Council debate over 'core' civic responsibilities turns testy
Article content
Councillors representing the Communities First political party, including Sonya Sharp, Andre Chabot, Terry Wong and Dan McLean, brought forward the motion. It sought for the city to better clarify the responsibilities of the three orders of government and to include a line in its reports to council stating whether or not the report's contents are a municipal, provincial, federal or shared responsibility.
Article content
Article content
Article content
According to Sharp, the motion was motivated by the city's — and council's — tendency to focus on policies that should typically fall under provincial or federal jurisdiction. She cited last year's single-use items bylaw, a proposal to cancel Canada Day fireworks in 2021 and the declaration of a climate emergency shortly after council took office in 2021 as examples.
Article content
Article content
'We talk a lot about responsibility being downloaded and we talk a lot about paying for things that aren't in our mandate,' Sharp said.
Article content
'We need to know what our job is and what it isn't.'
Article content
The proposal generated some finger-pointing and traded barbs between councillors, before it ultimately passed 8-6.
Article content
However, by the end of the discussion, the notice of motion was amended to the point where the movers no longer supported it. All four Communities First colleagues voted against it, alongside councillors Sean Chu and Jennifer Wyness.
Article content
Article content
Early into the debate, Ward 14 Coun. Peter Demong asked if the motion was akin to adding another layer of red tape to the city's reporting procedures. He also asked how exactly the city defines its core responsibilities.
Article content
The city's solicitor, Jill Floen, answered that the Municipal Government Act (MGA) outlines what municipalities are legally obligated to perform, but does not define what constitutes a core civic service.
Article content
Everything the city does is either necessary under the MGA, or is something council has deemed desirable, according to Floen. But she added there's no 'clear defined list' of what municipalities are responsible for. That's up to council's discretion, as democratically elected officials, to interpret.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
2 days ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
So much fun for the family in Lagimodière this summer
Lagimodière As the summer rolls on, my team and I have been focused on a few projects, but the overall theme has been about being in the community. Whether it's through connecting with folks at their doorstep or through organizing local events, our priority is simple: to be accessible, to listen, and to ensure we're on the right track. I believe that good representation shouldn't depend on your schedule matching mine; it's our job to meet you where you are. This summer has been filled with many memorable moments. We've continued to host our regular 'Tea with Tyler' gatherings at Charito Bakery & Pastry in Sage Creek, where we welcome people to discuss issues that resonate with them, while building community over drinks and snacks. The Bonavista neighbourhood has also been hopping with activity, from our popsicle and face-painting party in the park, to the well-attended consultation for the development of the Bonavista Community Centre. And of course, we had the pleasure of joining the Canada Day celebration in Sage Creek, at least until the thunder rolled in! A big thank-you to the Sage Creek Residents' Association and all the volunteers who continue to make it a vibrant, growing tradition. Lagimodière MLA Tyler Blashko had a great time celebrating Canada Day with the community in Sage Creek. This August and September, our office is excited to continue bringing the Lagimodière community together through fun, family-friendly events. Join us for a popsicle party in Island Lakes on Aug. 14, a storytime hike through the Bois-des-Esprits trail on Aug. 28, and a pet parade in Sage Creek on Sept. 7. Keep an eye on our social media for full event details, or if you're not on social media, feel free to contact our office anytime for more information. Mondays A weekly look at news and events that matter in your communities. While we've been hearing positive feedback from the community, we also know the work doesn't stop here. Your government is making investments to rebuild health care, including undergoing public consultations to ensure that when the new Victoria Hospital Emergency Room opens, it will meet the community's needs, and we've also introduced a new tool called that allows you to book hospital appointments and avoid unnecessary waits. Whether it's at your door or in the community, my team and I are here to listen, advocate, and help in any way we can. If you'd like to get in touch, you can reach us at 204-583-7423 or or swing by our office at 6-567 St. Anne's Rd. Tyler BlashkoLagimodière constituency report Tyler Blashko is the NDP MLA for Lagimodière. Read full biography Our newsroom depends on a growing audience of readers to power our journalism. If you are not a paid reader, please consider becoming a subscriber. Our newsroom depends on its audience of readers to power our journalism. Thank you for your support.
