GST rate rationalisation is welcome, but States' revenues must be protected: Karnataka Revenue Minister Byre Gowda
Speaking to The Hindu, Mr. Gowda, who is also a member of the Group of Ministers (GoM) on rate rationalisation, said that the impact of the Centre's proposals have to be carefully assessed. A major overhaul of GST was announced by Prime Minister Narendra Modi during his independence day address, with a flat two rate structure of 18% and 5% proposed by the Centre.
'We are for rate rationalisation. The rate impact of the same is on the revenues of the state are of great concern. Since the Central Govt has carried out these deliberations and developed proposals outside the GST consultation forum, we are not in the knowledge of the full proposals including measures to protect State revenues, if any. We are looking forward to understand and discuss,' he said.
While the Centre, he said, had various other revenue sources, i. e. Direct taxes, customs, dividends of monopoly PSUs, dividends from RBI, etc, the States have very limited sources.
'GST is the biggest source for the states. So, any major shock in GST will fundamentally affect the fiscal health of the states. So, we would like the rate rationalisation carried out along with protections for state revenues,' he added.
Mr. Gowda added that his government had raised the consequential impact of GST on State's finances before the Finance Commission, but did not get much joy out of the response, which basically kept separate the GST and other financial issues.
'In my view, though, this is a structural issue. The GST, by moving from origin to destination principle, has fundamentally affected and altered long term revenue and fiscal trajectory of some states. Hence, it is a fiscal issue. Now, if the Finance Commission refuses to recognise this, then states like Karnataka and few others will get the wrong end of both worlds. GST council will only discuss GsT issues and will consider fiscal issues as extraneous and outside the mandate of the Council and hence not really to be debated in the Council. And, FC will refuse to discuss the fiscal impact of GST in state finances,' he said.
'With no redressal mechanism in the federal structure. I sincerely hope, for the sake of our federal unity, that these issues will be understood and adequately addressed. I hope these issues will not be brushed aside. Such a move will only harm the federal spirit,' he added.
A meeting of the GoM on rate rationalisation will be addressed by Union Finance Minister Nirmala Sitharaman on Wednesday (August 20, 2025).
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Economic Times
2 minutes ago
- Economic Times
But defence stocks in dips, hope for acceleration in private banks in FY27: Rajesh Bhatia
Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads Tired of too many ads? Remove Ads CIO,, says despite a current slowdown and range-bound markets, India's macro context remains strong, preventing sharp market declines. Interest rate cuts and reforms like GST are expected to drive recovery in FY26 or FY27. Bhatia suggests optimism, focusing on successful companies in sectors like automobiles and private banks, particularly a comeback bank, while advising patience in the defence you have hit the nail on the head. You are absolutely correct in pointing out that it is a no-brainer that in the next 10 years, given this geopolitical context, the need to increase our independence on defence products is going to increase and therefore the visibility for spending on defence products is going to be high for the next 10 or 15 years. It is a no-brainer that there is going to be good allocations to defence spending. But as you also correctly point out, are these stocks valued at a reasonable price? My answer is no. Look at good business models or good moats in these companies and wait for corrections in stock prices of defence companies because it is a long journey. You can afford to wait for those declines and not necessarily as we it is a general expectation that the first half was not supposed to be good given that interest rates have declined and therefore, the asset book has got repriced whereas the liability book will take time to get repriced and therefore, there will be a little bit of pressure on their margins. Of course, there has been some concern on credit costs being a little elevated as well and the credit growth not being as much because the corporate sector is borrowing from the bond market or the commercial paper market or the equity to that extent, the corporate lending growth rate has also been a little anaemic and even in the retail sector, there is high competitive intensity in home loans and the other parts also are a little bit stressful. Although there has been a little bit of apprehension. So yes, the first half was expected to be a little soft and the second half is expected to be a little better. But here is the context. My view is that there has been a little bit of pessimism in financial stocks as we speak, especially the lenders and my view is that FY27 will be a growth year of from a structural point of view, private banks look attractive. Of course, you have to select the stocks in that portfolio. There is a comeback bank that looks a little