, a rising star in the leftist Workers' party of president Luiz Inácio Lula da Silva. Now a state congressman, he faces three more expulsion proceedings in which his mostly white, conservative colleagues will decide whether to remove him from office once again. He may also face a disciplinary sanction for allegedly organising a teachers' protest, which would bar him from speaking during legislative sessions for a month. Activists, analysts and historians view the cases against Freitas as evidence of how a city that proudly calls itself the 'European capital of Brazil' is ill-equipped to deal with a defiant Black politician. 'I go in hard – and that's upset a lot of people,' said Freitas one July afternoon, sporting his voluminous afro, dressed in a Malcolm X T-shirt, shorts and trainers, and taking occasional drags of cannabis during an interview soundtracked by a rap playlist blasting from a speaker he had brought along. It was nearby there that, during his first run for office in 2016, Freitas was arrested on charges of disturbing the peace for listening to rap 'too loud' in his car and allegedly disrespecting the officer who approached him. He was beaten and left naked in a police station corridor before being released. Freitas says he has been detained or arrested 16 times – and he has become a leading voice against police violence in a state where, under a far-right governor, police killings have soared. He defies almost every rule of what a typical political figure looks and sounds like in Brazil: he wears a suit and tie only when strictly required, speaks in slang and rhymes – often quoting or paraphrasing rap lyrics – and has a life story that is anything but conventional. 'I was a criminal child,' said Freitas, who recalls stealing ice-cream and sweets. 'I didn't have access to those things, so I stole them.' He was raised by his mother, a domestic worker, in a poor neighbourhood near the prison where his father was incarcerated in Piraquara, 13 miles (21km) from Curitiba. After an erratic time at school, Freitas used his wages earned bagging groceries to pay for a prepatory course and entered law school, later earning a master's degree. He joined Lula's Workers' party and ran twice before being elected in 2020, no small feat in a city that has become a conservative stronghold. Curitiba capital of the southern state of Paraná, was home to the lead judge and chief prosecutor of the Operation Car Wash – the massive anti-corruption investigation that led to the arrest of dozens of politicians, public officials and business leaders from 2014 to 2021. It was also here that Lula was imprisoned for 580 days. The 2022 church episode unfolded just months before the presidential election which Lula went on to win. Then president Jair Bolsonaro condemned Freitas for 'invading' and 'disrespecting the House of God'. And despite belonging to the same party as Freitas, Lula said he had 'made a mistake' and 'needed to apologise'. The councillor was removed from office by a vote of 25 to 7 by his colleagues. Despite having regained his political rights, Freitas still resents Lula's comment. 'Before saying I'd made a mistake, he could have spoken to me to find out what happened,' he said, adding that he still intends to campaign for Lula in next year's election. Among the current proceedings against him, Freitas is once again accused of 'breaching decorum', this time for leading a protest inside a supermarket in response to the fatal beating of a 22-year-old man who had allegedly stolen a chocolate bar. 'He makes a point of not being a traditional politician,' said Adriano Codato, a political science professor at the Federal University of Paraná, noting that Freitas is not inclined to strike deals with opposition politicians. 'However, this anti-political stance can end up being less effective when it comes to securing improvements for his constituents, like schools or paved roads.' For political scientist Mateus de Albuquerque, the political establishment's 'resistance' to Freitas is also rooted in race: 'Curitiba is a city that wants to present itself as 'European' and without Black people, but Freitas exposes the fact that they are here and that the police beat and kill them.' According to historian Noemi Santos da Silva, the notion of Curitiba as the 'European capital of Brazil' emerged in the 1950s, based on the belief that its cooler climate, efficient public services and large population of European descent made it a more 'civilised' city. Tourist attractions in the city pay tribute to its history of Italian and German immigration, but although nearly a quarter of residents are Afro-Brazilian, only one square honours the Black population – far from the main tourist routes. 'In a city that pushed Black people out to the outskirts, Freitas dared to occupy a space that was never intended for someone like him,' she said. Freitas is still unsure whether he'll seek higher office, perhaps as mayor or governor, but he said: 'It's easier to become president of Brazil than to be mayor of Curitiba, because the country isn't as hostile to someone like me as this city is.'