Calgary Herald
04-08-2025
- Calgary Herald
Summer reading: How a Liberal toppled Pierre Poilievre and won Carleton riding
Article content Also? Most candidates on the ballot don't win their campaign. Only one person per riding does. All the others, who work just as hard as the winners, go back to their previous lives and never go near that parliamentary pension. Article content I've covered politics for well over 20 years, and in my experience, most people get into it to serve. They have ideas they want to put forward and causes to champion. They have benefited from the community and want to give back. Some may think a stint as an MP will look great on their resume (it would), but they are primarily concerned with how to be of service to others. Article content Whatever the reasons to become a politician, laziness is not among them. Members of Parliament work hard, most of the time very far away from home. I'm not trying to make them sound like they need pity or anything, simply pointing out that while the pay is good once you do get elected, the work is arduous. It's a job. Article content Article content Why would someone like Bruce Fanjoy, recently retired from a successful career in the private sector, launch himself into a fight against the most difficult and unpleasant politician we've seen in this country in a very long time? Article content You have to go out and meet people, some of whom want nothing to do with you. This was especially true for Fanjoy in 2023 and 2024, when the federal Liberals had ceased being popular, and I'm trying to be nice when I put it that way. Article content I went to a few events with him and his wife Donna in the summer of 2023. The first one was Canada Day, at Claudette Cain Park in Riverside South. Bruce would introduce himself and offer a card with his photo, basic information, and the website his brother Stephen had set up for his campaign. Article content By that point it had been nearly two years since the September 2021 general election which had returned the second Liberal minority — the first minority being in 2019. By 2023, after the pandemic, the bloom was off the Trudeau rose. Article content Article content As I walked behind the Fanjoys, camera in hand, I saw many people stiffening up when they realized the smiling man was hoping to run for Team Trudeau. A few refused to have anything to do with a Liberal, but they did so politely. Most of the people we met reacted with a surprised chuckle. 'Wow,' they seemed to think. 'You're either very brave or slightly off your rocker.' Article content Canada Day is not a political rally, so Fanjoy was careful to keep interactions short, especially when the people he was talking to had children and were preoccupied with picnics more than politics. A few people offered kind words of encouragement and a couple thanked him for proposing an alternative to the Conservatives. Article content For over two years, Bruce Fanjoy has gone out in his community every day to meet people. He repeated his story thousands upon thousands of times. Who he is, what he believes in, and how what he's done in his life up to that point will help him unseat Poilievre, and give the people of Carleton the kind of federal representation they deserve. Article content He was also clear and transparent with the people he met that he was doing it to put a serious dent in the toxicity that's taken over the Conservative party since the trucker wing elected the only leadership candidate who openly supported them. Article content Even though he'd been involved in his community for many years, as a hockey dad, an activist and a board member of Bike Ottawa, the exercise of knocking on doors was a powerful lesson in humility as Fanjoy discovered how many people had no sweet clue who he was. Eventually, word of mouth started doing what it does best and when people opened their door, they would exclaim things like, 'Oh! It's you! I was wondering when you'd show up!' Article content Politics can be more ungrateful than the worst teenager. But it can also be rewarding. One of the most memorable people Fanjoy encountered early in his campaign was a person who moved to Canada many years ago and was a permanent resident but not a citizen yet, because they'd never taken that final step. That person went through the process and officially became a Canadian citizen a few months after meeting Bruce Fanjoy, just so they could vote for him. Article content The polling aggregator 338Canada has consistently shown (Carleton) riding as Conservative blue. Fair enough, I guess, until a stunning upset at the ballot box. Article content When I first chatted with Fanjoy about the possibility of running against Poilievre, I thought his odds weren't exceptionally good, but I knew they were better than the polls would suggest. Article content I had a few reasons for thinking that. First and foremost, the occupation of Ottawa … suffice to say for now that for most people in the Ottawa area, the occupation of our downtown was an affront we won't forget anytime soon. Article content Another reason is that while the Trudeau Liberals had outstayed their welcome, most Canadians did not appreciate Poilievre's tone, and plenty of voters worried he would be ideologically too far to the right. Article content You'd be amazed to hear how many variations there are of 'You're wasting your time' and Bruce Fanjoy has heard every single one of them. But in a democracy, campaigning to offer voters a choice is never a waste of time. Article content Article content The funny thing is, the more doors he knocked on, the more convinced he became that what the poll aggregators were saying about Carleton was not a true refection of what the voters of Carleton said when he took the time to listen to them. Article content Article content I am working my way through Ernest Hemingway's Islands in the Stream for the first time ever, after a dear friend and great writer recommended it. Growing up in French-speaking Quebec, we didn't overly study this author, and discovering him in my 50s is … eye-opening. I appreciate his economy of words in dialogue, and the love story he has so much difficulty acknowledging. Pairs well with a glass of rosé around dinner time. Article content