more attractive to me than the rest of the pack. My view is that from a private bank perspective, remain optimistic and hope for acceleration in if they delay, that is a very short-term problem. It is not only the GST trade that we have been playing in the automobile segment. We are playing stocks which are benefiting from market share increases. So, companies that you like from a structural perspective are the ones that we have in the auto space. So, let us say, SUV/tractor manufacturer. We have been holding that for a very long time. There is a two-wheeler company that continues to gain market share in various feel that is a champion two-wheeler company and therefore we continue to own those kind of companies, barring the fact that GST is a very good positive but we have extended the time horizon and looking for companies which are gaining market share and which have a very strong competitive moat in the business that they are operating in. So, GST rationalisation is certainly going to be positive when it comes to that and this is the first step of reforms that the government is going to do given that we are already just step back a bit, the macro context of India is very strong. The markets are unfortunately range-bound because we are experiencing a slowdown. Very sharp declines in markets only happen when you have a very sharp decline in macro. Fortunately that is not the case, and therefore, all we are experiencing is a bit of a time-wise correction and not a very sharp price-wise correction in the that there is a 100 bps decline in interest rates and we have already stepped up reforms, particularly GST being the first one and there are many other steps that are to come. Expectations for a recovery in the second half of FY26 or FY27 are going to be high. So, in the broader context, you should be a little optimistic as you move automobiles, GST is a positive move but from a broader perspective, the way to go about these things is to look for companies which are succeeding and own them for a longer period of time. That is how I would approach the automobile sector
&w=3840&q=100)
Business Standard
2 minutes ago
- Business Standard
SC asks if harmony between governor, state govt meets Constitution's vision
The Supreme Court on Wednesday asked whether the country has lived up to the expectations of the Constitution framers that there will be harmony between the governor and the state government, besides the consultation on various issues between the two power centres. The observation of a five-judge Constitution bench headed by Chief Justice BR Gavai came when Solicitor General Tushar Mehta, appearing for the Centre, referring to the Constituent Assembly debates on appointment and powers of the governor. The bench, also comprising Justices Surya Kant, Vikram Nath, PS Narasimha and AS Chandurkar, was told by Mehta that unlike criticism made in different quarters, the post of governor is not for political asylum seekers but has certain powers and responsibility under the Constitution. The solicitor general, who continued his submissions on the Presidential Reference which raised constitutional questions on whether the court can impose timelines for governors and the president to deal with Bills passed by state assemblies, said that elaborate debates on the role and appointment of governors has taken place in the Constituent Assembly keeping in view the federal scheme of the Constitution. On Tuesday, the top court questioned the Centre and the attorney general over the long pendency of Bills passed by assemblies with governors, underscoring the limitations of Constitutional courts in situations where legislation has been pending since 2020. The top court has said it would be expressing its views only on the law and not on the April 8 decision in the Tamil Nadu case, fixing a timeline for governors and the president for acting on Bills passed by state legislatures. The top court, while responding to the preliminary objections raised by Tamil Nadu and Kerala governments on maintainability of the Presidential Reference, said it would exercise its advisory jurisdiction as it was not sitting in the appellate jurisdiction. In May, President Droupadi Murmu exercised powers under Article 143(1) to know from the top court whether judicial orders could impose timelines for the exercise of discretion by the president while dealing with Bills passed by state assemblies. The Centre said in its written submission that imposing fixed timelines on governors and the president to act on Bills passed by a state assembly would amount to one organ of the government assuming powers not vested in it by the Constitution, and lead to "constitutional disorder". On April 8, the apex court while dealing with the powers of the governor with respect to Bills passed by the Tamil Nadu Assembly, for the first time, prescribed that the president should decide on the Bills reserved for her consideration by the governor within three months from the date on which such a reference is received. In a five-page reference, President Murmu posed 14 questions to the Supreme Court and sought to know its opinion on the powers of the governor and president under Articles 200 and 201 in dealing with Bills passed by the state legislature.