The Guardian
4 hours ago
- The Guardian
‘A whole spectrum of hatred': women face increased violence in Milei's Argentina as rights are eroded
In the week before her murder, Fernanda Soledad Yramain lay awake at night listening as a motorbike circled the house where she was hiding. 'She kept saying 'it's him',' remembers Daniella Viscarra, Soledad's sister-in-law with whom she had sought refuge in the Tucumán countryside. 'She was scared all of the time.' A month earlier, in September 2024, 29-year-old Soledad had ended a relationship with her boyfriend, Francisco Timoteo Saldaño. They had been together since she was 14 and he was 35, and shared three children. In the final year of their relationship, Saldaño had turned violent. 'She started coming round with bruises on her arms, crying. He held a knife to her throat and said he would kill her,' says Sandra Yramain, Soledad's aunt. Together, Sandra and Soledad went to the police station to request protection. 'They said that 'these things take time',' Sandra says. 'But nobody ever called.' Over the ensuing week, Soledad returned to the police station three more times. 'She was certain he would kill her,' says Daniella. 'So she kept trying.' Less than a day after her fourth – and final – visit to beg the police to protect her, Saldaño stabbed Soledad to death with a butcher's knife, before killing himself. 'Soledad did everything she was meant to do,' says Sandra. 'But, because the police did not care, she was cut in half.' We are living with a global femicide crisis across the world today, with a woman or girl killed by their partner or a close relative every 10 minutes, according to the UN. The 'She counts' series will report on stories behind this epidemic. While Argentina was once celebrated as a bastion for women's rights in Latin America, now, amid a rise in populism under far-right leader Javier Milei, protections for women are quickly being eroded. Women's rights groups warn that more women like Soledad could die as a result. Soon after taking power in December 2023, Milei dissolved the undersecretariat for protection against gender violence and closed the ministry of women. 'For the first time in nearly 40 years, Argentina has no dedicated institution to prevent, punish and eradicate gender-based violence,' says Mariela Belski, executive director of Amnesty International Argentina. The administration has also slashed funding for programmes aimed at combating gender violence. The Acompañar programme, which provided financial and psychological assistance for victims of gender-based violence, has been drastically defunded, while the 144 emergency hotline lost 42% of its staff by July 2024. 'The government is turning its back on women facing violence,' says Belski. In November, Argentina was the only country to vote against a UN general assembly resolution to prevent and eliminate violence against women and girls. Two months later, Milei's administration went further, pledging to strike the aggravating factor of femicide, defined as when a woman dies at the hands of a man on the basis of her gender, from the penal code – a move that drew swift condemnation from human rights groups. Belski says removing the legal definition would 'weaken the state's ability to prevent and punish such crimes'. Now, human rights experts warn that Milei's rhetoric is gaining traction nationwide. In Tucumán, a conservative province, lawyers and advocates say that legal protections for women are already being dismantled. 'Tucumán is one of the places where the situation is worsening,' says Myriam Bregman, a socialist leader. 'It follows the political line of the national government, of cutting women's rights protection programmes, which were already very scarce.' Soledad Deza, the Tucumán lawyer supporting Yramain's family and the president of Fundación Mujeres Por Mujeres (Women for Women Foundation), shared data showing a sharp drop in court-issued protection orders since Milei took office. Sign up to Global Dispatch Get a different world view with a roundup of the best news, features and pictures, curated by our global development team after newsletter promotion Between January and September 2024, according to information obtained from the authorities by Deza and shared with the Guardian, family courts in Tucumán issued 4,856 protection orders, while criminal courts issued 754. By comparison, across the whole of 2023, those figures were 7,549 and 2,448 respectively. Deza says that women in the province have struggled to access support because of funding cuts, and that the justice system is failing to investigate their reports. Law enforcement agencies have also been slow to respond, says Sofia Quiroga, of international women's rights organisation Equality Now. 'Worryingly, the police in Tucumán have stopped investigating why protection orders are needed in the first place,' she says. Luciana Belén Gramaglio, a feminist lawyer from Tucumán, says that the provincial government had embraced, 'the regressive and stifling policies promoted by Milei'. At the start of 2025, she says, the Tucumán government reduced the number of prosecutorial offices dedicated to investigating cases of gender-based violence and sexual abuse from seven to four. Gramaglio suggests almost half of the cases that enter the judicial system are linked to violence against women. 'How then, is the reduction in prosecutorial offices justified?' The weekend that Soledad was killed, two other women in the Tucumán province were murdered; both cases officially classified as femicides. Official data from the National Ombudsman's office found that 295 cases of femicide were reported nationally between 1 January and 31 December 2024, or one every 30 hours. The MuMaLá women's organisation reported a 15% increase in femicides in the first four months of 2025, compared with the same period a year earlier. Lawyers and advocates also warn of a growing narrative that women are fabricating claims of gender-based violence. In 2024, senator Carolina Losada, with the support of national justice minister Mariano Cúneo Libarona, introduced a bill to increase penalties for false accusations of gender-based violence. 'The credibility of the victims is being challenged by the narratives of the Milei administration. These narratives have unlocked a whole spectrum of hatred and obstacles,' says Deza. 'This is simply an indirect threat, to discourage women from reporting crimes.' Mariela Labozzetta, head of the specialised prosecutorial unit on violence against women, says that despite funding cuts, the justice system and the public prosecutor's offices across Argentina continue to function. But, she adds that 'to prevent the risks faced by victims from worsening, support programmes are necessary, and these have been eliminated'. Deza says that because Argentina 'has stripped away gender violence prevention programmes' women are left with little recourse but to remain 'hypervigilant'. She has filed a complaint against the police in Tucumán regarding Soledad's case, and hopes that the criminal justice system investigates why her calls for help went unanswered. The Tucumán state and police did not reply to requests for comment, nor did the Milei administration. For Soledad's family, the government's proposal to eliminate femicide from the penal code came as a fresh shock. 'I only hope that her death was not in vain,' says Sandra. 'And that no other woman is killed because the authorities didn't take control.'