Global News
29-07-2025
- Global News
Alberta premier's request for separation referendum question approval rebuffed
Alberta's chief electoral officer is rebuffing calls from Premier Danielle Smith and her justice minister to reverse course and sign off on a proposed referendum question on separation. On social media, Smith and Justice Minister Mickey Amery said earlier Tuesday that Albertans should be able to embark on gathering signatures 'without needless bureaucratic red tape or court applications slowing the process.' Their remarks came after chief electoral officer Gordon McClure announced he had referred the proposed referendum question on separation to the courts so a judge could decide if it contravenes Canada's Constitution. McClure, in a statement Tuesday, responded by saying he's merely following procedure and that the gravity of such a potential referendum invites judicial oversight and close inspection. 'In seeking the opinion of the Court, the Chief Electoral Officer is fulfilling his duty under the Citizen Initiative Act in an independent, neutral and non-partisan manner,' he said. Story continues below advertisement The proposed question — which needs McClure's approval before the group behind it can start gathering the signatures necessary to get it on a ballot — seeks a yes or no answer to: 'Do you agree that the Province of Alberta shall become a sovereign country and cease to be a province in Canada?' 1:52 Albertans speak about separatist sentiments on Canada Day Amery says in his post that since the province would ultimately be responsible for implementing any referendum result, the electoral officer's request for judicial scrutiny is premature. Get breaking National news For news impacting Canada and around the world, sign up for breaking news alerts delivered directly to you when they happen. Sign up for breaking National newsletter Sign Up By providing your email address, you have read and agree to Global News' Terms and Conditions and Privacy Policy 'We encourage Elections Alberta to withdraw its court reference and permit Albertans their democratic right to participate in the citizen initiative process,' he wrote. Smith's post said she agrees with Amery, but adds she believes in 'Alberta sovereignty within a united Canada.' McClure, in his statement, said the question is 'serious and significant,' and that it has 'the potential to have profound impact on all Albertans.' Story continues below advertisement He also clarified that he's specifically looking for a judge to rule if the proposed question contravenes specific sections of the Constitution, including the rights set out in the Charter, the enforcement of those rights, and treaty rights. 2:56 Alberta's UCP government lowers required threshold for citizens to initiate referendum Smith and Amery's comments came after the group that submitted the question called the electoral officer's Monday decision a 'delay tactic.' Opposition NDP deputy leader Rakhi Pancholi, in a statement, accused Smith and Amery of going against the administration of a law they themselves set in order to appease separatists within the United Conservative Party. 'Yet again, Danielle Smith and her UCP government's authoritarian tendencies, corruption and incompetence are on full display,' Pancholi said. 'Albertans deserve better than a government hell-bent on tearing our country apart to save their political skins.' Tweet This Click to share quote on Twitter: "Albertans deserve better than a government hell-bent on tearing our country apart to save their political skins." Story continues below advertisement Mitch Sylvestre with the Alberta Prosperity Project, whose name is attached to the application submitted to the electoral officer, has not responded to interview requests this week. Sylvestre has said he thinks interest among Albertans in holding a separation referendum increases with every speaking event his group organizes. 'The more people that hear what the message is, the more people that will be in favour,' he said in an interview last month. 1:51 One of Alberta's referendum petition pushes moving on to next step Provincial law says a hearing date must be scheduled within 10 days of the court referral, and McClure's office says he would have 30 days after a court ruling is issued to determine if the proposed referendum question meets other legislated requirements. If approved, Sylvestre and the Alberta Prosperity Project would need to collect 177,000 signatures in four months to put the question of Alberta separation on a ballot. Story continues below advertisement In June, the chief electoral officer approved a competing question that seeks to have Alberta make it official policy that the province will never separate from Canada. That petition, put forward by former Alberta Progressive Conservative deputy premier Thomas Lukaszuk, was approved before new provincial rules took effect that lowered the threshold for citizen-initiated referendums to get on ballots. 2:13 Alberta group proposes anti-separatism referendum: 'I'm thankful to this country' Amery said Tuesday the rule changes were intended to make the process 'broadly permissive' and that McClure's referral to the court didn't match the intent behind the changes.