Time of India
13 minutes ago
- Time of India
Buy defence stocks in dips, hope for acceleration in private banks in FY27: Rajesh Bhatia
Rajesh Bhatia , CIO, ITI MF , says despite a current slowdown and range-bound markets, India's macro context remains strong, preventing sharp market declines. Interest rate cuts and reforms like GST are expected to drive recovery in FY26 or FY27. Bhatia suggests optimism, focusing on successful companies in sectors like automobiles and private banks, particularly a comeback bank, while advising patience in the defence sector. There are lots of pieces in the market and let us start off with defence. Structurally it is a great story with order inflows coming in. But do you think the stocks right now are priced to perfection? Rajesh Bhatia: Yes, you have hit the nail on the head. You are absolutely correct in pointing out that it is a no-brainer that in the next 10 years, given this geopolitical context, the need to increase our independence on defence products is going to increase and therefore the visibility for spending on defence products is going to be high for the next 10 or 15 years. It is a no-brainer that there is going to be good allocations to defence spending. But as you also correctly point out, are these stocks valued at a reasonable price? My answer is no. Look at good business models or good moats in these companies and wait for corrections in stock prices of defence companies because it is a long journey. You can afford to wait for those declines and not necessarily as we speak. Coming to private banks, look at the earnings. We have had one or two surprises but not much is happening on the banking front. Do you believe a recovery is on the cards in the second half of the year? Rajesh Bhatia: Yes, it is a general expectation that the first half was not supposed to be good given that interest rates have declined and therefore, the asset book has got repriced whereas the liability book will take time to get repriced and therefore, there will be a little bit of pressure on their margins. Of course, there has been some concern on credit costs being a little elevated as well and the credit growth not being as much because the corporate sector is borrowing from the bond market or the commercial paper market or the equity market. So, to that extent, the corporate lending growth rate has also been a little anaemic and even in the retail sector, there is high competitive intensity in home loans and the other parts also are a little bit stressful. Although there has been a little bit of apprehension. So yes, the first half was expected to be a little soft and the second half is expected to be a little better. But here is the context. My view is that there has been a little bit of pessimism in financial stocks as we speak, especially the lenders and my view is that FY27 will be a growth year of acceleration. So from a structural point of view, private banks look attractive. Of course, you have to select the stocks in that portfolio. There is a comeback bank that looks a little more attractive to me than the rest of the pack. My view is that from a private bank perspective, remain optimistic and hope for acceleration in FY27. Live Events You Might Also Like: Focus on growth-oriented companies and stop going by market cap divisions: Alok Agarwal Let us talk about autos because in the past two days, we have seen all the excitement in this particular sector, backed by GST news , as well as the rare earth magnet issue subsiding. What is your view on the auto pack? Should one go ahead and find some opportunities right now or wait for some correction? What within the pack is your liking? Rajesh Bhatia: Even if they delay, that is a very short-term problem. It is not only the GST trade that we have been playing in the automobile segment. We are playing stocks which are benefiting from market share increases. So, companies that you like from a structural perspective are the ones that we have in the auto space. So, let us say, SUV/tractor manufacturer. We have been holding that for a very long time. There is a two-wheeler company that continues to gain market share in various products. We feel that is a champion two-wheeler company and therefore we continue to own those kind of companies, barring the fact that GST is a very good positive but we have extended the time horizon and looking for companies which are gaining market share and which have a very strong competitive moat in the business that they are operating in. So, GST rationalisation is certainly going to be positive when it comes to that and this is the first step of reforms that the government is going to do given that we are already benefiting. So just step back a bit, the macro context of India is very strong. The markets are unfortunately range-bound because we are experiencing a slowdown. Very sharp declines in markets only happen when you have a very sharp decline in macro. Fortunately that is not the case, and therefore, all we are experiencing is a bit of a time-wise correction and not a very sharp price-wise correction in the market. Now that there is a 100 bps decline in interest rates and we have already stepped up reforms, particularly GST being the first one and there are many other steps that are to come. Expectations for a recovery in the second half of FY26 or FY27 are going to be high. So, in the broader context, you should be a little optimistic as you move forward. You Might Also Like: Little chance of structural downside; FPIs, FIIs FDIs will return to India over next few months: Mayuresh Joshi On automobiles, GST is a positive move but from a broader perspective, the way to go about these things is to look for companies which are succeeding and own them for a longer period of time. That is how I would approach the automobile sector . You Might Also Like: FY26 may end with low double-digit earnings growth; auto and fertilisers are sectors to watch: Shibani Sircar Kurian
